Small-instanton effects in an atlas of Kim-Shifman-Vainshtein-Zakharov axion models

summary

The gist

Small-instanton effects in an atlas of KSVZ axion models investigate small-instanton contributions to the axion potential across various KSVZ models containing vector-like quarks (VQs) using naive…

In short

This study investigates small-instanton contributions to axion potentials in KSVZ models featuring vector-like quarks (VQs) using dimensional analysis. It explores scenarios with single, multiple identical, or distinct VQs, showing how the instanton size integral is sensitive to the UV cutoff. The findings indicate that these effects can enhance the axion mass and its coupling to photons, potentially opening new regions for axion searches.

Key concepts

Small-instanton contributions
These are corrections to the standard axion potential arising from non-perturbative quantum effects involving instantons—topological configurations in gauge theories. The paper specifically looks at how these small, high-scale instanton contributions modify the axion's mass and coupling.
Vector-like quarks (VQs)
These are hypothetical fermions that transform under a gauge group but have masses that do not scale with the energy of the theory. They are included in KSVZ models, and their presence dictates how fermion zero modes contribute to the instanton action.
Instanton-size integral
This is a mathematical evaluation performed over a range of possible instanton sizes ($ ho$). The paper shows that increasing VQ copies can make this integral dominated by very small instantons, which are sensitive to the ultraviolet (UV) completion scale of the theory.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Small-instanton effects in an atlas of Kim-Shifman-Vainshtein-Zakharov axion models · Read on arXiv

School of Physics, Nankai University

We investigate small-instanton contributions to the axion potential across a range of KSVZ models containing vector-like quarks (VQs), using naive dimensional analysis. We consider scenarios containing a single VQ, multiple identical copies, and sets of distinct VQs, requiring in each case that the gauge couplings remain perturbative up to the Planck scale under the two-loop gauge running. The associated fermion zero-mode content varies between these cases, requiring different combinations of mass insertions and scalar--Yukawa contractions for its saturation. Increasing the copies of VQs can render the instanton-size integral dominated by instantons of the smallest size, corresponding to the scale near the ultraviolet (UV) cut-off. The resulting contribution then becomes sensitive to the UV completion and the induced potential can compete with, or dominate over, the ordinary QCD contribution. Assuming that the QCD and small-instanton potentials are aligned, we determine the resulting axion-mass shift and its consequences for the axion--photon coupling. When the small-instanton induced susceptibility becomes comparable to or larger than the QCD susceptibility, the physical axion mass of m a is enhanced at fixed decay constant f a, while the axion-photon of g aγγ coupling remains controlled by f a and the anomaly ratio of E/N. The standard QCD relation among m a, f a and g aγγ is consequently modified, opening new regions of the (m a,g aγγ) plane for axion searches.

DOI: 10.1103/t3qf-t6bp

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Small-instanton effects in an atlas of Kim-Shifman-Vainshtein-Zakharov axion models".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Small-instanton effects in an atlas of KSVZ axion models investigate small-instanton contributions to the axion potential across various KSVZ models containing vector-like quarks (VQs) using naive dimensional analysis The resulting contribution can modify the axion mass and its coupling to photons, opening new regions for axion searches Investigating Instanton Contributions The study investigates small-instanton contributions to the axion potential across a range of KSVZ models containing vector-like quarks (VQs), using naive dimensional analysis Scenarios considered include those with a single VQ, multiple identical copies, and sets of distinct VQs The associated fermion zero-mode content varies between these cases, requiring different combinations of mass insertions and scalar–Yukawa contractions for its saturation Increasing the copies of VQs can render the instanton-size integral dominated by instantons of the smallest size, corresponding to the scale near the ultraviolet (UV) cut-off The resulting contribution then becomes sensitive to the UV completion and the induced potential can compete with, or dominate over, the ordinary QCD contribution Analyzing Semiclassical Estimates The Euclidean action of an SU(Nc) gauge theory coupled to the axion is given by a formula involving topological charge Q The physical vacuum is consequently a coherent sum of the topological vacua n⟩θ⟩ = X n∈Z e in θn⟩ For a unit-charge instanton, the classical one-instanton action is given by an expression involving αs = g 2s4π The instanton-size integral is evaluated over the range of 1/MUV < ρ < 1/Λ The oneinstanton measure of dµI is given by an expression involving CNc, d4x, dρρ5, and b3 The factor (µρ)b3 in the instanton measure is related to the RG-invariant scale ΛG as exp(-2παs(1/ρ)) = (ΛGρ)b3 Characterizing UV Sensitivity The analysis constructs an atlas of KSVZ spectra containing one VQ, identical copies or distinct representations, subject to the gauge perturbativity and discusses the UV sensitive instanton contribution to the axion potential The relevant Lagrangian includes a global U(1)PQ symmetry under which SM fermions are taken to be neutral The color and electromagnetic anomaly coefficients can be computed using specific expressions involving N, E, and NDW The allowed multiplicities must satisfy 2N = 2k + r, where k counts scalar-Yukawa loops and r counts mass insertions Determining Phenomenological Consequences The combined axion potential is given by V(a) = − (χQCD + χSI) cos θ + a/fa The physical axion mass due to the small instanton is m2a = χQCD + χSI / f 2a The relative change in the mass squared is given by chiSI/χQCD = m2a − m2a,QCD / m2a,QCD The largest ultraviolet enhancements of the small-instanton susceptibility obtained from the leading zero-mode closures are MPlΛ31/3, MPlΛ13, and MPlΛ13 for a single VQ, identical copies and distinct VQ sets, respectively Examining Axion Mass and Coupling The additional susceptibility increases the curvature of the potential and therefore raises the physical axion mass The largest one-VQ mass is ma = 3.43 eV, obtained for R14 and R15 The largest physical mass among the distinct spectra is ma = 65.3 MeV, obtained for the NDW = 22 assignment of S4 The largest one-VQ coupling is 4.12 × 10−13 GeV−1 at ma = 1.61 × 10−3 eV for R11 The results show that small-instanton effects can become significant and can enhance the axion-mass and axion-photon coupling in the KSVZ axion models They further show that the resulting axion mass is controlled not by the VQ representations alone, but also by the complete ultraviolet matter content and by the interactions responsible for saturating the instanton zero modes The strongest ultraviolet enhancements of the small-instanton susceptibility obtained from the leading zero-mode closures are MPlΛ31/3, MPlΛ13, and MPlΛ13 for a single VQ, identical copies and distinct VQ sets, respectively We then studied the consequences of such enhancement on the axion mass For yQ = 1 and Λ = 5 × 1011 GeV, the largest one-VQ mass is ma = 3.43 eV, obtained for R14 and R15 Two identical copies of R13 give ma = 71.2 MeV, while the largest mass among the distinct spectra is ma = 65.3 MeV, obtained for the NDW = 22 assignment of S4 (cf.

Kai: Figs.

Mira: 3 and 4) The same spectra were examined in the axion-mass–photon-coupling plane At fixed fa and fixed anomaly coefficients, the small-instanton susceptibility increases the axion mass without directly changing gaγγ The largest one-VQ coupling, as evident from the plot is 4.12 × 10−13 GeV−1 at ma = 1.61 × 10−3 eV for R11, corresponding to 9.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to summarize this paper, they map out different KSVZ spectra involving VQs.

Mira: The thesis is that small instanton effects are non-trivial and depend heavily on the specific VQ content you choose.

Kai: They look at single copies, multiple identical copies, and sets of distinct VQs.

Mira: Because the fermion zero mode content shifts with these configurations, you need different combinations of mass insertions and scalar Yukawa contractions to saturate those modes.

Kai: A key finding is that having more VQ copies can push the instanton size integral toward smaller scales, making the contribution sensitive to the ultraviolet completion of your theory.

Mira: This induced potential can then compete with or even dominate the standard QCD contribution.

Lev: But Mira, when you talk about saturation—those mass insertions and scalar Yukawa contractions—how does that relate to what we actually build in a simulation?

Kai: It's like we have these different ways to "plug in" the zero modes depending on the model structure.

Mira: The paper shows that for a single VQ, the largest ultraviolet enhancement of the small-instanton susceptibility they find is at M P times three to one divided by three, which is MPl over three <ref:2608.08602#pg1>.

Kai: That's a very large number in terms of scale, but it's tied to the single VQ case.

Mira: And they found that for identical copies, the largest ultraviolet enhancement of the susceptibility is MPl over three to one divided by one, which is MPl over three <ref:2608.08602#pg1>.

Lev: So if we take those largest enhancements and plug them into the axion mass formula, what does that imply for the actual physical mass?

Kai: The resulting largest one-VQ mass they find is three point four three electron volts, which they get for R14 and R15 assignments <ref:2608.08602#pg2>.

Mira: And when you look at the distinct VQ sets, the largest physical mass among those spectra is six point five three meV, which they get for an NDW of twenty two assignment of S4 <ref:2608.08602#pg2>.

Kai: So it shows that the final axion mass isn't just determined by the number or type of VQ representation alone; it depends on the entire ultraviolet matter content and those specific interactions that saturate the zero modes.

Mira: And they also checked a coupling result, looking at g a gamma gamma.

Lev: What did they find about that coupling? Did it change in a way that was independent of how big the mass got?

Kai: They found that at fixed decay constant f a and fixed anomaly coefficients, the small-instanton susceptibility increases the axion mass without directly changing the axion photon coupling.

Mira: But they also show that they determine a largest one-VQ coupling value of four point one two times ten to minus thirteen GeV over electron volt at a mass of one point six one times ten to minus three electron volts for R11 <ref:2608.08602#pg2>.

Conclusion: Kai: So looking at the whole picture, this paper shows that small instanton effects can become really significant in these KSVZ axion models.

Mira: It confirms that the resulting axion mass and axion-photon coupling can be enhanced by these effects.

Kai: The crucial part is that the final axion mass isn't just determined by the VQ representations themselves; it depends on everything else—the full ultraviolet matter content and how those zero modes are saturated.

Mira: And the implication for us is that we have to consider this when searching for axions.

Kai: It means if you only look at the VQ spectrum, you miss a big part of what determines the final mass and coupling.

Mira: The results show that this modifies the standard axion mass–photon coupling relation in some regions of the possible (m a, g a gamma gamma) plane.

Lev: From my perspective building for real hardware, it means we can't just rely on one simplified model of the VQ content to predict a specific mass.

Kai: We need to account for these higher-order instanton corrections if we want accurate predictions for experimental setups.

Mira: Exactly. The authors demonstrate that this opens up new regions in the axion search space where axions might exist and have couplings different from what we expect from the simplest models.

Kai: It’s a reminder that environmental selection across vacua, which is what these instantons probe, plays a much more active role than just the tree-level symmetries.

More episodes

← Home