Quantum lower bounds for convex optimization and real matrix-vector query problems
summary
The gist
The paper presents novel quantum lower bounds for convex optimization and real matrix-vector query problems…
In short
The paper establishes super-linear quantum lower bounds for convex optimization and real matrix-vector query problems. It proves that minimizing a convex function requires $ ilde{\Omega}(n)$ queries, matching existing upper bounds, even for quadratic minimization. Furthermore, it develops techniques to show that computing matrix properties like the trace and determinant needs $\Omega(n/\log n)$ queries.
Key concepts
- Quantum Query Complexity
- This measures the minimum number of quantum queries needed by an algorithm to solve a specific problem. The authors show that for convex optimization, this complexity is nearly linear ($ ilde{\Omega}(n)$), meaning quantum algorithms offer only a quadratic speedup over classical methods.
- Determinantal Witness Method
- This is a novel technique used to prove lower bounds. It involves finding a specific mathematical 'witness' whose Fourier transform vanishes on low-rank matrices and which strongly correlates with the function being computed, allowing the authors to bound the required queries.
- Matrix-Vector Query Model
- This formalizes how quantum algorithms interact with an unknown real matrix A. A query allows the algorithm to compute $A|x\rangle$, which is modeled using a discretized phase oracle based on the Fourier transform of the matrix, essential for analyzing query complexity.
- Gradient Oracle Setting
- This setting assumes access to an oracle that provides subgradients of a function $f$. The paper proves no quantum speedup exists here because existing quantum algorithms already use only polynomial ($ ext{poly}(\log n)$) queries to evaluate the evaluation oracle, making the gradient information redundant.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Quantum lower bounds for convex optimization and real matrix-vector query problems · Paper Radio
- Efficient Convex Optimization with Membership Oracles
- Near-Optimal Lower Bounds for Randomized Algorithms in Exact Value Zeroth-Order Convex Optimization
- Convex optimization using quantum oracles
- Quantum algorithms and lower bounds for convex optimization
- Automatic differentiation in machine learning: a survey
- No quantum speedup over gradient descent for non-smooth convex optimization
- Querying a Matrix through Matrix-Vector Products
- The gradient complexity of linear regression
- Quantum query complexity with matrix-vector products
- Quantum Lower Bounds by Polynomials
- Communication Lower Bounds Using Dual Polynomials
- Algebraic/combinatorial proofs of Cayley-type identities for derivatives of determinants and pfaffians
- Smoothed Analysis of the Condition Numbers and Growth Factors of Matrices
The paper
Quantum lower bounds for convex optimization and real matrix-vector query problems · Read on arXiv
Andrew M. Childs
Joint Center for Quantum Information and Computer Science · Department of Computer Science · Institute for Advanced Computer Studies · University of Maryland
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Quantum lower bounds for convex optimization and real matrix-vector query problems".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents novel quantum lower bounds for convex optimization and real matrix-vector query problems, showing that these tasks require super-linear query complexity in terms of the dimension n <ref:2609.056791, nearly matching existing upper bounds.
Kai: Quantum Query Complexity for Optimization The authors establish a lower bound of omega˜(n) for minimizing a convex function over a convex subset using evaluation and membership queries, which is even for quadratic minimization <ref:2609.05679#pg15>.
Mira: This result implies that the best known quantum algorithm achieves at most quadratic speedup over the best known classical algorithm up to log factors <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Kai: Furthermore, in the gradient oracle setting, no quantum speedup is known because algorithms work by computing a (sub)gradient using poly(log n) queries <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Quantum lower bounds for convex optimization and real matrix-vector query problems," and it's about setting some really high bars on how fast these things can be solved on a quantum computer.
Mira: It looks like the authors are tackling two main areas: minimizing convex functions and these matrix-vector query problems, specifically focusing on lower bounds.
Lev: Lower bounds sound intense when you think about what that actually means for building hardware, because it tells you the absolute minimum number of queries needed to solve something.
Kai: Exactly. They establish a lower bound of Omega(n) for minimizing a convex function over a convex subset using evaluation and membership queries, which is even true for quadratic minimization using matrix-vector queries <ref:2609.05679#pg15>.
Mira: That's significant because it implies that the best known quantum algorithm achieves at most quadratic speedup over the best known classical algorithm up to log factors <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Lev: Quadratic speedup means that if a classical computer needs n squared operations, the quantum one is at most n squared over some logarithmic corrections.
Kai: And in the gradient oracle setting, they say no quantum speedup is known because algorithms work by computing a subgradient using poly(log n) queries to an evaluation oracle using Jordan’s gradient estimation algorithm <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Mira: That means the added benefit of a gradient oracle isn't translating into any known quantum advantage for optimization, which is a key point they're making.
Lev: It sounds like the complexity in that setting just stays at that poly(log n) level for both sides, classical and quantum <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Kai: And when you look at optimization over a fixed unit ball, the lower bound still holds at Omega(n) <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Mira: Now let's move to the matrix operations part of this paper, which looks pretty deep. They develop techniques to lower bound quantum query complexity in the matrix-vector model over the reals <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Lev: The specific results they prove there are for computing things like the trace and the determinant <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Kai: They show an Omega(n/log n) lower bound for computing just the trace <ref:2609.05679#pg19>, and an Omega(n) lower bound for computing the sign of the determinant <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Mira: Then they show that computing the magnitude of the determinant requires Omega(n/log n) queries to achieve an additive error epsilon n <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Lev: So they're getting down to things like invertibility and matrix inversion, which is a big deal for solving systems of equations.
Kai: They extend these results to matrix inversion, proving an Omega(n/log n) lower bound for computing the first column of the inverse of an invertible matrix A <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Mira: This hardness extends to positive definite matrices, which implies that quadratic optimization requires Omega(n/log n) quantum matrix-vector queries <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Lev: That means even for the quadratic case, where we have a clean linear-algebraic description, you still need that n over log n complexity for the inversion part <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Kai: The technique they use to prove these bounds is called the determinantal witness method <ref:2609.05679#pg19>. It's based on identifying a witness whose Fourier transform vanishes on low-rank matrices and that correlates well with the function being computed <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Mira: That sounds clever because it replaces polynomial degree with matrix rank and orthogonality to low-degree polynomials by the vanishing of a certain measure on low-rank Fourier components <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Lev: The method constructs dual witnesses that satisfy the conditions of Lemma three point three, leading to lower bounds based on the correlation between the witness and the decision function <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Kai: They also formalized this model by discretizing real numbers with arbitrarily high precision, demanding success for every admissible A <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Mira: This discretization is crucial because it lets them study the complexity as a function of dimension n, focusing on algorithms that are independent of n when the output error epsilon is small <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Lev: The technical detail about how they define a matrix-vector query as a discretized version of Eq. (two) is important for understanding the model setup <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Kai: They show that a single matrix-vector query to A can be used to implement a matrix-vector query to AT, or the inverse of such a query, using one matrix-vector query to A <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Mira: That's interesting because they are showing that the structure of the matrix itself dictates this lower bound on inversion complexity <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Lev: And for optimization, Corollary six point eight suggests that the quantum query complexity of quadratic minimization—and therefore general convex optimization—is Omega(n/log n) <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Kai: So to summarize, this paper proves that for these problems, you're facing a lower bound of Omega(n) and nearly linear bounds on matrix operations like trace and determinant when using the determinantal witness method <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Mira: The main implication is that while we have quantum algorithms with some speedup, they don't beat the classical complexity in these fundamental settings, up to quadratic speedup <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Lev: It settles a lot of the open questions from earlier work on this matrix-vector query model <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Kai: For future work, they suggest looking into rank testing and applying these lower bound techniques to problems outside the matrix-vector query model <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Mira: It's a solid piece of work because it rigorously sets the limits on what quantum computation can do in these specific, fundamental settings for convex optimization and matrix math <ref:2609.05679#pg1>.
Lev: I think the core message is that even with quantum tools, you still need a significant number of queries to tackle these problems when you're dealing with real matrices <ref:2609.05679#pg19>.
Kai: It shows us exactly where the difficulty lies in using quantum query complexity to solve these tasks <ref:2609.05679#pg1>.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, this paper, "Quantum lower bounds for convex optimization and real matrix-vector query problems," essentially sets new minimum query counts for two big problems using quantum computers on a real matrix setup.
Mira: Right, so they are showing that minimizing a convex function over a set of vectors requires at least Omega of n queries, even in the quadratic case.
Lev: That means no matter how clever the quantum algorithm is, you need that many queries just to get the answer for optimization problems like this.
Kai: And they aren't stopping there; they also lower bound how many matrix-vector queries you need to calculate things like the trace or even the sign of a determinant.
Mira: That’s important because it links these fundamental math operations directly to quantum query complexity in a way that was hard to pin down before.
Lev: The main technique they use is this "determinantal witness method" which identifies special matrices whose Fourier transform vanishes on low-rank components, which then correlates with the function we're trying to compute.
Kai: That method lets them replace ideas about polynomial degree with ideas about matrix rank and how well a certain measure aligns with the function being computed.
Mira: It’s a really neat way to prove these lower bounds because it ties the structure of low-rank matrices into the complexity of the computation directly.
Lev: They also proved this hardness for inverting matrices, showing that you need Omega of n over log n queries just to find one column of an invertible matrix A.
Kai: That’s a concrete number, so it shows that even with a quadratic speedup possible in some scenarios, you still face this linear hurdle for inversion.
Mira: So what this really means for the world is that these lower bounds are nearly matching the best known upper bounds we have right now for these tasks.
Lev: That’s the key point; it suggests that those algorithms three and four are pretty close to being optimal, only hitting a quadratic speedup over classical methods up to some logarithmic factors.
Kai: It also confirms what we already suspected about gradient oracles; no known quantum speedup exists in that setting because you only need poly log n queries for the subgradient.
Mira: So this paper solidifies the idea that for these specific problems, we can't just throw more qubits at it and expect a massive speedup beyond quadratic.
Lev: The focus now shifts to where they stop working, which is proving things outside of this matrix-vector query model, which is a natural next step for future research.
Kai: So while the bounds are tight for what they studied, the real question now becomes whether we can apply these ideas to other kinds of computational problems.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So, this paper isn't just about setting these lower bounds; it suggests some ways to make the whole thing more robust or applicable in different settings.
Kai: Right, they point out that we need to look at rank testing now because those are related ideas, and also how to apply these lower bound techniques to problems that aren't just the matrix-vector query model.
Mira: That makes sense because the current analysis is very specific about how we model real numbers with discretization, so expanding that scope is a big move for the theory.
Lev: If they can successfully apply their witness method to broader problems, it means we might be able to set even more realistic performance expectations for quantum hardware.
Kai: They’re showing that even though the bounds are high, they aren't just theoretical limits; they give us a clear picture of what kind of query complexity we really have to deal with.
Mira: The implication is that it helps researchers decide which specific quantum algorithms are actually worth pursuing for these optimization tasks.
Lev: For hardware guys like me, knowing the exact query complexity helps us figure out if our error correction overhead is actually helping us get closer to those theoretical limits or just adding noise.
Kai: It seems they’re trying to bridge that gap between the high-level math and what we’re actually building on superconducting qubits.
Mira: It suggests that for the next phase, we should focus on how these bounds change when you move away from real matrices into other algebraic structures.
Lev: That moves us toward understanding how query complexity behaves in different mathematical environments, which is crucial for error correction design.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up on "Quantum lower bounds for convex optimization and real matrix-vector query problems," we’re seeing that these quantum algorithms don't actually offer a speedup over the best classical ones in these core settings, at most quadratic speedup.
Mira: Exactly, it confirms that even with the power of quantum computation, you still need those Omega of n queries for optimization and matrix inversion.
Lev: For our side of things, it means we can set more realistic targets for how hard these problems are to solve on actual hardware where we have finite precision.
Kai: It’s a bit sobering that the gradient oracle setting doesn't show any known quantum speedup either, just poly log n queries for the subgradient calculation.
Mira: That’s a limitation they clearly state; it means adding a gradient oracle doesn't magically unlock massive quantum advantages in optimization yet.
Lev: The method they use, the determinantal witness method, is clever because it connects the function we need to compute directly to low-rank matrix properties via Fourier transforms.
Kai: It’s a solid piece of work because it rigorously proves these limits using a model where real numbers are discretized with arbitrary high precision.
Mira: That discretization is key; it lets them focus on the dimension n dependence without getting bogged down in the messy details of continuous real analysis.
Lev: I think for error correction, this level of lower bound clarity is exactly what we need to plan out our resource requirements for these complex tasks.
Kai: It settles a lot of the open questions from previous work on this matrix-vector query model, giving us solid numbers to work with now.
Mira: So moving forward, the real challenge is figuring out how to apply these kinds of lower bound techniques to problems that fall outside this specific matrix-vector query model.
Lev: That’s where the next big research direction lies; pushing those ideas into other mathematical domains will be important for building more general quantum solvers.
More episodes
- 2603.29754-Coherent and dissipative energy transfer in driven open quantum systems: a driven quantum master equation approach
- 2604.01157-Thermal Entanglement and Out-of-Equilibrium Thermodynamics in 1D Bose Gases
- 2604.06410-Directional and correlated optical emission from a waveguide-engineered molecule with local control
- 2604.07214-Quantum Gibbs sampling through the detectability lemma
- 2604.13165-Finite-size Entanglement Certification via Third-Order Local Randomized Measurements
- 2604.18542-Dissipative Preparation of Correlated Quantum States in Dipolar Rydberg Arrays
- 2605.00096-Scalable spin-nematic squeezing in multi-level dipole-interacting Rydberg atom arrays
- 2605.02565-Sample-Based Quantum Diagonalization with Amplitude Amplification
- 2605.20111-Mechanism of wavefunction collapse in measurements of separated quantum subsystems
- 2606.05097-No-Go Theorem for Gaussian Quantum Repeaters from Fractional Extendibility