Mirror and triplet energy differences in sd-shell nuclei using microscopic interactions with isospin-symmetry breaking effects

summary

The gist

Mirror and triplet energy differences in sd-shell nuclei using microscopic interactions with isospin-symmetry breaking effects is studied to test nuclear models and understand nucleon-nucleon forces…

In short

The study developed two isospin symmetry breaking (ISB) shell-model interactions by adding Coulomb, charge-symmetry breaking (CSB), and charge-independence breaking (CIB) components to microscopic models. These interactions were tested on mirror energy differences and triplet energy differences in sd-shell nuclei. The results show that these ISB effects are important for describing these energy differences, providing a framework to test nuclear models.

Key concepts

Isospin Symmetry Breaking (ISB)
This refers to the slight difference between protons and neutrons, which breaks perfect isospin symmetry in nuclei. The study investigates how adding Coulomb forces and charge-symmetry/independence breaking terms helps model these small differences in nuclear energy levels.
Coulomb Displacement Energies (CDEs) and Triplet Displacement Energies (TDEs)
These are energy differences calculated for isobaric multiplet masses, specifically comparing states where the total isospin T is 1/2 versus T=1. They are used to test the validity of the developed ISB interactions in describing nuclear structure.
Mirror Energy Differences (MEDs) and Triplet Energy Differences (TEDs)
MEDs compare energy differences between mirror nuclei, while TEDs compare energy differences within triplet states. The research found that these quantities are generally well described by the ISB interactions developed in the study.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Mirror and triplet energy differences in sd-shell nuclei using microscopic interactions with isospin-symmetry breaking effects · Read on arXiv

Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee · University of Surrey · Nihon University · NAT Research Center Corporation

Starting from an isospin-symmetric microscopic interaction of Shin et al. [Phys. Rev. C 110, 034306 (2024)], we developed two isospin symmetry breaking (ISB) shell-model interactions by adding Coulomb interaction, as well as charge-symmetry breaking (CSB) and charge-independence breaking (CIB) components from the Argonne v18 (Av18) interaction at two different radial cutoffs, r c = 0.55 and 0.70 fm. With additional modifications to the proton single-particle energies, we then employed these interactions to calculate the Coulomb displacement energies (CDEs) and triplet displacement energies (TDEs) of the isobaric multiplet masses for nuclei with T z = 1/2 and T = 1 across the sd-shell to test their validity and applicability, and compared with the USDCm interaction. We found that both ISB interactions show important roles of the CSB and CIB components in the CDEs and TDEs. In addition, we investigated mirror energy differences (MEDs) in the low-energy spectra of nuclei around A = 20, and triplet energy differences (TEDs) in the A = 18 and 22 systems. They are generally well described by the ISB interactions, although some discrepancies remain. Furthermore, the calculated E2 transition strengths obtained with the ISB interactions are shown to be in good agreement with experimental data, indicating small ISB effects in these transitions. Overall, both the ISB interactions provide a consistent and physically motivated framework for describing ISB effects, while the phenomenological USDCm interaction achieves closer agreement with experiment due to a larger number of adjustable parameters.

DOI: 10.1093/ptep/ptag191

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Mirror and triplet energy differences in sd-shell nuclei using microscopic interactions with isospin-symmetry breaking effects".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Mirror and triplet energy differences in sd-shell nuclei using microscopic interactions with isospin-symmetry breaking effects is studied to test nuclear models and understand nucleon-nucleon forces <ref:2410.00765#pg2> The authors developed two isospin symmetry breaking (ISB) shell-model interactions by adding Coulomb interaction, as well as charge-symmetry breaking (CSB) and charge-independence breaking (CIB) components from the Argonne v18 (Av18) interaction <ref:2410.00765#pg4> They employed these interactions to calculate the Coulomb displacement energies (CDEs) and triplet displacement energies (TDEs) of isobaric multiplet masses for nuclei with Tz = 1/2 and T = 1 across the sd-shell to test their validity and applicability <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Both ISB interactions show important roles of the CSB and CIB components in the CDEs and TDEs <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Development of Microscopic Interactions The research started from an isospin-symmetric microscopic interaction of Shin et al.

Phys. [Mira: Rev.

Kai: C 110, 034306 (2024)], and two isospin symmetry breaking (ISB) shell-model interactions were developed by adding Coulomb interaction, as well as charge-symmetry breaking (CSB) and charge-independence breaking (CIB) components from the Argonne v18 (Av18) interaction at two different radial cutoffs <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Additional modifications to the proton single-particle energies were also made to employ these interactions for calculating CDEs and TDEs <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The CSB and CIB TBMEs depend on the radial cutoffs rc = 0.55 fm and rc = 0.70 fm, with parameters IST, PST, and QST <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Testing ISB Effects on Energy Differences The study investigated mirror energy differences (MEDs) in the low-energy spectra of nuclei around A = 20 and triplet energy differences (TEDs) in the A = 18 and 22 systems <ref:2410.00765#pg4> These quantities are generally well described by the ISB interactions, although some discrepancies remain <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Furthermore, calculated E2 transition strengths obtained with the ISB interactions are in good agreement with experimental data, indicating small ISB effects in these transitions <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Performance Comparison of Interaction Sets The authors compared the performance of three sets of interactions: (i) DJ16A + CD, (ii) DJ16A + CD + Av18 (rc = 0.55 fm), and (iii) DJ16A + CD + Av18 (rc = 0.70 fm) against the phenomenological USDCm interaction <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The performance of both DJ16A-based interactions and USDCm is comparable for nuclei with A <30 based on the root mean square deviation (rms) of b-parameters for the ground state of Tz = 1/2 and Tz = 1 nuclei across the sd-shell <ref:2410.00765#pg5> The c-parameters calculated using both DJ16A-based interactions along with the USDCm interaction can reproduce the staggering pattern of the experimental data correctly <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Both DJ16A-based ISB interactions yield comparable results for the b-parameters, MEDs, and E2 transition strengths <ref:2410.00765#pg4> A slight difference is observed in the c-parameters and TEDs, where the DJ16A + CD + Av18 interaction with rc = 0.70 fm shows improved performance <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Overall, both DJ16A-based ISB interactions provide an improved description of several observables associated with ISB effects, although their performance varies across the different quantities considered <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The overall description of b- and c-parameters, MEDs of mirror pairs, and TEDs of T = 1 triplets is satisfactory within the present framework <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Detailed Analysis of Observables The paper details the calculation of various observables, including IMME, low-energy spectra, and MEDs for mirror pairs around A = 20 and A = 22 <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The calculated MEDs are found to be consistent with the experimental data within certain error ranges for the lowest two or three excited states, specifically for the Tz = 1 pairs <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The TEDs for low-lying states of T = 1 triplets in the A = 18 and 22 systems were also studied, and the calculated results of the DJ16A + CD + Av18 (rc = 0.70 fm) interaction are found to be consistent with the experimental data <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The calculated E2 transition strengths for Tz = 1/2 nuclei from A = 19-31 are shown in Table 5, and the results are on average in good agreement with the experimental data <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The M0 and M1 matrix elements show that the calculated isoscalar matrix elements exhibit small deviations from the experimental M0 matrix elements compared to the isovector matrix elements <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The calculated MEDs for 2+ 1 and 4+ 1 states using DJ16A + CD + Av18 (rc = 55 fm) and USDCm are rather close to the experimental MEDs within the range of ∼ 48 keV <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The TEDs for low-lying states of T = 1 triplets in the A = 18 and 22 systems were also studied, and the calculated results of the DJ16A + CD + Av18 (rc = 0.70 fm) interaction are found to be consistent with the experimental data <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The calculated MEDs for the 5/2+ 1 and 7/2+ 1 states using DJ16A + CD + Av18 (rc = 0.55 fm) and USDCm are consistent with the experimental data within an error range of ∼ 48 keV <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The calculated TEDs for low-lying states of T = 1 triplets in the A = 18 and 22 systems were also studied, and the calculated results of the DJ16A + CD + Av18 (rc = 0.70 fm) interaction are found to be consistent with the experimental data <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The calculated E2 transition strengths for Tz = 1/2 mirror pairs and T = 1 triplets using DJ16A + CD + Av18 (rc = 0.55 fm) along with the USDCm interaction are on average in good agreement with the experimental data <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The M1 matrix element for USDCm is much higher than the DJ16A+CD+Av18 (rc = 0.55 fm) interaction <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Final Conclusion on Interaction Superiority The USDCm interaction, being phenomenologically fitted with a larger number of adjustable parameters, achieves closer agreement with experimental data for most observables <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The brms values for the ground state of Tz = 1/2 and Tz = 1 nuclei across sd-shell, all three ISB interactions showed brms within the range 77 to 142 keV up to A = 39 mirror pair <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The overall description of b- and c-parameters, MEDs of mirror pairs, and TEDs of T = 1 triplets is satisfactory within the present framework <ref:2410.00765#pg4> This agreement is achieved by incorporating short-range correlations in the CSB and CIB components through a radial cutoff in the physically reasonable range rc = 0.5–0.7fm <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The overall description of b- and c-parameters, MEDs of mirror pairs, and TEDs of T = 1 triplets is satisfactory within the present framework <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The overall description of b- and c-parameters, MEDs of mirror pairs, and TEDs of T = 1 triplets is satisfactory within the present framework <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The overall description of b- and c-parameters, MEDs of mirror pairs, and TEDs of T = 1 triplets is satisfactory within the present framework <ref:2410.00765#pg4> The overall description of b- and c-parameters, MEDs of mirror pairs, and TEDs of T = 1 triplets is satisfactory within the present framework <ref:2410.00765#pg4> In this work, the authors developed and tested the ISB versions of the DJ16A interaction by adding Coulomb-CD and also CSB and CIB effects from realistic Av18 interaction at two different radial cut-offs <ref:2410.00765#pg4> They considered two sets of interactions: (i) DJ16A + CD + Av18 (rc = 0.55 fm), and (ii) DJ16A + CD + Av18 (rc = 0.70 fm), and their performance is compared with the USDCm results <ref:2410.00765#pg4> Based on the brms values of the g.s.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Mirror and triplet energy differences in sd-shell nuclei using microscopic interactions with isospin-symmetry breaking effects." It sounds like they are digging into how different nuclear models handle these energy shifts when you break the simple isospin symmetry.

Mira: Yeah, it’s about testing those models by looking at mirror and triplet energy differences in nuclei within the sd-shell. The title tells us they’re using microscopic interactions to see what happens when you add those isospin-symmetry breaking effects into the calculation.

Lev: From my side, I'm curious how much of this is actually being built up for real hardware versus just theoretical calculation. Does this approach translate easily to things like error correction?

Kai: Well, what they’re doing is developing two specific isospin symmetry breaking shell model interactions by adding the Coulomb interaction and also charge-symmetry breaking and charge-independence breaking components from the Argonne v18 interaction.

Mira: That’s a lot of specific force components they’re baking into their calculations. They use these interactions to calculate things like Coulomb displacement energies, CDEs, and triplet displacement energies, TDEs, for nuclei with specific isospin projections.

Lev: So they are setting up these customized forces based on established nucleon-nucleon potentials to see how those small symmetry breaking effects pop out in the energy spectrum of these sd-shell nuclei.

Kai: Exactly. And they’re testing this framework by looking at mirror energy differences and triplet energy differences across different nuclei, specifically around A = twenty for one set and A = eighteen and A = twenty-two for another.

Mira: The implication here is that these symmetry breaking terms, the charge-symmetry breaking and charge-independence breaking parts, play a pretty important role in describing those energy differences we see experimentally.

Lev: So it’s about showing that these corrections aren't just noise; they’re necessary to get the right picture of what happens in these specific nuclear systems.

The paper's summary: Kai: The paper summarizes their approach by taking an isospin-symmetric microscopic interaction and modifying it to include those two types of isospin symmetry breaking interactions. They then use these modified versions to calculate the CDEs and TDEs for the isobaric multiplet masses across the sd-shell, looking at nuclei where the total isospin projection T is one or half.

Mira: What’s interesting about that summary is how they show that both of these new interaction sets—the DJ16A based ones—show a significant role for those charge-symmetry breaking and charge-independence breaking components in calculating both the CDEs and the TDEs, which is important.

Lev: That means if you're looking at experimental data for mirror energy differences or triplet energy differences, these symmetry breaking terms are definitely where you need to focus your attention when interpreting those numbers.

Kai: They also mentioned that they calculated E2 transition strengths using these new interactions, and the summary points out that these results agree quite well with what we see in the lab data, suggesting small ISB effects in those transitions.

Mira: So essentially, the summary is focused on showing that their specific interaction models can reproduce several observables—the energy differences and transition strengths—which gives them confidence in using these interactions to understand the physics of isospin symmetry breaking.

Lev: It’s about validating the model against experimental data for these specific observables, which is a necessary first step before you can use it to predict other things.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper points out several ways their work improves on previous approaches. One improvement they highlight is developing two different sets of ISB shell model interactions by adding the Coulomb interaction, as well as CSB and CIB components from the Argonne v18 interaction at two different radial cutoffs, zero point five five fm and zero point seven zero fm.

Mira: That refinement in the methodology is key because it allows them to test how sensitive these results are to those radial cutoffs, which helps pin down the physics of short-range correlations within the charge symmetry breaking and charge independence breaking parts.

Lev: From a computational standpoint, that’s important for me. If we were running this on real hardware, we’d have to account for how sensitive those results are to choosing a specific cutoff value like zero point five five fm versus zero point seven zero fm, because it directly affects the effective interaction parameters they calculated.

Kai: They also mention that they made additional modifications to the proton single-particle energies to make these interactions work better for calculating those energy differences, which is another way they’re improving the model setup.

Mira: And they compared their performance against a phenomenological interaction called USDCm, showing that while DJ16A based interactions are comparable for many observables, there are still some differences in things like c-parameters and TDEs where the zero point seven zero fm cutoff version actually does better.

Lev: That’s a practical finding because it tells you which of these microscopic approaches is more robust, even if the empirical USDCm interaction seems to fit the data better on a broader scale.

Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up, the paper with the title "Mirror and triplet energy differences in sd-shell nuclei using microscopic interactions with isospin-symmetry breaking effects" shows that these specific isospin symmetry breaking interactions work well for describing mirror and triplet energy differences in the sd-shell nuclei.

Mira: It confirms that incorporating charge symmetry breaking and charge independence breaking components, especially when you use realistic potentials like Argonne v18, provides a framework to study these effects microscopically.

Lev: The main implication is that we have a consistent way to calculate these energy differences using effective interactions that are physically motivated by underlying nucleon-nucleon forces, provided you manage the details of those symmetry breaking terms correctly.

Kai: And they found that the overall description of b- and c-parameters, mirror energy differences, and triplet energy differences is satisfactory within this framework.

Mira: Yes, but they did note a slight difference in the c-parameters and TDEs where using the interaction with zero point seven zero fm radial cutoff showed improved performance compared to the zero point five five fm one.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, it means that for real hardware applications, you need to be careful about which specific interaction parameters you use because the choice of those cutoffs matters for the precision you’re getting.

More episodes

← Home