Viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges to benchmark fluid simulations

summary

The gist

Viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges to benchmark fluid simulations presents semi-analytical solutions for the evolution of temperature and chemical potentials in viscous Gubser flow with…

In short

This work develops semi-analytical solutions for viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges to test fluid simulations. The solutions provide a benchmark for numerical codes like ccake, showing excellent agreement with theoretical results, especially concerning freeze-out hypersurfaces. This validates the approach and helps identify where numerical codes might fail at late times.

Key concepts

Gubser Flow
This describes a type of fluid expansion characterized by specific symmetries (SO(3)q ⊗SU(1, 1)⊗Z2). It models how a system expands transversely while maintaining boost invariance. The flow is naturally described using Milne coordinates, which are hyperbolic coordinates suitable for such expanding systems.
Conserved Charges
These are quantities like baryon number or strangeness that remain constant throughout the fluid evolution. In this flow, the conservation of these charges is independent of the energy-momentum tensor dynamics because there is no diffusion. This independence simplifies the equations of motion for multiple conserved quantities.
Freeze-out Hypersurface
This surface defines a specific point in spacetime where particles stop interacting and form a fluid. It is calculated by setting the energy density to a fixed threshold (EFO). The paper uses this as a new unit test for numerical codes, comparing the predicted surfaces with those from the exact solution.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges to benchmark fluid simulations · Read on arXiv

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

We present semi-analytical solutions for the evolution of both the temperature and chemical potentials for viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges. Such a solution can be especially useful in testing numerical codes intended to simulate relativistic fluids with large chemical potentials. The freeze-out hypersurface profiles for constant energy density are calculated, along with the corresponding normal vectors and presented as a new unit test for numerical codes. We also compare the influence of the equation of state on the semi-analytical solutions. We benchmark the newly developed Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) code CCAKE that includes both shear viscosity and three conserved charges. The numerical solutions are in excellent agreement with the semi-analytical solution and also are able to accurately reproduce the hypersurface at freeze-out.

DOI: 10.1103/v334-d32w

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges to benchmark fluid simulations".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges to benchmark fluid simulations presents semi-analytical solutions for the evolution of temperature and chemical potentials in viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges, which is especially useful for testing numerical codes intended to simulate relativistic fluids with large chemical potentials The freeze-out hypersurface profiles for constant energy density are calculated along with the corresponding normal vectors and presented as a new unit test for numerical codes The numerical solutions are in excellent agreement with the semi-analytical solution and also are able to accurately reproduce the hypersurface at freeze-out Theoretical Framework Gubser flow is characterized by the symmetry group SO(3)q ⊗SU(1, 1)⊗Z2, which describes transversely expanding and boost invariant solutions This system is naturally described in Milne (hyperbolic) coordinates with the metric ds2 = −dτ 2 + dr2 + r squared dϕ squared + τ squared dη squared The conservation of energy and momentum is expressed as DµTµν = 0, where Tµν is the energy-momentum tensor In a hydrodynamic system undergoing Gubser flow, the most general energy-momentum tensor in the Landau frame is given by Tµν = (E + P)uµuν + Pgµν + πµν Conserved Currents and Decoupling A conserved current in a system with no diffusion is simply given by the constitutive relation NµY = nY uµ, where nY is the conserved charge density for the quantity Y Its conservation is expressed as DµNµY = 0, leading to the equation of motion DnY + nY θ = 0 Because the fluid velocity is fixed in Gubser flow, the evolution of the charge density is completely independent of dynamics of the energy-momentum tensor In Gubser flow, the equations of motion for multiple conserved charges are completely independent of each other and without diffusive terms Equation of State Mapping To relate the time evolution of the chemical potential µY to the time evolution of temperature and viscous corrections, we need an equation of state The natural choice of variables for expressing an equation of state in the grand canonical ensemble is that of T, µB, µS, µQ The GibbsDuhem relation E + P = sT + X Y nY µY can be used solve for either s or nY without taking derivatives Numerical Benchmarking The viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges (VGCC) solution provides a benchmark for hydrodynamics codes with conserved charges, such as ccake We benchmark ccake against the semi-analytical solutions presented in this paper We find good numerical agreement between the semi-analytical and numerical solutions, with the largest discrepancy arising from the off-diagonal shear components Freeze-out Analysis The freeze-out hypersurface for Gubser flow can be defined by requiring the energy density be equal to some threshold EFO, i.e, E(τFO, r) = EFO This constraint allows us to define freeze-out time as a function of the radial distance τFO = τFO(r) The normal vectors for the freeze-out surfaces are defined by nµ = ∂µF(τ, r) = ∂F/∂τ τˆ + ∂F/∂r rˆ Comparison with Numerical Code The comparison between the freeze-out hypersurface predicted by ccake and the one calculated by VGCC is made in Fig.

Kai: 5 We see excellent agreement between the two This confirms that our approach to obtaining the hypersurface works well and is numerically accurate The breakdown of hydrodynamics occurs outside of the regime where we expect the system to behave as a fluid The viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges (VGCC) solution provides a benchmark for hydrodynamics codes with conserved charges, such as ccake We show that ccake passed our new Gubser test up until times of τ = τlim ≈ 1.85 fm/c At times after τlim, ccake crashes due to far-from-equilibrium effects that lead to negative entropy in certain SPH particles However, we find that the fluid has already reached the freeze-out temperature by this time such that we can make direct comparisons between the VGCC and ccake hypersurfaces Lastly, we show that ccake can very accurately reproduce the hypersurface generated using via Gubser flow The inclusion of a critical point on the EoS used would help elucidate exactly how a critical point affects the fluid in neighboring regions of the phase diagram Another interesting avenue is the implementation of a Gubser flow solution of relativistic viscous fluids in (3+1)D with conserved charges, which would provide a helpful tool in the context of low and medium beam energies, where the chemical potentials probed are expected to be the largest Appendix Details In Appendix A, diffusion vanishes in Gubser flow because SO(3)q rotational invariance and SO(1, 1) boost invariance forbid any nonzero diffusion current Equation (A3) shows that diffusion vanishes in the time-like direction, even when Dρ(ˆµY /Tˆ) ≠ 0 Transformation Details In Appendix B, we present explicit expressions for the coordinate transformation of the shear stress tensor in Milne coordinates The transformation formula is πµν = −πˆ2τ4 (u2r uxuτ uyuτ 1 + u2x uxuy 1 + u2y −2τ 2) Data Summary Table I summarizes the initial conditions, equation of state, and ccake parameters used The same VGCC parameters and EoS must be used in both the semianalytical solution and in ccake for direct comparisons The inverse Reynolds number R−1 parametrizes how far from equilibrium a hydrodynamic system is Large R−1, in turn, leads to numerical instabilities which can cause the entropy density to become negative Causality violations are manifest at distances of r ≈ 1.5–2.5 fm away from the center and at late times The size of the viscous corrections are also limited by causality

63, 67–69: and stability

47: Key Findings on Profiles The inclusion of conserved charges increases the magnitude of shear stresses in the system, and pushes it further away from equilibrium Away from the core the combined quantity µY nY vanishes quickly such that sT has to compensate to maintain the equality within the Gibbs-Duhem relation shown in Eq.

Mira: (15), leading to the formation of shoulders observed in the entropy density, and consequently, the temperature The blue shaded area marks the region where the energy density falls below the threshold EFO At non-vanishing chemical potential, freeze-out is neither isothermal nor isentropic The entropy density (indicated by the color of the line and the color bar) close to the core is lower than the tails, i.e., freeze-out is no longer isentropic The slope of these realistic EoS trajectories can be connected to a softening of the EoS close to the phase transition such that c 2s(T) reaches a minimum or, in other words, P(E) has a softer slope The conformal system E = 3P and c 2s = 1/3 such that no softening occurs at hadronization and there is no bend in the isentropic trajectories At early times the range of T and µY reached are to the left of the isentropic expansion, reaching lower chemical potentials µY and either hotter or lower temperatures T, depending on the initial conditions The slope of these realistic EoS trajectories can be connected to a softening of the EoS close to the phase transition such that c 2s(T) reaches a minimum or, in other words, P(E) has a softer slope The deviation from isentropes (s/nB), in terms of the passage through the T −µB plane, is significantly more complex due to higher-order terms away from equilibrium Numerical Agreement We see excellent agreement for all variables shown with a very mild deviation of around 1% around the core for the energy density and number density For the xx component of the shear stress tensor, we also observe an increasing deviation of the numerical solution from the semi-analytical one for increasing time, specifically between r = 1 fm and r = 2 fm, with the maximum relative deviations at τ = 1.

Paper summary: Kai: So we've talked about what this paper is trying to achieve—it's using a viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges to give us semi-analytical solutions for temperature and chemical potentials, which they say is useful for testing codes simulating relativistic fluids with large chemical potentials.

Mira: They also calculated freeze-out hypersurface profiles for constant energy density, including the normal vectors, which they call a new unit test for numerical codes.

Lev: The core idea seems to be decoupling the evolution of different conserved charges, which they say is a key feature in Gubser flow when there are no diffusion terms.

Kai: Exactly. They show that for multiple conserved charges like baryon number B, strangeness S, and electric charge Q, the equations of motion are completely independent of each other without diffusive terms.

Mira: But then they point out that the equation of state introduces a mapping from the hydrodynamic variables—like energy density and those conserved densities—into the natural hydrodynamic variables.

Lev: So it’s not just about solving these separate charge equations; it’s about how that equation of state links them together in practice, which is where things get complicated.

Kai: They compare their solutions to ccake, their smoothed particle hydrodynamics code with conserved charges, and they found good numerical agreement overall, despite the largest discrepancies coming from those off-diagonal shear components of the stress tensor.

Mira: That tells us that while the overall picture matches up well for these fluids, we need to be extra careful about how we model those specific shear stresses when running simulations.

Lev: From a real hardware perspective, if the off-diagonal terms are causing issues in ccake, it means the numerical stability or accuracy of running those simulations under high viscosity conditions is highly dependent on how well you treat those components.

Conclusion: Kai: Looking at the paper "Viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges to benchmark fluid simulations," what we see is that this work provides a solid benchmark for hydrodynamics codes that have conserved charges, like ccake.

Mira: They showed that ccake passed their new Gubser test up until times of tau equals one point eight five fm over c, but after that time, it starts crashing due to far-from-equilibrium effects that lead to negative entropy in some smoothed particle hydrodynamics particles <ref:2503.20021#pg2>.

Lev: So even though the fluid was already at the freeze-out temperature by that time, the fact that ccake crashes tells us there are still major limitations from far-from-equilibrium physics we need to account for in our simulations.

Kai: And what they did show is that ccake can reproduce the freeze-out hypersurface generated using Gubser flow very accurately.

Mira: So, this paper confirms their approach to getting that hypersurface works well and it's numerically accurate for testing these codes against a known solution.

Lev: It’s good confirmation, but they also suggest an interesting avenue: including a critical point on the equation of state used would help us understand exactly how that critical point affects the fluid in neighboring regions of the phase diagram.

Kai: And another idea they bring up is implementing this Gubser flow solution for relativistic viscous fluids in three dimensions with conserved charges, which could be helpful for studying low and medium beam energies where the chemical potentials are expected to be largest.

Mira: So, ultimately, this paper gives us a tool to test our current numerical simulations against a well-defined analytical solution of viscous Gubser flow with conserved charges.

More episodes

← Home