From Quantum Cryptography to Intuitionism and beyond: relativity, many-worlds and non-locality
summary
The gist
From Quantum Cryptography to Intuitionism and beyond: This paper develops an idea on creation of new information at a limited rate and explores how "indeterminacy is relative" to illuminate the…
In short
The paper explores how indeterminacy is relative to reconcile relativity and non-locality. It suggests that new information is created at a limited rate, linking intuitionistic mathematics with classical physics and quantum phenomena. This framework offers a way to understand correlations without invoking spooky action at a distance.
Key concepts
- Finite Information Quantities (FIQs)
- This concept suggests that many features of quantum physics can be explained by indeterministic classical physics if we limit the information density in space or phase space. It posits that physical quantities are not infinitely defined simultaneously, aligning with the idea that information appears sequentially over time.
- Intuitionistic Real Numbers
- These numbers are described as digits appearing one after another as time passes, rather than being fully present at once. This view suggests that classical mathematics is viewed from the end of time, where everything settles into determinate values sequentially.
- Relativity of Indeterminacy
- This idea argues that facts are relative to a space-time location within a relativistic context, not just observers. It explains non-locality by treating correlations as conditional propensities that depend on where the measurement occurs in space-time, avoiding spooky action at a distance.
- Classical Collapse
- In chaotic classical systems, this refers to nature making choices—like picking a hot or cold day—as time progresses. This actualization process resolves initial small indeterminacy into large outcomes, showing how determinism emerges through sequential choices.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- From Quantum Cryptography to Intuitionism and beyond: relativity, many-worlds and non-locality · Paper Radio
- Creative and geometric times in physics, mathematics, logic, and philosophy
- Naturalistic intuitionism for physics
- The Multiverse Pandemic
- The equivalence of local-realistic and no-signalling theories
- Proposed experiments for detecting contextual hidden variables
The paper
From Quantum Cryptography to Intuitionism and beyond: relativity, many-worlds and non-locality · Read on arXiv
University of Geneva · Constructor University, Bremen
After a recollection of some of my encounters with Gilles Brassard, on the occasion of his 70th birthday I present, first, a new idea on creation of new information at a limited rate. Next, I develop the idea that "indeterminacy is relative" [Entropy 23 1326 (2021)] and how this illuminates the compatibility between relativity and non-locality.
DOI: 10.3390/e28111178
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "From Quantum Cryptography to Intuitionism and beyond".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. From Quantum Cryptography to Intuitionism and beyond: This paper develops an idea on creation of new information at a limited rate and explores how "indeterminacy is relative" to illuminate the compatibility between relativity and non-locality Foundational Concepts The author introduces the idea that many quantum features are already present in indeterministic classical physics For instance, the need of an interpretation is equally present in classical mechanics if one rejects infinite information density in space (or in phase space) When contemplating indeterministic classical mechanics, one is tempted to search for additional hidden variables, a feature the author used to think typical of quantum theory The concept of "Finite Information Quantities" (FIQs) was invented initially with the close collaborator Flavio Del Santo Intuitionistic real numbers are described as numbers where the digits do not appear all at once but instead appear one after the other, as in a process that occurs as time processes This view suggests that classical mathematics is intuitionistic mathematics seen from the end of time once everything settled to well determinate values and nothing new happens The Role of Time and Information In intuitionistic mathematics, the law of the excluded middle does not hold, meaning propositions about future quantum measurement outcomes have presently no truth value This perfectly reflects the physical fact that future quantum measurement outcomes have presently no values Classical logic asserts both the law of the excluded middle and that the truth value of a proposition never changes if it is true at some time t This contradicts standard classical physics, creating tension with classical timeless mathematics The question arises when indeterminate quantities gain determinacy, such as the temperature in Geneva in 10 years A first possible answer suggests that the quantity gains determinacy when some agent performs a measurement more precise than the determinacy of the measured quantity This leads to the measurement problem, questioning when physical quantities gain determinacy or when potentialities actualize Indeterminacy and Chaos in Classical Systems In classical mechanics interpreted as an indeterministic theory where all quantities have finite information, the evolution is chaotic, leading to the initial small indeterminacy becoming large The Lorenz chaotic system illustrates this by showing how a small initial bubble splits into different trajectories after some finite time Nature has to make up her mind, choosing either a hot day or a cold day, which is not predetermined randomness but an act of actualization that indicates the now The system continues to process and nature will again have to make choices as time passes If a quantum system is classically chaotic, the quantum analogue produces enormous amount of entanglement requiring about 220 parameters, some of which would be totally undefined with less than 1 bit per parameter Nature would have to produce an enormous amount of information in a very short time if it cannot produce that amount quickly enough Relativity and Non-Locality The paper examines true random number generators (TRNGs) within the framework of special relativity, where time "created" one or several new bits of information A bit produced at the origin of the first light-cone is indeterminate in the entire space-time region outside the future light-cone The proposition “a = 0” has a truth value only inside that light-cone, illustrating the failure of the Law of the Excluded Middle When considering two space-like separated TRNGs, correlation between distant events is non-locality, expressed by the non-factoring joint probability p(a, b)!= p(a) · p(b) The conditional objective probability p(ba) depends on the condition a and is valid only inside the future light-cone of the TRNG producing a This relativity of indeterminacy suggests that non-locality does not imply spooky action at a distance because local propensities never change until they turn into local facts or gain new information The most counter-intuitive picture is when there is no actualization on Bob’s side, in which case the propensity of b remains 1/2 until Bob’s TRNG enters Alice’s future light-cone The paper concludes that facts are relative, but not relative to observers or agents, rather relative to their space-time location in a relativistic context This allows for the consideration of indeterminism in relativity, including correlated indeterminism without spooky action at a distance The main argument is that measurements have outcomes, one and only one outcome per measurement, and Bell non-locality is an empirical fact The other idea expressed here is that nature might be limited in her power to produce fresh information at a limited rate This would have dramatic effects in quantum dynamical systems producing a lot of entanglement, as in those that are classically chaotic Agents and observers are not necessary to do physics, being more than privileged reference frames The tension remains whether a world able to split and recombine local branches with mysterious weights is better than a world full of indeterminacy where things can really happen with non-local correlations References
1: B.
Kai: Huttner, A.
Mira: Muller, J.D.
Kai: Gautier, H.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're diving into Nicolas Gisin's paper, "From Quantum Cryptography to Intuitionism and beyond: relativity, many-worlds and non-locality." We're starting with the title itself. It sounds like it touches on a lot of heavy stuff.
Mira: Yeah, it really does. The title points us toward quantum cryptography, intuitionism—which is this idea about how numbers are created sequentially over time—and then relativity and non-locality. It suggests they're trying to link these seemingly different areas together in some kind of new framework.
Lev: From my side, I'm thinking about what this means for building things on real hardware. If we can model these ideas, does that translate into a more robust way to handle errors?
Kai: Exactly. The paper says the main thrust is developing an idea about creating new information at a limited rate and exploring how indeterminacy itself is relative to illuminate the compatibility between relativity and non-locality. It's trying to bridge what we see in quantum theory with classical physics interpretations, which is where I usually get stuck with my qubits.
Mira: It’s ambitious because it tries to use these different mathematical viewpoints—intuitionistic numbers, for instance—to make sense of the physical reality that involves time and measurement outcomes.
Lev: And the real question for me is how this relates to error correction. If indeterminacy is relative, does that simplify the structure of what we're trying to correct on a physical chip?
The paper's summary: Kai: So, looking at the summary section of "From Quantum Cryptography to Intuitionism and beyond: relativity, many-worlds and non-locality," they introduce a few core ideas. They suggest that many quantum features are actually present in indeterministic classical physics.
Mira: They point to something interesting here: even in classical mechanics, if you reject the idea of infinite information density in space or phase space, you need an interpretation. When we look at that indeterministic classical mechanics, we're tempted to look for hidden variables, which is a feature they think is typical of quantum theory.
Lev: So they're suggesting that the need for an interpretation isn't just a quantum thing; it’s rooted in how we handle information limits in classical systems. That sounds like it could be relevant when we talk about decoherence, maybe?
Kai: It does, because then the question becomes when these physical quantities actually gain determinacy, or when potentialities actualize. The paper frames this as a measurement problem that's really a physics problem, not just a logic issue.
Mira: And they propose that by looking at how time processes information—where new bits are created sequentially—we can model the fact that future quantum measurement outcomes presently have no definite values, which perfectly matches what we see in quantum mechanics.
Lev: So the core summary is linking intuitionistic mathematics, where numbers appear one after the other as time passes, to how classical mechanics behaves when you limit information density. That’s a neat way to frame the tension we see between timeless math and physical measurement.
The paper's improvements: Kai: Now let's talk about what they suggest as improvements in "From Quantum Cryptography to Intuitionism and beyond: relativity, many-worlds and non-locality." They focus on how this framework addresses the issues we discussed earlier.
Mira: They propose that by framing indeterminacy as relative to space-time location, rather than just being a fixed property of a system, they can describe correlated events without needing spooky action at a distance.
Lev: That's interesting because it changes the way we think about non-locality entirely. Instead of needing some mysterious force connecting distant particles instantly, they suggest that local propensities only change once they become local facts or gain new information.
Kai: So, in essence, the improvement is shifting from looking for instantaneous connections to looking at how conditions depend on where you are in space-time. It makes non-locality an empirical fact without invoking those kinds of weird effects.
Mira: They also emphasize the idea that nature might be limited in its power to produce fresh information at a limited rate, which has big implications for quantum systems that create a lot of entanglement through classical chaos.
Lev: If nature is limited in how fast it can generate new information, does that place constraints on the growth of entanglement we see in chaotic quantum systems? That's a concrete thing to test with simulation.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this discussion on "From Quantum Cryptography to Intuitionism and beyond: relativity, many-worlds and non-locality," the paper argues that facts are relative, but not relative to observers or agents, rather relative to their space-time location in a relativistic context.
Mira: They conclude that this allows us to consider indeterminism in relativity, including correlated indeterminism without spooky action at a distance. The main argument they push is that measurements have outcomes, one and only one outcome per measurement, and Bell non-locality is an empirical fact.
Lev: From a hardware perspective, if we accept this view of relative facts in space-time, it means the correlations we see are rooted in the geometry of spacetime itself rather than some external force acting on our qubits.
Kai: It's a big shift for how we interpret quantum foundations. The idea that nature might be limited in its power to produce fresh information at a limited rate has dramatic effects on quantum dynamical systems, especially those producing a lot of entanglement through classical chaos.
Mira: They leave us with the tension between a world that can split and recombine local branches with mysterious weights versus a world full of indeterminacy where things can really happen with non-local correlations. It's a thought-provoking end to this paper.
Lev: I just want to say that accepting this means we have to rethink how we model the noise and uncertainty in our experiments, because everything becomes contextual based on location.
More episodes
- 2603.05137-Classical shadows for non-iid quantum sources
- 2603.23036-Zero-Uncertainty States Relative to Observable Algebras
- 2603.29754-Coherent and dissipative energy transfer in driven open quantum systems: a driven quantum master equation approach
- 2604.01157-Thermal Entanglement and Out-of-Equilibrium Thermodynamics in 1D Bose Gases
- 2604.06410-Directional and correlated optical emission from a waveguide-engineered molecule with local control
- 2604.07214-Quantum Gibbs sampling through the detectability lemma
- 2604.13165-Finite-size Entanglement Certification via Third-Order Local Randomized Measurements
- 2604.18542-Dissipative Preparation of Correlated Quantum States in Dipolar Rydberg Arrays
- 2605.00096-Scalable spin-nematic squeezing in multi-level dipole-interacting Rydberg atom arrays
- 2605.02565-Sample-Based Quantum Diagonalization with Amplitude Amplification