Damping of phonons in Bose gas at low temperatures

summary

The gist

Damping of phonons in Bose gas at low temperatures computes the imaginary part of the phononic excitation spectrum in perturbation theory to describe how quasiparticle dispersion relations broaden…

In short

The study computes how phonons (sound waves) in a Bose gas become damped when interacting with a small potential at low temperatures and low momenta. Using perturbation theory, the analysis shows that this damping arises from two main mechanisms: Beliaev damping, where one quasiparticle decays into two others, and Landau damping, where it decays into one left and one right quasiparticle. This provides a detailed picture of how quasiparticle dispersion relations broaden due to interactions.

Key concepts

Phononic Excitation Spectrum
This refers to the energy-momentum relationship ($ ext{E}$ vs $ ext{k}$) describing the sound waves (phonons) in the Bose gas. The paper investigates its imaginary part, which represents damping or decay. A non-zero imaginary part means the excitation is not a stable quasiparticle but decays over time.
Beliaev Damping ($\gamma_B$)
This damping mechanism occurs when a single left-moving quasiparticle decays into two other left-moving quasiparticles. It is calculated as one of the primary terms contributing to the total damping rate. This process is a specific type of decay within the system's many-body interactions.
Landau Damping ($\gamma_L$)
This damping involves a different decay pathway where a left quasiparticle breaks down into one left and one right quasiparticle. The rate of this process depends on the temperature and momentum/temperature ratios, leading to different asymptotic behaviors depending on the specific limits being examined.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Damping of phonons in Bose gas at low temperatures · Read on arXiv

J. DEREZINSKI, L. PETTINARI

National Group of Mathematical Physics (GNFM-INdAM) · University of Warsaw · Universita di Trento and INFN-TIFPA

We consider a homogeneous Bose gas in a large cubic box with periodic boundary conditions interacting with a small potential with a positive Fourier transform. We compute the imaginary part of the phononic excitation spectrum in the lowest order of perturbation theory in the thermodynamic limit at low temperatures and low momentum. Our analysis is based on perturbation theory of the standard Liouvillean. We use two approaches: the first, motivated by the standard representation of operator algebras, examines resonances near zero; the second analyzes the 2-point correlation function in the energy-momentum space.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematical Physics. The day in mathematical physics: rigorous models of physical systems.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Damping of phonons in Bose gas at low temperatures".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Damping of phonons in Bose gas at low temperatures computes the imaginary part of the phononic excitation spectrum in perturbation theory to describe how quasiparticle dispersion relations broaden due to interactions Theoretical Framework and Approximations The analysis considers a homogeneous Bose gas interacting with a small potential, focusing on the lowest order of perturbation theory in the thermodynamic limit at low temperatures and low momenta The paper employs two approaches to examine resonances near zero: one motivated by standard operator algebra representations and another analyzing the two-point correlation function in energy-momentum space The Bogoliubov approximation yields a quasiparticle dispersion relation of the form ωbg(k) = s 1/4k 4 + νvˆ(k)vˆ(0)k 2/2 (1.1) which behaves as √νk for low momenta, defining the phonons Damping Rate Decomposition The main result is that the imaginary part of the quasiparticle dispersion relation in the lowest nontrivial order in κ is given by a sum of two terms: −γB(k, β, ν) − γL(k, β, ν) (1.2) The term γB goes under the name of Beliaev damping and is caused by a left quasiparticle decaying into two left quasiparticles The term γL is called Landau damping and involves a decay process where a left quasiparticle decays into one left and one right quasiparticle Asymptotic Behavior of Damping Rates The paper provides estimates for the damping rates in the small momentum and low temperature limits, showing that the Beliaev damping rate γB(k, β, ν) is given by expressions like 3ˆv(0)ν 3/2 640πk 5/ν 5/2 1 + O 1/(β√νk)3 as k√νk, 1/(β√νk) → 0 The Landau damping rate γL(k; β, ν) exhibits different asymptotic behaviors depending on the temperature and momentum/temperature ratios, such as 3π/3vˆ(0)ν 3/2 40k√ν-1/(βν) 4 1 + O β√νk, 1/(βν) squared as k√ν, 1/(βν), β√νk, → 0 Formalism and Spectrum Analysis The paper utilizes two formalisms for the damping rates: the standard representation approach based on the Hamiltonian with a c-number condensate and the Green function approach using time-ordered two-point correlation functions The Araki-Woods representation is used to describe these systems, where the joint spectrum of the Bogoliubov Liouvillean and standard momentum covers the whole space R(1+d) in the thermodynamic limit The decay of one-quasiparticle states involves computing a shift ξ(k) which is purely imaginary in the thermodynamic limit, leading to nonzero imaginary contributions at the lowest nontrivial order of perturbation theory Computational Results for Damping The computation of the damping rate involves integrals of functions like j(k; p, q) and κ(k, p, q) weighted by thermal factors and spectral densities The final result for the imaginary part of the correction iImδ(k) is given by a sum involving these integrals that yields exactly the Fermi Golden Rule term The real correction is shown to be a sum of contributions from both the Fermi Golden Rule and a Hellmann-Feynman term High Temperature Regimes The high temperature results analyze the limits where βωbg(k) → 0, showing that for the Landau damping rate, it can be estimated as 3π/3vˆ(0)ν 3/2 40k√ν-1/(βν) 4 1 + O β√νk, 1/(βν) squared as k√ν, βnu, β√νk, → 0 The analysis of the high temperature limit for the Landau damping rate confirms that it coincides with results from existing literature when considering a specific form for the potential The paper concludes that in the limit of small temperature 1/βν → 0 and small momenta k√ν → 0, the Landau damping rate is equal to a complex expression involving functions Gk(θ) derived from integrals over momentum space The final result for the Landau damping rate in this limit is given by γL(k; β, ν) = 3ˆv(0)ν 3/2 32/1/(βν)k√ν 1 + O k 2/ν + βν as k√ν, βnu → 0 The proof of this result involves careful analysis of the integral convergence and the asymptotic properties of the functions involved References

1: Abo-Shaeer, J.

Kai: R., Ketterle, W., Raman, C., Vogels, J.

Mira: M., Xu, K., Experimental Observation of the Bogoliubov Transformation for a Bose–Einstein Condensed Gas

2: Araki, H., Woods, E.

Kai: J., Representations of the Canonical Commutation Relations Describing a Nonrelativistic Infinite Free Bose Gas

3: Arnowitt, R., Girardeau, M., Theory of Many-Boson Systems: Pair Theory

4: Beauvois, K., Dawidowski, J., Godfrin, H., Krotscheck, E., F˚ak, B., Ollivier, J., Sultan, A., Dispersion Relation of Landau Elementary Excitations and Thermodynamic Properties of Superfluid 4He

5: Beliaev, S.

Paper summary: Kai: So this paper, "Damping of phonons in Bose gas at low temperatures," it looks at how the sound waves—the phonons—get damped when they interact with a small potential in a large box.

Mira: Exactly. The main idea here is computing the imaginary part of that phononic excitation spectrum using perturbation theory, specifically looking at the lowest order in the thermodynamic limit, which means we're talking about very low temperatures and very low momenta.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, what this paper really tackles is how you describe quasiparticle dispersion relations broadening because of interactions. It's about finding that damping rate.

Kai: Right. And they use two different ways to look at it: one approach is based on the standard representation of operator algebras, which they use to examine resonances near zero, and the second analyzes the two-point correlation function in energy momentum space.

Mira: That's interesting because those two methods give you different windows into the physics. The first one is motivated by how we usually set up these kinds of problems with operator algebras, while the second method looks at how things correlate in space and time.

Lev: When I think about running this on real hardware, I immediately think about what kind of approximations are needed to keep it tractable. What they are doing here seems to be a theoretical foundation before you try to map it onto actual qubit systems or BEC experiments.

Kai: Right, so the core result they present is that the imaginary part of the quasiparticle dispersion relation has two main terms: one called Beliaev damping and another called Landau damping.

Mira: That decomposition is key because it separates the different physical mechanisms causing the broadening. The Beliaev term comes from a left quasiparticle decaying into two left ones, and then there's the Landau term involving a decay into one left and one right quasiparticle.

Lev: When we look at these terms asymptotically, they give us specific scaling behaviors for the damping rates at low momentum and low temperature. The paper gives estimates for Beliaev damping rate gamma B as something like three times v sub zero times nu cubed over two times sixty four pi k to the fifth over nu to five over two plus some error term.

Kai: That shows that in the very small momentum and low temperature limits, the Beliaev damping rate goes like k to the fifth divided by nu squared, with an error term that falls off with something related to one over beta times root of nu times k cubed.

Paper summary: Mira: And then you have Landau damping, gamma L, which behaves differently depending on whether the temperature and momentum scale are compared. For instance, it has a term like three pi over three v sub zero times nu cubed over two times forty k times root of nu to negative one over beta times nu to four plus some error term that falls off with something related to beta times root of nu times k plus something related to one over beta multiplied by nu squared.

Lev: For real hardware, the caveat here is that these asymptotic behaviors only hold when the momentum and temperature are both very small simultaneously. If you push those parameters away from zero too fast, the approximation breaks down and you need to look at more complex regimes where we don't have these simple scaling laws.

Kai: Right. So they establish this framework using things like the Araki-Woods representation, which describes the joint spectrum of the Bogoliubov Liouvillean and standard momentum covering all space in the thermodynamic limit.

Mira: That representation is what lets them compute that decay shift xi of k, which turns out to be purely imaginary in that limit. This imaginary shift is what leads to those nonzero imaginary contributions at the lowest order of perturbation theory, as mentioned in the paper.

Lev: From an error correction perspective, knowing this decay mechanism tells us exactly where the noise floor will be for a system described by these excitations. It’s telling us how quickly coherent states will decohere based on these interaction effects.

Kai: The computational part involves integrating functions like j of k p q and kappa of k p q, weighted by thermal factors and spectral densities to get the final imaginary part of the correction i Im delta of k.

Mira: And what they find is that this integral yields exactly the Fermi Golden Rule term for the damping rate. The real correction to the dispersion relation is shown to be a sum involving both that Fermi Golden Rule term and a Hellmann-Feynman term.

Lev: When you try to translate that calculation into something you can run, like modeling noise in a superconducting circuit, you have these integrals, and they are sensitive to how well your spectral density model matches the actual physics of the medium.

Kai: Thinking about the high temperature regimes, which is when beta omega bg(k) goes to zero, they analyze that too. They show that for Landau damping rate, it has an estimate like three pi over three v sub zero times nu cubed over two times forty k times root of nu to negative one over beta times nu to four plus some error term that falls off with something related to beta multiplied by root of nu multiplied by k plus something related to one over beta multiplied by nu squared.

Paper summary: Mira: That high temperature analysis confirms that the Landau damping rate aligns with results from other literature when you use a specific form for the potential, which is good for checking consistency across different theoretical approaches.

Lev: The paper does acknowledge its limitations, and it points out that the method relies on perturbation theory of the standard Liouvillean, so it stops working when you need to go beyond that level of approximation. That's a big caveat for practical application because real systems are rarely this simple.

Kai: So to wrap up this discussion on "Damping of phonons in Bose gas at low temperatures," the paper uses perturbation theory of the standard Liouvillean and two approaches—operator algebras and correlation functions—to find that the damping rate is a sum of Beliaev damping and Landau damping.

Mira: It gives us specific asymptotic behaviors for these rates, like gamma B being proportional to k to the fifth over nu squared, and gamma L having different scaling depending on temperature and momentum ratios.

Lev: For someone who builds error correction codes, this tells you precisely what kind of quasiparticle decay channels you have to worry about when designing the system. It’s a roadmap for where the noise will come from.

Kai: And in terms of broader implications, this work connects the microscopic physics of interacting bosons in a box to measurable properties like neutron scattering and sound propagation in real systems like Helium-four <ref:2602.07701#pg2>.

Mira: It helps bridge that gap between abstract quantum field theory and the actual experimental measurements we get from condensed matter experiments. We see how theoretical models predict behavior that can be tested by observing things like the quasiparticle dispersion relation being remarkably sharp, even when interactions are present >

Lev: The main implication for future work is moving beyond this lowest order perturbation theory because real systems require capturing those higher-order corrections and non-perturbative effects that these simple formulas miss.

Kai: So, the title "Damping of phonons in Bose gas at low temperatures" points to a deep dive into how the thermal environment and weak interactions fundamentally alter the energy spectrum of sound waves in a Bose system.

Mira: It’s essentially showing us that even in what looks like a simple free boson system described by the Bogoliubov approximation, there is still an underlying mechanism for damping that needs careful accounting for.

Lev: For real hardware designers, it means you can't just rely on the simplest quadratic approximations of your Hamiltonian; you have to account for these damping channels if your device is operating at low temperatures and low energies >

Conclusion: Kai: So we've looked at how damping happens in these Bose gases at low temperatures, and now we need to talk about what this specific paper is actually saying.

Mira: It's titled "Damping of phonons in Bose gas at low temperatures," and the authors are looking at how sound waves, or phonons, get damped when they interact with a small potential.

Lev: Basically, they figure out the imaginary part of the excitation spectrum using perturbation theory at low momentum and low temperature.

Kai: What that means in simple terms is that they're describing how those quasiparticle dispersion relations broaden because of interactions. It’s about finding that damping rate.

Mira: They use two different ways to look at it, one based on operator algebras and the other by analyzing the two-point correlation function in energy momentum space.

Lev: That structure tells us they are setting up a theoretical foundation before you can actually run this on real hardware with real numbers.

Kai: So, what’s the big picture here? This work connects microscopic physics of interacting bosons to measurable properties we see in experiments like neutron scattering or sound propagation in helium-four.

Mira: It bridges the gap between abstract quantum field theory and the actual experiments we get from condensed matter science. We see how models predict behavior that can be tested by observing things like the quasiparticle dispersion relation being remarkably sharp, even when interactions are present.

Lev: The main thing is that they show you exactly where the noise floor will be for a system described by these excitations based on their decay mechanisms. It’s a roadmap for where the noise will come from in actual hardware design.

Kai: So, it's about understanding those specific decay channels—the Beliaev and Landau damping terms—to predict how quickly coherent states decohere in a physical setting.

Mira: Exactly, they give us specific scaling behaviors for these rates that depend on the temperature and momentum ratios. It shows you exactly when one damping mechanism dominates over the other.

Lev: And the authors themselves flag that this analysis stops working once you need to go beyond this lowest order perturbation theory because real systems are rarely this simple.

Kai: So, it's a solid first step for understanding how interactions fundamentally alter the energy spectrum of sound waves in a Bose system before we try to build complex error-correction schemes on top of it.

More episodes

← Home