Subtransmission Grid Control via Online Feedback Optimization

summary

The gist

Online Feedback Optimization (OFO) is a feedback real-time control method that can be employed to enable optimal operation of transmission and subtransmission grids.

In short

Online Feedback Optimization (OFO) is a real-time control method designed to optimize power grid operation by maximizing efficiency and minimizing curtailment while respecting voltage and current limits. The controller iteratively updates inputs using a mixed integer quadratic optimization problem, allowing it to handle complex decisions like wind farm curtailment in real-time.

Key concepts

Online Feedback Optimization (OFO)
A feedback control method where the controller continuously updates its actions based on real-time grid measurements. It solves a mixed integer quadratic optimization problem at each step to determine the best next move for the grid, ensuring it stays near the ideal operating point.
Mixed Integer Quadratic Optimization Problem (MIQP)
The mathematical problem that OFO solves at every time step. It involves both continuous variables (like power injections) and discrete variables (like whether a tap changer is on or off). Solving this problem helps find the optimal balance between maximizing power output and satisfying all grid constraints.
Model Mismatch Robustness
The ability of the OFO controller to perform well even when its internal model of the grid does not perfectly match reality. The paper shows OFO is highly precise and not overly sensitive to these mismatches, which is crucial for real-world deployment where perfect information is impossible.
Sensitivity ($ abla_u h(u, d)$)
A key piece of model information that describes how much the grid output changes when an input (like power injection) is slightly altered. OFO uses this sensitivity to make informed updates, approximating it with a fixed value for practical, real-time operation.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Subtransmission Grid Control via Online Feedback Optimization · Read on arXiv

Lukas Ortmanna, Jean Maeght, Patrick Panciatici, Florian Dörfler, Saverio Bolognani

OST – Eastern Switzerland University of Applied Sciences · § Réseau de Transport d’ Electricity (RTE) · Automatic Control Laboratory, ETH Zurich

The increasing electric power consumption and the shift towards renewable energy resources demand for new ways to operate transmission and subtransmission grids. Online Feedback Optimization (OFO) is a feedback real-time control method that can be employed to enable optimal operation of these grids. Such controllers can maximize grid efficiency (e.g., minimizing curtailment) while satisfying grid constraints like voltage and current limits. The OFO control method is tailored and extended to handle discrete inputs and it is explained how to design an OFO controller for the subtransmission grid. A novel benchmark is presented and published that corresponds to the real French subtransmission grid on which the proposed controller is analyzed in terms of robustness against model mismatch, constraint satisfaction, and tracking performance. It is shown that OFO controllers can help utilize the grid to its full extent, virtually reinforce it, and operate it optimally and in real-time by using the flexibility offered by renewable generators connected to distribution grids.

DOI: 10.1016/j.apenergy.2025.127142

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Subtransmission Grid Control via Online Feedback Optimization".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. Online Feedback Optimization (OFO) is a feedback real-time control method that can be employed to enable optimal operation of transmission and subtransmission grids.

Rosa: Such controllers can maximize grid efficiency (e.g., minimizing curtailment) while satisfying grid constraints like voltage and current limits.

Dev: Problem Motivation The increasing electric power consumption and the shift towards renewable energy resources demand for new ways to operate transmission and subtransmission grids.

Rosa: Grid operators have deployed different solutions to tackle this issue.

Title and authors: Rosa: Now we're moving into the title and authors of this paper, "Subtransmission Grid Control via Online Feedback Optimization." The authors are Lukas Ortmanna, Jean Maeght b, Patrick Panciatici b, Florian Dörfler c, and Saverio Bolognani c.

Dev: Those are a good mix of people here. You’ve got the field roboticist perspective from Rosa running trials outside the lab and the controls engineer focus on real-time loops and safety cases.

Taro: I'm curious if any of them have experience with real-world failure modes, like what happens when the world misbehaves, because that's where my testing usually gets complicated.

Rosa: The paper is from a group that clearly has strong ties to power systems research, which is expected given the specific grid benchmark they chose—the real French subtransmission grid.

Dev: That context is important because it means their focus isn't just on abstract theory; they’re grounding this in something tangible, which helps with the safety case side of things.

Taro: I hope this doesn't get too bogged down in synthetic models again, because we want to see how these things actually behave when they hit real-world complexities.

Rosa: They explicitly use a real French subtransmission grid as their benchmark for robustness against model mismatch and constraint satisfaction, which is pretty telling about their practical goals.

Dev: That level of testing against a real system is what separates this from just theoretical papers that don't have to deal with the messy details of physical reality.

The paper's summary: Rosa: So, summarizing what the paper says, they’re presenting the Online Feedback Optimization method as a way to achieve optimal operation of these grids. It’s a feedback control approach designed to maximize grid efficiency by minimizing curtailment while respecting voltage and current limits.

Dev: That boils down to using real-time measurements to drive the controller, updating the inputs based on what you see, which is how they manage the system in real time.

Taro: So it’s about this iterative update process where the inputs are adjusted based on a combination of current state and some estimated sensitivity model.

Rosa: Right. They use an integral form for this update, where the inputs at step k plus one are calculated based on the previous input plus some term that depends on how you're doing now, the disturbance you’ve seen, and their estimate of how much things will change.

Dev: That update involves solving a mixed integer quadratic optimization problem to figure out what the next best move is for the system.

Taro: So it’s not just a simple calculation; it's an iterative decision-making process that incorporates discrete choices, which makes sense for managing those physical components.

Rosa: Right. And they use a tuning matrix G to fine-tune the transient behavior of this closed-loop system to manage how things transition between states.

Dev: That tuning matrix G is crucial because it dictates the rate at which different inputs change and also how much those tap changers are used during those transitions.

The paper's improvements: Taro: So, when we talk about improvements, I see they are really focusing on making this method robust against model mismatch and constraint satisfaction issues.

Rosa: That’s right. They show that this controller is highly precise and not sensitive to model mismatch when compared to the current practice of curtailing injection at a fixed level.

Dev: So, the main improvement here is moving away from fixed curtailment strategies by showing that OFO can extract fifty percent more wind power in the real-world benchmark than what's currently done.

Taro: That fifty percent increase is pretty compelling when you think about how much energy we could save if we could actually achieve those gains.

Rosa: They also showed that the controller can track the time-varying local optimum of the optimization problem, which means it performs practically identically to what you'd get from a perfectly omniscient solver.

Dev: So, even though they acknowledge there are limitations regarding model mismatch, this paper is really pushing for better decision-making accuracy over just relying on fixed rules.

Conclusion: Rosa: Wrapping up the whole thing, the main implication is that this OFO controller can safely operate a subtransmission grid in real time under model mismatch and with limited model information, which is pretty significant.

Dev: It means we don't need perfect information to run a grid optimally; we just need this feedback mechanism to keep it tracking the local optimum as conditions change.

Taro: For my testing perspective, it shows that even when things are unpredictable, the system can recover gracefully and stay in a safe operating point.

Rosa: And they've extended OFO to handle discrete actuators, which is a major step forward for versatile control systems on these grids.

Dev: It’s about giving operators a unified controller for both active and reactive power and those physical switching actions, which simplifies things significantly.

More episodes

← Home