Formal multiple Eisenstein series and their derivations

summary

The gist

The paper introduces the algebra of formal multiple Eisenstein series and studies its derivations, providing a novel formal approach to classical (quasi)modular forms and building a new link between…

In short

The paper develops an algebra of formal multiple Eisenstein series, which generalize classical Eisenstein series and relate to multiple zeta values. It introduces formal quasimodular forms and studies their derivations, showing that this structure is an sl2-algebra generalizing quasimodular forms. This provides a new link between these formal objects and modular forms.

Key concepts

Formal Multiple Eisenstein Series
These are formal versions of classical multiple Eisenstein series. They generate an algebra called formal quasimodular forms, which have algebraic relations similar to the classical ones. This space is viewed as the image of a linear map from a space generated by products of variables.
Formal Multiple Zeta Values
This space is defined as formal multiple zeta values modulo extended double shuffle relations. A key finding is that these formal values satisfy exactly these relations, providing a new perspective on them and linking them to modular forms.
Derivations and sl2-algebras
The algebra of formal multiple Eisenstein series, $G_f$, is an sl2-algebra. The derivations within this algebra, denoted W, D, and $\delta$, form an sl2-triple. This structure generalizes the sl2-algebra associated with quasimodular forms.
Formal Quasimodular Forms
This is the smallest sl2-subalgebra of $G_f$ containing $G_f(2)$. It is isomorphic to the algebra of classical quasimodular forms and is spanned by specific combinations of generators, such as $Q[G_f(2), G_f(4), G_f(6)].

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Formal multiple Eisenstein series and their derivations · Read on arXiv

HENRIK BACHMANN, JAN-WILLEM VAN ITTERSUM

University of Cologne · University of Copenhagen

We introduce the algebra of formal multiple Eisenstein series and study its derivations. This algebra is motivated by the classical multiple Eisenstein series, introduced by Gangl-Kaneko-Zagier as a hybrid of classical Eisenstein series and multiple zeta values. In depth one, we obtain formal versions of the Eisenstein series satisfying the same algebraic relations as the classical Eisenstein series. In particular, they generate an algebra whose elements we call formal quasimodular forms. We show that the algebra of formal multiple Eisenstein series is an sl 2-algebra by formalizing the usual derivations for quasimodular forms and extending them naturally to the whole algebra. Additionally, we introduce some families of derivations for general quasi-shuffle algebras, providing a broader context for these derivations. Further, we prove that a quotient of this algebra is isomorphic to the algebra of formal multiple zeta values. This gives a novel and purely formal approach to classical (quasi)modular forms and builds a new link between (formal) multiple zeta values and modular forms.

DOI: 10.1016/j.aim.2025.110739

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: I'm Ada.

Emmy: And I'm Emmy, here with Kolya.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Formal multiple Eisenstein series and their derivations".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper introduces the algebra of formal multiple Eisenstein series and studies its derivations, providing a novel formal approach to classical (quasi)modular forms and building a new link between (formal) multiple zeta values and modular forms Formal Multiple Eisenstein Series The algebra of formal multiple Eisenstein series is motivated by the classical multiple Eisenstein series, introduced by Gangl–Kaneko–Zagier as a hybrid of classical Eisenstein series and multiple zeta values In depth one, we obtain formal versions of the Eisenstein series satisfying the same algebraic relations as the classical Eisenstein series In particular, they generate an algebra whose elements we call formal quasimodular forms The space E can then be seen as the image of the Q-linear map G: H 2 → O(H) defined on the generators by zk1 · · · zkr 7→ Gk1,..., kr Formal Multiple Zeta Values The space of formal multiple zeta values is defined as H 1 modulo the extended double shuffle relations The map π: G f → Z f is a surjective algebra homomorphism, with π(G f(k1,..., kr)) = ζ f(k1,..., kr) Theorem 1.1 offers a new perspective on the extended double shuffle relations The formal multiple zeta values satisfy exactly the extended double shuffle relations, i.e., the kernel of the map (2.12) is the ideal generated by w ∗ v − w v for w ∈ H 1 and v ∈ H 0 Derivations and sl2-algebras The second and main part of this work focuses on the derivations of the algebra G f The algebra G f is an sl2-algebra which can be seen as a natural generalization of the sl2-algebra of quasimodular forms The derivations W, D, δ will be given explicitly The algebra G f is an sl2-algebra which can be seen as a natural generalization of the sl2-algebra of quasimodular forms Formal Quasimodular Forms The algebra of formal quasimodular forms Mff is defined as the smallest sl2-subalgebra of G f which contains G f(2) The space Mff = Q

G f(2), G f(4), G f(6): is isomorphic to M as sl2-algebras Corollary 5.5 states that the algebra of formal quasimodular forms Mff satisfies (i) G f(k) ∈ Mff for all even k ≥ 2 and (ii) Mff = Q

G f(2), G f(4), G f(6): = Q

G f(2), D G f(2), D squared G f(2): Balanced Setup This setup is motivated by the idea of making the involution σ simpler on the level of coefficients as it was done in

Zu: for the q-series g given in (1.8) The algebra G f in

Bu3: agrees with the original definition of the algebra of formal multiple Eisenstein series used here Analogues and Realizations The authors introduce a ‘rational version’ of multiple Eisenstein series, which gives a realization in A = QJqK such that ϕ(k 0) = (-2πi)-kG k for k ≥ 2 The image of ϕG in Theorem 2.19 for an arbitrary G f(k1,..., kr) d1,..., dr is given by the combinatorial bi-multiple Eisenstein series value defined explicitly in

BB, Definition 6.4: Quasi-shuffle Algebras and their Derivations The quasi-shuffle product ∗⋄ on QhLi is defined as a Q-bilinear product which satisfies 1 ∗ w = w ∗ 1 = w for any word w ∈ QhLi and aw ∗ bv = a(w∗bv) + b(aw∗v) + (a ⋄ b)(w∗v) The map Der(QL, ⋄) −→ Der(QhLi, ∗⋄) (3.3) ϕ 7→ Θϕ is a Lie algebra homomorphism sl2-action on G f The derivations D, W and δ on G f form an sl2-triple The map ω is the zero map if the sequence (k1,..., kr) is admissible The space E f is a subalgebra of G f Formal Cusp Forms The algebra of formal cusp forms by S f = ker πMf The first example of a non-zero formal cusp form appears in weight 12 = lcm(4, 6) We have M f k = QG f(k) ⊕ S f k The paper concludes by showing that the Ramanujan differential equations are satisfied in G f The Chazy equation is satisfied, i.e., D 3G f(2) + 24 G f(2) D 2G f(2) − 36(D G f(2)) squared = 0 The space M f is Q

G f(k): + hG f(a) G f(b) a + b = k, a, b ≥ 4 even iQ The result that M f k = QG f(k) ⊕ S f k is shown by Proposition 5.

Paper summary: Ada: So, this paper, "Formal multiple Eisenstein series and their derivations," it introduces an algebra of formal multiple Eisenstein series. What they're doing is taking the classical multiple Eisenstein series from Gangl–Kaneko–Zagier, which are a mix of classical ones and multiple zeta values, and creating a formal version of them.

Emmy: Exactly. In depth one, they get these formal versions that follow the same algebraic rules as the original ones. And these elements generate an algebra they call formal quasimodular forms. It sounds like they're building a new way to look at these classical objects.

Kolya: So what does this mean for us? They see this whole space E as the image of a map G from H two to the old circle group, where H is the group generated by words like z k one, z k two, and so on. It's connecting these formal series directly to classical modular forms.

Ada: And they do that by defining a space of formal multiple zeta values as H one modulo some extended double shuffle relations. They show that this map from the generators of the formal series to those zeta values is a surjective algebra homomorphism, which they call pi, and theorem one point one gives them a new view on those extended double shuffle relations.

Emmy: That's interesting because it means these formal multiple zeta values satisfy exactly those extended double shuffle relations they were looking for; the kernel of that map is generated by stuffle products between words from H one and H zero.

Kolya: So, if we think about this structure, the main focus then shifts to the derivations of this algebra, G f. They treat G f as an sl two-algebra, which they say is a natural generalization of the sl two-algebra for quasimodular forms.

Ada: And they give explicit examples for those derivations W, D, and delta on G f. This suggests that these formal structures have a rich internal symmetry, just like the classical ones we study in modular forms.

Emmy: Then they define the algebra of formal quasimodular forms, Mff, as the smallest sl two-subalgebra of G f that contains everything from G f two through G f six. This space is isomorphic to M as sl two-algebras. Corollary five point five says that this algebra satisfies two things: first, every even number k greater than or equal to two has a generator in it, and second, it equals the algebra generated by G f two through G f six.

Kolya: It’s interesting when they say Mff equals the space generated by G f two, D times G f two, and D squared times G f two. That suggests that the structure is controlled by a single generator and its first few derivations.

Paper summary: Ada: And this setup is motivated by making the involution sigma simpler on the coefficient level, similar to how it was done in other q-series papers. They also introduce a 'rational version' of multiple Eisenstein series, which gives them a realization in Q J q K where phi k zero equals negative two pi i to the minus k G k for all even numbers greater than or equal to two.

Emmy: The image of this map phi G, as shown in theorem two point one nine, is actually given by what they call the combinatorial bi multiple Eisenstein series value defined explicitly in definition six point four. That connects it back to concrete combinatorial objects.

Kolya: Moving into the structure of products, they define a quasi shuffle product called star diamond on Q h l i. This product has a specific rule for how elements multiply, and they show that the map from derivations on Q L to derivations on q h l i is a Lie algebra homomorphism.

Ada: And then they introduce an sl two action on G f using those same derivations D, W, and delta, showing that these three form an sl two triple. They also mention that the map omega is zero if the input sequence of k one through k r is admissible. This implies a certain way the algebra behaves when you choose specific inputs.

Emmy: And they have this space E f which is a subalgebra of G f, and they show it's related to formal cusp forms by saying that the algebra of formal cusp forms S f is the kernel of the map pi restricted to M f. They even give an example where weight twelve equals lcm four six has a non-zero formal cusp form.

Kolya: So what does this mean for the bigger picture? The paper concludes by showing that Ramanujan's differential equations are satisfied in G f, and it also shows the Chazy equation is satisfied, which means D cubed G f two plus twenty four G f two D squared G f two minus thirty six of D times G f two squared equals zero.

Ada: And they summarize the structure again: M f is generated by the formal series for even numbers greater than or equal to four and all combinations of g times h for a plus b equals k, where a and b are even integers greater than or equal to four.

Emmy: That final result about M f being generated that way is shown by proposition five point five, which confirms the structure we saw earlier. The whole paper is about formal multiple Eisenstein series and their derivations because they provide this purely formal approach to classical quasimodular forms and link them formally to multiple zeta values.

Conclusion: Ada: So we’ve been looking at how they built this whole system of formal multiple Eisenstein series and their derivations on this paper, "Formal multiple Eisenstein series and their derivations."

Emmy: It’s about taking those old classical ideas from Gangl–Kaneko–Zagier—the ones that mix classical Eisenstein series with multiple zeta values—and giving them a clean, formal algebraic language.

Kolya: Basically, they’re showing how you can treat these complex structures formally so you can actually do math on them instead of just guessing at the formulas.

Ada: Exactly. They define an algebra called formal quasimodular forms, and they link this entire structure directly to multiple zeta values via a surjective map.

Emmy: The big structure they find is that the algebra of formal quasimodular forms is essentially governed by just a few generators and their first few derivatives, which simplifies things quite a bit algebraically.

Kolya: From my side, what’s really interesting is how they handle those derivations—W, D, and delta—they turn it into an sl two-algebra that generalizes the one we know for quasimodular forms.

Ada: And the conclusion they draw is that these formal structures actually satisfy some very famous differential equations we’ve seen before, like Ramanujan's differential equations.

Emmy: They also show that the Chazy equation holds in this space, which is a big confirmation of the internal consistency of this algebraic setup.

Kolya: What I see for someone who just listens to the show is that they’re providing a rigorous framework to connect these seemingly disparate areas—modular forms and multiple zeta values—through this formal lens.

Ada: It really boils down to showing that there’s a deep, underlying symmetry here that we can explore using these formal tools.

Emmy: And this connection suggests there might be more structure waiting to be uncovered in how we think about these classical objects.

More episodes

← Home