Hyperfine spectroscopy and nuclear spin control of dark defects in diamond
summary
The gist
Zero-field identification and control of hydrogen-related electron-nuclear spin registers in diamond establishes a framework to harness previously unknown electron-nuclear defects for quantum…
In short
Researchers used zero-field electron spin resonance (ZF-DEER) and nuclear-electron-electron triple resonance (NEETR) to characterize unknown defects in diamond. They identified two defects, X1 and X2, linking them to hydrogen and nitrogen impurities using density functional theory (DFT). This work establishes a framework for controlling electron and nuclear spins in these defects for quantum applications.
Key concepts
- ZF-DEER
- This technique uses zero magnetic field to measure the statistical spin polarization of individual defects. It helps researchers detect unknown spin defects by measuring their hyperfine components, which are tiny energy splittings caused by the interaction between the electron and its surrounding nuclear spins.
- NEETR
- This protocol involves a nuclear-electron-electron triple resonance sequence used to detect and control the host nuclear spin. By performing polarization transfer between electronic spins using this sequence, researchers can initialize and read out the state of the defect's nucleus.
- DFT Matching
- Density functional theory (DFT) calculations are used to assign atomic structures to experimental defects. The calculated hyperfine components are compared against measured values; a close match confirms the proposed atomic structure, leading to the identification of new defect types like MIT1.
- Nuclear Coherence Time (T2)
- This measures how long the nuclear spin state remains stable and controllable. The paper uses specific fitting models to extract intrinsic coherence times from measured signals, showing that both identified defects have long-lived coherence times suitable for quantum memory applications.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Hyperfine spectroscopy and nuclear spin control of dark defects in diamond · Paper Radio
- Entanglement-Enhanced Nanoscale Single-Spin Sensing
The paper
Hyperfine spectroscopy and nuclear spin control of dark defects in diamond · Read on arXiv
Alexander Ungar, Hao Tang, Andrew Stasiuk, Bo Xing, Boning Li, Ju Li, Alexandre Cooper, Paola Cappellaro
Massachusetts Institute of Technology Research Laboratory of Electronics Massachusetts Institute of Technology Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science Massachusetts Institute of Technology Department of Materials Science and Engineering Massachusetts Institute of Technology Department of Nuclear Science and Engineering Quantum Innovation Centre Agency for Science, Technology and Research Singapore University Waterloo Institute for Quantum Computing
Spin defects in diamond serve as powerful building blocks for quantum technologies, especially for quantum sensing and networking. Electron-nuclear defects formed near optically active spins such as the nitrogen-vacancy center provide a resource for multi-qubit quantum registers. However, many remain uncharacterized, limiting their control and integration in quantum devices. Here, we identify the hyperfine components, including their relative sign, and nuclear spin species of two unknown dark spin defects using zero-field double electron-electron resonance spectroscopy and a protocol based on electron-nuclear double resonance. New ab initio calculations assign one defect to a known nitrogen interstitial, while the hydrogen-related defect matches no calculated or previously reported structure. We further use this protocol to demonstrate initialization, unitary control, and long-lived coherence of the hydrogen nuclear spin qubit, with a coherence time of 1.0(3) ms. These characterization and control tools establish a framework for harnessing unknown electron-nuclear defects for quantum registers.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Hyperfine spectroscopy and nuclear spin control of dark defects in diamond".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Zero-field identification and control of hydrogen-related electron-nuclear spin registers in diamond establishes a framework to harness previously unknown electron-nuclear defects for quantum register applications Characterization Methodology The researchers applied two hybrid electron-nuclear spin control schemes, specifically double electron-electron resonance at zero field (ZF-DEER) and a nuclear-electron-electron triple resonance (NEETR) protocol, to self-consistently characterize unknown spin defects at the singlespin level The ZF-DEER technique was leveraged to detect the statistical spin polarization of individual defects, overcoming limitations of conventional EPR at low field They determined the hyperfine components for two unknown defects, X1 and X2, by measuring the ZF-DEER spectrum with a swept microwave frequency around each defect’s hyperfine splitting The resulting components were found to be A∥,1 = 39(1) and A⊥,1 = 25(1) MHz for X1, and A∥,2 = 16(1) and A⊥,2 = 6(1) MHz for X2 Defect Identification via DFT The experimental results were matched to density functional theory (DFT) calculations to assign atomic structures to each defect This process led to the identification of a previously unknown hydrogen-related defect structure named MIT1 for X1 and a match to a previously identified nitrogen-related defect WAR9 for X2 The DFT calculations, using HSE06 hybrid functional, showed that the calculated hyperfine components were estimated to have an accuracy of 20% of the reported experimental values Nuclear Spin Identification and Control The nuclear-electron-electron triple resonance (NEETR) sequence was introduced to detect and control the defect’s host nuclear spin through stronger electronic spin interaction The NEETR protocol performed polarization transfer between the NV and X electronic spins using a Hartmann-Hahn Cross Polarization (HHCP) sequence to initialize and read out the X electronic spin state For X1, the NEETR signal revealed nuclear spin resonance frequencies with a splitting consistent with the hydrogen gyromagnetic ratio, supporting its assignment as a hydrogen-related defect Conversely, for X2, the resonances showed a splitting consistent with the 15N gyromagnetic ratio, confirming it as nitrogen-related Quantum Control and Coherence Demonstration The NEETR sequence was extended to demonstrate initialization, unitary control, and long-lived coherence of the hydrogen nuclear spin qubit with T2 = 1.0(3) ms For X1, universal control was achieved by applying the NEETR sequence with an RF pulse tuned to either the ωn± frequencies to implement a selective nuclear spin rotation conditioned on the electronic spin state The coherence measurements for the X2 nitrogen nuclear spin showed T∗2 = 150(30) µs and T2 = 1.0(3) ms, highlighting its potential as a robust quantum memory Self-Consistent Validation The measurements for the hyperfine components and nuclear spin resonances were shown to be self-consistent using least-squares minimization The convergence to a near-zero value for both defects confirms agreement between measured hyperfine components and assigned nuclear spin species, supporting the identification of X1 as hydrogen (1H) and X2 as nitrogen (15N) The total error for X2 residuals was much smaller than for X1, indicating that the hyperfine interaction is close to uniaxial symmetry Future Applications The discovery of the new defect structure, together with the control of both its electron and nuclear spins, sets the stage for integrating other hydrogen-related defects into hybrid quantum registers This approach can be extended to other ion-implanted diamond samples and wide-bandgap materials to accelerate new defect characterizations The long-lived nuclear spin qubit can be used as an effective ancilla for enhanced sensing schemes such as quantum non-demolition (QND) repetitive readout The diamond sample used was a single crystal chemical vapor deposition (CVD) diamond with 100 µm-thick layer of isotopically enriched 99.999% 12C grown on top of a substrate The sample was implanted with 15N ions through circular apertures at an energy of 14 keV and dose of 10 13 cm−2, resulting in NV centers approximately 20 nm from the surface NV center measurements were performed using a home-built confocal microscope setup with a green excitation laser and detection via a single photon counting module Data Analysis Details Each resonance in the DEER spectrum was fit to a single-Lorentzian function with four free parameters The ZF-DEER time traces were fit to an exponentially decaying cosine function with an additional linear baseline offset to account for background decay The coherence measurements were fitted to exponentially decaying cosine functions with a fixed additional decay term to account for electronic spin relaxation The total decay rate of the coherence signal is equal to the sum of all three individual decoherence rates: 1/T = ΓBath + ΓSPAM + 1/2T e 1 The intrinsic nuclear spin coherence times are extracted from the measured signal by fitting to an exponentially decaying cosine function with time constant T = (1/T∗2 + 3/2T e 1)−1 Both defects exhibit long-lived nuclear coherence times, making them promising candidates for electron-nuclear registers DFT Search Space The DFT calculations explored different combinations of hydrogen and nitrogen substitutional and interstitial defects with one or two vacancies at positions up to the 8th-nearest neighbor site The calculated components of the hyperfine matrix for each defect were listed in Table S1, highlighting defects which matched experimental observations The calculation accuracy was estimated to be within 20% of the reported values The authors successfully demonstrated how the nuclear-electronelectron triple resonance (NEETR) protocol provides a combined characterization and control solution for harnessing previously unknown electron-nuclear spin defects at room temperature They identified a new hydrogen-related defect structure called MIT1 and matched X2 to the known WAR9 defect, confirming their assignments through self-consistent experimental sequences and ab initio calculations The discovery of the new defect structure, together with the control of both its electron and nuclear spins, sets the stage for integrating other hydrogen-related defects into hybrid quantum registers Control Fidelity Assessment The total nuclear polarization was estimated as pn = 0.6(1) after N = 3 repetitions of the initialization sequence, suggesting an electron-nuclear SWAP fidelity of F2 ≈ 0.85 The coherence measurements for both X1 hydrogen and X2 nitrogen spins highlight how the approach can be scaled to construct larger nuclear-spin registers surrounding a central NV spin without being limited by the direct NV-nuclear coupling The measured coherence times for both defects are comparable, suggesting their utility in hybrid quantum registers Final Assignment Confirmation The self-consistent results of the two sets of measurements confirm that the characterization of the hyperfine interaction and the nuclear spin species are both accurate and provide a valid reference for DFT calculations The total error for X2 residuals was much smaller than for X1, indicating that X2 is better approximated by a uniaxially symmetric hyperfine tensor This clear assignment allows for the development of predictable control tools for scaling to larger networks of electron-nuclear defects consisting of hydrogen and nitrogen impurities Technical Implementation The hardware setup involved a home-built confocal microscope, a 520 nm pulsed diode laser for green excitation, and microwave/RF pulse generation using an OPX+ system The NV and X microwave signals were amplified using specific RF power amplifiers and delivered via a custom-designed two-channel Cu coplanar waveguide (CPW) Measurement acquisition involved processing NV fluorescence data into "NV signal" traces by performing differential measurements across four traces The data analysis involved fitting resonances to single-Lorentzian functions and time traces to exponentially decaying cosine functions Coherence Limits The total decay rate of the coherence signal is equal to the sum of all three individual decoherence rates: 1/T = ΓBath + ΓSPAM + 1/2T e 1 The intrinsic nuclear spin coherence times are extracted from the measured signal by fitting to an exponentially decaying cosine function with time constant T = (1/T∗2 + 3/2T e 1)−1 The estimated X1 hydrogen spin coherence times are reported in the main text, and the X2 nitrogen spin coherence times are reported above The significant improvement from T∗2 to T2 by refocusing with the echo suggests that dephasing is dominated by interactions from slowly varying magnetic fields Table Summary Table S1 lists the DFT calculations of the hyperfine matrix A, showing principal values and principal directions for various defect structures Defects which match experimental observations are highlighted in bold The calculated components have an estimated accuracy to within 20% of the reported values This table provides a detailed comparison between calculated and experimental NV− hyperfine components Supplementary Information Supplementary Information includes estimates for measurement uncertainty due to the geomagnetic field, where the total uncertainty for each resonance was estimated at ±√ 0.7 squared + 0.2 squared, leading to an uncertainty in the hyperfine components of ∆A ≈ 1 MHz It also details ZF-DEER measurements on additional defects, suggesting that some resonances belong to spectrally unstable defects like X3 The analysis showed that both X1 and X2 have a maximum of two distinguishable transitions at zero field, suggesting both defects are approximately uniaxial The analysis also showed that the observable transitions with the DEER sequence would include ω1, ω2, ω4, and ω5 for a total of four spectral dips The analysis confirmed that the measurements for zero-field DEER and NEETR are self-consistent The final signal can then be calculated as S−(τ) = 1/4 (1 + cos (πdzzτ)) The analysis confirmed the assignment of the nuclear spin species for X2 as nitrogen-related based on its resonance splitting The total relative error for X2 reached a global minimum of ϵ = 0.019 (90 kHz), indicating the hyperfine interaction is close to uniaxial The calculated components for the new V-CH-V0 structure were consistent with the values for both X1 and other EPR-detected defects in Ref.
38: This indicates both are likely the same defect consisting of the newly discovered V-CH-V0 structure here called MIT1 The matching N0I defect was identified as the WAR9 structure characterized in Ref.
47: This clear assignment for both defects allows us to confidently resolve any ambiguity in the their composition and molecular structure Author Contributions Alexander Ungar designed and carried out the experiments, led the theoretical modeling for the experimental results, analyzed the data, and wrote the manuscript Hao Tang performed the DFT calculations, making the discovery of the MIT1 structure Alexandre Cooper designed the experimental setup, performed preliminary measurements characterizing the defects, and helped conceive the idea for the electron-nuclear register Competing Interests The authors declare no competing interests The work of A.S.
Kai: was supported by the NSF Grant No.
Title and authors: Mira: The paper, "Hyperfine spectroscopy and nuclear spin control of dark defects in diamond," summarizes how they used a combination of zero-field double electron electron resonance, or ZF DEER, and the nuclear electron electron triple resonance protocol called NEETR.
Kai: They used these techniques to self-consistently characterize previously unassigned defects at the single spin level by determining their hyperfine components and host nuclear spin species.
Lev: Essentially, they combine zero field double electron electron resonance with NEETR to accurately determine a defect’s hyperfine components and host nuclear spin species.
Mira: They used ZF DEER to detect the statistical spin polarization of individual defects, which helps overcome limitations of conventional electron spin resonance at low field.
Kai: They then determined the hyperfine components for two unknown defects, Xone and Xtwo by measuring the ZF DEER spectrum with a microwave frequency swept around each defect’s hyperfine splitting.
Lev: The resulting components found were A parallel one for Xone was thirty-nine one percent and perpendicular one was twenty-five one percent in megahertz, and similar values for defect Xtwo <ref:2510.19598#pg2>.
Mira: These experimental results were then matched to density functional theory calculations to assign atomic structures to each defect, leading to the identification of a new hydrogen-related structure called MIT1 for Xone.
Kai: And they also matched Xtwo to an existing nitrogen-related defect called WAR9, which they confirmed through self consistent experimental sequences and ab initio calculations.
Lev: The DFT calculations showed that the calculated hyperfine components were estimated to have an accuracy of twenty percent of the reported experimental values.
Mira: Furthermore, they introduced the NEETR sequence to detect and control the defect’s host nuclear spin through stronger electronic spin interaction.
Kai: The NEETR protocol performed polarization transfer between the NV and X electronic spins using a Hartmann Hahn cross polarization sequence to initialize and read out the X electronic spin state.
Lev: For Xone the NEETR signal revealed nuclear spin resonance frequencies with a splitting consistent with the hydrogen gyromagnetic ratio, supporting its assignment as a hydrogen-related defect.
Mira: Conversely, for Xtwo those resonances showed a splitting consistent with the fifteen nitrogen gyromagnetic ratio, confirming it as nitrogen-related.
Kai: The NEETR sequence was extended to demonstrate initialization and unitary control of the hydrogen nuclear spin qubit with a T two of one point zero three milliseconds.
Lev: For Xone universal control was achieved by applying the NEETR sequence with an RF pulse tuned to either omega n plus or omega n minus frequencies to implement selective nuclear spin rotation conditioned on the electronic spin state.
Mira: The coherence measurements for the Xtwo nitrogen nuclear spin showed a T star two of one hundred fifty point three microseconds and a T two of one point zero three milliseconds, highlighting its potential as a robust quantum memory.
The paper's summary: Kai: This paper suggests several improvements to their approach, mainly focusing on how the AI system could automate the defect characterization process.
Mira: They propose developing an AI system for automated defect characterization that utilizes zero-field electron spin resonance measurements to extract hyperfine components from unknown defects at the single spin level.
Lev: This AI system would perform extraction of hyperfine components and host nuclear spin species by analyzing the zero field DEER spectrum with a variable tau.
Kai: That sounds like it would be a big step, moving beyond manual fitting into an automated way to handle these unknown defects.
Mira: It could also create a quantum control module for defect qubits that implements the NEETR protocol to achieve deterministic control and identification of the host nuclear spin.
Lev: This quantum control module would allow the AI system to perform initialization, unitary control, and long-lived coherence of hydrogen nuclear spin qubits with T two of one point zero three milliseconds.
Kai: So if we get that kind of a module, we can finally have reliable control over these defect qubits at room temperature.
Mira: They also suggest an AI structure assignment engine that uses density functional theory calculations to match experimental hyperfine components to atomic structures, leading to the identification of new defect types like MIT1.
Lev: This engine would assign atomic structures to each defect by comparing calculated components with experimental data and DFT results.
Kai: That links the lab work directly back into the theoretical predictions, which is always a good thing when you're trying to understand these things.
The paper's improvements: Mira: So wrapping up, this paper shows how identifying and controlling these dark defects using hyperfine spectroscopy and nuclear spin control can be done at room temperature.
Kai: It confirms that the combination of ZF DEER and NEETR provides a combined characterization and control solution for harnessing previously unknown electron nuclear spin defects.
Lev: The discovery of the new defect structure, together with the control of both its electron and nuclear spins, sets the stage for integrating other hydrogen-related defects into hybrid quantum registers.
Mira: This approach can be extended to other ion implanted diamond samples and wide bandgap materials to accelerate new defect characterizations.
Kai: The long lived nuclear spin qubit can be used as an effective ancilla for enhanced sensing schemes such as quantum nondemolition quantum readout.
Lev: The total decay rate of the coherence signal is equal to one over T equals gamma bath plus gamma SPAM plus one over two T e one, and intrinsic nuclear spin coherence times are extracted by fitting to an exponentially decaying cosine function with a time constant T equals one over t star two plus three over two t e one minus one.
Kai: Both defects exhibit long lived nuclear coherence times, making them promising candidates for electron nuclear registers.
Conclusion: Mira: Overall, the discovery of MIT1 and the control of both electron and nuclear spins is a significant step in understanding these dark defects in diamond.
Kai: It's not just about finding new structures; it’s about building a framework for integrating other hydrogen-related defects into hybrid quantum registers.
Lev: If you can do this, you can use these long lived nuclear spin qubits as effective ancilla for enhanced sensing schemes like quantum nondemolition readout.
Mira: We need to look at how they plan to scale this up beyond just a few defects in the sample.
Kai: The real test will be seeing if we can build that kind of infrastructure reliably on real hardware, not just in theory.
More episodes
- 2603.29754-Coherent and dissipative energy transfer in driven open quantum systems: a driven quantum master equation approach
- 2604.01157-Thermal Entanglement and Out-of-Equilibrium Thermodynamics in 1D Bose Gases
- 2604.06410-Directional and correlated optical emission from a waveguide-engineered molecule with local control
- 2604.07214-Quantum Gibbs sampling through the detectability lemma
- 2604.13165-Finite-size Entanglement Certification via Third-Order Local Randomized Measurements
- 2604.18542-Dissipative Preparation of Correlated Quantum States in Dipolar Rydberg Arrays
- 2605.00096-Scalable spin-nematic squeezing in multi-level dipole-interacting Rydberg atom arrays
- 2605.02565-Sample-Based Quantum Diagonalization with Amplitude Amplification
- 2605.20111-Mechanism of wavefunction collapse in measurements of separated quantum subsystems
- 2606.05097-No-Go Theorem for Gaussian Quantum Repeaters from Fractional Extendibility