On Boston's Unramified Conjecture for GL 2 and McLeman's (3,3) -Conjecture

summary

The gist

Let p be an odd prime number.

In short

The paper proves that continuous odd representations of $GQ,S$ over a complete Noetherian local ring with characteristic $p$ have finite image, strengthening Boston's unramified conjecture for $ ext{GL}_2$. It also shows that conjugate self-dual two-dimensional $p$-adic representations of the pro-$p$ Galois group of an imaginary quadratic field have finite image under certain prime conditions. This result also resolves a sufficiency direction for McLeman's (3, 3)-conjecture.

Key concepts

Odd Unramified Representations over Q
This refers to continuous representations $GQ,S o ext{GL}_2(A)$ where $p$ is an odd prime. The paper shows that these representations have a finite image even without assuming they are residually irreducible or satisfy minimality conditions. This result builds upon Zhang's work in characteristic zero and applies his unramified finiteness results to the characteristic $p$ setting.
Conjugate Self-Dual Representations over Imaginary Quadratic Fields
This involves two-dimensional representations of the pro-$p$ Galois group of an imaginary quadratic field, $ ext{GK},S(p)$, that are conjugate self-dual. The paper proves these representations have finite image if the set $S$ of primes satisfies a modest condition, using Zhang's theorem applied to extended odd representations.
McLeman’s (3, 3)-Conjecture
This conjecture concerns p-class field towers for imaginary quadratic fields. The paper proves a sufficiency direction for this conjecture by showing that if the field has certain properties (p-class rank two and Zassenhaus type (3, 3) structure), then the associated p-class field tower is finite. This relies on structural theorems about strong Schur $ ext{S} ext{-groups}$.
Zassenhaus Type (3, 3)
This refers to a specific structural property of the pro-$p$ Galois group $ ext{GK}, ullet(p)$ for imaginary quadratic fields. The paper uses Pink's structural theorem to classify these groups. This classification is crucial for proving finiteness results related to the p-class field tower and McLeman's conjecture.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

On Boston's Unramified Conjecture for GL 2 and McLeman's (3,3) -Conjecture · Read on arXiv

Let p be an odd prime and let A be a complete Noetherian commutative local ring with finite residue field of characteristic p. Let G Q be the absolute Galois group of the rational number field and fix an inertia subgroup I p G Q at p. We prove that every continuous odd representation ρ:G Q to GL 2(A), unramified outside finitely many primes and with finite ρ(I p), has finite image if p>3 or A has positive characteristic. For p=3, the conclusion also holds when the local representation at 3 is reducible, or the local residual semisimplification has no mod- 3 cyclotomic self-twist. In particular, this proves the two-dimensional odd case of Boston's unramified Fontaine--Mazur conjecture over Q for every odd p. Furthermore, we deduce finiteness results for conjugate self-dual representations of pro- p Galois groups over imaginary quadratic fields under a ramification condition, and for representations of their unramified pro- p groups of generator rank at most two. As an application, we resolve the sufficiency direction of McLeman's (3,3) -conjecture on p-class field towers for p>3. Namely, we prove that if K is an imaginary quadratic field with p-class rank two and the Galois group Gal(K(p)/K) of the maximal unramified p-extension of K has Zassenhaus type (3,3), then the p-class field tower of K is finite. For p=3, we also rule out infinite towers for ten of the thirteen fourth Zassenhaus quotients classified by Ahlqvist and Pink.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "On Boston's Unramified Conjecture for GL 2 and McLeman's (3,3) -Conjecture".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. Let p be an odd prime number.

Ada: Based on recent work of Zhang, we prove that for a finite set S of primes of Q containing ∞ but not p, any continuous odd representation GQ,S → GL2(A) over a complete Noetherian local ring A with finite residue field of characteristic p has finite image <ref:2609.37252#pg2> Odd Unramified Representations over Q The paper proves that for K = Q, n = 2, and p > 2 for odd representations, the continuous representation GQ,S → GL2(A) has finite image without residual irreducibility or adequacy hypotheses and without a minimality condition This result is based on Zhang’s recent work <ref:2609.37252#pg2> The proof first treats representations over local fields, using Zhang’s weight-one theorem in characteristic zero for the residually reducible case and Pilloni–Stroh's results for the residually absolutely irreducible case <ref:2609.37252#pg2> In characteristic p, Zhang’s unramified finiteness results suffice Conjugate Self-Dual Representations over Imaginary Quadratic Fields The paper establishes that for an imaginary quadratic field K, any continuous conjugate self-dual two-dimensional p-adic representation of its pro-p Galois group GK,S(p) has finite image provided the primes in S satisfy a modest condition This is proven by using conjugate self-duality to extend a finite-order twist of an absolutely irreducible representation to an odd representation of GQ, to which Zhang’s theorem applies Specifically, Theorem 1.3 states that if the number of rational primes in TK(S) congruent to 1 modulo p is at most one, then every continuous conjugate self-dual representation ρ: GK,S(p) → GL2(Qp) has finite image McLeman’s (3, 3)-Conjecture The paper resolves the sufficiency direction of McLeman’s (3, 3)-conjecture on p-class field towers for p > 3 by proving that if K is an imaginary quadratic field with p-class rank two and GK,∅(p) has Zassenhaus type (3, 3), then the p-class field tower of K is finite For p = 3, a similar result is proven under specific conditions involving the fourth Zassenhaus quotient and a certain group structure This relies on Pink’s structural theorem for strong Schur σ-groups and Ahlqvist–Pink’s projective embeddings Arithmetic Inputs The paper introduces several arithmetic inputs, including Lemma 3.1 which states that if a continuous two-dimensional representation ρ: GK,S → GL2(F) of GK,S is not absolutely irreducible, then it has finite image Proposition 3.2 asserts that every continuous odd representation ρ: GQ,S → GL2(F) has finite image when F is a non-Archimedean local field of residue characteristic p The proof of Theorem 1.2 uses Lemma 3.3 to show that the image of ρ(GQ,S) → GL2(A) is virtually nilpotent, which implies the claim follows from Lemma 2.1 Representations of Imaginary Quadratic Pro-p Galois Groups The paper proves that for an imaginary quadratic field K, any continuous representation ρ: GK−→ GL2(E) is finite if it is absolutely irreducible, the image is a pro-p group, and there exists a matrix A satisfying specific conditions related to complex conjugation This result relies on Proposition 4.1, which uses an involution derived from the complex conjugation c to construct an odd representation ρe whose image is finite Furthermore, Corollary 4.4 shows that if dp Cl(K) = 2, every continuous representation ρ: GK,∅(p) → GL2(F) has finite image The proof of Theorem 1.3 follows from Proposition 4.2 and Corollary 4.4 Classification and Structural Results The paper utilizes structural results concerning pro-p groups, such as Theorem 5.2 by Pink, which states that every infinite strong Schur σ-group of Zassenhaus type (3, 3) is isomorphic to an open subgroup of G(Qp) for a Qp-form G of PGL2 The proof of Theorem 1.6 assumes the infinitude of GK,∅(p) leads to an embedding into PGL2(E), which then yields a faithful lift ρ: G → SL2(E) This faithful representation's image is finite by Corollary 1.4 The classification of fourth Zassenhaus quotients at p = 3 is noted, with the remaining cases still open Acknowledgments The author acknowledges Dr.

Emmy: Xinyao Zhang for sharing his manuscript and providing helpful discussions <ref:2609.37252#pg12> The author is also grateful to Dr.

Ada: Eric Ahlqvist for discussions on McLeman’s (3, 3)-conjecture <ref:2609.37252#pg12> The paper utilized ChatGPT 6 to assist with language refinement and verifying the logical consistency of mathematical proofs <ref:2609.37252#pg12> The references listed include work by Ahlqvist and Carlson, Allen and Calegari, Fontaine and Mazur, Golod and Shafarevich, McLeman, Pink, Ribes and Zalesskii, Sen <ref:2609.37252#pg12> References The references cited include E.

Paper summary: Ada: So, to wrap up this discussion on "On Boston's Unramified Conjecture for GL two and McLeman's (thirty-three) -Conjecture," the authors essentially proved that for odd primes p, you can get finite images for continuous odd representations over Q without needing those extra hypotheses <ref:2609.37252#pg1>

Emmy: And they also showed a similar finiteness result for imaginary quadratic fields under certain conditions on the set of primes S, which is useful because it links representation theory to the structure of class field towers <ref:2609.37252#pg1>

Kolya: It means that for a lot of these deep conjectures in number theory, we might be able to get finiteness results just by looking at the basic structure and not needing all those extra technical conditions <ref:2609.37252#pg1>

Ada: The title itself is quite broad, covering both Boston's conjecture and McLeman's conjecture, showing how they relate to each other in this context <ref:2609.37252#pg1>

Emmy: It’s a piece of work that uses the machinery of unramified representations to solve a problem about the finiteness of certain field extensions, which is pretty neat <ref:2609.37252#pg1>

Conclusion: Ada: So, we're wrapping up this look at "On Boston's Unramified Conjecture for GL two and McLeman's (thirty-three) -Conjecture." This paper basically shows that you can get finite image results for continuous odd representations over Q without needing extra technical conditions.

Emmy: It connects the unramified representation stuff with something called class field towers. It's like they’re using deep tools from Galois theory to show that these complex arithmetic structures are actually more constrained than we thought.

Kolya: What I see is that for the p-adic side, it's about how those representations behave when you move from the field Q to an imaginary quadratic field K. If you have certain conditions on those primes S, like having only one rational prime in TK(S) congruent to one modulo p, then every conjugate self-dual representation of that Galois group has a finite image.

Ada: That’s the main result for that part. And they use this to actually solve a specific direction of McLeman's conjecture concerning those towers for primes larger than three. It makes the structure of those field extensions finite under specific assumptions about their class rank and Zassenhaus type.

Emmy: It really shows how these representation theory problems are deeply intertwined with the algebraic geometry side, especially when you look at those pro-p groups they're dealing with—the structural results from Pink, for example. It’s not just about the numbers; it’s about the shape of these groups.

Kolya: From a probabilistic viewpoint, what this means is that these towers don't go on forever in all cases. The bound they give you for those representations suggests that the number of possible structures shrinks as you add more primes to S. It helps rule out infinite families of solutions by showing they can't exist under these constraints.

Ada: So, it’s a statement about finiteness across different types of Galois groups and fields, all tied together by the properties of those specific representations. It’s a big step in understanding the limits of what can happen with these objects over Q and imaginary quadratic fields.

Emmy: And this whole paper points toward how we might tackle the broader unramified conjecture for GL two using these techniques to handle the odd representations, which is where things get really interesting next.

More episodes

← Home