Fractionalized Fermi liquids with the ghost-Gutzwiller Ansatz

summary

The gist

Fractionalized Fermi liquids (FL∗), elusive metallic states characterized by fractionalized quasiparticles alongside conventional ones and defying Luttinger’s theorem…

In short

The ghost-Gutzwiller approximation is used to model fractionalized Fermi liquids (FL*) in the underdoped cuprates, a state defying standard Fermi liquid theory. The approach successfully maps physical operators onto auxiliary ones, yielding a phase diagram featuring FL*, d-wave superconductivity, and conventional Fermi liquid behavior.

Key concepts

Fractionalized Fermi Liquids (FL*)
These are elusive metallic states in cuprates where quasiparticles split into fractionalized components—neutral spinons and conventional electrons. They exhibit hole-like Fermi pockets whose size depends only on doping, unlike standard metals.
Ghost-Gutzwiller Approximation
This is a variational method applied to the t-J model using a 'ghost' wavefunction. It replaces physical operators with auxiliary ones to simplify calculations while respecting the constraint of no double occupancy in the system.
Phase Diagram Features
The resulting phase diagram shows three distinct regions: low-doping FL*, a d-wave superconducting dome, and an overdoped conventional Fermi liquid. This successfully reproduces key experimental features observed in underdoped cuprate materials.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Fractionalized Fermi liquids with the ghost-Gutzwiller Ansatz · Read on arXiv

International School for Advanced Studies (SISSA) · University of Toulouse, Laboratoire de Physique Théorique

Fractionalized Fermi liquids (FL!*), elusive metallic states characterized by fractionalized quasiparticles alongside conventional ones and defying Luttinger's theorem, are prime candidates for the pseudogap regime of underdoped cuprates. We show that a FL!* phase emerges in the single-band t - J model through a simple ghost-Gutzwiller Ansatz, optimized at the cost of a mean-field calculation. The resulting temperature-doping phase diagram encompasses a low-doping FL!*, a d-wave superconducting dome, and an overdoped conventional Fermi liquid, thereby reproducing key qualitative features of cuprate phenomenology.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Fractionalized Fermi liquids with the ghost-Gutzwiller Ansatz".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Fractionalized Fermi liquids (FL∗), elusive metallic states characterized by fractionalized quasiparticles alongside conventional ones and defying Luttinger’s theorem, are prime candidates for the pseudogap regime of underdoped cuprates The resulting temperature-doping phase diagram encompasses a low-doping FL∗, a d-wave superconducting dome, and an overdoped conventional Fermi liquid, thereby reproducing key qualitative features of cuprate phenomenology Model and Variational Ansatz The Hamiltonian of the t-J model is given by H = − X ijσ t ij c†iσcjσ + H.c.

Kai: with J > 0 the exchange coupling between nearest-neighbor spins Si = Pαβ c†iα Sαβ ciβ, S the vector of spin-1/2 matrices, and c†iσ the creation operator for an electron with spin σ at site i The local Hilbert space is constrained by the no-double occupancy condition, and we fix the average occupation number per site to n = 1 − δ, with δ > 0 The Gutzwiller wavefunction is defined as ΨgGut⟩ = ∏P i ψqp⟩, (2) where the uncorrelated ψqp⟩ is, by construction, a Fock state, thus a Slater determinant or BCS wavefunction, so as to leverage Wick’s theorem The parameters defining the wavefunction (2) are optimized by minimizing the ground-state energy within the Gutzwiller approximation (GA), which becomes exact in the limit of infinite lattice coordination Operator Mapping and Renormalization Factors The transmutation of the physical operators into auxiliary ones discussed in Eq.

Mira: (5) is not an operator identity but must be understood as valid inside the expectation value of the physical Hamiltonian (1) over the ghostGutzwiller wavefunction (2) Within the Gutzwiller approximation, this expectation value is obtained by replacing each physical operator with its renormalized auxiliary counterpart and evaluating the result on the uncorrelated Fock state ψqp⟩ The renormalization factors Ra and Qab in Eqs.

Kai: (8) and (11) are fixed by the impurity wavefunction ψimp⟩, so that the variational problem is entirely mapped onto finding the optimal uncorrelated state ψqp⟩ that minimizes the expectation value of the quasiparticle Hamiltonian Entropy Lower Bound The variational free-energy approach leads to an upper bound on the true free energy F ≤ U(ρgGut) − T S(ρgGut) Since the entropy S(ρgGut) cannot be computed exactly within the GA, it is replaced by a lower bound derived from a Golden-Thompson-type trace inequality This leads to the inequality S(ρgGut) ≥ S(ρqp) − X i TrΦ†iΦi ln Q The chain of inequalities establishes that D1/S∞ is bounded from below and above by the exact deficit W0 and the loose estimate W1, i.e., W0 ≤ D1(ρqp, Q)/S∞ ≤ W1 Phase Diagram The resulting temperature-doping phase diagram encompasses a low-doping FL∗, a d-wave superconducting dome, and an overdoped conventional Fermi liquid At low doping the normal state is a fractionalized Fermi liquid (FL∗) with a small, hole-like Fermi surface accounting just for the doped holes The π-flux order parameter ∆π-flux is finite below T∗ ∝ Q21 J ∼ (1 − δ)2 and zero above If superconductivity is prevented, the FL∗ transitions above a critical doping into a conventional FL state characterized by the A-type impurity wavefunction We have demonstrated that the ghostGutzwiller approximation, applied to the single-band t-J model, provides a straightforward variational route to a fractionalized Fermi liquid (FL∗) This phase is characterized by neutral yet spinful quasiparticles coexisting with conventional ones, which form hole-like Fermi pockets whose volume is determined solely by the doping away from half-filling Despite its minimal structure, the Ansatz successfully reproduces the essential qualitative features of the cuprate phase diagram: a FL∗ metal, a d-wave superconducting dome, and an overdoped conventional Fermi liquid with a large Fermi surface The spinons arrange into a π-flux phase, which is gauge equivalent to a d-wave condensate, below a temperature scale T∗ associated with the onset of pseudogap behavior Superconductivity emerges only when the paired spinons acquire physical electron spectral weight through the Gutzwiller projection The flexibility and low cost of the ghost-Gutzwiller Ansatz render it a promising tool for investigating FL∗ and related unexplored phases in multiorbital models of correlated materials Explicit Evaluation in the Two Limiting Cases For the conventional Gutzwiller solution (case A), orbital 2 is doubly occupied and factorizes out, leaving the four-dimensional local space of orbital 1, whose reduced density matrix and variational matrix are both diagonal The distortion term and the infinite-temperature entropy per site thus read D1 N= δ ln 4δ(1 + δ)2−(1 − δ) ln 1 + δ squared, S∞ N=-(1 − δ) ln 1 − δ 2−(1 + δ) ln 1 + δ squared Fractionalized FL∗ Solution Now both orbitals are active: orbital 1 is half-filled and orbital 2 hosts 2 − δ electrons The variational matrix acquires a non-diagonal singlet block, Φ†Φ = 1 − δ 2↑, 2⟩⟨↑, 2 + ↓, 2⟩⟨↓, 2 + δ 2/4(↑,↓),(↓,…),(↓,…), (S55) while the reduced density matrix stays diagonal The distortion term and the infinite-temperature entropy per site thus read D1 N= (1 − δ) ln 2(1 − δ)(1 − δ/2) 2+δ ln 8/ (1 - δ/2), S∞ N=ln 4−(2 − δ) ln 2−δ 2−δ ln delta squared, the latter being the per-site entropy of a half-filled orbital plus an orbital at filling 2 − δ High-Temperature Consistency We can explicitly verify that for both solutions the estimate saturates correctly as T → ∞: subtracting the distortion term from S∞ recovers the exact infinite-temperature entropy of the t-J model at doping δ, S∞ − D1 N=−δ ln δ−(1 − δ) ln 1−δ squared, i.e.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Fractionalized Fermi liquids with the ghost-Gutzwiller Ansatz." The authors are Pasqua, Mejuto-Zaera, and Fabrizio. They're tackling that puzzle around high-temperature cuprate superconductors, specifically the pseudogap regime.

Mira: Exactly. The core idea here is that they show a fractionalized Fermi liquid state emerges in the single band t-J model using a simple ghost Gutzwiller Ansatz, and this state defies Luttinger's theorem.

Lev: It’s interesting that they use this approach to reproduce the key features of the cuprate phase diagram—the low doping FL star, the d wave superconducting dome, and the overdoped conventional Fermi liquid. But we have to remember this is built on a mean field calculation, which is a big assumption.

Kai: Right, so what's their specific claim about what this state actually looks like? They are suggesting these fractionalized quasiparticles coexist with conventional ones in a way that forms hole-like Fermi pockets whose volume only depends on the doping level away from half-filling.

Mira: And they go further by showing that spinons arrange themselves into a pi flux phase, which is gauge equivalent to a d wave condensate, below some temperature scale T star associated with the onset of pseudogap behavior.

Lev: That sounds like it’s linking spin physics to the superconducting pairing in a very specific way. But for real hardware, we have to consider that this whole structure relies on optimizing that uncorrelated Fock state, which they call psiqp>, to minimize the expectation value of the quasiparticle Hamiltonian.

Kai: I wonder how robust this is when you move into something more complex than a single band t-J model. The paper focuses on the two cases, Case A and Case B, showing how different impurity models lead to different things.

Mira: In case A, bath one hybridizes with the impurity forming a spin singlet, which can accommodate doped charge and potentially develop d wave quasiparticle pairing. But in case B, bath one stays half-filled but gets entangled with the impurity in a way that makes the quasiparticle orbital one represent a dispersive spinon that might develop pi flux pairing.

Lev: If we had to run this on real hardware, we'd have to figure out how to implement those specific entanglement structures you described for case B. The paper mentions some renormalization factors, R1 and Q22, which are fixed by the impurity wavefunction in Eq eight and eleven <ref:2607.12410#pg3>.

Paper summary: Kai: So what does that mean practically for us? It suggests that superconductivity only emerges when these paired spinons actually acquire physical electron spectral weight through the Gutzwiller projection.

Mira: That's a crucial point. The flexibility of this ghost-Gutzwiller Ansatz is what makes it a promising tool for investigating these fractionalized Fermi liquid states in multiorbital models of correlated materials.

Lev: It’s promising because it’s relatively low cost, but we still have to deal with the constraints from the Golden-Thompson type trace inequality that sets bounds on the entropy. The paper shows that the chain of inequalities bounds D1 over S infinity between W0 and W1.

Kai: That's a bit abstract for someone who works on qubits, but it tells us that even in this variational approach, there are still inherent limits on how accurately we can estimate the true free energy without knowing the exact entropy.

Mira: So what’s the main implication for understanding cuprates? It reproduces the qualitative features: low doping FL star, d wave dome, and overdoped conventional Fermi liquid. It gives us a picture of how these different regimes connect.

Lev: The paper also explicitly verifies that this estimate saturates correctly as temperature goes to infinity. Subtracting the distortion term from the infinite temperature entropy recovers the exact infinite temperature entropy of the t-J model at doping delta, which is defined by delta empty and one minus delta singly occupied sites.

Kai: That saturation check is good because it confirms that even though we’re using an approximation, our high-temperature reference point matches what we expect from the full model. But I’m still curious about those specific numbers for Case A and Case B in the two limiting cases mentioned on page three <ref:2607.12410#pg3>.

Mira: For case A, the distortion term is D1 N equals one minus delta times ln two times one minus delta times one minus half of delta squared plus delta times ln eight over one minus half of delta, and the infinite temperature entropy per site S infinity N is log four minus two times Delta Times ln two negative half of delta squared negative Delta Times log one plus six over two.

Paper summary: Lev: And for case B, it’s D1 N equals one minus delta times log two times one minus delta times one minus a half of delta squared plus delta times log eight over one minus a half of delta, and S infinity N is log four minus two times Delta Times log two negative half of delta squared negative Delta Times log epsilon squared.

Kai: Those expressions look dense. So what does this all mean for the real world when we're trying to build better materials? It suggests that focusing on these fractionalized quasiparticles, even with a simple Ansatz, might be a good way to map out the phase diagram of underdoped cuprates.

Mira: It suggests that even minimal structural assumptions can reproduce essential phenomenology. The authors show that this approach provides a variational route to a fractionalized Fermi liquid state that is characterized by neutral yet spinful quasiparticles coexisting with conventional ones.

Lev: For us in error correction, the implication is that if we were to try and model this physics on real hardware, we’d need to account for those specific entanglement structures you mentioned for case B when designing the system. The overhead really lands on controlling those spin-entangled states.

Kai: It sounds like this paper lays a good groundwork for what experimentalists should be looking for in the pseudogap regime of cuprates—specifically, these fractionalized metallic states that don't follow standard Luttinger theorem behavior.

Mira: Exactly. The ghost-Gutzwiller Ansatz is a low cost way to get these qualitative features down, and it points toward the importance of spinon arrangements in defining the superconducting dome structure.

Lev: And remember, the paper flags that this approach is optimized at the cost of a mean field calculation. So, while it gives us a picture of what *might* be there, we can’t assume these results hold perfectly without going back to more rigorous treatments.

Kai: It seems like the ghost-Gutzwiller Ansatz is a very flexible tool for exploring these elusive phases, even if it needs further refinement for precise quantitative predictions. That's what this paper offers us right now.

Mira: It does provide a roadmap by reproducing the key qualitative features of cuprate phenomenology, linking the FL star to the superconducting dome through these fractionalized concepts.

Lev: So it’s a useful starting point for theorists, but for experimentalists, it tells them what kind of physics they should be hunting for in those underdoped regimes.

Kai: That’s what we get from this paper today: a solid variational route to understanding the fractionalized Fermi liquid state in cuprates.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve been looking at how Pasqua, Mejuto-Zaera, and Fabrizio used this ghost Gutzwiller Ansatz to map out the phase diagram of cuprates.

Mira: Yeah, the title itself is pretty telling because it points directly to these fractionalized Fermi liquids that aren't standard.

Lev: It’s about finding a metallic state that defies Luttinger’s theorem while still looking like a normal metal in some ways.

Kai: Basically, they show how this simple method can reproduce the key features of the cuprate picture—the low doping state, the superconducting dome, and the overdoped conventional liquid.

Mira: What’s really interesting is that they link this fractionalization directly to spin physics; it suggests spinons arrange themselves into a pi flux phase below some temperature scale T star.

Lev: From my side, that means if we were building hardware for this, we'd have to design systems that can handle those specific entangled states you mentioned.

Kai: So the big picture here is that this approach gives us a variational route to seeing how these different metallic phases connect in cuprates.

Mira: It’s a low-cost way to get these qualitative features down, but it's important to remember it’s an approximation built on specific assumptions about the model.

Lev: That means we need those rigorous treatments later when we try to see if this really holds up when you move beyond the single band t-J model.

Kai: It’s a solid starting point for what experimentalists should be looking for in those underdoped regimes of these materials.

Mira: And it points toward the importance of spinon arrangements in defining the superconducting dome structure.

More episodes

← Home