Probing the X(3700) through two-photon D production in ultraperipheral collisions and at the EIC

summary

The gist

Probing the X(3700) through two-photon D production in ultraperipheral collisions and at the EIC investigates whether photon-induced production in ultraperipheral heavy-ion collisions and at the EIC…

In short

This study investigates searching for a scalar molecular candidate, X(3700), by looking at two-photon production of D mesons in ultraperipheral heavy-ion collisions and at the Electron-Ion Collider (EIC). The analysis uses coupled-channel calculations to interpret observed features, finding consistent dressed-to-bare ratios across both collision types, suggesting a common underlying dynamics near the production threshold.

Key concepts

Ultraperipheral Collisions (UPCs)
These are high-energy collisions between heavy ions where the impact parameter is large enough that the nuclei pass each other without touching. In these events, photons from one nucleus interact with the other, providing a unique environment to study photon-induced production processes.
Dressed-to-Bare Ratios
These ratios compare theoretical calculations that include final-state interactions (dressing) with simpler calculations that ignore them (bare). They serve as a diagnostic tool to quantify how strongly the produced particles interact after they are created, helping researchers understand the nature of the bound state.
Bound State Interpretation
The analysis found a theoretical bound state at an invariant mass of 3.7162 GeV, which is below the threshold for producing D0Dbar0 mesons. This suggests that observed features in the continuum spectrum are not isolated peaks but are distorted by this underlying molecular structure.
Two-Photon Production Channels
The study models the production of D+D- and D0Dbar0 pairs via two photons ($\gamma\gamma$). It distinguishes between charged and neutral channels, using different exchange mechanisms (like scalar-QED terms or $D^*$ exchange) to understand the specific dynamics of how these mesons are created.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Probing the X(3700) through two-photon D production in ultraperipheral collisions and at the EIC · Read on arXiv

F.C. Sobrinho, F.S. Navarra, K.P. Khemchandani, A. Martínez Torres

Instituto de FĹsica, Universidade de S£ao Paulo · Universidade Federal de Sªo Paulo

We investigate whether photon-induced production in ultraperipheral heavy-ion collisions and at the EIC can provide a new environment to search for the scalar D D bar molecular candidate usually denoted as X(3700). We calculate the tree-level amplitudes for γγ to D+ D- and γγ to D 0 D 0 bar, dress the outgoing pair with a coupled-channel Bethe-Salpeter interaction in the (D+ D-, D 0 D 0 bar) basis, and convolute the resulting subprocess cross sections with equivalent-photon spectra. In the adopted two-channel scenario the analytic continuation of the T-matrix gives a bound state at M X=3.7162 GeV, which is below the D 0 D 0 bar threshold. As a consequence of this, the observed signal in the continuum is not simply an isolated narrow peak, and a characteristic near-threshold line-shape distortion is produced: around 3.70 at most W at most 3.85 GeV the integrated dressed-to-bare ratios are (13.71,0.35) in Pb-Pb UPCs and (13.74,0.35) in e-Au collisions for (D+D-,D 0 D 0 bar). Using the BABAR-fitted central normalization K dressed=0.382, the corresponding dressed cross sections are (24.6,14.6) μ b in Pb-Pb UPCs and (2.41,1.43) nb at the EIC. The charged-to-neutral ratios are directly accessible observables, whereas the dressed-to-bare ratios provide theoretical diagnostics of the final-state interaction. The near-threshold features are controlled by the common γγ to D D bar dynamics and are rather independent of the external photon source.

DOI: 10.1103/w6qz-cckc

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Probing the X(3700) through two-photon D production in ultraperipheral collisions and at the EIC".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Probing the X(3700) through two-photon D production in ultraperipheral collisions and at the EIC investigates whether photon-induced production in ultraperipheral heavy-ion collisions and at the EIC can provide a new environment to search for the scalar DD¯ molecular candidate usually denoted as X(3700)<ref:2607.12224#pg2> Investigation of Production Channels The study calculates tree-level amplitudes for γγ → D+D− and γγ → D0D¯ 0, dresses the outgoing pair with a coupled-channel Bethe-Salpeter interaction in the basis of the two channels, and convolutes these subprocess cross sections with equivalent-photon spectra<ref:2607.12224#pg16> The charged amplitude contains scalar-QED terms and anomalous D∗ exchange, whereas the neutral amplitude is generated only by D∗0 exchange<ref:2607.12224#pg20> The charged-to-neutral ratios are directly accessible observables, while the dressed-to-bare ratios provide theoretical diagnostics of the final-state interaction<ref:2607.12224#pg20> Bound State Interpretation The analytic continuation of the T-matrix gives a bound state at MX = 3.7162 GeV, which is below the D0D¯ 0 threshold<ref:2607.12224#pg16> As a consequence of this, the observed signal in the continuum is not simply an isolated narrow peak, and a characteristic near-threshold lineshape distortion is produced: around 3.70 ≤ W ≤ 3.85 GeV the integrated dressed-to-bare ratios are (13.71, 0.35) in Pb-Pb UPCs and (13.74, 0.35) in e-Au collisions for (D+D−, D0D¯ 0)<ref:2607.12224#pg16> The near-threshold features are controlled by the common γγ → DD¯ dynamics and are rather independent of the external photon source<ref:2607.12224#pg16> Comparison with Experimental Data The integrated dressed-to-bare ratios obtained in UPCs and EIC show agreement, as (13.71, 0.35) in UPCs and (13.74, 0.35) at the EIC for the (D+D−, D0D¯ 0)<ref:2607.12224#pg16> The absolute normalization is constrained by comparison with the BABAR spectrum, for which we obtain Kdressed = 0.382±0.029<ref:2607.12224#pg16> The central value gives dressed cross sections of (24.6, 14.6) µb in UPCs and (2.41, 1.43)×10−3 µb at the EIC for (D+D−, D0D¯ 0)<ref:2607.12224#pg16> Sensitivity to Model Inputs Varying the charged electromagnetic coupling over −0.040 ≤ gγ,+ ≤ −0.030 GeV−1 and the neutral electromagnetic coupling over 0.125 ≤ gγ,0 ≤ 0.159 GeV−1 gives 8.16 ≤ Rch ≤ 21.57<ref:2607.12224#pg14> The largest change comes from gγ,0 because the neutral production amplitude contributes to the charged final state through the channel-changing interaction<ref:2607.12224#pg14> Varying fD from 155 to 175 MeV gives 0.236 ≤ Rneu ≤ 0.572<ref:2607.12224#pg14> Direct Bound State Estimate The separate Low-formula calculation of direct on-shell production gives σ Low EIC = 6.60 nb for the same normalization<ref:2607.12224#pg16> With the BABAR normalization, we obtain Γγγ = 3.49 keV and σ Low EIC = 6.60 nb<ref:2607.12224#pg16> Channel Dependence of Bound State Width The decomposition shows the strong channel dependence of the Low-formula estimate, with Γch = 0.270 keV, Γneu = 6.264 keV, and Γint = 2.602 keV<ref:2607.12224#pg16> The electromagnetic γDD∗ couplings and fD produce the largest changes in the channel ratios, whereas the EPA inputs mainly affect the overall normalization<ref:2607.12224#pg16> Experimental Observables and Constraints The UPC and EIC cross sections have different normalizations, but their dressed-to-bare ratios are very similar because the same photon flux multiplies the bare and dressed subprocesses at fixed W<ref:2607.12224#pg16> The charged and neutral channels offer different reconstruction possibilities<ref:2607.12224#pg16> Measurements in UPCs and at the EIC would provide information complementary to the existing Belle and BABAR data<ref:2607.12224#pg16> The electromagnetic couplings and fD mainly control the final-state-interaction pattern, while the EPA inputs mainly change the overall normalization<ref:2607.12224#pg16> The bound-state interpretation remains dependent on the adopted interaction kernel and the two-channel approximation<ref:2607.12224#pg16> Additional coupled channels and higher partial waves are beyond the present calculation Projected Amplitudes for S-Wave The S-wave projection is obtained by integrating over the center-of-mass scattering angle, resulting in M0,+−(ˆs) = 4i

2e 2m D squared arctanh(βD±) − 4g 2γ,+m D∗± sˆarccoth(z∗) qˆs(ˆs − 4m D squared D±) + 2g 2γ,+sˆ: The S-wave projection for the neutral channel is M0,00(ˆs) = -4ig 2γ,0 sˆ

4m D∗0 arccoth(z 0) qˆs(ˆs − 4m D squared D0) − 2: Kinematic Limits and Form Factors For the EIC, the invariant mass W = √4ωeωA and rapidity Y = 1/2 ln(ωe/ωA) determine the photon energies through ωe = W squared e + Y and ωA = W squared e - Y The nuclear form factor suppresses large transverse momenta and imposes nuclear coherence The cumulative Pb spectrum shows that 86.39% of the photons lie below 10 GeV in the default model Event Yield Estimates The number of produced events is estimated using N = Lint · σdressed For the UPC estimates we use 1.5 nb−1, the total Pb–Pb luminosity delivered to ALICE during Run 2, and 3.9 nb−1 for Run 3 The EIC cross sections are shown in Figs.

Kai: 9 and 10 Direct Bound-State Production Estimate Using MX = 3.7162 GeV, gX,+− = 8.512 GeV, and gX,00 = 8.604 GeV, we estimate the effective electromagnetic pole residue as g eff γγ ≃ −0.0413 i GeV The resulting cross sections in Table II are proportional to the effective two-photon width The BABAR normalization gives σ Low EIC = 6.60 nb Final Summary of Findings The integrated dressed-to-bare ratios are (13.71, 0.35) in UPCs and (13.74, 0.35) at the EIC for the charged and neutral channels respectively<ref:2607.12224#pg16> The bound state interpretation remains dependent on the adopted interaction kernel and the two-channel approximation Measurements in UPCs and at the EIC would provide information complementary to the existing Belle and BABAR data Acknowledgments This work was partially financed by the Brazilian funding agencies CNPq, CAPES, FAPESP and INCT-FNA (process number 464898/2014-5) The authors gratefully acknowledge the support from the Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP), process number 2024/19103-9 Appendix Details The appendix provides kinematic limits and nuclear-flux checks used in the UPC and EIC calculations The main calculation uses the hard-sphere×Yukawa form factor as the default The cumulative Pb spectrum shows that 86.39% of the photons lie below 10 GeV in the energy range relevant for threshold DD¯ production The finite-size results are nearly identical in the energy range relevant for threshold DD¯ production The cumulative Pb spectrum shows that 86.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to summarize this paper, they are probing for that scalar candidate X(three thousand seven hundred) by calculating tree level amplitudes for gamma gamma production of plus minus D bar and zero D bar zero <ref:2607.12224#pg1>. They dress these with a coupled channel interaction and then use equivalent photon spectra to compare the cross sections in ultraperipheral heavy-ion collisions and at the EIC.

Mira: The main thesis is that they are testing the same DD bar final state interaction found in B factory data but in different photon environments. They calculate how this coupled channel scenario appears specifically when you look at near threshold D bar production in Pb plus lead up collisions and e on Au collisions with high energy.

Lev: They extend a previous calculation by including the neutral D zero D bar zero production amplitude explicitly alongside the charged channel, and they dress both amplitudes consistently using the same two-channel Bethe-Salpeter equation.

Kai: The key mechanism they highlight is that the charged amplitude gets scalar QED terms and anomalous D star exchange, while the neutral one only comes from D star zero exchange.

Mira: They found a bound state at three point seven one six two two GeV below the zero D bar zero threshold, which leads to a specific near-threshold lineshape distortion around three point seven zero to three point eight five GeV in continuum production.

Lev: This means the observed signal isn't just some simple isolated peak; it has this structure around that threshold region, and they show this structure is controlled by the common gamma gamma to D bar dynamics regardless of the photon source.

Kai: They also compare their results with experimental data, showing that their predicted dressed to bare ratios match what they expect from BABAR data for the charged channel.

Mira: The absolute normalization is constrained by comparing it to BABAR spectrum, giving them a dressed cross section of twenty four point six and fourteen point six microbarns in UPCs and two point four one times ten to the minus three microbarns at the EIC for that D bar production.

Lev: They also look at how sensitive their results are to input parameters, finding that varying the charged electromagnetic coupling gives a range between eight point one six and two point one five seven.

Kai: The main sensitivity comes from changing the neutral electromagnetic coupling because its contribution feeds into the charged final state through a channel changing interaction.

Mira: They also found that varying the f D parameter affects their results by giving a ratio between zero point two three six and zero point five seven two.

Lev: It's important to note that these inputs mostly affect the overall normalization rather than the fine structure of the interaction pattern itself.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up, this paper is about using these two photon production channels to see if we can find evidence for that scalar candidate X(three thousand seven hundred) <ref:2607.12224#pg1>. They are showing that the results from ultraperipheral collisions and the EIC are consistent.

Mira: The core of it is testing the DD bar final state interaction inference from B factory data under different photon-induced conditions. It shows how this molecular structure manifests in near threshold production, producing a distortion we talked about around three point seven zero to three point eight five GeV.

Lev: From an engineering perspective, it confirms that the cross sections they predict are what you'd expect if you were running those experiments on real hardware and not some ideal setup.

Kai: The authors of this paper are F.C. Sobrinho, F.S. Navarra, K.P. Khemchandani, and A. Mart´ınez Torres from the Instituto de Física at the University of São Paulo in Brazil, which is where they did this work on ultraperipheral collisions and at the EIC and where they did their core calculations on the X(three thousand seven hundred) coupling couplings <ref:2607.12224#pg1,ultraperipheral collisions and at the EIC>.

Mira: The implication is that these measurements provide information complementary to existing Belle and BABAR data about how that scalar candidate behaves in different photon-induced environments.

Lev: The work confirms that while it's still dependent on the adopted interaction kernel and sticking to the two channel approximation, so future work should look at going to more coupled channels or higher partial waves for better detail.

More episodes

← Home