Three-body contact for fermions. II. Non-degenerate limit
summary
The gist
A fundamental quantity characterizing Fermi gases with zero-range interactions is the three-body contact C 3…
In short
This work computes three-body contact $C_3$, a fundamental quantity for Fermi gases with zero-range interactions, to leading order in the non-degenerate limit. It derives analytical expressions for $C_3$ at the unitary limit ($a=\infty$) and uses diagrammatic expansions for negative scattering lengths ($a<0$). The results reveal that correct short-distance behavior arises from cancellations between two-body and three-body correlations, providing a benchmark for strongly correlated systems.
Key concepts
- Three-body contact $C_3$
- $C_3$ is a key quantity describing how fermions interact in groups of three. It governs observables like nearby triplet fermion numbers and loss rates in cold atom experiments. It is calculated to leading order to characterize the gas's properties.
- Unitary limit ($a=\infty$)
- This limit occurs when the scattering length $a$ is infinite, meaning the interaction strength is tuned perfectly. In this regime, an analytical expression for $C_3$ is derived using a wavefunction approach, showing a specific temperature dependence of $1/T^{0.22728}$.
- Feynman diagrammatic virial expansion
- This technique is used to compute $C_3$ for negative scattering lengths ($a<0$). It shows that the correct short-distance power law behavior emerges only after a non-trivial cancellation between leading order two-body and three-body correlations, stemming from a large-wavevector tail of the three-body T-matrix.
- Power law divergence $R^{2s - 4}$
- This describes the short-distance behavior of the three-body correlation function $g_3(r, \rho)$. The leading order behavior is determined by $g_{e_3}(r, \rho)$, which exhibits a specific power-law divergence ($R^{-0.45455146}$). This scaling is crucial for understanding how fermions behave at very small separations.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Three-body contact for fermions. II. Non-degenerate limit · Paper Radio
- The Unitary Gas and its Symmetry Properties
- Universal Relations for Fermions with Large Scattering Length
- Theory of Radio Frequency Spectroscopy of Polarized Fermi Gases
- Exact relations for quantum-mechanical few-body and many-body problems with short-range interactions in two and three dimensions
- Short Range Scaling Laws of Quantum Gases With Contact Interactions
- Pseudogap regime of the unitary Fermi gas with lattice auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo in the continuum limit
The paper
Three-body contact for fermions. II. Non-degenerate limit · Read on arXiv
Xavier Leyronas, Félix Werner
Laboratoire de Physique de l’ Ecole Normale Supƃre, ENS - University of Paris PSL, Sorbonne University, Sorbonne University, CNRS · Laboratoire Kastler Brossel, Ecole Normale Supƃre - University of Paris PSL, CNRS · Collége de France
A fundamental quantity characterizing Fermi gases with zero-range interactions is the three-body contact C 3, which determines several observables including the number of nearby triplets of fermions and the three-body loss rate in cold atom experiments, as shown in a companion article. Here, we compute C 3 to leading order in the non-degenerate limit for the homogeneous gas with negative or infinite scattering length a. At a= infinity, using a wavefunction approach, we obtain the analytical expression of C 3, which has a remarkably slow 1/T 0.22728 dependence on the temperature T. In the Feynman diagram technique, which we use for a<0, the correct three-body short-distance correlations emerge only after a non-trivial cancellation between leading order two-body and three-body correlations, and the resulting power-law scaling comes from the large-wavevector tail of the 3-body T-matrix, which we derive inspired by the analytical solution of the three-body problem at the unitary limit.
DOI: 10.5802/crphys.291
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Three-body contact for fermions. II. Non-degenerate limit".
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now, "Three-body contact for fermions. II. Non-degenerate limit." It tackles that fundamental quantity called the three body contact C3 that characterizes Fermi gases with zero range interactions <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: Exactly, and what's really interesting here is they compute this C3 to leading order in the non degenerate limit for a homogeneous gas, whether we have a negative or infinite scattering length a <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that means they are looking at what happens when you have many particles and you can't ignore the fact that the temperature is high enough to matter, which is where things get tricky for us on hardware.
Kai: For the infinite scattering length case, they use a wavefunction approach to get this C3 value and it shows a really slow temperature dependence of one over T to point zero point two two seven two two eight on T <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: That slow dependence is significant because it gives us some insight into how the three body contact behaves in that regime, even when the interaction range is effectively infinite.
Lev: It's interesting to see that they use a wavefunction approach there; for real hardware, we usually have to rely on something more practical for those kinds of limits.
Kai: And for negative scattering lengths, they use a Feynman diagram technique which shows that the correct short distance correlations only appear after a non trivial cancellation between leading order two body and three body correlations <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: That cancellation is key because it's what allows them to see the true physics of short distance behavior, and they say this scaling stems from a large wavevector tail of the three body T matrix.
Lev: A large wavevector tail in a T matrix means you have very high momentum components involved, which translates to needing very good resolution when you try to simulate this on real systems.
Kai: They present some main results in section three, and then they do a calculation in section four that gives an analytical result for C3 at the unitary limit where the scattering length is infinite <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Mira: And then in section five, they compute C3 for any negative value of lambda T over a using a Feynman diagrammatic virial expansion technique <ref:2608.15324#pg2>.
Lev: The virial expansion sounds like it's going to generate a lot of terms, and we always have to worry about the convergence when we try to map that onto actual simulations.
Kai: What they show is that the correct short distance power law behavior of g three comes from this non trivial cancellation between two body and three body leading contributions <ref:2608.15324#pg2>.
Mira: And this scaling originates from a large wavevector tail of the off shell three body T matrix, which they say is inspired by the analytical solution of the three body problem at unitarity <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Lev: So they are connecting a theoretical property from a simpler case, unitarity, to their calculation for this non degenerate limit. That's a nice bridge to build on for understanding error scaling in our systems.
Kai: In the non degenerate limit where n lambda cubed T is small, C3 has an asymptotic expression that looks like this C3 equals n cubed mu over h bar squared m k b T to the power of one half minus s f three mu lambda T over a to the power of one half <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: That expression shows how C3 scales with particle density, temperature, and the scattering length a, which is helpful because it gives us a way to predict its behavior across different experimental conditions.
Lev: If we were trying to implement this on real hardware, the dependence on n cubed suggests that scaling up the particle number will make our noise much harder to manage than just linear or quadratic scaling.
Kai: At the unitary limit where a is infinite, they find a specific value for a function f three at zero which is four point five five five two eight nine two nine two <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: That specific number, f three equals four point five five five two eight nine two nine two, seems like the key constant that emerges from the unitary limit calculation <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Lev: If we were running a simulation at unitarity, we'd expect to see this constant emerge, but getting it right requires knowing exactly how to handle those strong correlations in the simulation setup.
Kai: For negative scattering lengths, they recover that analytical result from the unitary limit calculation, which means it works for both cases <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: That consistency is a good sign because it suggests that the underlying physics captured by that function f three is robust across different interaction regimes.
Lev: Robustness is what we need when we're trying to design error correction codes; you don't want your whole system to collapse just because you change a parameter slightly.
Kai: They also look at the large momentum tail of the center of mass momentum distribution for nearby fermion pairs and they find that it scales with K squared plus four over K two <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Mira: That scaling, n P of K is proportional to K to the power of two s plus four over K two, is directly determined by C3 <ref:2608.15324#pg7>.
Lev: If we look at that scaling in terms of momentum distribution, it tells us how the correlations between particles spread out in momentum space, which is vital for understanding decoherence and loss mechanisms.
Kai: In the non degenerate limit, this implies that the limit of K to infinity times K to the power of two s plus four over K two scales with negative one two eight p cubed pi over five n cubed mu beta m D one <ref:2608.15324#pg77>.
Mira: That result connects the momentum distribution directly back to other parameters like density and temperature, showing how they are all linked through this C3 quantity.
Lev: It means if we can measure that high momentum tail in an experiment, we can use this equation to extract information about the three body contact C three without needing a full simulation <ref:2608.15324#pg2>.
Kai: They relate C3 to the l zero three body contact density C prime three which has a subleading correction <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Mira: The paper says that the leading order behavior of g three at small R is determined by g e three which exhibits a power law divergence of R to the power of two s minus four, which is negative zero point four five four five one eight six <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Lev: That negative exponent, that R to the power of two s minus four, that's really telling us about the spatial structure of these interactions at very small distances.
Kai: They say that the sum of the two body contribution g three and the l zero three body contribution g three is negligible in that small R limit because they diverge more strongly like R to the power of negative two but they cancel each other to leading order <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Mira: That cancellation is another piece of evidence for why their approach works; it shows that even when you have multiple contributions, the dominant short distance physics comes from this specific combination <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Lev: It's like saying that in a complex system, you only need to worry about the most singular part of the math to get your main result.
Kai: The final expression for C3 is obtained by integrating g three over the hyperangles and it looks like this C3 is proportional to minus s plus one over four times one over one minus s pi over two times sin squared pi s gamma of s plus two squared n two mu beta m n cubed <ref:2608.15324#pg70>.
Mira: The constant D one in that equation is determined numerically through the STM equations, and for the infinite scattering length case, this gives f three equals four point five five six six three three <ref:2608.15324#pg70>.
Lev: So they have a numerical bridge here connecting their final analytical expression back to the more complex STM equations they used to determine that constant, which is exactly what we need for implementation.
Kai: The paper suggests that the leading order R to zero behavior of g three is given by g e three with that power law divergence of R to the power of two s minus four, consistent with equation four <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Mira: And they point out that terms like g three at two and l zero three body contributions diverge more strongly like R to the power of negative two but they cancel each other to leading order, making their sum negligible in the R to zero limit <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Lev: So for anyone trying to calculate these things on a real simulator, you need to focus on isolating that singular behavior at small distances and ignoring the rest at first.
Kai: This work suggests that this paper provides a unique possibility for benchmarking challenging computations of C3 in the degenerate strongly correlated regime <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: They suggest that the exact determination of C3 in the non degenerate limit offers a unique means to benchmark those difficult computations, alongside experimental determinations of C3 such as those performed at Heidelberg University via three body loss rates <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Lev: It sounds like they are giving us a concrete target for what a real experiment should aim to measure when trying to understand these many particle interactions.
Kai: They also suggest that the cancellation between leading order two body and three body contributions, coupled with a high wavevector power law behavior of the three body T matrix will be crucial ingredients for any Feynman diagrammatic calculation of C3 <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: That means for future theoretical work, we really need to focus on modeling that large wavevector tail in the three body T matrix because it seems to be a fundamental ingredient here.
Lev: If we can nail that tail, then maybe we can make the full diagrammatic calculations converge faster when we try to run them on actual quantum computers.
Kai: The paper is generalizable to the mass imbalanced case below the efimov effect threshold and you can extend it to positive scattering lengths <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: And they anticipate asymptotically exact computations in the weak coupling bcs and strong coupling bec limits, although computing C3 there remains particularly challenging <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Lev: So the paper sets a very high bar for what an exact calculation should look like, especially when you try to push it into those strongly correlated limits where things usually get messy.
Kai: It’s also important that a prerequisite for computing C3 accurately is obtaining the exponent for that power law scaling g three proportional to R to the power of two s minus four which equals negative zero point four five four five one eight six <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Mira: And they mention that mean field bcs theory yields a result of g bcs at small R that is proportional to R to the power of negative two, which means we need to find the exact exponent for the power law behavior <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Lev: That's a crucial piece of information because if we can nail that exponent, it tells us how far off our mean field approximations are in describing these short range interactions.
Kai: They also look at the large momentum limit of the t three l by diagonalizing the operator r two two at the unitary limit and they find an asymptotic form for y two two that depends on u and u prime going to infinity <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Mira: That asymptotic form shows how the correlations behave when you look at very large relative momenta, which is exactly what we need to connect it back to the C3 calculation <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Lev: If we can diagonalize that operator, it gives us a structured way to handle those high momentum states in our numerical models.
Kai: They also look at the asymptotic behavior of Im t three l at large wavevectors and they find it scales with minus m times two l plus one to the power of three minus s l times k to the power of two s l plus four over q squared over q prime <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Mira: And for zero, that means for zero, it yields a result proportional to R to the power of two s minus four divided by q squared over q prime which is exactly what we expect from equation four <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Lev: So they have an explicit link between the momentum space behavior and the real space divergence, which is very helpful for checking our model consistency.
Kai: This whole paper, "Three-body contact for fermions. II. Non-degenerate limit," gives us a really solid framework for understanding C3 in these types of Fermi gases <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: It suggests that the leading order R to zero behavior of g three is given by g e three with that power law divergence of R to the power of two s minus four, which is negative zero point four five four five one eight six <ref:2608.15324#pg3>.
Lev: So we have a concrete exponent to check against when we try to build error correction codes or simulate these systems on real chips.
Kai: The paper's main contribution is providing this method to benchmark C3 calculations in the degenerate strongly correlated regime <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Mira: And they suggest that the cancellation between leading order two body and three body contributions, coupled with a high wavevector power law behavior of the three body T matrix will be crucial ingredients for any Feynman diagrammatic calculation of C3 <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Lev: That means we should probably focus our next efforts on finding ways to compute that large wavevector tail in a way that's computationally feasible, not just theoretically elegant.
Kai: This paper is generalizable to the mass imbalanced case below the efimov effect threshold and you can extend it to positive scattering lengths <ref:2608.15324#pg1>.
Lev: So the paper sets a very high bar for what an exact calculation should look like, especially when you try to push it into those strongly correlated limits where things usually get messy.
The paper's summary: Kai: So what we've just heard is that this paper, "Three-body contact for fermions," is actually part two, focusing on what happens when you have many particles and they aren't in the most extreme state of being cold or dense.
Mira: Right. Essentially, they are looking at the three body contact C three which is a number that tells you how strongly fermions interact over very short distances in a gas.
Kai: They spend this paper computing that C three to leading order in the non degenerate limit, and they do it for both cases: when you have an infinite scattering length and when you have a negative one.
Mira: That's the main thing. For the infinite scattering length case, they use a wavefunction approach to get this number, and it shows that temperature dependence is super slow—one over T to the power of point zero point two two seven two two eight on T.
Lev: Slow temperature dependence is good for simulation overhead because it means you don't have to worry about the thermal noise killing your signal too fast just because you raise the temperature a little bit.
Kai: Then for negative scattering lengths, they use a Feynman diagram technique, and they find that the short distance correlations only show up after there's this specific cancellation between two body and three body interactions.
Mira: That cancellation is crucial because it means the true physics of what's happening at those tiny distances only appears if you consider both the two body and the three body effects together.
Lev: So, for someone building a simulator, that cancellation tells us we can't just look at two or three body terms in isolation; they have to be calculated as one combined entity.
Kai: They then show that this scaling comes from a large wavevector tail of the three body T matrix, which is inspired by how the three body problem looks at unitarity, where you have an infinite scattering length.
Mira: It's like they are taking a solved problem from a simpler case—the unitary limit—and using that insight to understand the complex behavior in this non degenerate regime.
Lev: That connection between the simple unitary case and this more realistic scenario is exactly what we need to see when you try to make these simulations work on actual quantum hardware.
Kai: They give us an asymptotic expression for C three in terms of particle density, temperature, and that scattering length, which helps predict how the number scales as you change those conditions.
Mira: And they find a specific constant value for a function called f three at zero when you are at the infinite scattering length limit.
Lev: That constant is what we need to pin down if we want to compare our simulation results against what theory predicts for that special unitary case.
Kai: They also connect this C three number back to how particles spread out in momentum space, looking at the distribution of nearby fermion pairs, which they find scales with a power of K squared plus four over K two.
Mira: That momentum scaling is directly determined by the C three value they calculated earlier, so if we can measure that high momentum tail experimentally, we can use this relationship to extract the contact number.
Lev: If you can measure that high momentum tail in an experiment, it means you have a way to check if your simulation is capturing the right physics at those extreme scales.
Kai: They also look at how C three relates to another quantity, C prime three, which has this subleading correction.
Mira: The authors make a point that the leading order behavior of the three body interaction at very small distances comes from a specific term, g e three.
Lev: That g e three term shows this power law divergence of R to the power of two s minus four, which is negative zero point four five four five one eight six.
Kai: So that negative exponent is what we need to know about the spatial structure when things get really close together in this system.
Mira: They say that the sum of the two body contribution and that l zero three body term becomes negligible at very small distances because they both diverge more strongly than just one term, but they cancel each other out to leading order.
Lev: That cancellation is a big deal for simulation design because it means we can ignore some complex terms when we're trying to isolate the most important part of the interaction.
Kai: The final expression for C three is derived by integrating that three body contact density over all possible angles, and it gives us a result that depends on a constant D one determined numerically through those STM equations.
Mira: And they find that this numerical constant D one matches the value they got from the unitary limit calculation, which is four point five five six six three three when you have an infinite scattering length.
Lev: So they've closed the loop between their final formula and their initial theoretical inputs, which is important for making sure everything adds up before we try to run it on a machine.
Kai: Basically, this paper gives us a solid method for benchmarking these tough C three calculations in the strongly correlated regime using experimental data from things like three body loss rates.
Mira: And they suggest that focusing on modeling that large wavevector tail of the three body T matrix is a crucial ingredient if we want any Feynman diagrammatic calculation of C three to be accurate.
Lev: That means for future work, our priority should be finding a way to compute that high momentum tail in a way that's actually computationally feasible on real quantum computers.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So we've seen how this paper calculates that C three contact number in both infinite and negative scattering length limits under non degenerate conditions, and now we look at what they suggest for improving the research itself.
Kai: They point out that for any calculation to be accurate, you absolutely need to get the exponent for the power law scaling of g three right.
Mira: They say that this exponent is negative zero point four five four five one eight six, and they stress that mean field bcs theory gives a result of R to the power of negative two at small distances.
Lev: If you're running a simulation, that means your mean field approximation will be off by a factor related to that exponent, so you need to account for it in your error budget from the start.
Kai: They also highlight this cancellation between the two body and three body contributions as something crucial for any Feynman diagrammatic calculation of C three.
Mira: That's what they mean: you can't just calculate them separately; you have to treat that cancellation as a necessary condition for getting the right short distance physics.
Lev: For us building error correction, it means we should focus our efforts on modeling that large wavevector tail of the three body T matrix, because that's where this crucial interaction information lives.
Kai: They also mention that this work is generalizable to the mass imbalanced case below the efimov effect threshold and can be extended to positive scattering lengths.
Mira: That means they are showing that their framework isn't just limited to negative scattering lengths, it works in a wider range of physics scenarios.
Lev: Extending it to positive scattering lengths is interesting because those are often harder to model accurately in simulation because the physics changes quite a bit there.
Kai: They also mention that they anticipate asymptotically exact computations in the weak coupling bcs and strong coupling bec limits, even though computing C three there remains particularly challenging.
Mira: It's a hope that the underlying math is robust enough to eventually give us exact answers even in those extreme theoretical limits, even if we can't do it right now.
Lev: That hope is what drives the need for better numerical methods because we need something that works reliably when you push past those boundaries.
Kai: In short, they suggest that this paper gives us a framework to benchmark C three calculations in the strongly correlated regime using experimental data from things like three body loss rates.
Mira: And they believe focusing on modeling that large wavevector tail is the key ingredient for any future diagrammatic calculation of C three.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper on "Three-body contact for fermions" really gave us a concrete way to calculate that three body contact C three number under non degenerate conditions for both infinite and negative scattering lengths.
Mira: Right. The main thing is that they've provided a benchmark for calculating C three using experimental data from things like loss rates, which is pretty important.
Lev: If we look at what this means for error correction, it gives us a target to check our simulation against when we're dealing with these strongly correlated systems on real hardware.
Kai: They also show that the cancellation between the two body and three body terms is key for getting the right short distance behavior, and that scaling comes from a large wavevector tail of the three body T matrix.
Mira: That means if you're doing any Feynman diagram calculation for C three, you have to make sure your model includes that high momentum tail because it seems fundamental here.
Lev: So we need to focus on modeling that high momentum tail in a way that's actually computationally feasible for our hardware overhead.
Kai: They also laid out the requirement for the exponent of the power law scaling, which is negative zero point four five four five one eight six, which is what you need to know about spatial structure at small distances.
Mira: That exponent confirms that mean field bcs theory underestimates how strongly those interactions diverge at short range.
Lev: So we need to be careful not to assume the simple power law behavior from mean field when we start designing our error correction protocols.
Kai: Overall, this work on "Three-body contact for fermions" provides a solid framework for checking these difficult C three calculations in strongly correlated regimes.
Mira: And they suggest that even though exact answers in the weak coupling limits are hard, there's a path forward by focusing on those large wavevector contributions.
Lev: That path is what we need to follow if we want to build reliable models for these complex interactions on actual chips.
More episodes
- 2603.05137-Classical shadows for non-iid quantum sources
- 2603.23036-Zero-Uncertainty States Relative to Observable Algebras
- 2603.29754-Coherent and dissipative energy transfer in driven open quantum systems: a driven quantum master equation approach
- 2604.01157-Thermal Entanglement and Out-of-Equilibrium Thermodynamics in 1D Bose Gases
- 2604.06410-Directional and correlated optical emission from a waveguide-engineered molecule with local control
- 2604.07214-Quantum Gibbs sampling through the detectability lemma
- 2604.13165-Finite-size Entanglement Certification via Third-Order Local Randomized Measurements
- 2604.18542-Dissipative Preparation of Correlated Quantum States in Dipolar Rydberg Arrays
- 2605.00096-Scalable spin-nematic squeezing in multi-level dipole-interacting Rydberg atom arrays
- 2605.02565-Sample-Based Quantum Diagonalization with Amplitude Amplification