Universal seesaw mechanism for fermion masses and strong CP problem

summary

The gist

The paper proposes a framework for fermion mass generation based on a universal seesaw mechanism that extends the Standard Model by introducing an Abelian gauge symmetry to explain fermion…

In short

The framework proposes extending the Standard Model with an Abelian gauge symmetry and vector-like fermions to explain fermion mass hierarchies and strong CP violation. A universal seesaw mechanism generates charged fermion masses, while a specific Nelson-Barr structure ensures the strong CP phase remains zero at tree level, generating the CKM phase through mixing.

Key concepts

Universal Seesaw
This is a mechanism where the masses of various fermions are related by a common underlying structure. It uses mixing between Standard Model particles and new vector-like partners to naturally explain why some fermions are much heavier than others, linking charged fermion masses to a single scale.
Nelson-Barr Mechanism
This is a specific way to handle the strong CP problem. Instead of relying on complex corrections, this mechanism uses the universal seesaw block structure. This structure ensures that the physical strong CP angle is zero at tree level, allowing for a consistent generation of the CKM phase through other means.
Vector-like Fermions
These are hypothetical fermions that have both left-handed and right-handed components, similar to SM fermions but with different chiral properties. They are introduced into the Standard Model extension to facilitate mixing that generates the observed hierarchies in charged fermion masses.
Abelian Gauge Symmetry
This is a new type of force symmetry added to the Standard Model, acting specifically on right-handed fermions. This symmetry is crucial for forbidding ordinary Yukawa couplings and setting up the structure necessary for generating the fermion mass patterns and addressing strong CP violation.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Universal seesaw mechanism for fermion masses and strong CP problem · Read on arXiv

Physics Department and Center for Education and Research in Cosmology and Astrophysics, Case Western Reserve University · Theoretical Physics Department, CERN

We propose a framework for fermion mass generation based on a universal seesaw. The Standard Model is extended by an Abelian gauge symmetry acting on right-handed fermions, together with vector-like fermions and scalar fields. The ordinary Yukawa couplings are forbidden, except for the top-quark coupling to the Higgs, which is allowed at the renormalizable level and remains unsuppressed. The charged-fermion hierarchies then arise from mixing with the vector-like sector, and light neutrino masses emerge from a neutral sector Majorana seesaw. CP is exact in the ultraviolet and broken spontaneously by scalar vacuum expectation values. The resulting CP-violating phase is transmitted to the quark sector and generates the CKM phase, while a Nelson-Barr structure, realized through the universal seesaw block form, keeps the physical QCD vacuum angle zero at tree level. Consistency with EDM bounds beyond tree level requires moderately suppressed Yukawa couplings between SM doublets to the vector-like sector. If the leading higher-dimensional operators are unsuppressed, the same requirement can favor a low breaking scale for the new Abelian symmetry. In this regime the vector-like fermions can lie at the TeV scale, with suppressed mixing with the electroweak sector. This framework provides a simple setting in which the hierarchies of charged-fermion masses, neutrino masses, and CP-violating parameters can be accounted for within a common extension of the Standard Model.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Universal seesaw mechanism for fermion masses and strong CP problem".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper proposes a framework for fermion mass generation based on a universal seesaw mechanism that extends the Standard Model by introducing an Abelian gauge symmetry to explain fermion hierarchies and strong CP violation in a common extension of the Standard Model Framework Overview The theory extends the SM by a chiral Abelian gauge symmetry acting on right-handed fermions, which forbids ordinary Yukawa couplings except for the top-quark coupling to the Higgs, while allowing SM fermions to mix with vector-like states After spontaneous symmetry breaking, charged fermion spectrum is generated through a universal seesaw mechanism controlled by moderately suppressed Yukawa couplings between SM electroweak doublets and the vector-like sector The top quark is singled out by a direct Higgs coupling that accounts for its large mass Neutrinos can be Majorana particles and acquire naturally smaller masses through the corresponding neutral sector seesaw Fermion Mass Generation The mass matrix for each charged-fermion sector is written as Mf = 1/sqrt(2) 03x3 Yf vH / sqrt(2) mF λF vS!, where f denotes the SM fermions and F their vector-like partners The light fermion masses are generated by the universal seesaw relation m eff f = -Mf12(Mf22)-1Mf21 = -Yfλ-1Fλf vHΛm / vS For the first two generations, masses of charged fermions can be accommodated for vHΛm/vS = O(0.1) GeV The third-generation charges are chosen such that the ordinary up-type Yukawa coupling to u3R is allowed, while the down-quark and charged-lepton sectors retain the universal seesaw form Nelson-Barr Mechanism for Strong CP A distinctive Nelson-Barr-type mechanism ensures that the physical strong CP phase vanishes at tree level while a CKM phase can be consistently generated This is realized through the universal seesaw block structure rather than through complex corrections to an otherwise allowed SM Yukawa matrix The resulting relative phase is transmitted to the light quark sector and can generate a CKM phase The determinant of the full up-quark mass matrix is shown to be independent of the entries in Mf22, leading to arg(detMu) = 0 at tree level Quality and Constraints Radiative corrections and higher-dimensional operators can perturb the Nelson-Barr texture and induce a nonzero bar theta QCD The most dangerous correction is usually a nonzero upper-left block, deltaMd11, corresponding to a direct SM-like Yukawa interaction Requiring these effects to remain compatible with EDM bounds motivates moderately suppressed couplings between the SM electroweak doublets and the new vectorlike sector If leading higher-dimensional operators are unsuppressed, it favors a low breaking scale for the new Abelian symmetry, implying vector-like fermions in the O(1−10) TeV range Neutrino Sector Realization For order-one Yukawa couplings, Dirac neutrino masses would be suppressed by the same universal seesaw scale as the charged fermions and would typically be too large A more appealing option is to allow lepton-number violation, so that neutrinos are Majorana particles Under this charge assignment, the neutrino sector is described by the following Dirac terms and Majorana mass terms The light neutrino masses are estimated to be mlight nu = O(Y 2v 2H/vS), up to order-one factors In this Letter, we presented a framework for fermion mass generation based on a universal seesaw mechanism that extends the Standard Model by introducing an Abelian gauge symmetry to explain fermion hierarchies and strong CP violation The model is best viewed not as a complete theory of flavor, but as a theory of hierarchies: within a simple Abelian extension of the Standard Model, it provides a common origin for the charged-fermion spectrum, the neutrino scale, the possibility of CP violation in the quark and lepton sectors, and the smallness of bar theta QCD Supplemental Material for “Flavor Hierarchies the Right Way” In this Supplemental Material we give the charge assignments used in the main text and derive the corresponding mass-matrix textures The resulting charge assignment is summarized in Table S1, where x ≡ Rl/rl The scalar charges are H ∼ (1, 2, 1/2, -x) and S ∼ (1, 1, 0, 1 + x), in units of rl The complete neutral lepton mass matrix in the basis (νL, νcR, NL, NcR) T for a single generation is given as Mnu = 0 vT v MH!, where MH is a 3x3 matrix containing the heavy neutralfermion Dirac and Majorana masses The light neutrino masses are estimated to be mlight nu = O(Y 2v 2H/vS), up to order-one factors The complete neutral lepton mass matrix in the basis (νL, νcR, NL, NcR) T for a single generation is given as Mnu = 0 vT v MH!, where MH is a 3x3 matrix containing the heavy neutralfermion Dirac and Majorana masses The light neutrino masses are estimated to be mlight nu = O(Y 2v 2H/vS), up to order-one factors The complete neutral lepton mass matrix in the basis (νL, νcR, NL, NcR) T for a single generation is given as Mnu = 0 vT v MH!, where MH is a 3x3 matrix containing the heavy neutralfermion Dirac and Majorana masses The light neutrino masses are estimated to be mlight nu = O(Y 2v 2H/vS), up to order-one factors The complete neutral lepton mass matrix in the basis (νL, νcR, NL, NcR) T for a single generation is given as Mnu = 0 vT v MH!, where MH is a 3x3 matrix containing the heavy neutralfermion Dirac and Majorana masses The light neutrino masses are estimated to be mlight nu = O(Y 2v 2H/vS), up to order-one factors The complete neutral lepton mass matrix in the basis (νL, νcR, NL, NcR) T for a single generation is given as Mnu = 0 vT v MH!, where MH is a 3x3 matrix containing the heavy neutralfermion Dirac and Majorana masses The light neutrino masses are estimated to be mlight nu = O(Y 2v 2H/vS), up to order-one factors The complete neutral lepton mass matrix in the basis (νL, νcR, NL, NcR) T for a single generation is given as Mnu = 0 vT v MH!, where MH is a 3x3 matrix containing the heavy neutralfermion Dirac and Majorana masses The light neutrino masses are estimated to be mlight nu = O(Y 2v 2H/vS), up to order-one factors The complete neutral lepton mass matrix in the basis (νL, νcR, NL, NcR) T for a single generation is given as Mnu = 0 vT v MH!

Paper summary: Kai: So, to wrap up this discussion on "Universal seesaw mechanism for fermion masses and strong CP problem," what we've seen is that this framework uses a universal seesaw mechanism extended by an Abelian symmetry acting on right-handed fermions. It connects the charged fermion spectrum, the neutrino scale, and CP violation in quarks into one consistent structure.

Mira: The paper argues that this structure can naturally generate hierarchies of several orders of magnitude around the common seesaw scale for the first two generations of charged fermions, while allowing a different charge assignment for the third generation to accommodate the top quark mass.

Lev: From an engineering perspective, it points toward vector-like fermions potentially sitting at a TeV scale if those couplings are suppressed. This gives us a concrete target region to look for in experimental searches.

Kai: And they also show that even with radiative corrections and higher-dimensional operators, the mechanism can remain stable and consistent with electric dipole moment bounds, provided there’s some suppression in the couplings or a low breaking scale for the new Abelian symmetry.

Mira: It’s important to remember that this is framed as a theory of hierarchies rather than a complete model of flavor physics, but it provides a common origin for several key features we struggle with.

Lev: The main implication is that we can look at how these different mass scales and CP properties are related through this universal seesaw structure. It simplifies the landscape by suggesting one underlying mechanism governs them all.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about taking the fermion mass problem and strong CP violation and trying to fix them with one single universal seesaw mechanism that extends our Standard Model.

Mira: Yeah, they’re using an Abelian gauge symmetry acting on right-handed fermions to forbid most of the usual Yukawa couplings.

Lev: From my side, it's interesting because it suggests a very specific structure for how those fermion masses get generated through mixing with these vector-like states.

Kai: The authors are proposing this as a common origin for charged fermion hierarchies and neutrino scales. They’re trying to fit everything into one framework.

Mira: It really hinges on how they handle the top quark coupling differently, keeping that SM Yukawa term unsuppressed while other couplings get suppressed by this new mechanism.

Lev: The Nelson-Barr part is what keeps the strong CP angle zero at tree level, which is a neat trick because it usually requires complex corrections to the Standard Model itself.

Kai: So, they’re claiming this framework can naturally generate CKM phase in quarks and neutrino masses from a single underlying structure.

Mira: The constraints they lay out are interesting too; they need those couplings between the SM doublets and the vector-like sector to be moderately suppressed to stay away from electric dipole moment bounds.

Lev: And if we push for unsuppressed higher-dimensional operators, it suggests the new Abelian symmetry might break at a lower energy scale, maybe in the one to ten TeV range.

Kai: It’s basically saying this extension of the Standard Model could be a very simple way to explain why we see these mass patterns and CP violation where we do.

Mira: The authors are framing this less as a complete flavor theory and more as a theory about hierarchies, which makes the scope a bit clearer.

Lev: It gives us something tangible to look for in terms of experimental signatures, like those vector-like fermions at the TeV scale if the couplings aren't too small.

Kai: It’s a neat way to link three different puzzles—fermion masses, neutrino masses, and strong CP—all through one mechanism.

Mira: It sets up a lot of questions about what that universal seesaw really implies for the whole particle content beyond the Standard Model.

More episodes

← Home