Ramping Procurement and Bid-Cost Recovery in Real-Time Market

summary

The gist

We study ramping procurement co-optimized with economic dispatch under net-demand uncertainty This paper establishes a framework for analyzing ramping procurement in the real-time electricity market…

In short

This study analyzes ramping procurement co-optimized with economic dispatch under uncertainty to improve real-time electricity markets. It addresses issues where existing flexible ramp products fail because current pricing mechanisms do not incentivize generators to provide necessary ramping support. The research proposes new pricing methods to better align incentives for ramping capabilities.

Key concepts

Flexible Ramp Product (FRP)
These are programs developed by operators like CAISO and MISO to position generators to provide both upward and downward ramping services in the real-time market. They aim to ensure there is sufficient capacity available when electricity demand fluctuates rapidly.
Locational Marginal Pricing (LMP)
This is a pricing system used in wholesale energy markets that determines the price of electricity based on where power is needed. The paper suggests that current LMP and ramp pricing are often too low, which fails to motivate generators to provide ramping support.
Maximum Dispatch Cost Pricing (MDCP)
This proposed pricing method calculates the procurement cost by taking the maximum of various dispatch costs for generation and storage resources. It is designed specifically to eliminate out-of-market payments that currently occur in these markets.
Maximum Temporal Locational Marginal Pricing (MTLMP)
This alternative pricing mechanism uses a maximum locational marginal price across multiple time intervals. It is another proposed method intended to incentivize generators to provide ramping capabilities by adjusting how they are compensated for their service over time.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Ramping Procurement and Bid-Cost Recovery in Real-Time Market · Read on arXiv

Dartmouth College · Cornell University

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.

Rosa: I'm Rosa.

Dev: And I'm Dev, here with Taro.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Ramping Procurement and Bid-Cost Recovery in Real-Time Market".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. We study ramping procurement co-optimized with economic dispatch under net-demand uncertainty This paper establishes a framework for analyzing ramping procurement in the real-time electricity market, identifies the causes of out-of-market BCR uplifts, and proposes new pricing mechanisms to incentivize generators to provide ramping capabilities Core Problem and Motivation Deep penetration of renewable energy resources has increased net-load uncertainty and the need for both upward and downward ramping capability in the real-time market This challenge is particularly pronounced in renewable-rich regions such as those operated by the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) and Midcontinent Independent System Operator (MISO) Since 2016, both MISO and CAISO have developed Flexible Ramp Product or Ramp Capability Product (herein referred to as FRP), aimed at positioning generators to provide ramping supports via energy and ramp-capacity co-optimizations Significant challenges remain because existing FRP implementations do not use bid-based ramp procurement and the ramp demand curves are set administratively, ramp prices are often too low under current Locational Marginal Pricing (LMP)-based energy and ramp pricing Thus, LMP and ramp capacity shadow price may not be sufficiently high to incentivize generation and storage resources to provide ramping support in real-time dispatch Modeling the Co-optimization Framework The paper develops an energy–ramping co-optimization framework that captures the essential features of practical FRPs, from which we characterize fundamental properties of FRP dispatch and pricing The complete dispatch horizon is denoted by

T: := 1,..., T Let Tt′:= t′, t′ + 1,..., t′ +W −1 as a rolling-window look-ahead horizon with t′ as the binding interval and the rest are advisory intervals The operator solves the optimization Gt′ in (1) to determine the generation gt′, ramping up capacity rt′, and ramping down capacity rt′, defined by (X i,t citgit) + st = ˆdt + lt, etc.

Rosa: This formulation minimizes the system operating cost J(lt′, st′, st′, st′):= P t∈Tt′(ptst+ptst+p tst+mtlt) Proposed Pricing Mechanisms To address the issues arising from out-of-market settlements, we propose two uniform pricing methods—maximum dispatch cost pricing (MDCP) and maximum temporal locational marginal pricing (MTLMP)—that eliminate out-of-market payments MDCP is defined as πMDCPt:= max c1t1

g R 1t>0: , …, cNt1

g R Nt>0: , pt1

s R t>0: MTLMP is defined as πMTLMPt:= max πTLMP 1t, …, πTLMP Nt, pt1

s R t>0: Analytical results show that MDCP eliminates MWP (Proposition 1) and MTLMP does so in most cases (Proposition 2) Empirical Findings and Efficiency Trade-offs Empirical results on CAISO and ERCOT data show that MDCP and MTLMP increase producer profits with negligible BCR, albeit at the expense of higher consumer payments relative to LMP The relative efficiency of single- versus multi-interval dispatch depends fundamentally on the system’s ramping capability and forecast error Multi-interval dispatch incurs higher upfront costs to secure ramping capacity but reduces penalties in scenarios with tight ramping requirements, whereas single-interval dispatch is more cost-effective under high forecast uncertainty due to avoiding over-procurement In the CAISO data, the severe variations in price caused a massive portion of the total energy revenue to come from MWPs (reaching up to 41.

Paper summary: Rosa: So wrapping up this look at "Ramping Procurement and Bid-Cost Recovery in Real-Time Market," these authors, Cong Chen, Norambuena, Tong, and others, developed a framework that links energy and ramping procurement under net demand uncertainty.

Dev: They introduced MDCP and MTLMP as uniform pricing mechanisms to tackle the issue of out-of-market adjustments stemming from current LMP structures.

Taro: The core finding is that these pricing methods eliminate those out-of-market payments, which is a key technical achievement for improving financial recovery in real time.

Rosa: It also showed that while producer profits go up with negligible benefit cost ratio changes, consumer payments do increase relative to the LMP baseline.

Dev: The paper highlights how the choice between single and multi-interval dispatch really depends on the system's specific ramping capabilities and forecast error levels.

Taro: The authors admit that their model focuses on specific rollling-window stochastic optimization techniques, so it might not capture every single failure mode in a completely open world scenario.

Rosa: But overall, it provides a solid analytical foundation for operators to test these new pricing rules before deploying them in their actual real time dispatch systems.

Dev: The title of the paper perfectly captures the tension: balancing ramping procurement and bid cost recovery within the complexities of real-time market operations.

Conclusion: Rosa: So this paper is about how you buy ramping services in the real time electricity market, and how that connects to getting your money back when you have uncertainty about demand.

Dev: Right, they look at ramping procurement and bid cost recovery under net demand uncertainty. It’s a framework for analyzing that whole process.

Taro: It sets up a system where you look ahead, like over a rolling window of time, to figure out exactly what energy and ramp capacity you need to secure.

Rosa: They introduce these specific pricing methods, maximum dispatch cost pricing and maximum temporal locational marginal pricing. These are meant to fix problems with how money flows between the market and the generators.

Dev: The point is that these new prices eliminate those out of market adjustments, which makes the financial picture much cleaner for everyone involved in real time dispatch.

Taro: It means you can stop worrying so much about those specific payments that come from settlements outside the main market structure.

Rosa: But there are trade-offs, right? The empirical findings show that using these new prices increases producer profits, but it also changes how much money consumers pay compared to the old way.

Dev: And the efficiency of using a single dispatch interval versus multiple intervals really depends on how much ramping capability you have and how much uncertainty in your weather forecasts you're dealing with.

Taro: If your forecast is super uncertain, single-interval dispatch might be better because it avoids over-buying when you don't need that extra ramp capacity.

Rosa: It’s about balancing those upfront costs of securing the ramp versus the penalties you avoid when things get tight on ramping demands.

Dev: So, they give operators a way to test these new pricing rules before they put them into their actual real time dispatch systems.

Taro: It gives us a way to see how the system recovers when things go wrong in those uncertain scenarios.

Rosa: This framework is important because it gives operators concrete tools to handle the ramping needs of big renewable energy sources, like solar and wind.

Dev: The authors show how to structure that co optimization problem so that it actually works in a practical loop.

Taro: We'll look at what happens when you test this setup against some real data from places like CAISO and ERCOT.

More episodes

← Home