Reconciling anomalous quadrupole deformation in 200,202 Hg with Coulomb excitation
summary
The gist
Stable isotopes of mercury with two fewer protons than magic lead are found experimentally to exhibit oblate deformation…
In short
Researchers used a Coulomb excitation experiment to remeasure spectroscopic quadrupole moments ($Q_s(2^+_1)$) for $^{200}$Hg and $^{202}$Hg. The results were $Q_s(2^+_1)$ values of 0.52(14) eb and 0.63(10) eb, which are within physical limits but suggest near axially-symmetric oblate deformation. This finding is consistent with neighboring Pt isotopes and implies a reduction in the nuclear Schiff moment.
Key concepts
- Quadrupole Deformation
- This describes the shape of the nucleus, quantified by $Q_s$. A positive $Q_s$ indicates an oblate shape, meaning the nucleus is flattened like a pancake. This deformation is crucial because it influences how electric dipole moments are measured and relates to potential charge-parity violation.
- Spectroscopic Quadrupole Moment ($Q_s(2^+_1)$)
- This value measures the specific quadrupole deformation of a nucleus, specifically related to its first excited state ($2^+_1$). It is determined experimentally through Coulomb excitation experiments. The measured values for $^{200,202}$Hg were found to be relatively small compared to some literature estimates.
- Schiff Moment
- The Schiff moment is a quantity related to the permanent electric dipole moment of a nucleus. Its magnitude is strongly dependent on the nuclear quadrupole deformation ($eta_2$) and octupole deformation ($eta_3$). Smaller $Q_s(2^+_1)$ values suggest a reduced Schiff moment for these mercury isotopes.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Reconciling anomalous quadrupole deformation in 200,202 Hg with Coulomb excitation · Paper Radio
- T Violation in K-Meson Decays
The paper
Reconciling anomalous quadrupole deformation in 200,202 Hg with Coulomb excitation · Read on arXiv
G. Willmotta, J. Heerya, J. Henderson, P. Stevensona, C. Cousinsa, D. T Dohertya, A Ertoprakc, B P Kayc, L Morrisona, Á Müller-Gatermannc C O’Sheaa P H Regana B Reviolc D M Rhodese R Russella N Sensharmac D Seweryniak M Sicilianoc R S Sidhua I A Tolstukhinc C Y Wud
School of Mathematics and Physics University of Surrey · National Physical Laboratory · Physics Division Argonne National Laboratory · Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory · TRIUMF
Stable isotopes of mercury, with two fewer protons than magic lead, are found experimentally to exhibit oblate deformation, similar to neighbouring platinum isotopes. These isotopes are of special interest due to the use of 199 Hg as an experimental laboratory for electric dipole moment searches, which are a powerful test of charge-parity (CP) violation and the interpretation of which depends critically on the quadrupole and octopule shapes of the underlying nucleus. It is observed that the ratio between experimental quadrupole moments and electric quadrupole transition strengths exceed physical limits, placing uncertainty on this underlying shape. In an effort to resolve this situation, a Coulomb excitation experiment was performed to remeasure the spectroscopic quadrupole moment (Q s(2+ 1)) of 200 Hg and 202 Hg utilising 48 Ti and 120 Sn targets. The values obtained were Q s(2+ 1) 200,202 Hg = 0.52(14), 0.63(10) eb, lying within physical limits defined by B(E2) values but still consistent with near axially-symmetric oblate deformation. A systematic study of nuclei indicates that, as with neighbouring Pt isotopes, 200,202 Hg are strongly oblate deformed, albeit without fully developing into an axial rotor.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Experiment. The day in nuclear experiment: beams, targets and what came out.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Reconciling anomalous quadrupole deformation in 200,202 Hg with Coulomb excitation".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Stable isotopes of mercury with two fewer protons than magic lead are found experimentally to exhibit oblate deformation, similar to neighbouring platinum isotopes The ratio between experimental quadrupole moments and electric quadrupole transition strengths exceed physical limits, placing uncertainty on this underlying shape A Coulomb excitation experiment was performed to remeasure the spectroscopic quadrupole moment Qs(2+1) of 200Hg and 202Hg utilising 48Ti and 120Sn targets The values obtained were Qs(2+1) 200,202Hg = 0.52(14), 0.63(10) eb, lying within physical limits defined by B(E2) values but still consistent with near axially-symmetric oblate deformation A systematic study of nuclei indicates that, as with neighbouring Pt isotopes, 200,202Hg are strongly oblate deformed Introduction to Nuclear Deformation and EDM Searches Quadrupole deformation is ubiquitous across the nuclear landscape with significant variations in both magnitude and resultant shape A positive Qs indicates oblate quadrupole deformation The A ≈ 200 region of the nuclear chart has limited Qs(2+1) data, and warrants special interest due to the proximity to doubly magic 208Pb and a region of shape coexistence in the neutron deficient Hg isotopes These nuclei are also a rare example of a region of the nuclear landscape that exhibits extensive oblate quadrupole deformation The search for a non-zero permanent electric dipole moment remains a promising route to investigate beyond Standard Model physics The nuclear Schiff moment is approximately proportional to both the quadrupole and octupole deformation of the system S ∝ β2β3 squared (1) Experimental Methodology for Remeasurement The experiment was performed at Argonne National Laboratory at the Argonne Tandem Linear Accelerator System (ATLAS) Beams were provided to the target station at the end of the accelerator in Area 4 Samples of 200Hg and 202Hg were accelerated to 783.7 MeV (3.92 MeV/u and 3.88 MeV/u respectively) in a 31+ charge state Beams with currents of approximately 6 × 10 7 pps (310 epA) were impinged on two targets; 452 µg·cm−2 of natural titanium (74% 48Ti), and 780 µg·cm−2 of tin which was enriched to >98% 120Sn A Micron S3 Dual-sided Silicon Strip Detector (DSSD) was placed downstream of the target ladder to detect the scattered beam and target ions The Gammasphere array of high purity germanium (HPGe) detectors with Compton suppressors surrounded the vacuum chamber containing the targets and DSSD Following detection by Gammasphere, de-excitation γ rays were Doppler corrected to recover their energy in the centre-of-mass frame Analysis of Spectroscopic Quadrupole Moments The recorded waveforms and time stamps were processed with a modified version of the GEBSort code
26: The underlying Coulomb-excitation calculations used in the minimisation procedure included the geometries of both detector systems, level schemes, and the literature values of electromagnetic matrix elements The χ squared total between the experimental γ-ray yields and corresponding simulated yields from GOSIA is minimised through repeated modification to values of the beam and target nuclei matrix elements The fitted values and uncertainties of the Hg matrix elements output from the first minimisation procedure were input to the Hg and Sn minimisation as constraints The results presented in Table 2 offer independent measurements of the B(E2; 0+1 → 2+1) and Qs(2+1) of 200Hg and 202Hg Reconciliation of Results and Nuclear Structure Implications The constrained Qs(2+1) from this work (0.52(14) eb) is ∼ 4σ below the Bockisch et al.
Kai: (1.11(11) e.b)
2: and Spear et al.
Mira: (1.07(19) e.b)
22: values for 200Hg The unconstrained Qs(2+1) is also not consistent with the literature values The new constrained and unconstrained Qs(2+1) values for both 200Hg and 202Hg show a significant departure from the values of Bockisch et al.: 1.11(11), 0.32(14) e.b
2: and Spear et al.: 1.07(19), 1.01(e)
22: The new data points (red) calculated from the constrained Qs(2+1) values are more in line with neighbouring nuclei, 198Hg and 194,196,198Pt The consequence of smaller Qs(2+1) values in conjunction with the β3 ≈ 0 results from the potential energy surface calculations is a reduction in the magnitude of the Schiff moment for nuclei in this region The Qs(2+1) values from this work are more typical considering the systematics of neighbouring nuclei in the A ≈ 200 region The values now also have a smaller magnitude than the theoretical limit of a quadrupole deformed rigid rotor, which shows these nuclei are not total axial rotors Furthermore, triaxiality or configuration mixing may be occurring The consequence of smaller Qs(2+1) values in conjunction with the β3 ≈ 0 results from the potential energy surface calculations is a reduction in the magnitude of the Schiff moment for nuclei in this region Due to the quadratic dependency of the Schiff moment on β3, B(E3; 0+1 → 3−1) measurements via state lifetimes should be performed to confirm understanding of the exotic deformation in this region The potential energy surface calculations predict a greater degree of softness in both deformation parameters for 200Hg as compared to 202Hg A lack of observation of γ rays from 3− states in this work is consistent with the small β3 from the calculations References
1: B.
Kai: Pritychenko, M.
Paper summary: Kai: We’re looking at the paper "Reconciling anomalous quadrupole deformation in two hundred thousand two hundred two Hg with Coulomb excitation," which tackles how we understand the shape of mercury isotopes near lead <ref:2610.28202#pg1,Reconciling anomalous quadrupole deformation in 200>.
Mira: The thesis is that stable isotopes of mercury have oblate deformation, similar to platinum, and this shape is key for testing fundamental symmetries because it affects electric dipole moment searches.
Kai: They argue that the way you interpret those electric dipole moments depends on whether you consider the quadrupole or octupole shape underneath the nucleus.
Mira: The paper points out that experimental ratios between quadrupole moments and transition strengths are exceeding physical limits, which creates uncertainty about this underlying shape.
Lev: So, they set up a Coulomb excitation experiment using 48Ti and 120Sn targets to get new measurements for Qs(two plusone) of 200Hg and 202Hg.
Kai: Those results gave them Qs(two plusone) values of zero point five two(fourteen) eb for 200Hg and zero point six three(ten) eb for 202Hg, both of which fit within the physical limits defined by the B(E2) values.
Mira: But even with those new constraints, they still remain consistent with a near axially-symmetric oblate deformation of these mercury nuclei.
Lev: The paper also points out that a systematic study shows 200Hg and 202Hg are strongly oblate deformed, but they aren't fully developing into an axial rotor <ref:2610.28202#pg1>.
Kai: This suggests the structure is more complex than just a simple shape description, pointing toward potential triaxiality or configuration mixing.
Mira: The paper then explains that these smaller Qs(two plusone) values and the beta3 results mean a reduction in the Schiff moment for nuclei in this A equals two hundred region.
Lev: And they conclude that measurements of B(E3; zero plusone → three−one) via state lifetimes are needed to confirm this exotic deformation because of its quadratic dependency on beta three.
Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at this paper by Willmotta et al., the main point is that their new measurements of Qs(two plusone) for 200Hg and 202Hg are more consistent with the general pattern seen in neighboring nuclei.
Mira: They’ve shown that these values are smaller than what you’d expect from a rigid rotor, which reinforces the idea that these nuclei aren't total axial rotors, even though they are oblate deformed.
Lev: What this means for us is that we have to be careful about how we calculate fundamental properties like the Schiff moment when looking at these specific isotopes because of this shape uncertainty.
Kai: It also points toward the possibility of triaxiality or configuration mixing happening in these regions, which adds another layer to understanding the nuclear structure.
Mira: Ultimately, confirming this deformation is important because it gives us a better picture for how we interpret those electric dipole moment searches aimed at finding physics beyond the standard model.
Lev: And if you want to confirm that exotic shape, you’ll need those B(E3; zero plusone → three−one) measurements using state lifetimes they mentioned.
Kai: It’s about tying together the shape evidence with the fundamental symmetry tests we are trying to perform with systems like 199Hg <ref:2610.28202#pg1>.
More episodes
- 2602.10658-Inclusive and multiplicity-dependent pseudorapidity densities of charged particles in pp collisions at sqrt s = 13.6 TeV
- 2606.07905-Precision cross section measurements of neutron-induced non-elastic gamma production reactions at 14 MeV
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-16
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-16
- 2504.07795-Measurement of coincident photon-initiated processes in ultra-peripheral Pb+Pb collisions with the ATLAS detector
- 2611.16075-Exclusive cross section measurements of 12 C(n,p n) and 12 C(n,d n) reactions
- 2611.17010-Observation of the lambda(1520) suppression in Pb-Pb collisions at sqrt s NN = 5.02 TeV
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-15
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-15
- 2611.08725-Probing the initial geometry and the onset of collectivity with anisotropic flow in light-ion collisions with ALICE at the LHC