Photon-nucleon entanglement in Compton scattering at low and high energies

summary

The gist

Photon-nucleon entanglement in Compton scattering at low and high energies studies spin-spin entanglement in the final state photon-nucleon system in Compton scattering…

In short

The study investigates spin-spin entanglement between a photon and a nucleon during Compton scattering at low and high energies. It proves that entanglement requires polarized initial states, establishing a no-go theorem for unpolarized scattering with real amplitudes. Findings show distinct patterns in the proton versus neutron targets, heavily influenced by polarizabilities at low energy.

Key concepts

Spin Density Matrix
This mathematical tool describes the quantum state of the spin system. It quantifies how entangled two particles (like a photon and a nucleon) are by summarizing all possible spin correlations present in their final state, allowing researchers to measure entanglement.
No-Go Theorem
This theorem proves that it is impossible to generate entanglement in unpolarized Compton scattering if the scattering amplitudes are purely real numbers. This sets a fundamental constraint, showing that polarization is necessary to create this quantum connection between the photon and nucleon.
Polarizabilities
These are fundamental properties of nucleons (protons and neutrons) that describe how they respond to electromagnetic fields. Electric ($\alpha_E$) and magnetic ($\beta_M$) polarizabilities significantly influence entanglement patterns, especially for the neutron, acting as crucial ingredients for generating correlations.
Bell States
These are maximally entangled quantum states between two particles. The paper explores how different initial polarization setups can lead to the realization of various Bell states (like $|\Phi^{\pm}\rangle$ or $|\Psi^{\pm}\rangle$) in the final photon-nucleon system.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Photon-nucleon entanglement in Compton scattering at low and high energies · Read on arXiv

Yoshitaka Hatta, Váctor Martínez-Fern귚zerd

Physics Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory · RIKEN BNL Research Center · Université Paris-Saclay - CEA - IRFU · Center for Frontiers in Nuclear Science, Stony Brook University

We study spin-spin entanglement in the final state photon-nucleon system in Compton scattering, both at low energy below the pion threshold and at high energy in perturbative QCD to next-to-leading order. We first establish a no-go theorem showing that, for any spin- 1 over 2 target, entanglement cannot be generated in unpolarized Compton scattering if the scattering amplitudes are real. We then consider polarized Compton scattering off the electron, the proton and the neutron. At low energy, we uncover a rich variety of maximally entangled Bell states and their unitary equivalents realized across different regions of the kinematic plane. Interestingly, the proton and neutron targets exhibit distinct patterns of entanglement. In the neutron case, the electric and magnetic polarizabilities dramatically influence the pattern and even the existence of entanglement. This suggests that entanglement can serve as a novel tool for investigating the detailed electromagnetic properties of the nucleons.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Photon-nucleon entanglement in Compton scattering at low and high energies".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Photon-nucleon entanglement in Compton scattering at low and high energies studies spin-spin entanglement in the final state photon-nucleon system in Compton scattering, both at low energy below the pion threshold and at high energy in perturbative QCD to next-toleading order Establishing Theoretical Constraints The authors first establish a no-go theorem showing that for any spin-1/2 target, entanglement cannot be generated in unpolarized Compton scattering if the scattering amplitudes are real The study then considers polarized Compton scattering off the electron, the proton and the neutron At low energy, they uncover a rich variety of maximally entangled Bell states and their unitary equivalents realized across different regions of the kinematic plane Interestingly, the proton and neutron targets exhibit distinct patterns of entanglement In the neutron case, electric and magnetic polarizabilities dramatically influence the pattern and even the existence of entanglement This suggests that entanglement can serve as a novel tool for investigating the detailed electromagnetic properties of the nucleons Kinematic Framework and Amplitudes The process under study is Compton scattering N(k) + γ(q) → N(k′) + γ(q′) off the nucleon N which can be either the proton N = p or the neutron N = n To compute the spin density matrix, it is advantageous to work in the center-of-mass (CM) frame where the nucleon and the photon γ move in the +z and −z directions, respectively Due to parity and time-reversal symmetry, there are six independent scattering amplitudes

3, 14, 53, 54: The helicity amplitudes ϕ1 through ϕ6 are defined based on the Jacob-Wick formalism For example, the explicit relation to the amplitudes in (2) is given by phi1 = m squared cos θ squared h 2A1 − A2 + 6A3 + A4 − 6A5 + 8A6 + 2(A1 − A3 + 4A5 − 4A6) cos θ + (A2 − A4 − 2A5) cos 2θ i Entanglement Quantification and No-Go Theorem Proof The degree of entanglement is quantified by computing the spin density matrix ρ = 1/4 I ⊗ I + B aN σ a ⊗ I + B bγ I ⊗ τ b + C abσ a ⊗ τ b The authors show that if the ϕ’s are real, the condition for entanglement (25) cannot be satisfied because it simplifies to a non-positive expression (26) They establish a no-go theorem that in unpolarized Compton scattering and when the amplitudes are real, the final state photon and nucleon (or any other spin-1/2 particle) cannot be entangled Polarization-Assisted Entanglement To realize entanglement, the authors consider polarized Compton scattering where either the incoming nucleon, or the incoming photon, or both are polarized The density matrix is generalized in terms of initial polarizations as C ab(⃗sN, ⃗sγ) For instance, B bγ(⃗sN, 0) is given by (B1), which depends on the amplitudes and polarization vectors The negative eigenvalue of the partially transposed density matrix ρ T(⃗sN, ⃗sγ) is used as a measure of entanglement Regime-Dependent Results In the low energy regime ω < mπ, the scattering amplitudes are real and can be expanded in powers of ω/m, with coefficients given by charge Q and magnetic moment

4–6: In this regime, they uncover a rich pattern of entanglement including the emergence of maximally entangled Bell states At higher energy ω >> 1 GeV, the process becomes sensitive to the partonic structure of the nucleon, where helicity amplitudes are calculable in terms of GPDs The NLO effects are small due to the difference in orders of magnitude between the helicity amplitudes ϕ N2,3,6 ∼ O(αs) and ϕ N1,4,5 that are non-vanishing at LO Low Energy Findings for Nucleons In the low energy regime ω < mπ = 140 MeV where all six amplitudes are real, the scattering amplitudes can be expanded in powers of ω/m The O(ω 2) terms require the inclusion of electric αE and magnetic βM polarizabilities For the proton target, λmin is everywhere negative, meaning that the outgoing proton and photon are always entangled In contrast to the unpolarized case where there is no entanglement anywhere as we have seen, in Fig.

Kai: 4, they find that λmin is everywhere negative for the proton target as a function of θ and ω < 140 MeV High Energy Findings for Nucleons At high energy, the highest entangled states prefer the most possible backward region (θ ∼ 120◦) as well as linearly polarized initial photons The NLO effects are small due to the difference in orders of magnitude between the helicity amplitudes ϕ N2,3,6 ∼ O(αs) and ϕ N1,4,5 that are non-vanishing at LO For the neutron target case N = n, they find a rich pattern of entanglement including maximal entanglement in many initial spin configurations The polarizabilities α nE and β nM are essential to generate entanglement in this case Experimental Outlook The paper suggests that the simplest experimental setup would be to place detectors that serve as polarization analyzers in the far-forward θ ≈ 0 and far-backward θ ≈ π regions, and measure their spin correlations The angular distribution of nucleon-photon pairs arriving in coincidence is therefore Tr

(DN ⊗ Dγ)ρ: ∝ AN Aγ sin(2ϕγ ± ϕN), where the ± sign is for the Φ-type and Ψ-type Bell states, respectively This is analogous to the cos 2(ϕ1 − ϕ2) correlation originally studied for entangled photon pairs in e+e− → 2γ The authors hope their work triggers discussions in this direction The degree of entanglement is strongly influenced by fundamental constants such as the magnetic moment and polarizabilities at low energy, and by the partonic structure at high energy The authors have considered all possible configurations of the initial beam polarizations and found all four Bell states Φ±⟩, Ψ±⟩ and their unitary rotations At high energy, they find that entanglement is never maximally realized and the highest entangled states prefer the most possible backward region (θ ∼ 120◦) as well as linearly polarized initial photons The NLO effects are small due to the difference in orders of magnitude between the helicity amplitudes ϕ N2,3,6 ∼ O(αs) and ϕ N1,4,5 that are non-vanishing at LO Role of Polarizabilities The role of the polarizabilities αE and βM in the proton target case is minor However, in the neutron case, due to the absence of the Thomson scattering term, entanglement is strongly affected by α nE and β nM For example, if they are set to zero, the structures in the (ˆx, xˆ) plot of Fig.

Mira: 5 disappear completely.

Kai: The system becomes separable (not entangled) Thus, the polarizabilities are essential to generate entanglement in this case Role of QCD Corrections The NLO QCD corrections on QIS observables are still relatively unexplored Entanglement requires communications between different helicity states, but such effects are suppressed either by m/√−t or αs The purely NLO helicity amplitudes ϕ N2,3,6 are numerically 1–2 orders of magnitude lower than the photon helicity non-flip amplitudes ϕ N1,4,5 that are non-vanishing at LO Role of Initial Polarization If only one of the incoming particles is polarized, entanglement is overall weaker When the proton is maximally polarized sN = 1 but the photon is unpolarized sγ = 0, they find entanglement everywhere in all cases but maximal entanglement nowhere found On the other hand, when the photon is 100% polarized sγ = 1 but the proton is unpolarized sN = 0, the system is entangled everywhere for certain polarization directions but nowhere entangled for others Final Summary of Findings The authors have shown that entanglement can be generated in Compton scattering off the nucleon, and they have considered all possible configurations of the initial beam polarizations and found all four Bell states Φ±⟩, Ψ±⟩ and their unitary rotations At high energy, they find that, conversely to the low-energy scattering, entanglement is never maximally realized and the highest entangled states prefer the most possible backward region (θ ∼ 120◦) as well as linearly polarized initial photons The NLO effects are small due to the difference in orders of magnitude between the helicity amplitudes ϕ N2,3,6 ∼ O(αs) and ϕ N1,4,5 that are non-vanishing at LO Appendix Details The Appendix provides an alternative derivation of the density matrix for unpolarized initial states in terms of the amplitudes Ai commonly used in the low-energy literature The components of the spin density matrix are computed from A = 1/4 Tr

(T gT†)λλ: The nonvanishing components of the polarization vectors are given by (A14) and (A15) The transformation between the linear and helicity bases can be performed by a constant matrix multiplication U†MU, which gives Bz'lin = Bx'hel = Bx'γ The two approaches based on ϕ’s and A’s give equivalent results Experimental Feasibility The authors suggest that the simplest experimental setup would be to place detectors that serve as polarization analyzers in the far-forward θ ≈ 0 and far-backward θ ≈ π regions, and measure their spin correlations Combining the two measurements in a single experimental setup is unprecedented, and requires significant experimental innovations The angular distribution of nucleon-photon pairs arriving in coincidence is therefore Tr

(DN ⊗ Dγ)ρ: ∝ AN Aγ sin(2ϕγ ± ϕN), where the ± sign is for the Φ-type and Ψ-type Bell states, respectively This is analogous to the cos 2(ϕ1 − ϕ2) correlation originally studied for entangled photon pairs in e+e− → 2γ The authors hope their work triggers discussions in this direction Final Statement on Maximal Entanglement The authors find that maximal entanglement can be always achieved in the scattering of a 100% transversely polarized electron and a 100% linearly polarized photon in the backward region θ ∼ π, irrespective of the direction of polarizations However, if they set me = 0 (µ = ∞) from the beginning, they do not see maximal entanglement, not even entanglement, for any value of θ In this limit, pure states ρ(ˆz, −zˆ) = diag(0, 1, 0, 0) = ↑↓⟩⟨↑↓ and ρ(−z, ˆ −zˆ) = diag(0, 0, 0, 1) = ↓↓⟩⟨↓↓ independently of θ In contrast to the red region in Fig.

Title and authors: Kai: So let's talk about the title again and who wrote this paper. It’s "Photon-nucleon entanglement in Compton scattering at low and high energies." It sounds very specific, which is good for us because it tells us exactly what kind of physics they are tackling >

Mira: And it’s written by Yoshitaka Hatta and Víctor Martínez-Fernández. They seem to be covering a lot of ground, starting from the basic kinematics in Section II and then building up to the density matrix construction in Section III >

Lev: I'm curious about how they handle that complexity. They mention six independent scattering amplitudes in Section III, defined using Jacob-Wick formalism, which is standard but always a bit heavy on notation >

Kai: Right. They show you how these amplitudes A1 through A6 are related to the Mandelstam variables s t and u in Equation three <ref:2608.05330#pg1>. It sets up the whole framework for what they're measuring >

Mira: And the key thing is that these amplitudes become real functions below the pion threshold, which is where they find all those entangled states >

Lev: That means at low energy, we can actually treat them as real numbers for entanglement calculations, which simplifies things a bit compared to the higher energy stuff >

The paper's summary: Kai: Moving on to what they actually found. The summary is that they uncover a rich variety of maximally entangled Bell states when looking at the low energy regime below the pion threshold >

Mira: And they specifically compare the proton and neutron targets, and the neutron case shows distinct patterns that are influenced by electric and magnetic polarizabilities >

Lev: So, to put it plainly for our audience, what this means is that entanglement isn't just some abstract concept; it's tied directly to how strongly these nucleons interact with light in a specific way >

Kai: Right. And they also mention that at higher energy, above one gigaparsec, the process gets sensitive to the partonic structure of the nucleon, where you start looking at things like Generalized Parton Distributions >

Mira: And they point out that even though NLO effects are small at high energy because of how the helicity amplitudes scale with alpha s, they still find patterns in entanglement >

Lev: That suggests that while the fundamental QCD structure kicks in at high energy, there's still something observable about spin correlations that we can track >

The paper's improvements: Kai: They suggest a few ways to push this research forward. One major improvement they point out is using polarization analyzers in the far-forward and far-backward regions, specifically at angles near zero and angle pi >

Mira: That’s an experimental suggestion, but it connects directly to the physics because it’s where they expect to see the strongest spin correlations in those specific regions >

Lev: If you look at their quantification of entanglement using that partially transposed density matrix, they use its negative eigenvalue as a measure of entanglement >

Kai: And if you check Figure eight which shows that minimum eigenvalue, it helps predict what kind of maximally entangled states you should be looking for in the high energy regime >

Mira: The paper also highlights the crucial role of polarizabilities at low energy: alpha E and beta M are essential to generate entanglement when you look at the neutron target, because without them, the structures disappear completely >

Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up this paper "Photon-nucleon entanglement in Compton scattering at low and high energies," it shows that entanglement can be generated in these collisions under polarized conditions >

Mira: But they emphasize that maximal entanglement isn't always achieved, especially at high energy, where the highest states prefer the most backward region and specific initial photon polarizations >

Lev: From my side, I think the NLO corrections are small because those higher helicity amplitudes scale lower than the leading order ones by a factor of alpha s >

Kai: So to summarize, entanglement is strongly influenced by fundamental constants like magnetic moments at low energy and by the partonic structure at high energy >

Mira: And for us, this means that for future experiments at an Electron-Ion Collider, we should be looking for those specific spin correlations in the forward and backward directions >

Lev: I just think we need to focus on making sure our detectors can handle the required precision to measure these subtle spin correlations accurately enough to see what they're proposing >

More episodes

← Home