Radiative decays of J/psi,, psi(2S) to gamma eta in perturbative QCD with relativistic corrections
summary
The gist
The paper presents the first calculation of radiative decays J/ψ, ψ(2S) → γη(′) in perturbative QCD that includes order-q2 relativistic corrections in all three shortdistance contributions…
In short
This study calculates radiative decays of J/psi and psi(2S) to gamma eta using perturbative QCD with order-q² relativistic corrections across quark, gluon, and QED contributions. Results show the corrections significantly enhance branching ratios for both charmonia, but the expansion converges poorly for psi(2S), suggesting physics beyond the hard process is needed.
Key concepts
- Perturbative QCD
- This approach uses calculations based on Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) where interactions are treated as a series of small corrections. It helps describe high-energy processes like the decay by calculating amplitudes using Feynman diagrams, focusing on the short-distance interactions between quarks and gluons.
- Relativistic Corrections
- These corrections account for special relativity effects in the decay process. They are crucial because they significantly increase the predicted branching ratios for both J/psi and psi(2S) when compared to simpler calculations, showing that relativistic effects play a major role in these decays.
- Light-Cone Distribution Amplitude (DA)
- The DA describes how the momentum is distributed among the quarks inside the light meson. The paper finds that the main quark contribution is remarkably insensitive to this distribution and light-quark mass, which increases confidence in their predictions.
- Mixing Schemes
- These are different mathematical ways to combine theoretical contributions, particularly concerning how η and η' mesons mix. The ratio R1S is highly sensitive to the mixing angle, helping theorists distinguish between different models of this mixing.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Radiative decays of J/psi,, psi(2S) to gamma eta in perturbative QCD with relativistic corrections · Paper Radio
- Heavy Quarkonium Physics
- Heavy quarkonium: progress, puzzles, and opportunities
- Charmonium
- Quarkonia and their transitions
- Mixing and Decay Constants of Pseudoscalar Mesons
- Ultimate survival in anomalous psi(2S) decays
- Understanding the radiative decays of vector charmonia to light pseudoscalar mesons
- Reexamining radiative decays of 1-- quarkonium into eta' and eta
- Radiative decays J/psi to eta gamma in perturbative QCD
- Revisiting the OZI-forbidden Radiative Decays of Orthoquarkonia
- upsilon(1s)--> gamma(eta', eta) decays
- Radiative decays of charmonium into light mesons
- Revisiting the radiative decays J/psi to gamma eta in perturbative QCD
- Relativistic corrections to J/psi exclusive and inclusive double charm production at B factories
- Relativistic Corrections to e+e- to J/psi + eta c in a Potential Model
- Heavy quarkonium decay V to ggg with both relativistic and QCD radiative corrections
- A study of relativistic corrections to J/psi to p p bar decay
- Relativistic corrections to psi(nS) to rho pi exclusive decays and their role in the understanding of the rho pi-puzzle
- Three-gluon decays of radially excited quarkonia psi(2S) and upsilon(2S) with both relativistic and QCD radiative corrections
- Relativistic effects in the double S- and P-wave charmonium production in e+e- annihilation
The paper
Radiative decays of J/psi,, psi(2S) to gamma eta in perturbative QCD with relativistic corrections · Read on arXiv
College of Physics and Electronic Science, Hubei Normal University
DOI: 10.1103/jsxb-5335
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Radiative decays of J/psi,, psi(2S) to gamma eta in perturbative QCD with relativistic corrections".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents the first calculation of radiative decays J/ψ, ψ(2S) → γη(′) in perturbative QCD that includes order-q2 relativistic corrections in all three shortdistance contributions, namely the quark-antiquark, two-gluon, and QED contributions The amplitudes are found to be remarkably insensitive to the light-cone distribution amplitude and to the light-quark mass, a robustness that persists through order q2 and makes the predictions correspondingly reliable The relativistic correction enhances the J/ψ branching ratios by roughly a factor of two, narrowing their shortfall from experiment, whereas for the ψ(2S) it is about twice as large as for the J/ψ and the low-order expansion converges poorly In two representative η–η′ mixing schemes, the ratio R1S = B(γη′)/B(γη) proves sharply sensitive to the mixing angle and favours the smaller of the two The predicted ψ(2S) rates lie well above the data in both channels, already at leading order, and most severely for the anomalously small γη channel Such a discrepancy suggests that a mechanism beyond the hard perturbative process is at work Theoretical Framework The theoretical description of these decays involves two main approaches: nonperturbative and perturbative.
Kai: The first approach, nonperturbative, assumes the transition is dominated by the UA(1) anomaly and is controlled by the gluonic matrix elements ⟨0GaµνG˜a,µνη(′)⟩.
Mira: The second approach is perturbative, where the amplitude for these decays is generated at leading twist by the subprocess cc¯ → γg∗g∗.
Kai: Quark-Content Contribution The quark-content contribution proceeds through the annihilation of the cc¯ pair into a photon and two virtual gluons, which subsequently convert into the qq¯ content of the η(′).
Title and authors: Mira: Now, let's talk about the structure of this paper, "Radiative decays of J/psi,, psi(2S) to gamma eta in perturbative QCD with relativistic corrections <ref:2607.23737#pg1,in perturbative QCD with relativistic corrections>." It lays out two main theoretical approaches for these decays.
Kai: The first approach is nonperturbative, which assumes the decay is dominated by the UA(one) anomaly, meaning it’s controlled by certain gluonic matrix elements like <0GaµνG˜a,µνη(′) > <ref:2607.23737#pg2,dominated by the UA(1) anomaly>.
Lev: And this nonperturbative side involves estimating those matrix elements in the large-Nc expansion and using the QCD multipole formalism. That's where things get phenomenological constants like fq, fs, and the mixing angle phi come into play to describe things like that FKS scheme nine <ref:2607.23737#pg2,fq, fs, and the mixing angle>.
Mira: The second approach is perturbative, where they calculate the amplitude at leading twist from the process cc¯ → γg*g*. This calculation involves two steps: calculating ψn → γg*g* and then g*g* → η(′) separately before joining them with gluon propagators and loop integrations over gluon momentum.
Kai: When we look at the quark-content contribution, it proceeds through the annihilation of a cc¯ pair into a photon and two virtual gluons, which then convert into the qq¯ content of the eta prime.
Lev: The leading-order amplitude for that part is governed by something called Rψn(zero), and they use its Laplacian, ∇2Rψn(zero), to account for the relativistic correction <ref:2607.23737#pg2>.
Mira: Then there’s the gluon-content contribution, which uses the same hard process but involves those two gluons coupling directly to the leading-twist gluonic distribution amplitude of the eta prime.
Kai: The leading-order kernel for that gluon part simplifies down to just two terms, A and B, I g0(u) = NA g P0 Pu + N B g P0 u¯ (thirty-two).
Lev: They note that the q-squared correction in the gluon contribution is smaller still than in the quark one, so it’s subleading compared to the quark contribution.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, putting that together, this paper summarizes how they calculated all three components—quark, gluon, and QED—and how they added them up coherently to fix the partial width for ψn → γη′.
Mira: They found that the dominant quark amplitude is by far the largest contribution to the total rate. And when you look at its q-squared piece, it’s actually nearly as large as its leading order itself, so Hq almost doubles in both channels compared to how much it grew for the J/psi.
Lev: That doubling of the quark amplitude is significant because it suggests a strong enhancement from that specific part of the calculation.
Kai: Then you have this QED contribution, which involves cc¯ annihilating into a single virtual photon, and a key feature there is that the charm line carries no internal propagator.
Mira: And because of that, the hard amplitude for the QED piece is independent of the relative momentum ˆq', and its q-squared relativistic correction vanishes identically, leaving it purely at leading order.
Lev: So, in terms of structure, you have a very strong quark component enhanced by relativistic effects, a smaller gluon component where the correction is less significant, and a QED part that stays at leading order.
Kai: This whole setup means that the partial width for ψn → γη′ is fixed by the modulus squared of the single helicity amplitude to which all three contributions add coherently.
Mira: But they also point out that there’s another, physically distinct mechanism where the cc¯ pair doesn't annihilate but survives and enters through the ηc component of the meson.
The paper's improvements: Lev: Now let’s talk about what improvements this paper suggests for future work, because they point out some major weaknesses in their current approach.
Kai: They focus on the fact that for the psi(2S), the q-squared correction is as large as the leading order, and this means a poor convergence of the expansion when we look at that relative momentum expansion <ref:2607.23737#pg1>.
Mira: That poor convergence undermines their ability to make a quantitative account of that psi(2S) relativistic correction, which is why they flag it as a difficult problem <ref:2607.23737#pg1>.
Lev: They suggest that instead of just truncating the expansion at q-squared, you need to retain the full relative-momentum dependence of the hard kernel rather than just cutting off at q-squared.
Kai: That means for psi(2S), we should be looking at keeping more than just the q-squared truncation, which is a lot more work computationally <ref:2607.23737#pg1>.
Mira: But they also highlight that this whole situation with the mixing angle—the sensitivity of the gamma-eta rates and ratios—ties this interference very closely to the choice of mixing scheme.
Lev: So, a clean extraction of how these two mechanisms interfere might be difficult because it depends so much on which scheme you choose.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up the paper "Radiative decays of J/psi,, psi(2S) to gamma eta in perturbative QCD with relativistic corrections," the main conclusion is that the dominant quark-antiquark contribution is almost completely insensitive to the light-cone distribution amplitude and to the light-quark mass <ref:2607.23737#pg1,insensitive to the light-cone distribution amplitude and to the light-quark>.
Mira: They say it varies by less than two percent across three different distribution amplitude models and less than one percent over the light-quark mass range, which makes those parts very reliable.
Lev: The q-squared correction is essential in closing the gap for J/psi branching ratios, but for psi(2S) it’s comparable to the leading order, which is a big difference <ref:2607.23737#pg1>.
Kai: The enhancement for psi(2S) is about twice as large as it is for the J/psi, and that poor convergence with the q-squared correction makes a quantitative account of that expansion difficult <ref:2607.23737#pg1,is about twice as large as>.
Mira: And they confirm that the lattice scheme favors the smaller mixing angle, which aligns with what we saw in previous leading-order conclusions.
Lev: In short, while these calculations are reliable for J/psi and psi(2S) because of the relativistic correction, extracting the full picture requires more work on those nonperturbative aspects <ref:2607.23737#pg1>.
Kai: It’s a solid piece of work that shows how to incorporate higher-order effects consistently across all three shortdistance contributions in this decay process.
Mira: This paper on "Radiative decays of J/psi,, psi(2S) to gamma eta in perturbative QCD with relativistic corrections" gives us a concrete picture of the enhancements and the limitations we need to address next <ref:2607.23737#pg1,in perturbative QCD with relativistic corrections>.
More episodes
- 2610.38463-Gauge-parameter cancellation and finite form factors in one-loop quark scattering in the refined Gribov-Zwanziger framework
- 2610.37198-Searches for new particle physics by methods of classical and neutrino astronomy
- 2511.15779-SURFing to the Fundamental Limit of Jet Tagging
- 2505.01492-Photo- and Hadrodisintegration constraints on massive relics decaying into neutrinos
- 2505.20389-Dispersion relation of the neutrino plasma: Unifying fast, slow, and collisional instabilities
- 2511.10731-Keeping It Renormalizable: Minimal Baryogenesis induced Asymmetric Dark Matter
- 2404.04021-Vacuum correlations of the stress-energy-momentum tensor with constituent quarks
- 2503.02931-Relativistic Navier-Stokes description of the quark-gluon plasma radial flow
- 2606.06105-Bulk viscosity of a binary mixture: the role of the intra-species interaction
- 2607.03343-First look at the evaluation of two-loop Feynman integrals for radiative return processes