Radiative generation of chiral vector operators in b to s nu transition
summary
The gist
Radiative generation of chiral vector operators in b to s nu transition is addressed by systematically classifying one-loop topologies and constructing minimal benchmark scenarios to explain tensions…
In short
The paper investigates how new physics can generate chiral vector operators in B to s nu transitions, motivated by tensions in flavor physics like B+ -> K+nuν¯. By systematically classifying one-loop diagrams and testing minimal models (scalar-rich and fermion-rich), the authors show that the specific flavor structure dictates how loop contributions affect decay modes, leading to constraints on new physics parameters.
Key concepts
- Chiral Vector Operators
- These are types of interactions in particle physics that involve both left-handed and right-handed components of fermions. The paper focuses on how these operators are generated through radiative processes (one-loop diagrams) in the b to s nu transition, which is a key area for finding new physics beyond the Standard Model.
- Topological Classification
- This is a systematic method used to categorize all possible ways that particles can interact at the quantum level. The authors use this to classify one-loop diagrams, distinguishing between those that are mathematically valid (renormalizable) and those that are not, focusing on the most physically relevant ones.
- Benchmark Models
- These are simplified, minimal theoretical scenarios—specifically a scalar-rich model and a fermion-rich model—used to test the general framework. These models help researchers understand how different types of new physics contributions manifest in observable quantities like branching fractions.
- Flavor Structures (A-D)
- These represent different ways the underlying interactions between quarks and leptons can be arranged. The analysis shows that the specific flavor structure chosen significantly impacts whether new physics contributes constructively or destructively to the decay rates of B mesons.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Radiative generation of chiral vector operators in b to s nu transition · Paper Radio
- Evidence for B+ to K+ nu nu bar decays
- Revisiting B to K nu nu bar decays in the Standard Model and beyond
- Search for decays with semileptonic tagging at Belle
- Impact of B to K nu nu measurements on beyond the Standard Model theories
- R nu K(*) and non-standard neutrino interactions
- A Tale of Invisibility: Constraints on New Physics in b to s nu nu
- When Energy Goes Missing: New Physics in b to s nu nu with Sterile Neutrinos
- Complementarity of B to K(*) mu mu and B to K(*) + inv for searches of GeV-scale Higgs-like scalars
- Constructing model-agnostic likelihoods, a method for the reinterpretation of particle physics results
- Disentangling left and right-handed neutrino effects in B to K(*) nu nu
- Disentangling new physics in K to pi nu bar nu and B to K(K*) nu bar nu observables
- Right-handed interactions in puzzling B-decays
- B to K nu nu, MiniBooNE and muon g-2 anomalies from a dark sector
- Search for Dark Matter in b -> s Transitions with Missing Energy
- New strategies for New Physics search in B -> K* nu anti-nu, B -> K nu anti-nu and B -> X(s) nu anti-nu decays
- FCNC B and K Meson Decays with Light Bosonic Dark Matter
- Revisiting models that enhance B+ to K+ nu nu in light of the new Belle II measurement
- Deciphering the Belle II data on B to K nu nu decay in the (dark) SMEFT with minimal flavour violation
- Scalar dark matter explanation of the excess in the Belle II B+ to K+ + invisible measurement
- Recent B+ ! to K+ nu nu bar excess and muon g-2 illuminating light dark sector with Higgs portal
The paper
Radiative generation of chiral vector operators in b to s nu transition · Read on arXiv
Xin-Shuai Yan, Wen-Feng Liu, Qin Chang, Ya-Dong Yang
Institute of Particle and Nuclear Physics, Henan Normal University · Institute of Particle Physics and Key Laboratory of Quark and Lepton Physics (MOE), Central China Normal University
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Radiative generation of chiral vector operators in b to s nu transition".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The recent Belle II evidence for B+ → K+νν¯, combined with a suppressed branching fraction ratio R ≡ B(B0 → K∗0νν¯)/B(B+ → K+νν¯), necessitates new physics contributing to both left- and right-handed vector operators The paper investigates the radiative generation of chiral vector operators in b to s nu transition, which is motivated by tensions observed in the flavor sector, particularly in the flavorchanging neutral current (FCNC) transition b → sνν¯ The experimental observation of B+ → K+νν¯ exceeding the Standard Model prediction by 2.7σ, and the upper limit on Rexp ≤ 1.125 versus RSM = 2.14 ± 0.35, strongly suggest new physics contributing to both left- and right-handed vector operators The presence of the right-handed operator ORV is mandatory for any explanation involving these vector currents Systematic Classification of Topologies The authors perform a systematic topological classification of one-loop completions that radiatively generate both operators without tree-level mediation They define concepts such as Topology, Renormalizable Topology, Diagram, and Model-Diagram to categorize the Feynman diagrams The classification scheme begins by systematically generating all one-loop topologies for a four-point interaction using only three and four-point vertices They discard non-renormalizable topologies, focusing on the irreducible T1-1 diagram as the template for physical realizations Benchmark Model Construction Two minimal benchmark scenarios are constructed to study these frameworks: a scalarrich model and a fermion-rich model The scalar-rich model is notable for its primarily scalar content, combining diagrams that independently generate ORV and OLV The fermion-rich model employs a single topology that produces both chiralities These models are selected based on the criterion of minimality, seeking the most parsimonious solutions Phenomenological Analysis and Constraints The viability of these models is assessed by evaluating their Wilson coefficients under specific benchmark mass schemes and four distinct flavor structures Constraints are established using relevant observables such as B → K(∗)νν¯, b → sτ +τ −, Bs–B¯s mixing, and Z-boson decays For the scalar-rich model under structure D (BP-I-D), NP contributions can provide constructive interference for both channels simultaneously The paper concludes that the specific flavor structure directly dictates the pattern of loop-induced deviations in the two decay modes For correlated structures (A, B, and C), the loop contributions to the charged and neutral channels are strongly anticorrelated Structure D, however, provides enough flexibility to generate constructive loop interference The ratio R decreases in the scalar-rich model where the charged-mode enhancement dominates, and increases in the fermion-rich model where the neutral mode is more strongly enhanced Acknowledgments This work is supported by several national and provincial science funding bodies The authors acknowledge support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China under various grants The authors also thank various institutions for their support in this research project Appendix Details Appendix A provides the explicit analytical expressions for the loop-integral functions referenced in the main text Appendix B details one-loop corrections to Z¯fifj couplings using effective Lagrangians Appendix C provides the complete classification for the remaining five topologies by connecting UV models to SMEFT operators Appendix D details the calculation of NP contributions to b → sγ in benchmark models Appendix E covers constraints from radiative corrections to Z¯ff couplings Appendix F provides the general expression for one-loop corrections to Z¯fifj couplings Appendix G defines the auxiliary functions FV and KV used in the form factor calculations The paper also includes detailed tables summarizing SMEFT operator strengths generated by different diagrams The analysis of the constraints on quark and lepton couplings is performed independently using different experimental observables The final section performs a combined analysis to delineate the viable parameter space based on these constraints The paper presents numerical optimizations for each benchmark model across four flavor structures A–D to determine the upper bounds on branching ratios The results show that in the simplest flavor structure, the scalar-rich model yields an exact cancellation in the charged mode Conversely, for the fermion-rich model under this structure, NP loop effects contribute destructively, suppressing both decay modes below their SM expectations The analysis concludes that the constraints derived from Bs–B¯s mixing and b → sγ are strictly bounded by the quark-sector couplings The leptonic Z-pole observables impose less severe constraints than the perturbative unitarity requirement on the lepton coupling The analysis of semileptonic decays involves the full set of couplings, making a direct analytical inversion infeasible The final numerical constraint on NP contributions is derived from combining bounds across all decay channels The paper presents two benchmark points (BP-I and BP-II) for the scalar-rich and fermion-rich models, respectively The analysis of the parameter space is restricted by perturbativity conditions on dimensionless couplings g ≤ 1 The paper demonstrates that decoupling g2' from other parameters provides considerable freedom to satisfy the flavor structures in structure D The analysis of the ratio R shows that the lowest attainable ratio across all investigated scenarios can be R ≈ 1.41, realized in BP-I-D under the B+ → K+νν¯ optimization The authors conclude by considering the simplest flavor structure where NP contributions to the charged mode strictly vanish The paper presents a detailed analysis of how different diagram topologies generate both OLV and ORV operators Table IV Table IV lists the maximum attainable branching fractions for B+ → K+νν¯ and B0 → K∗0νν¯ in the scalar-rich (BP-I) and fermion-rich (BP-II) models Table V Table V lists possible assignments of quantum numbers under the SU(3c ⊗SU(2L) ⊗U(1α) symmetry to the mediators in diagram (a) to generate operator O RV Table VI Table VI lists possible assignments of quantum numbers under the SU(3c ⊗SU(2L) ⊗U(1α) symmetry to the mediators in diagram (b) to generate operator O RV Table VII Table VII lists possible assignments of quantum numbers under the SU(3c ⊗SU(2L) ⊗U(1α) symmetry to the mediators in diagram (c) to generate operator O RV Table VIII Table VIII lists possible assignments of quantum numbers under the SU(3c ⊗SU(2L) ⊗U(1α) symmetry to the mediators in diagram (d) to generate operator O LV Table IX Table IX lists possible assignments of quantum numbers under the SU(3c ⊗SU(2L) ⊗U(1α) symmetry to the mediators in diagram (d) to generate operator O RV Table X Table X lists possible assignments of quantum numbers under the SU(3c ⊗SU(2L) ⊗U(1α) symmetry to the mediators in diagram (e) to generate operator O LV Table XI Table XI lists possible assignments of quantum numbers under the SU(3c ⊗SU(2L) ⊗U(1α) symmetry to the mediators in diagram (f) to generate operator O LV Table XII Table XII lists the relative strengths of the SMEFT operator Qld generated by diagram (a) for the different SU(2L) models Table XIII Table XIII lists the relative strengths of the SMEFT operator Qld generated by diagram (b) for the different SU(2L) models Table XIV Table XIV lists the relative strengths of the SMEFT operator Qld generated by diagram (c) for the different SU(2L) models Table XV Table XV lists the relative strengths of the SMEFT operators Q(1lq) and Q(3lq) generated by diagram (d) for the different SU(2L) models Table XVI Table XVI lists the relative strengths of the SMEFT operator Qld generated by diagram (d) for the different SU(2L) models Table XVII Table XVII lists the relative strengths of the SMEFT operator Q(1lq) and Q(3lq) generated by diagram (e) for the different SU(2L) models Table XVIII Table XVIII lists the relative strengths of the SMEFT operator Q(1lq) and Q(3lq) generated by diagram (f) for the different SU(2L) models Appendix A Appendix A provides explicit analytical expressions for the loop-integral functions referenced in the main text Appendix B Appendix B revisits radiative corrections to Z¯fifj couplings using effective Lagrangians Appendix C Appendix C provides the complete classification for the remaining five topologies by connecting high-scale UV models to LEFT basis SMEFT operators Appendix D Appendix D details the calculation of NP contributions to b → sγ in benchmark models Appendix E Appendix E covers constraints from radiative corrections to effective Z-boson couplings Appendix F Appendix F provides the general expression for one-loop corrections to Z¯fifj couplings Appendix G Appendix G defines the auxiliary functions FV and KV used in the form factor calculations The paper also includes detailed tables summarizing SMEFT operator strengths generated by different diagrams The analysis of constraints on quark and lepton couplings is performed independently using different experimental observables The final section performs a combined analysis to delineate the viable parameter space based on these constraints Table I Table I presents SM gauge quantum number assignments for the internal fields of diagram (c) that generate the operator O LV The table provides specific SU(3c) and SU(2L) representations for different cases Table II Table II summarizes the relative strengths of the SMEFT operators Q(1lq) and Q(3lq) generated by diagram (c) for the different SU(2L) models Table III Table III presents particle content and SM gauge representations for the scalar-rich (left) and fermion-rich (right) benchmark models The table defines the quantum numbers for each field in both models Table IV Table IV presents the maximum attainable branching fractions for B+ → K+νν¯ and B0 → K∗0νν¯ in the scalar-rich (BP-I) and fermion-rich (BP-II) models Table IX
Title and authors: Kai: Let's look at the title of this paper, "Radiative generation of chiral vector operators in b to s nu transition". It sounds very technical, which is expected for this kind of work.
Mira: It points directly to the core mechanism: radiative generation of chiral vector operators in a b to s neutrino transition. So we’re talking about how these specific types of interactions appear through loops between the Standard Model particles and some new physics.
Lev: What that really means is they are looking for ways to create these left- and right-handed vector operators without needing some kind of direct tree-level coupling from a heavy mediator.
Kai: Right, that’s the big deal because if we find them generated at one loop, it means the new physics can be relatively high scale while still showing up in low energy observables like these B decays.
Mira: The authors are Xin-Shuai Yan, Wen-Feng Liu, Qin Chang and Ya-Dong Yang from Henan Normal University and Central China Normal University. They are the ones who did this systematic topological classification of one-loop completions to generate both OLV and ORV.
Lev: And they defined concepts like Topology, Renormalizable Topology, Diagram, and Model-Diagram to systematically classify all the possible ways these operators can appear in a loop without tree-level mediation.
Kai: They focus on the irreducible T1-one diagram as the template for physical realizations because it represents a genuine one-loop contribution that they think is physically relevant <ref:2601.18147#pg1>.
Mira: They then construct two minimal benchmark scenarios, a scalarrich model and a fermion-rich model, to study these frameworks under specific mass schemes and flavor structures.
Lev: These models are chosen because they’re the most parsimonious ways to introduce new particles capable of generating both chiralities in the loop.
Kai: So, we have this framework for finding new physics that can explain the tensions in the B+ to K+nuν¯ measurement and that ratio R.
Mira: This sets up a systematic search strategy based on these two minimal scenarios, which is what they want us to consider when looking at future data.
Lev: We’re essentially mapping out what kind of new physics couplings we would expect if this radiative generation mechanism was the source of the observed deviations in B decays.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, to summarize what they’re doing, they take all those one-loop topologies and systematically classify them to find how both OLV and ORV operators can be generated.
Mira: They are classifying diagrams involving new scalars and fermions, focusing on the irreducible T1-one diagram because it avoids reducible vertices that would just imply a tree-level contribution instead of a genuine loop effect <ref:2601.18147#pg1>.
Lev: So they’re filtering out any diagrams that have an ultraviolet divergent loop integral, like diagram T2-two because those require special symmetry or fine-tuning to make them dominant without introducing an unwanted tree-level term <ref:2601.18147#pg1>.
Kai: They focus their analysis on the irreducible T1-one diagram which is a genuine one-loop realization of these operators fifty-seven fifty-eight <ref:2601.18147#pg3,analysis on the irreducible T1-1 diagram which>.
Mira: They then employ four representative flavor structures for the quark sector and evaluate the Wilson coefficients under specific mass schemes to determine the maximum reach of these radiative contributions.
Lev: The result they get is that for correlated structures A, B, and C, they find a generic anti-correlation where enhancing one decay channel typically suppresses the other.
Kai: That’s an important point because it means you can’t just have a simple enhancement in one decay mode without worrying about the other.
Mira: However, they found an exception within the scalar-rich model: a decoupled flavor configuration within that model which yields simultaneous constructive interference.
Lev: So that specific arrangement is a key result because it shows there’s a way to get constructive interference for both channels at the same time in this framework.
Kai: It means structure D is important because it offers enough flexibility to explore these different interference patterns across both the charged and neutral decay rates.
Mira: This analysis quantitatively determines the maximum reach of these loop contributions while making sure they are compatible with constraints from complementary flavor observables.
Lev: They use Bs minus B bar s mixing and b to s gamma as key constraints to check if their predicted NP contributions are allowed by existing experimental limits.
The paper's improvements: Kai: One improvement they suggest is a more comprehensive classification of the remaining five topologies by connecting high-scale UV models to the LEFT basis SMEFT operators.
Mira: They also include detailed appendices covering things like one-loop corrections to Z bar fifj couplings using effective Lagrangians, and how to connect diagrams to UV models in appendix C.
Lev: Appendix D specifically details the calculation of new physics contributions to b to s gamma in the benchmark models under structure D.
Kai: They also have appendix E covering constraints from radiative corrections to Z bar fifj couplings, which is useful for checking model consistency with electroweak precision data.
Mira: Appendix F gives the general expression for one-loop corrections to Z bar fifj couplings, and Appendix G defines auxiliary functions FV and KV used in the form factor calculations.
Lev: Table IV summarizes the maximum attainable branching fractions for B+ to K+nuν¯ and B0 to K∗0nuν¯ in both the scalar-rich BP-I and fermion-rich BP-II models <ref:2601.18147#pg1>.
Kai: They also have detailed tables summarizing SMEFT operator strengths generated by different diagrams across all these different SU(2L) models, which is useful for seeing how the couplings scale <ref:2601.18147#pg1>.
Mira: And they perform independent analyses on constraints on quark and lepton couplings using different experimental observables to get a broader picture of the viable parameter space.
Lev: The final section does a combined analysis to delineate the viable parameter space based on all these constraints, including perturbativity conditions where dimensionless couplings stay below one in that region.
Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up the paper "Radiative generation of chiral vector operators in b to s nu transition", the main point is how flavor structure dictates the pattern of loop-induced deviations.
Mira: Specifically, for correlated structures A, B, and C, you get a generic anti-correlation between charged and neutral channels.
Lev: But structure D is an exception where constructive interference can happen in both channels at the same time due to the specific way the model is set up.
Kai: In this case, we see that for the scalar-rich model, R decreases when the charged mode enhancement dominates, and in the fermion-rich model, it increases when neutral mode is more strongly enhanced.
Mira: The paper demonstrates that even with these constraints from Bs minus B bar s mixing and b to s gamma being bounded by quark couplings.
Lev: So for the final result from this work on "Radiative generation of chiral vector operators in b to s nu transition", the lowest attainable ratio R can be about one point four one, realized in BP-I-D under the B+ to K+nuν¯ optimization.
Kai: It’s a specific numerical bound derived from combining all those constraints across all decay channels.
Mira: So we’re left with a clear picture of where new physics might show up in these decays if it's through this radiative mechanism.
Lev: The paper lays out the detailed analysis of how different diagram topologies generate both OLV and ORV operators, giving us a complete map for future searches.
More episodes
- 2610.38463-Gauge-parameter cancellation and finite form factors in one-loop quark scattering in the refined Gribov-Zwanziger framework
- 2610.37198-Searches for new particle physics by methods of classical and neutrino astronomy
- 2511.15779-SURFing to the Fundamental Limit of Jet Tagging
- 2505.01492-Photo- and Hadrodisintegration constraints on massive relics decaying into neutrinos
- 2505.20389-Dispersion relation of the neutrino plasma: Unifying fast, slow, and collisional instabilities
- 2511.10731-Keeping It Renormalizable: Minimal Baryogenesis induced Asymmetric Dark Matter
- 2404.04021-Vacuum correlations of the stress-energy-momentum tensor with constituent quarks
- 2503.02931-Relativistic Navier-Stokes description of the quark-gluon plasma radial flow
- 2606.06105-Bulk viscosity of a binary mixture: the role of the intra-species interaction
- 2607.03343-First look at the evaluation of two-loop Feynman integrals for radiative return processes