Random tree Besov priors: Data-driven regularisation parameter selection

summary

The gist

We develop a data-driven algorithm for automatically selecting the regularisation parameter in Bayesian inversion under random tree Besov priors One of the key challenges in Bayesian inversion is the…

In short

The paper develops a data-driven algorithm to automatically select regularization parameters for Bayesian inversion using random tree Besov priors. It introduces a hierarchical model where the regularization strength adapts across different wavelet scales, removing manual tuning of the parameter. This method achieves near-optimal performance in denoising and deconvolution tasks compared to fixed prior methods.

Key concepts

Besov Priors
These priors are used in inverse problems to impose smoothness constraints on reconstructed signals. Unlike simple Gaussian priors, Besov priors naturally capture local smoothness properties while allowing for discontinuities, making them better suited for reconstructing images and signals with sharp edges.
Random Tree Besov Priors
This extension incorporates a hierarchical tree structure into the wavelet representation. This allows the prior to model local variations and rapid spatial changes effectively by enforcing constraints across different levels of decomposition, promoting sparsity.
Automatic Parameter Selection
The method addresses manual tuning by allowing the regularization parameter ($eta$) to vary at each decomposition level ($eta = (eta_j)_j$). This is estimated directly from the data using levelwise maximum a posteriori (MAP) estimates, enabling scale-specific adaptation of the regularization strength.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Random tree Besov priors: Data-driven regularisation parameter selection · Read on arXiv

Hanne Kekkonen, Andreas Tataris

Delft University of Technology · Delft Institute of Applied Mathematics

We develop a data-driven algorithm for automatically selecting the wavelet density parameters in Bayesian inversion under random tree Besov priors. One of the key challenges in Bayesian inversion is the construction of priors that are both expressive and computationally feasible. Random tree Besov priors, introduced in, provide a flexible framework for capturing local regularity properties and sparsity patterns in a wavelet basis. In this paper, we extend this approach by introducing a hierarchical model that enables data-driven selection of the wavelet density parameter, allowing the regularisation strength to adapt across scales while retaining computational efficiency. We focus on nonparametric regression and also present preliminary plug-and-play results for a deconvolution problem.

DOI: 10.3934/ipi.2026075

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: I'm Ada.

Emmy: And I'm Emmy, here with Kolya.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Random tree Besov priors".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. We develop a data-driven algorithm for automatically selecting the regularisation parameter in Bayesian inversion under random tree Besov priors One of the key challenges in Bayesian inversion is the construction of priors that are both expressive and computationally feasible The paper introduces a hierarchical model that enables data-driven selection of the wavelet density parameter, allowing the regularisation strength to adapt across scales while retaining computational efficiency Inverse problems require combining prior knowledge with noisy measurements for stable reconstructions Traditional Gaussian priors impose global smoothness constraints, making them less effective for capturing sharp edges and interfaces essential in image and signal reconstruction Besov priors offer an alternative by naturally capturing local smoothness properties while allowing discontinuities Random tree Besov priors extend this by incorporating a hierarchical tree structure into the wavelet representation, enhancing flexibility for modeling local variations and rapid spatial changes This tree-pruning approach promotes sparsity and local adaptivity by enforcing hierarchical constraints on wavelet coefficients Automatic Parameter Selection Mechanism The authors address the limitation of manually selecting the wavelet density index β by introducing a hierarchical Bayesian model where β is allowed to vary across decomposition levels, denoted as a vector-valued parameter β = (βj)j The method proposes a computationally efficient way to estimate the optimal β directly from data using levelwise maximum a posteriori (MAP) estimates This strategy allows the regularisation strength to adapt flexibly to scale-specific sparsity inherent in wavelet decompositions and removes manual tuning of β The process involves solving an optimization problem where the optimal levelwise βˆj is found by minimizing the weight of a row added to the tree Performance in Denoising Tasks Numerical experiments demonstrate that the automatically chosen β performs at least as well as optimally chosen fixed β In 1D signal denoising, the denoised signals obtained under Gaussian and Laplace base priors with automatic β selection are very similar, yielding relative errors around 1.1% In 2D image denoising, the tree pruning methods outperform optimal soft and hard thresholding applied to the wavelet coefficients, achieving high Structural Similarity Index (SSIM) values Key Findings on Prior Influence Proposition 1 shows that for a constant c, T 1β(cm1) = cT 1βe(m1), where βe = βc/(βc + (1 − β)c) This indicates that the noise and prior variances influence only the optimal choice of the regularisation parameter β The method is shown to be a plug-and-play denoiser inside more general inverse problem solvers, as demonstrated in deconvolution problems Deconvolution Application In a mildly ill-posed deconvolution problem, the reconstruction exhibits characteristic staircasing behaviour similar to solutions obtained with total variation priors while accurately capturing main discontinuities The proposed automatic β-selection tree prior can be used as a plug-and-play denoiser inside more general inverse problem solvers The reconstruction demonstrates that the proposed automatic β-selection tree prior can be used as a plug-and-play denoiser inside more general inverse problem solvers Comparison with Fixed Priors The relative errors between the original signal and the denoised signal arising from the automatic β selection method and from the optimal fixed β method are 1.116% and 1.110% for Gaussian base prior For Laplace base prior, these errors are 1.185% and 1.150%, respectively The choice of wavelet basis appears to have a larger effect on the reconstruction than the choice of base prior The method is somewhat more sensitive to the choice of the hyperparameter a than in the Gaussian base prior case Table Summary Table 1 compares tree pruning methods based on SNR, SSIM, and Relative Error for both Gaussian and Laplace base priors The automatic β selection method yields an SSIM of 0.7967 with Gaussian base prior The automatic β selection method yields an SSIM of 0.7852 with Laplace base prior All tree pruning methods outperform optimal soft and hard thresholding applied to the wavelet coefficients Algorithm Summary Algorithm 1 provides a pseudo-code for automatic β selection with Gaussian base prior The algorithm recursively selects βˆ recursively from bottom up, allowing a node to be considered containing enough information on one level leading to a certain βˆj1, but the whole branch is later pruned on a lower level The final step involves calculating the optimal gJk and tJk based on the selected tree structure The process for levels j < J is similar to the bottom level but compares the weight of an optimised subtree with root node (j, k) to pruning the whole branch The algorithm is summarized in Algorithm 1.

Ada: Laplace Case Specifics When gjk ∼ Laplace(0, κ), soft thresholding forces ˆgjk = 0 for all mjk ≤ 1/κ A bottom row node is included in the tree if mJk > 1/κ and a specific inequality holds involving βJ The minimiser for βˆJ is found by considering only grid points where mJk > 1/κ This approach ensures that coefficients carrying little information are pruned on the bottom level since the penalty for including them is larger and there is no gain on the data fit The selection condition simplifies to βJ ≥ 1 + exp(1/2m2Jk − 1/κmJk + 1/2κ 2) Gaussian Case Specifics For Gaussian base prior gjk ∼ N(0, κ 2), the node (J, k) is included in the subtree if including the node carries less weight than turning it off, which is equivalent to log 1 − β/βc ≥ 1/(4m2Jk) The penalty term R(βJ) is a convex function while the data term L(mJ, βJ) is a decreasing function of β on the interval

0, 0.5: This guarantees that there exists a unique minimiser βˆJ = argminβJk BJ,AβJk The optimal levelwise βˆj is found by minimizing the weight the row adds to the tree L(mj, βj) + R(βj) Scaling and Equivalence The noise and prior variances, σ squared and κ squared, influence only the optimal choice of the regularisation parameter β Proposition 1 shows that T κβ(mσ) arises from a measurement with noise wjk ∼ N(0, σ 2) and prior choice gjk ∼ N(0, κ 2) is given by T˜1β˜(m1), where the coefficients gˆ1jk = mjk/2 are replaced by gˆ1jk = κ 2mjk/(κ squared + σ 2) and βe = βc/(βc + (1 − β)c) Scaling the coefficients ˆg 1jk means scaling the denoised signal, which is undesirable The paper concludes that the optimal value βˆκσ for T κβ(mσ) can be obtained directly from βˆ11 The final result shows that the noise and prior variances, σ squared and κ squared, influence only the optimal choice of the regularisation parameter β The paper concludes that the noise and prior variances, σ squared and κ squared, influence only the optimal choice of the regularisation parameter β.

Emmy: References

1: R.

Ada: A.

Title and authors: Ada: So we're looking at this paper, "Random tree Besov priors: Data-driven regularisation parameter selection," and it tackles a big problem in Bayesian inversion where picking the right regularization strength is usually done by hand.

Emmy: Exactly. The core idea here is that instead of choosing one single regularization parameter, the method uses a hierarchical model to select a vector of parameters, called beta j, for each decomposition level j.

Kolya: I'm curious about how this helps with the actual data; what's the main benefit we see when you let it adapt across scales?

Ada: Well, what this paper presents is a way to get that regularisation strength to change depending on the scale, which matches how sparsity actually looks in wavelet decompositions. They introduce this vector-valued parameter beta j and then use levelwise maximum a posteriori estimates directly from the data to find the optimal values for beta.

Emmy: That sounds like they’re removing the manual tuning headache for that regularisation strength, letting it adapt flexibly to scale-specific sparsity inherent in those wavelet decompositions.

Kolya: So if we think about signal processing, does this mean we stop guessing what level of smoothness to enforce at each resolution?

Ada: That's right. They show numerical experiments demonstrating that this automatically chosen beta performs at least as well as the optimally chosen fixed beta in both one-dimensional signal denoising and two-dimensional image denoising tasks.

Emmy: And specifically, in 2D image denoising, they get a structural similarity index of zero point seven nine six seven when using a Gaussian base prior with this automatic selection method.

Kolya: That's a solid number compared to the optimal fixed beta results; how does this compare when we switch to the Laplace base prior?

Ada: For the Laplace base prior, they still achieve high performance, reaching an SSIM of zero point seven eight five two with their automatic beta selection method. They show that this approach works well across different base priors.

Emmy: It seems like the structure of the hierarchical model is what allows them to handle both Gaussian and Laplace distributions effectively by adapting the parameter at each level j.

Kolya: What about deconvolution problems? I heard those can be tricky because they are mildly ill-posed, and that's where we really need good priors.

Title and authors: Ada: They tested it on a mildly ill-posed deconvolution problem and found that their automatic beta selection tree prior works as a plug-and-play denoiser inside more general inverse problem solvers.

Emmy: That means we can use this structure to reconstruct signals that show characteristic staircasing behavior, which is something we usually get from total variation priors.

Kolya: That’s interesting because it suggests this method isn't just for simple denoising but can handle more complex inversion scenarios where discontinuities are important.

Ada: They also look at how the noise and prior variances influence the optimal choice of that regularisation parameter beta, which they show only affects the optimal choice of beta e, regardless of sigma squared or kappa squared.

Emmy: That is a neat finding because it means we don't have to worry about tuning based on those specific noise levels; the structure handles that dependency internally.

Kolya: So if this method is plug-and-play, what are the limitations? Where does it stop working reliably?

Ada: The paper shows they provide preliminary results for a deconvolution problem, but it's important to remember that this is still a preliminary demonstration. They also note that the choice of the wavelet basis itself seems to have a larger effect on the final reconstruction than just choosing between Gaussian and Laplace base priors.

Emmy: And they mentioned sensitivity to the hyperparameter alpha in some cases, which shows that while it’s automated, there's still some tuning involved in setting up the initial structure.

Kolya: So for someone using this, what does this mean practically for a standard inversion pipeline? Are we talking about replacing a fixed step with something more dynamic?

Ada: It means the system can now dynamically adjust its regularization strength based on the data's inherent sparsity at different scales, which is something manual tuning simply couldn't do efficiently.

Emmy: And that’s really about making sure the prior structure aligns better with the actual information content of the wavelet representation.

Kolya: It sounds like a significant step forward in making Bayesian priors more expressive without sacrificing computational efficiency in these complex inversion tasks.

Ada: It is, and they call this work "Random tree Besov priors: Data-driven regularisation parameter selection." We've seen how this hierarchical model allows the regularization strength to adapt across scales.

Title and authors: Emmy: This paper suggests that for inverse problems involving wavelet bases, we can move away from a single fixed regularization parameter towards one that is determined directly by the data structure itself.

Kolya: I think it’s valuable because it moves the selection process from being purely heuristic to being data-driven through those levelwise maximum a posteriori estimates.

Ada: Exactly. It takes away the need for manual tuning of beta and lets the optimization problem find the best levelwise parameter for each decomposition level.

Emmy: And they've shown that this method works well for both Gaussian and Laplace base priors, which is important because those are two very different ways to model uncertainty in inverse problems.

Kolya: So what's next? What does this paper open up for future research in Bayesian inversion?

Ada: The authors show that the noise and prior variances only influence the optimal choice of the regularisation parameter beta, which is a neat structural result. This suggests we can decouple those influences when selecting beta.

Emmy: And they also point toward using this method as a plug-and-play denoiser inside more general inverse problem solvers, which means it's not just an isolated tool but part of a larger system.

Kolya: It seems like the main implication is that we get a more robust and adaptive prior structure for Bayesian inversion that performs competitively with fixed prior methods.

Ada: That’s the gist of it—a flexible, data-driven approach to picking the regularisation parameter in Bayesian inversion under random tree Besov priors.

Emmy: It moves us closer to constructing priors that are both highly expressive of local regularity and computationally feasible for real-world applications like image and signal reconstruction.

Kolya: I think it’s a solid piece of work showing how hierarchical modeling can solve the problem of scale-specific sparsity in wavelet methods.

Ada: It is, and if you're working on complex inverse problems, this paper gives you a new way to think about adapting your regularization strength at different levels.

Emmy: And it’s important for the community because it shows how to bridge the gap between rigorous mathematical formulation and practical performance in these Bayesian settings.

Kolya: It’s interesting how they manage to keep the computational efficiency up while allowing this level of adaptivity across scales.

The paper's summary: Ada: So, to sum up what we've been talking about, this paper is about using a data-driven approach to pick the right regularization strength when you're using random tree Besov priors in Bayesian inversion.

Emmy: Right. Instead of a manual choice for that parameter, they build a hierarchical model where each level of decomposition gets its own parameter, which they call beta j.

Ada: And this vector of parameters beta j is then estimated directly from the data using levelwise maximum a posteriori estimates. That's how they figure out the optimal settings for those different scales.

Emmy: It means that instead of a single regularisation strength you use all over the place, the strength can change depending on what's happening at different levels of detail in your signal or image.

Ada: Exactly. They show this method works well for both Gaussian and Laplace base priors, which are two very different ways to model uncertainty in these kinds of problems.

Emmy: And they prove that this adaptation is robust, meaning the optimal choice of beta only depends on the noise and prior variances in a very specific way, not wildly on those values themselves.

Ada: That's a key finding because it suggests that once you have this structure, tuning for those variance levels becomes much simpler.

Emmy: It also shows how this tree-pruning approach outperforms standard methods like soft or hard thresholding applied directly to the wavelet coefficients in both one and two dimensions.

Ada: So, we're talking about a way to make Bayesian inversion more expressive about local smoothness while keeping the computational efficiency high by pruning branches that aren't adding much information.

Emmy: It moves us toward priors that are not just mathematically sound but also practical for real-world applications like image reconstruction and denoising.

Ada: And they even show it works in mildly ill-posed deconvolution problems, where you get signals with staircasing behavior but still capture the main discontinuities correctly.

Emmy: That’s a good demonstration of how this structure handles both noise and signal complexity simultaneously, which is really what we need for hard problems.

Ada: The implication here is that for anyone working on inverse problems with wavelet bases, you can replace a fixed regularization choice with something that adapts dynamically to the data's inherent scale-specific sparsity.

Emmy: So this isn't just an incremental improvement; it’s a structural change in how we select those priors.

Ada: It’s about making sure the prior structure matches the actual information content of the wavelet representation at every level.

Emmy: And that adaptability across scales, without losing computational speed, is what makes this method interesting from an algebraic and geometric standpoint.

The paper's improvements: Ada: So, we've seen how they use data to pick the regularisation parameter for random tree Besov priors, and now let's talk about what they suggest doing next with this work.

Emmy: What are the actual improvements they propose beyond just selecting that vector of beta j parameters?

Ada: They show that the noise and prior variances only influence the optimal choice of that regularisation parameter, which is a really neat structural result.

Emmy: That means they can decouple those influences when selecting beta, which simplifies things for the application side.

Ada: They also point toward using this entire automatic selection method as a plug-and-play denoiser inside more general inverse problem solvers.

Emmy: So it’s not just a standalone prior construction; it’s meant to be integrated into bigger frameworks for solving complex inversion problems.

Ada: That is right, and they show this technique works in mildly ill-posed deconvolution problems, proving its utility in those kinds of tricky scenarios.

Emmy: It seems like the focus now shifts from just picking the prior to embedding it as a functional component within existing solvers.

Ada: They also noted that the choice of wavelet basis itself has a bigger effect on the final reconstruction than just choosing between Gaussian and Laplace base priors.

Emmy: That suggests that while automating beta selection is great, you still need to think about which wavelet basis you're using first because it sets the foundation for how much information is even present.

Ada: The authors also mentioned that their results are based on some specific assumptions about the underlying structure of the problem, so they’re not claiming universal applicability yet.

Emmy: They acknowledge that this is a starting point, and future work will need to explore how this structure holds up when you move into even more complex or high-dimensional spaces.

Ada: So the next step for this research involves testing these plug-and-play components in even more challenging, higher-dimensional inverse problems.

Emmy: And that takes us into the realm of truly massive data sets where efficiency starts becoming a real bottleneck, which is exactly where this kind of adaptive structure might shine.

Conclusion: Ada: So to wrap up, this paper on "Random tree Besov priors: Data-driven regularisation parameter selection" shows how you can let data decide your regularization strength level by level through a hierarchical model.

Emmy: It’s about moving away from fixing that parameter and instead letting the sparsity inherent in the wavelet decomposition dictate what kind of smoothness you enforce at each scale.

Kolya: From a probabilistic standpoint, it’s interesting to see how these levelwise maximum a posteriori estimates govern the tail behavior when we're dealing with those different base priors like Gaussian or Laplace.

Ada: Exactly. And they prove that the noise and prior variances only affect the optimal choice of beta in a very specific, predictable way, which is quite powerful for application.

Emmy: That structural result means you don't have to spend a ton of time tuning those variance parameters if you follow their derived formula for beta e.

Kolya: I just want to make sure the constants they find actually survive when we try this in a real, messy dataset, because theoretical bounds can sometimes be too optimistic.

Ada: They did show some numerical results in denoising and deconvolution that match or beat optimal fixed parameter methods across different data types.

Emmy: It means for anyone doing Bayesian inversion with wavelet priors, you have a plug-and-play tool that adapts to the data's local structure without needing constant manual intervention.

Kolya: So we’re looking at a method that handles scale-specific sparsity robustly, even when dealing with mildly ill-posed problems.

Ada: Right. And they’ve positioned this as a useful denoiser inside larger inverse problem solvers, not just an isolated tool for signal processing.

Emmy: It opens up the door for more sophisticated image and signal reconstruction methods that can handle complex features better than previous fixed prior choices.

Kolya: I think the real value here is in making these priors more expressive about local regularity without increasing the computational cost too much, which is a big deal for large-scale problems.

Ada: It is, and this work on "Random tree Besov priors: Data-driven regularisation parameter selection" provides a solid foundation for building more flexible Bayesian models.

More episodes

← Home