Anomalous charge conjugation and parity in (2+1)-dimensional relativistic hydrodynamics

summary

The gist

We present a hydrostatic and first-order constitutive description of a mixed anomaly that involves U(1)Q, U(1)F, charge conjugation symmetry (acting only on U(1)Q)…

In short

The study investigates a mixed anomaly in 2+1D relativistic hydrodynamics involving U(1)Q and U(1)F symmetries, charge conjugation, and parity. It develops a hydrostatic functional to describe this anomaly, leading to constitutive relations where one symmetry's background field induces a non-vanishing cross-charge response in the other sector, distinct from standard fluid dynamics poles.

Key concepts

Mixed Anomaly
This refers to a specific topological obstruction in the system where the characteristic form is odd under charge conjugation. It dictates how U(1)Q and U(1)F interact, leading to a fractional Chern-Simons level kQF = 1/2 (mod Z).
Charge Conjugation (C)
This is a discrete symmetry operation that acts as charge conjugation on the U(1)Q sector but leaves the U(1)F sector unchanged. This asymmetry is crucial for defining the mixed anomaly and constraining the coupling between sectors.
Hydrostatic Functional
This functional, Whs, describes equilibrium states in 2+1D fluid dynamics. Its variation reveals that a specific vortical term is necessary to cancel local anomalous variations, even when the response appears metric-independent via a Chern-Simons functional.
Cross-Charge Response
The resulting physical effect where a background field in one U(1) sector causes a transverse response in the other. This response is non-vanishing and is fixed by the fractional part of the anomaly class, distinguishing it from standard transport information.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Anomalous charge conjugation and parity in (2+1)-dimensional relativistic hydrodynamics · Read on arXiv

Sonali Patnaik, *, Rajeev Singh, *

Indian Institute of Technology, North Guwahati · Institut fu¨r Theoretische Physik, Goethe University

We present a hydrostatic and first-order constitutive description of a mixed anomaly that involves U(1) Q, U(1) F, charge conjugation symmetry (acting only on U(1) Q), and parity symmetry in 2+1 dimensions. It is represented by a mutual Chern-Simons level k QF= 12,(mod Z). Adopting the already established multi-charge anomaly sector, we explicitly provide the information that this response is odd under and symmetries separately, but even under combined symmetry. We also provide a global inflow representative and compute the equilibrium cross-charge response which includes d n Q/d B F= d n F/d B Q=1/4π 1/2π. Using an analytic neutral-fluid example we show that this response is non-vanishing whereas the source-free hydrodynamic poles are invariant.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Anomalous charge conjugation and parity in (2+1)-dimensional relativistic hydrodynamics".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We present a hydrostatic and first-order constitutive description of a mixed anomaly that involves U(1)Q, U(1)F, charge conjugation symmetry (acting only on U(1)Q), and parity symmetry in 2+ 1 dimensions It is represented by a mutual Chern–Simons level kQF = 1/2 (mod Z) The study focuses on a specific realization of this structure in which the discrete transformation acts as charge conjugation on one U(1) factor while leaving the second U(1) factor unaffected Our focus is instead on a specific realization of this structure in which the discrete transformation acts as charge conjugation on one U(1) factor while leaving the second U(1) factor unaffected This construction allows a direct comparison between equilibrium contact response and collective dynamics Symmetry Setup and Assumptions The work considers a normal relativistic fluid in 2 + 1D with two compact, unbroken global symmetries U(1)Q and U(1)F The internal involution discrete transformation called charge conjugation is C: (AQ, AF) 7−→ (−AQ, AF), (µQ, µF) 7−→ (−µQ, µF) This asymmetric action is important for the mixed construction considered below The mixed characteristic form FQ ∧ FF is odd under C Mixed Anomaly Obstruction The specific discrete anomaly considered here requires a characteristic form that is odd under the charge-conjugation action defined in Eq.

Kai: (2) The second compact U(1) allows the mixed characteristic form I4 = FQ ∧ FF / 2π, Z X4 I4 ∈ Z The anomaly is given by a fractional mutual Chern-Simons level kQF = 1/2 (mod Z) This establishes the shared obstruction and its local CP invariance Hydrostatic Functional Construction The hydrostatic functional reads Whs = Z M3 vol3

p + αQBQ + αFBF + αomegaomega: + O(∂ 2) The cancellation of its local anomalous variation by the boundary functional permits only αQ = C⋆µF, αF = C⋆µQ, and αomega = C⋆µQµF This implies that the vortical term is necessary even though the response is locally represented by a metric-independent Chern-Simons functional Constitutive Relations and Response The complete first-order Landau-frame relations for the energy-momentum tensor and the charge currents become T µν = ϵuµu ν +

p − ζθ − C⋆(pFBQ + pQBF): ∆µν − ησµν, J µQ = nQu µ + σQbV µ b + C⋆Eeµ F, J µF = nF u µ + σF bV µ b + C⋆Eeµ Q The resulting response is a cross-charge response: a background field in one U(1) sector induces a transverse response in the other sector, with its fractional part fixed by the anomaly class Static Response and Analytic Example The analytic example shows how the anomaly can be seen in local response without incorporating an additional hydrodynamic mode The resulting response is non-vanishing while the source free sound, shear, and charge diffusion poles are unaffected by the mixed coefficient These expressions stem from the longitudinal determinant ω 2 − k 2 / 2 + i(η/w0)ωk2 = 0 and the transverse momentum equation The non-dependence on C⋆ is a direct result of the source-local topological current Physical Edge Considerations For that restricted edge sector one must have c = 0 A boundary that breaks CP symmetry, or has further edge sectors, does not follow this restriction merely because the bulk has the given anomaly The chosen current convention, edge action, and inflow must be treated together The model distinguishes the fractional anomaly response from the thermodynamic and dissipative information that remains unconstrained The mixed transverse source response is non-vanishing, although the source free sound, shear, and charge diffusion poles remain independent of the anomaly coefficient The model distinguishes the fractional anomaly response from the thermodynamic and dissipative information that remains unconstrained The model distinguishes the fractional anomaly response from the thermodynamic and dissipative information that remains unconstrained Acknowledgments RS acknowledges the support of the Humboldt research fellowship for postdocs from the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation and the kind hospitality of the Department of Physics, IIT Guwahati SP acknowledges financial support from the IIT Guwahati Postdoctoral Fellowship under Project No.

Title and authors: Kai: Looking at the title again, "Anomalous charge conjugation and parity in (two plusone)-dimensional relativistic hydrodynamics," it sounds dense but it tells you immediately that we're dealing with how symmetries break down when you introduce anomalies into a fluid description <ref:2611.11454#pg1,Anomalous charge conjugation and parity in (2+1)-dimensional relativistic hydrodynamics>.

Mira: It’s about taking those quantum constraints—the anomalies—and seeing how they manifest in the macroscopic, hydrodynamic equations for matter flow. It’s trying to bridge the gap between microscopic quantum rules and what we see in bulk fluids.

Lev: The authors are Sonali Patnaik and Rajeev Singh from IIT Guwahati and Goethe University Frankfurt. From my viewpoint, having people from different theoretical backgrounds like that should be good because they can push each other on the assumptions about the fluid itself.

Kai: Right, so it’s a collaboration between quantum hardware guys and condensed matter theorists trying to nail down these fundamental symmetry constraints in a relativistic setting. It sounds like they are building something that connects two very different worlds.

Mira: They are using this setup to explicitly show how the response is odd under charge conjugation and parity separately, but even when you combine them into a combined CP symmetry, which is where the real complexity lies.

The paper's summary: Kai: The abstract explains that they adopt an established multi-charge anomaly sector and then explicitly provide the information about this response being odd under C and P symmetries separately, but even under combined CP symmetry. They also compute an equilibrium cross-charge response where the ratio of change in Q current with respect to F field is one over four pi modulo one over two pi.

Mira: That fractional part, that one over four pi modulo one over two pi, is a key number they are getting from this construction. It links the anomaly class directly to the physical charge densities in a very specific way.

Lev: I think what’s interesting here for real hardware is that this calculation gives us something concrete about how the fields couple, even when we are dealing with these fractional levels of anomalies. We need to see if this coupling has a manageable overhead for error correction later on.

Kai: So they are showing that the anomaly inflow provides a connection to the underlying quantum theory, and they implement this in thermal equilibrium and effective actions for fluids with anomalies, creating a roadmap from anomaly data to hydrodynamic constitutive relations.

Mira: That's the big picture—using discrete anomalies as input to systematically derive how fluids behave in equilibrium, which is what we need for any realistic simulation or experiment.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper suggests a few things that they see as improvements, specifically focusing on how they handle the mixed anomaly obstruction and the hydrostatic functional. They mention that the cancellation of its local anomalous variation by the boundary functional only permits specific relationships between those coefficients.

Mira: They find that this implies alpha Q equals C star mu F, alpha F equals C star mu Q, and alpha Omega equals C star mu Q mu F. This forces the vortical term to be necessary even if you are locally representing the response with something that doesn't depend on a metric.

Lev: That means they’re not just looking at a simple Chern–Simons functional; they’re finding that you need that vortical term to make the math work out consistently when you match the charge densities in the Landau frame, which is where real simulations live.

Kai: And this leads to their constitutive relations, like T nu nu equals epsilon u mu u nu plus p minus zeta theta minus C star of p F B Q plus p Q B F, which is a direct result of matching both charge densities. It’s a very specific way to derive those stress-energy tensor relations.

Mira: What I find particularly interesting is how they handle the static response and show that this non-vanishing cross-charge response doesn't affect the source free sound, shear, or charge diffusion poles in the analytic example they use. It isolates the anomaly effect cleanly.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper on "Anomalous charge conjugation and parity in (two plusone)-dimensional relativistic hydrodynamics" shows that these mixed anomalies give rise to a non-vanishing transverse source response, even when the standard hydrodynamic poles seem unaffected <ref:2611.11454#pg1,Anomalous charge conjugation and parity in (2+1)-dimensional relativistic hydrodynamics>.

Mira: The main implication is that symmetry allows for constitutive information whose values aren't determined by just the anomaly itself; you need the full framework involving charge conjugation and parity to nail down the physics.

Lev: For me, what this means is that if we want to run this on real hardware, we have to account for these coupled terms—the magnetic and vortical ones—because they are necessary for equilibrium matching, even though they complicate the implementation.

Kai: So it’s a solid foundation for using anomaly data to systematically derive constitutive relations in fluids. It sets up a clear path from those quantum constraints to macroscopic fluid behavior.

Mira: We see this as a way to distinguish between the fractional anomaly response and the thermodynamic or dissipative information that stays unconstrained by this specific setup, which is valuable for separating different physical effects.

Lev: It’s good work, but the authors flag a limitation: they mention that for that restricted edge sector, you have to have c equals zero or some boundary breaking CP symmetry if you want to follow their exact construction. They're not solving the whole problem yet.

Kai: So they’ve shown what this specific structure yields and where it stops working right now. It opens up a new way to think about how anomalies influence fluid responses across different dimensions and symmetries.

More episodes

← Home