Modeling and analysis of a novel two-strain dengue epidemics model considering secondary infections with increased mortality
summary
The gist
Modeling and analysis of a novel two-strain dengue epidemics model considering secondary infections with increased mortality develops and analyzes a deterministic two-strain host–vector model for…
In short
This study developed a mathematical model for two dengue virus strains considering secondary infections and increased mortality. The model analyzes how temporary cross-immunity, antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE), and vector co-infection interact to create complex disease dynamics. It shows that dengue can persist even when the basic reproduction number is below one.
Key concepts
- Antibody-Dependent Enhancement (ADE)
- This occurs when antibodies from a previous infection actually make subsequent infections more severe, rather than protecting the host. In this model, ADE is modeled by comparing a parameter sigma to alpha; if sigma is larger than alpha, it leads to enhanced transmission.
- Backward Bifurcation
- This mathematical phenomenon means that dengue outbreaks can continue to occur even when the basic reproduction number (R0) is less than 1. This happens because the system can have both a stable disease-free state and a stable endemic state simultaneously, allowing for persistence.
- Bistability
- Bistability refers to a situation where the model can settle into two different stable states depending on initial conditions. In this context, it means the system can exist in either a single-strain endemic state or a two-strain endemic state under certain baseline parameters.
- Hopf Bifurcation
- This bifurcation predicts the onset of recurrent outbreaks characterized by oscillations. When the primary infection rate reaches a specific threshold, the system transitions from steady states to stable periodic orbits, meaning human and vector infections will cycle over time.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Modeling and analysis of a novel two-strain dengue epidemics model considering secondary infections with increased mortality · Paper Radio
The paper
Modeling and analysis of a novel two-strain dengue epidemics model considering secondary infections with increased mortality · Read on arXiv
Institut für Mathematik, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz · Ordu University · Center for Applied Dynamical Systems and Computational Methods (CADSCOM) · Mathematical Institute, University of Koblenz · Center for Dynamics, Department of Mathematics, TU Dresden · Institute für Quantitative and Computational Biosciences (IQCB)
In this study, we develop and analyze a deterministic two-strain host-vector model for dengue transmission that incorporates key immuno-epidemiological mechanisms, including temporary cross-immunity, antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE), disease-induced mortality during secondary infections, and explicit vector co-infection. The human population is divided into compartments for primary and secondary infections, while the mosquito population includes single- and co-infected classes. ADE is modeled through distinct primary (α) and secondary (σ) transmission rates. Using the next-generation matrix method, we derive the basic reproduction number R 0 and establish the local stability of the disease-free equilibrium for R 0 < 1. Analytical results show that one-strain endemic equilibria lose stability under ADE conditions (σ> α), allowing invasion by a heterologous strain. Employing center-manifold theory and numerical continuation (COCO), we demonstrate the occurrence of backward bifurcation, bistability between disease-free and endemic states, and Hopf-induced oscillations. Numerical simulations confirm transitions among disease-free, endemic, and periodic regimes as key parameters vary. The model highlights how ADE, waning cross-immunity, and vector co-infection interact to generate complex dengue dynamics and provides insights useful for designing effective control and vaccination strategies in dengue-endemic regions.
DOI: 10.3934/era.2026364
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.
Ada: I'm Ada.
Emmy: And I'm Emmy, here with Kolya.
Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Modeling and analysis of a novel two-strain dengue epidemics model considering secondary infections with increased mortality".
Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. Modeling and analysis of a novel two-strain dengue epidemics model considering secondary infections with increased mortality develops and analyzes a deterministic two-strain host–vector model for dengue transmission that incorporates key immuno-epidemiological mechanisms, including temporary cross-immunity, antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE), disease-induced mortality during secondary infections, and explicit vector co-infection.
Ada: This model highlights how ADE, waning cross-immunity, and vector co-infection interact to generate complex dengue dynamics and provides insights useful for designing effective control and vaccination strategies in dengue-endemic regions.
Emmy: Model Formulation The mathematical model describes the transmission dynamics of two interacting serotypes of the dengue virus within a host-vector framework.
Ada: The human population is divided into several compartments, including susceptibles, infected individuals with strain 1 or 2, recovered individuals from strain 1 or 2, partially susceptible individuals after recovery, and fully immune individuals.
Title and authors: Ada: So we're looking at this paper called "Modeling and analysis of a novel two-strain dengue epidemics model considering secondary infections with increased mortality".
Emmy: It sounds like they've put together a deterministic model for how two different strains of dengue move around in humans and vectors, but they added some pretty complex biological stuff.
Kolya: The key thing I see is that it goes beyond just one strain spreading; it looks at the interaction between two strains and how people get sick twice, which introduces increased mortality during those secondary infections.
Ada: Right, so it’s not just about the first infection anymore, but what happens when you get a second one?
Emmy: Exactly. They're modeling temporary cross-immunity and something called antibody-dependent enhancement or ADE where the disease actually spreads more easily after you've already been infected.
Ada: That sounds really complicated, how do they capture that enhanced transmission?
Kolya: Well, they model it by varying a parameter sigma relative to alpha; if sigma is greater than alpha, that means enhanced transmission due to ADE happens > Emmy So, the model uses this comparison between two rates to show how the disease dynamics change when enhancement is present.
Ada: And they also include disease-induced mortality when you get that secondary infection, which they call delta; though for simplicity in their main analysis, they set that parameter to zero for now so it stays analytically tractable.
Emmy: That’s a common move in these types of models to see the core transmission structure first.
Kolya: But the real meat here is how ADE interacts with waning cross-immunity and vector co-infection; that interaction is what generates the really complex dynamics they're looking for.
Ada: So, if we just look at one strain spreading, it's one thing, but seeing how two strains fight each other through these mechanisms is another whole level of complexity.
Emmy: And the model formulation itself divides the human population into a lot of compartments—susceptibles, infected with strain one or two, recovered from each strain—and then they have separate states for the mosquitoes too, including co-infected vectors.
Ada: That means you’re tracking where every single person and every single mosquito is at all times to see the whole picture.
Kolya: It's a lot of variables, but that level of detail lets them see things like how temporary cross-immunity lasts for nine months, which they call nu minus one.
Title and authors: Ada: Nine months is a specific duration they used for the immunity period, which is important because it dictates when people become susceptible again.
Emmy: The analytical results show that the basic reproduction number R zero of this system is calculated as alpha beta divided by kappa gamma plus mu to the power of one over two.
Ada: And from that, they find that if R zero is less than one, which means the disease should die out on its own, then the disease-free equilibrium is stable >
Kolya: But here’s where it gets interesting for control: they show that even when R zero is less than one, the system can still have a stable endemic equilibrium > This suggests dengue persistence is possible even when R zero is less than one because of backward bifurcation, which means dengue persistence is possible even when R zero < one <ref:2601.07403#pg1>.
Ada: That’s a big deal for public health planning if we're thinking about simple threshold-based interventions.
Emmy: And they also found that under ADE conditions, where sigma is greater than alpha, the one-strain endemic equilibrium loses its stability and opens up the possibility of invading with a heterologous strain > So, enhancement doesn't just increase transmission; it fundamentally changes which strains can coexist.
Ada: That means we have to look beyond just trying to reduce the initial primary infection rate alpha; if ADE is strong, focusing only on that might not be enough to eliminate the disease entirely > Kolya] What does this mean practically for someone on the ground trying to control an outbreak? Does this paper give them a specific number or a strategy beyond "reduce infections"?
Kolya: It suggests that control measures targeting secondary transmission, which is related to sigma, prolonging temporary immunity by adjusting nu, or mitigating those ADE effects could play a more effective role than just focusing on the primary infection rate reduction > Emmy] So we’re moving toward strategies that look at both the initial spread and how the virus continues to circulate through reinfections and co-infections.
Emmy: This whole model gives them a framework to explore that, but they also found some interesting numerical results when they did their simulations > They saw bistability between single-strain and two-strain endemic equilibria under baseline parameters > This is important because it means depending on the specific rates you pick, the system can settle into either one strain dominating or both strains circulating simultaneously.
Title and authors: Ada: And then there's a Hopf bifurcation occurring when the primary infection rate alpha gets to about zero point three three three five five, which marks the transition from disease-free to endemic conditions > Kolya] So what’s actually happening during that transition? Is it a slow fade or a sudden jump in cases?
Kolya: It's more like a sharp branching bifurcation near that value, where the system shifts into the endemic regime as alpha increases > And then there is another event, a Hopf bifurcation at alpha about zero point five zero zero one two two, which gives rise to a family of stable periodic orbits > Emmy] Those periodic orbits mean the system settles into regular oscillations for both human and vector infections that repeat over time.
Ada: So we've got persistence when R zero is low, and we’ve got cycles when the infection rate hits a certain point, which gives us different kinds of things to worry about > Kolya] The caveat I see is that they mention disease-induced mortality as being set to zero for analytic tractability, so that might be an oversimplification if you want a super detailed picture of human loss from secondary infections.
Emmy: That’s a limitation they admit; setting delta to zero makes the math easier to handle, but it means the model doesn't capture that added layer of death when people get sick again > But for understanding the core mechanism of ADE and cross-immunity interaction, it serves its purpose well.
Ada: So, to wrap up this paper on modeling and analysis of a novel two-strain dengue epidemics model considering secondary infections with increased mortality, we see that the dynamics are much richer than simple models suggest > It shows how ADE and waning immunity can create bistability and even allow persistence when the basic reproduction number is less than one.
Kolya: My final thought is that while the model itself has these limitations, it’s a powerful tool for designing targeted interventions because it points us toward controlling secondary transmission rather than just the first infection rate > Emmy] I agree. It gives us a better lens to look at things like how we prolong temporary immunity or reduce those enhancement effects.
Emmy: This work gives us the structure, showing exactly how those different mechanisms—like ADE and cross-immunity duration—interact to create these complex outbreaks > And it sets up the next steps for researchers who want to build on this framework with more realistic parameters.
The paper's summary: Ada: So, we’re looking at this paper on dengue transmission dynamics between two strains that includes secondary infections and how much death happens in those second rounds of sickness > Emmy, so if you want the summary of what they actually did with this model...
Emmy: Well, they built a deterministic model for how two different dengue viruses move through humans and mosquitoes, specifically looking at things like temporary immunity and antibody-dependent enhancement or ADE > Ada, that’s the core structure they use to track everyone.
Ada: Right, so they have these human compartments—susceptibles with strain one, susceptibles with strain two—and then they model the vectors too, including vectors that are carrying both strains at once > Emmy, it's a detailed snapshot of every interaction.
Emmy: Exactly. They're modeling key biological mechanisms like how long temporary cross-immunity lasts and how antibody-dependent enhancement causes the disease to spread more easily after you’ve already been infected > Ada, they’re quantifying those interactions with parameters like sigma and alpha.
Ada: And they also put in disease-induced mortality when you get that second infection, which is tracked by a parameter delta, even though they set it to zero for their main math because it makes the calculations more manageable > Kolya, what does that mean for the real situation on the ground?
Kolya: It means they're focusing on the core transmission structure first; setting delta to zero lets them really see how ADE and waning cross-immunity interact without getting bogged down in all those extra death rates for a moment > Ada, so it’s like looking at a simplified version to understand the main engine.
Ada: But Kolya, what does that simplified engine tell us about when the basic reproduction number R zero is less than one? Because if R zero is less than one, you expect the disease to die out on its own > Emmy, they actually found a situation called backward bifurcation where dengue persistence is possible even when R zero is below one > Kolya, that's a big departure from what we usually expect.
Kolya: It suggests that the disease doesn't just vanish; it can persist because of these complex feedback loops between the strains and the immunity levels > Ada, so this changes how we think about simple control measures like just trying to get R zero below one.
Ada: Right, so they’re saying that reducing R zero isn't always enough when you have these kinds of mechanisms at play > Emmy, and they’ve also identified a bistability between single-strain and two-strain endemic equilibria under baseline parameters > Kolya, so depending on the specific rates you choose for the model, the system can settle into either one strain dominating or both strains circulating simultaneously.
Kolya: That bistability is important because it shows that dengue doesn't have just one stable state; it has multiple possible stable states depending on what’s happening in the system > Ada, so we have to consider both single-strain and two-strain scenarios when planning for control.
Ada: And they also found a Hopf bifurcation when the primary infection rate alpha hits about zero point three three three five five, which marks the transition from disease free to endemic conditions > Emmy, that’s where things start getting cyclical.
Emmy: That Hopf bifurcation leads to a family of stable periodic orbits, meaning the system settles into regular oscillations for both human and vector infections over time > Kolya, so this predicts recurrent outbreaks rather than just a single steady state.
Kolya: So to sum up, this paper gives us a framework showing how ADE and waning immunity create bistability and even allow persistence when R zero is less than one > Ada, it’s essentially providing a toolkit for understanding the non-linear ways dengue can behave.
Ada: Exactly. It sets up the next steps for researchers who want to build on this framework with more realistic parameters to see how these dynamics play out in the actual world > Kolya, so that means future work needs to focus on those parameters we talked about earlier, like sigma and nu.
The paper's improvements: Kolya: So we're looking at how the authors suggest they can make this model better than what they presented initially > Ada, what’s that about?
Ada: Well, they look at where their model stopped working and propose ways to enhance it based on those complex dynamics we just talked about > Emmy, it’s like taking a rough sketch and adding the fine details.
Emmy: They suggest focusing control measures not just on reducing the primary infection rate alpha but also targeting the enhancement mechanism itself, which is related to sigma > Kolya, so they're pushing control strategy toward secondary transmission instead of just first infections.
Kolya: That makes sense. So if ADE is driving things, then interventions that specifically mitigate those enhancement effects would be more effective than just trying to get the initial infection rate down > Ada, it’s a shift in focus for public health planning.
Ada: Exactly. They also point out that prolonging temporary immunity by adjusting the parameter nu could also play a role in making the system settle into a more stable state > Emmy, it’s about manipulating the time frame of immunity to control how quickly people cycle back into being susceptible.
Emmy: They basically argue that you need to look at both sides of the curve; you can't just focus on one input variable like alpha or sigma alone > Kolya, so they want strategies that address the whole interaction between these biological factors.
Kolya: Right, and this ties back to those bistability results we saw earlier; if we can manipulate those parameters—sigma or nu—we might be able to push the system out of one stable state and into a more manageable one > Ada, it suggests that control isn't just about hitting a single target point on the graph.
Ada: It’s about navigating the whole landscape they mapped out, which includes those critical points like the Hopf bifurcation we found earlier > Emmy, so their suggestion is to use this model as a guide for designing interventions that target these specific non-linear features.
Kolya: And what this means for the world is that it gives us a way to test complex control theories against realistic biological mechanisms, showing where simple models fall short > Ada, it's about using math to inform practical decisions in dengue-endemic regions.
Conclusion: Ada: So we’re wrapping up our look at "Modeling and analysis of a novel two-strain dengue epidemics model considering secondary infections with increased mortality" > Emmy, if you had to distill the whole paper down to one big idea for the listener, what would it be?
Emmy: It's about showing that in complex systems like dengue transmission, you have to look at how different mechanisms—like ADE and waning immunity—don't just add up linearly but interact in ways that create totally different behaviors > Kolya, so it’s a structural argument about system dynamics.
Kolya: Right, it’s less about the simple numbers and more about the shape of the mathematical space where these two strains can exist simultaneously, or how they can persist when standard theory says they shouldn't > Ada, it’s exploring the boundaries of what we thought was possible with basic epidemiological models.
Ada: I agree. The paper shows that persistence is possible even when the basic reproduction number R zero is less than one because of backward bifurcation > Emmy, so that’s a crucial point for anyone thinking about disease control in areas where simple threshold-based interventions might seem sufficient.
Emmy: It means we have to be careful not to focus only on reducing the primary infection rate alpha when designing strategies > Kolya, because those secondary interactions are what keep the system going when R zero is low.
Kolya: Exactly. And that points us toward control measures that target how the virus enhances transmission or how long temporary immunity lasts, which is a more nuanced approach than just trying to cut down the first infection rate > Ada, it shifts the focus from just volume to quality of interaction.
Ada: So we’ve seen how this model can predict bistability between single-strain and two-strain endemic equilibria under baseline conditions > Emmy, that tells us that depending on your specific parameters, you might end up with a situation where either one strain dominates or both coexist stably.
Emmy: And the numerical results also showed a Hopf bifurcation at alpha about zero point five zero zero one two two leading to stable periodic orbits > Kolya, so the model predicts recurrent outbreaks that cycle over time rather than just settling into a steady state.
Kolya: That means for someone on the ground, it’s not just about stopping an outbreak once; it’s about managing cycles and recognizing when you're in one of those oscillatory phases > Ada, that gives us a better picture of what to expect over the long term.
Ada: So, to wrap up this paper on "Modeling and analysis of a novel two-strain dengue epidemics model considering secondary infections with increased mortality," we see it’s a powerful tool for exploring these non-linear dynamics > Emmy, it’s about giving researchers a rigorous platform to test interventions that go beyond simple infection reduction.
Emmy: It sets up the next steps for people who want to build on this framework with more realistic parameters to see how these complex interactions play out in the actual world > Kolya, so future work should focus on incorporating those biological factors more realistically into the system.
More episodes
- 2508.20749-Rates of convergence for extremal spacings in Kakutani's random interval-splitting process
- 2509.05860-Concentration Inequalities for Branching Random Walks
- 2509.19309-Small Prime Primitive Roots in Arithmetic Progressions
- 2509.21830-Noncollapsing for Curvature Flows with Inhomogeneous Speeds
- 2510.08346-Separability and Submetrizability in Locally Convex Spaces
- 2510.27290-Borel Combinatorics of Schreier Graphs of Z-actions
- 2511.13500-Sampling Density for Gabor Phase Retrieval
- 2511.19161-Linear dynamics of random products of weighted shifts
- 2511.21548-Metastability of diffusion processes in narrow tubes
- 2512.01536-Abelian approximations for bicrossed products