Revisiting predictions for cosmic-ray antinucleon fluxes from Galactic Dark Matter

summary

The gist

The paper presents predictions for cosmic-ray antinucleon fluxes from Galactic Dark Matter and explores their detection potential with current and future experiments.

In short

The study predicts cosmic-ray antinucleon fluxes from Dark Matter annihilation using improved modeling of particle production and Galactic propagation. By comparing different transport models (BIG vs. QUAINT), the work constrains dark matter annihilation cross-sections, showing that heavier nuclei offer better constraints at low masses.

Key concepts

Production Modeling
This involves calculating how antiprotons and antideuterons are created from Dark Matter annihilation and secondary cosmic ray interactions. The authors use state-of-the-art spectra and nuclear coalescence models to estimate production cross-sections, reducing uncertainties compared to previous work.
Galactic Transport
This section solves the steady-state transport equation using the usine code to model how antinuclei move through our Galaxy. The model accounts for primary sources, secondary production, and energy redistribution, using a diffusion coefficient that changes depending on particle rigidity.
Antiproton Constraints
The analysis uses AMS-02 antiproton data to set upper limits on the dark matter annihilation cross-section ($\langle\sigma v\rangle$) as a function of Dark Matter mass ($m_\chi$). The choice between propagation models (BIG or QUAINT) directly affects how stringent these constraints are.
Antideuteron Prospects
This assesses the potential for detecting primary antideuterons, especially at low energies. For light DM candidates, the predicted primary flux can be much larger than the secondary background in certain scenarios, suggesting that instruments like GAPS could potentially detect these signals.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Revisiting predictions for cosmic-ray antinucleon fluxes from Galactic Dark Matter · Read on arXiv

Lorenzo Stefanuto, Mattia Di Mauro, Fiorenza Donato, Nicolao Fornengo, Jordan Koechler, David Maurin

Dipartimento di Fisica, University of Torino · Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Sezione di Torino Department of Theoretical Physics, CERN Theoretical Physics Department at CERN, LPSC University Grenoble Alpes CNRS/IN2P3

DOI: 10.1103/ljzd-c2mt

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Revisiting predictions for cosmic-ray antinucleon fluxes from Galactic Dark Matter".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents predictions for cosmic-ray antinucleon fluxes from Galactic Dark Matter and explores their detection potential with current and future experiments.

Kai: This work is important because it provides updated predictions incorporating improved modeling of particle production, coalescence mechanisms, and Galactic propagation to constrain dark matter annihilation cross-sections Production Modeling The authors compute the CR antiproton and antideuteron fluxes both for the secondary component and for DM annihilation with the usine propagation code They use state-of-the-art production spectra, nuclear coalescence for antinuclei, and Galactic propagation models to derive upper limits on the dark matter annihilation cross-section from AMS-02 antiproton data in different propagation scenarios (BIG and QUAINT) They compute the CR antiproton and antideuteron fluxes both for the secondary component and for DM annihilation with the usine propagation code The differential production cross-sections for the secondaries and source spectra for primaries are calculated from Refs.

31, 32: where coalescence uncertainties are estimated to be 20% smaller than in previous modelings Coalescence Mechanisms The production of light (anti)nuclei is commonly modeled via the coalescence of (anti)nucleons The authors limit themselves here to a concise summary of the implementations adopted in this work, highlighting the key assumptions and parameters They consider three classes of prescriptions (analytic, cutoff afterburners, and Wigner-based coalescence) to connect to the standard literature, retain generator-level correlations relevant for collider and CR applications, and quantify the residual model dependence associated with the bound-state kernel and the effective source description Galactic Transport The steady-state transport equation for the differential density n of Galactic CR antinuclei in the thin disc approximation is solved semi-analytically with the usine code The transport equation includes primary and secondary source terms, as well as a tertiary source term that accounts for energy redistribution of antinuclei The diffusion coefficient is taken to be a generic power law with a possible low-energy break (or alternatively a modification in the non-relativistic regime) and another one at high-rigidity Antiproton Constraints The resulting constraints are plotted in Fig.

Kai: 2, which displays the upper limits on ⟨σv⟩ as a function of mχ ranging from 5 GeV to 10 TeV, assuming annihilation into the b¯b channel The BIG model yields less stringent bounds on Dark Matter Mass mχ

GeV: because it exhibits a low-rigidity diffusion break around 4 GV, which produces a noticeable kink in the flux Conversely, the QUAINT model provides tighter constraints because the corresponding secondary flux follows the AMS-02 measurements more closely in the lower rigidity bins The inclusion of simulated low-energy antiproton data from GAPS can significantly improve the constraints on ⟨σv⟩ for light DM masses, even more than one order of magnitude Antideuteron Prospects At sub-GeV/n energies, the maximum allowed primary flux can exceed the secondary background by up to ∼ 2–3 orders of magnitude for light DM candidates (mχ ∼ 10 GeV), confirming the wellknown advantage of this channel Within the BIG scenario, GAPS could detect O(1) primary antideuterons for mχ ≲ 10 GeV, whereas in the QUAINT setup the signal remains below the experimental sensitivity over the full mass range Antihelium Assessment The predicted fluxes from DM annihilation are ∼ 3–4 orders of magnitude below the sensitivities of AMS-02 and GAPS, although they may approach the reach of next-generation instruments The updated tuning suppresses the expected signal at masses mχ ≲ 10–15 GeV, pushing the expected signal below the detection threshold of both GAPS and AMS-02 in this region, for the b¯b annihilation channel A non-observation of antideuterons by AMS02 could strengthen current antiproton-derived bounds by up to a factor of ∼ 3–5 for mχ ≲ 200 GeV under the BIG model In conclusion, our analysis provides a unified and updated framework for interpreting cosmic-ray antinuclei measurements and emphasizes the complementarity between antiprotons and heavier antinuclei The foreseen difficulty to decrease the modelling uncertainties on the secondary antiproton flux makes heavier antinuclei the only guaranteed route to improve significantly (by up to two orders of magnitude) the DM constraints at low masses Acknowledgments M.D.M., F.D., N.F., J.K.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now, "Revisiting predictions for cosmic-ray antinucleon fluxes from Galactic Dark Matter". It’s about how dark matter annihilation in our galaxy might create these rare particles we call antiprotons and antideuterons.

Mira: Exactly. The authors are taking existing models and updating them by using better physics for particle production, how these particles move through the galaxy, and the coalescence mechanisms.

Lev: So, what's the core idea here? They want to see if we can get tighter limits on dark matter annihilation cross-sections from existing data like AMS zero two antiproton measurements.

Kai: Right. They use two different Galactic transport models, BIG and QUAINT, to test how sensitive these limits are. The paper shows how the choice of model really changes the upper limits they can place on the dark matter annihilation cross-section as a function of the dark matter mass, or m chi.

Mira: And they highlight that in one model, say BIG, you get weaker constraints for dark matter masses below five gigaelectron volts because it has a diffusion break around four gigaelectron volts that causes a kink in the flux data.

Lev: While QUAINT gives tighter constraints because its secondary flux follows the AMS zero two measurements more closely in those lower rigidity bins. That means QUAINT is better for constraining dark matter if you're looking at those specific low-energy regions.

Kai: Then they bring in some future experiments, like the GAPS experiment from Antarctica, to see what potential we have for detecting antideuterons. They look at sub-gigaelectron volt energies.

Mira: That’s a big point because they find that at sub gigaelectron volt energies, the maximum allowed primary flux can be up to two or three orders of magnitude higher than the secondary background for light dark matter candidates, like m chi around ten gigaelectron volts.

Lev: So if you're looking at light dark matter, GAPS could potentially detect one particle antideuteron signal in the BIG scenario for masses less than ten gigaelectron volts.

Kai: But in the QUAINT setup, that signal stays below what their experiment can see across the entire mass range. The paper also looks at antihelium, though it suggests the predicted fluxes are three to four orders of magnitude below what AMS zero two and GAPS are sensitive to right now for b bar b annihilation.

Mira: And they mention that with their updated tuning, the expected signal at masses less than ten to fifteen gigaelectron volts gets pushed below the detection threshold for both GAPS and AMS zero two in that region.

Lev: They also note a specific result: a non-observation of antideuterons by AMS zero two could strengthen those antiproton derived bounds by about a factor of three to five for dark matter masses less than two hundred gigaelectron volts under the BIG model.

Kai: So, overall, this paper presents an updated framework for interpreting cosmic-ray antinuclei measurements and emphasizes that there's a lot of complementarity between studying antiprotons and studying heavier nuclei like antideuterons.

Mira: And they stress that the difficulty in reducing modeling uncertainties on the secondary antiproton flux means heavier antinuclei are the only guaranteed way to get a significant improvement, by up to two orders of magnitude, on dark matter constraints at low masses.

Lev: That makes sense from an engineering standpoint. If you can't nail down the background accurately, you can't tell if the tiny signal you are looking for is real or just model noise.

Kai: So, to wrap up this discussion on "Revisiting predictions for cosmic-ray antinucleon fluxes from Galactic Dark Matter", the main implication is that we need to use these different models carefully when interpreting data.

Mira: And the specific result they highlight is that the QUAINT model gives tighter constraints because it fits the AMS zero two measurements better in lower rigidity bins.

Lev: From my side, it’s about how much overhead we have to add to a real detector like GAPS to actually see these signals for light dark matter.

Kai: We've covered the title and authors, then walked through the summary of what the paper is trying to achieve with antiprotons and antideuterons.

Mira: We discussed how they are improving their existing predictions by incorporating better production modeling, coalescence mechanisms, and galactic transport models like BIG and QUAINT.

Lev: And we touched on how those specific model choices directly affect the resulting constraints on the dark matter annihilation cross-section as a function of m chi.

Kai: We also looked at the prospects for antideuteron detection with GAPS and how it compares to the sensitivity of AMS zero two for light dark matter masses.

Mira: And finally, we wrapped up by discussing how heavier nuclei are key to improving constraints on low mass dark matter candidates due to modeling uncertainties.

Kai: So, that’s what this paper does: it provides a unified and updated framework for interpreting cosmic-ray antinuclei measurements and points toward where future experiments might get the best results.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, this paper is basically taking all our existing knowledge about cosmic ray antinucleons and updating it by using better models for how particles are made and how they travel through the galaxy.

Mira: Right, they’re focusing on dark matter annihilation, so they’re trying to see if we can use these rare particles to find clues about dark matter properties.

Lev: They've used two different ways of modeling galactic transport—BIG and QUAINT—to see how much those models affect the limits they put on the dark matter annihilation cross-section.

Kai: What I found interesting is how the choice between BIG and QUAINT directly changes the upper limits on that cross-section, especially for dark matter masses below five gigaelectron volts.

Mira: That makes sense, because one model has a diffusion break around four gigaelectron volts which causes a kink in the flux data, while the other one fits the existing measurements better in those lower rigidity bins.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that means if you were building an experiment to look for these signals at low energies, you’d need to be super careful about which transport model you use to predict your background noise.

Kai: Then they also looked at antideuterons, which are heavier nuclei, and they found that for light dark matter candidates around ten gigaelectron volts, GAPS could potentially see a signal of one primary antideuteron within the BIG scenario.

Mira: That’s significant because it confirms the advantage of studying these heavier nuclei when searching for light dark matter.

Lev: But they also showed that in the QUAINT setup, that signal stays below what their experiment can detect across the full mass range, which shows how model dependence really matters for detection prospects.

Kai: They also looked at antihelium and found that predicted fluxes are way below what AMS zero two and GAPS are sensitive to right now for b bar b annihilation.

Mira: And they pointed out that with their updated tuning, the expected signal at masses below ten to fifteen gigaelectron volts gets pushed below the detection threshold for both instruments in that specific energy region.

Lev: So, it seems like this paper highlights a real challenge here—we need better modeling of these secondary antiproton fluxes before we can really use them to constrain dark matter at low masses.

Kai: That’s the main point, and it really shows the need for that next step in our understanding.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, we’re looking at how this paper suggests they improved their original predictions for cosmic ray antinucleon fluxes using better physics for production and propagation models.

Mira: They aren't just saying "it's better"; they are detailing exactly which parts—the particle production spectra, the coalescence mechanisms, and the Galactic propagation code—were updated.

Lev: That means they took the original estimates and plugged in state-of-the-art production spectra and used nuclear coalescence models that are twenty percent smaller uncertainties than previous work.

Kai: So what does that actually mean for us? It means when we look at the constraints they derive from AMS zero two data, those limits are more robust because the underlying physics assumptions have been tightened up.

Mira: Exactly, and they tested this by comparing results from different Galactic transport models like BIG and QUAINT to show how much the choice of model actually impacts those upper limits on dark matter annihilation cross-section.

Lev: That comparison is crucial because it shows that the QUAINT model provides tighter constraints on that cross-section for light dark matter masses when looking at those lower energy bins.

Kai: It also suggests a specific way to interpret the data shapes; they found that where the constraints weaken around eight zero to two hundred gigaelectron volts, it aligns much better with what AMS zero two actually measured in those regions.

Mira: That’s a good way to see how the model choice influences the interpretation of what we observe in the sky.

Lev: If you were building a detector right now, this tells you that your background subtraction needs to be extremely precise if you want to get meaningful constraints on dark matter signals at those low energies.

Kai: And they also looked at future experiments like GAPS and projected how they could improve constraints using simulated future data based on the Asimov dataset approach.

Mira: That projection shows that if GAPS gets good, it could improve the cross-section constraints by more than a factor of one hundred for light dark matter candidates below fifty gigaelectron volts.

Lev: That's a big number, but we have to remember those projections rely on the assumptions about how those particles actually travel through space over long distances.

Kai: So, the main improvement here is providing this unified framework that shows exactly where our knowledge is strong and where we still need more refinement before we can really pin down dark matter properties.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve talked through how this paper updates the predictions for cosmic ray antinucleon fluxes from Galactic Dark Matter, focusing on those production models and transport codes like BIG and QUAINT.

Mira: Essentially, they are showing us that better modeling of particle production and coalescence leads to more robust constraints on dark matter annihilation cross-sections using existing data from AMS zero two.

Lev: It’s interesting how the choice between those two transport models directly shifts the upper limits, so it really shows how much we depend on our assumptions about where these particles are going in the galaxy.

Kai: And they pointed out that for light dark matter candidates, like m chi around ten gigaelectron volts, GAPS could potentially detect one primary antideuteron signal in the BIG scenario.

Mira: That’s a big deal because it confirms that studying these heavier nuclei gives us a real shot at finding light dark matter signals.

Lev: But they also showed that for the QUAINT setup, that signal stays below what their experiment can see across the full mass range, which proves how much model dependence affects detection prospects.

Kai: They also mentioned that with their updated tuning, the expected signal at masses below ten to fifteen gigaelectron volts gets pushed below the detection threshold for both GAPS and AMS zero two in that specific energy region.

Mira: So it seems like this paper highlights a real challenge here—we need better modeling of these secondary antiproton fluxes before we can really use them to constrain dark matter at low masses.

Lev: That's the practical implication, because if you’re building an experiment right now, you need that background subtraction to be extremely precise if you want any meaningful constraints on dark matter signals at those low energies.

Kai: This paper provides a unified and updated framework for interpreting these measurements and points toward where our knowledge is strong versus where we still need more refinement before we can pin down dark matter properties.

Mira: It really emphasizes that there's a lot of complementarity between studying antiprotons and studying heavier nuclei, but that the modeling uncertainties on the secondary antiproton flux are still a big hurdle.

Lev: If you’re looking for the next step, it points to how heavy nuclei are the only guaranteed route to get a significant improvement on dark matter constraints at low masses because of those modeling uncertainties.

Kai: So that’s what we covered with "Revisiting predictions for cosmic-ray antinucleon fluxes from Galactic Dark Matter."

Mira: And it leaves us thinking about how these models need to be refined further before we can fully exploit the data from future experiments like GAPS.

Lev: I think the next step is figuring out how much better those production and propagation models have to get for us to make solid claims about dark matter annihilation cross-sections.

More episodes

← Home