Parton Distribution Functions from Large Momentum Expansion of Current-Current Correlators

summary

The gist

Parton distribution functions (PDFs) are fundamental quantities in quantum chromodynamics (QCD) that describe the hadronic structure in terms of quark and gluon degrees of freedom on the light cone…

In short

The study explores extracting Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs) from lattice QCD using current-current correlations within the LaMET framework. This method avoids renormalization issues found in other approaches by directly calculating PDF x-dependence through perturbative matching on lattice data, offering a feasible path to determine PDFs from first principles.

Key concepts

Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs)
PDFs describe how quarks and gluons are distributed inside a hadron when probed at high momentum. They are fundamental quantities in quantum chromodynamics that characterize the internal structure of hadrons, allowing physicists to understand how momentum is shared among the constituents.
LaMET Framework
LaMET introduces a universality class of distributions that can be perturbatively matched to lightcone PDFs. It uses Euclidean correlators, like quasi-PDFs or current-current correlations, as starting points. This framework allows for the calculation of PDFs by matching these Euclidean distributions to their lightcone counterparts.
Current-Current Correlations
Instead of using simpler quasi-PDFs, this method utilizes current-current correlations calculated on the lattice. This approach is theoretically sound because it bypasses renormalization problems and allows for a direct calculation of the x-dependence of PDFs through perturbative matching kernels.
Perturbative Matching
This technique factorizes lightcone PDFs into components derived from current-current correlations and perturbative matching kernels. By applying this matching to lattice measurements, the paper aims to directly calculate the x-dependence of the PDFs, providing a systematic way to relate lattice results to physical observables.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Parton Distribution Functions from Large Momentum Expansion of Current-Current Correlators · Read on arXiv

Tsung-Dao Lee Institute and School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University · Department of Physics, University of Maryland · Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Regensburg · Center for Theoretical Physics - a Leinweber Institute, Massachusetts Institute of Technology · Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Kentucky · Nuclear Science Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

The universality of the large momentum expansion allows computing parton distribution functions (PDFs) starting from any Euclidean correlator with appropriate large momentum Fourier Components. Here we consider current-current correlators which have been used in short-distance expansion to obtain moments of PDFs. The advantage of such correlators is that they have simple renormalization properties and do not have linear power divergences as in quasi-PDF. However, in lattice calculations, four-point functions are needed. Here we present an expansion formula with current-current correlators up to the next-to-leading order, and preliminary numerical calculations with four-point functions.

DOI: 10.1103/vdtk-mps3

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Parton Distribution Functions from Large Momentum Expansion of Current-Current Correlators".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Parton distribution functions (PDFs) are fundamental quantities in quantum chromodynamics (QCD) that describe the hadronic structure in terms of quark and gluon degrees of freedom on the light cone The universality of the large momentum expansion allows computing parton distribution functions (PDFs) starting from any Euclidean correlator with appropriate large momentum Fourier Components Theoretical Framework and Universality The LaMET framework introduces a universality class of distributions

11: The leading order expansion of these distributions in terms of (ΛQCD/Pz) contains the same infrared (IR) structure as the lightcone PDFs, thus can be perturbatively matched to them The simplest member of this universality class is the quasi-PDF, which is the Euclidean version of the lightcone correlation function and can be interpreted as the physical momentum distribution of quarks and gluons in a hadron with finite momentum Other variants in the same universality class include the Coulomb gauge distributions proposed recently

12, 13: and the current-current correlations

11: The LaMET calculation using current-current correlations does not have a renormalization issue and is well understood in theory, but has not been studied because it requires the more expensive measurements of four-point correlation functions on the lattice Extraction Methodology The common basis of these methods is the operator product expansion (OPE), which allows a short distance factorization (SDF) of the correlators into lightcone distributions and perturbative matching kernels when the two currents are separated by a perturbative Euclidean distance These correlators can extract moments of PDFs, or fit the data to some parametrization of the x-dependent PDFs Lightcone PDFs can be factorized in terms of current-current correlations and their x-dependence can be directly calculated through perturbative matching The light-cone PDF can be factorized into the VVdistribution and perturbative matching Lattice Implementation Details The matrix element in (1) is defined as MµνXY,ab(z, P) = ⟨P JνX,ab(z) JµY,ba(0)P⟩ The spatial separation z = (0,⃗z) is chosen to be parallel to the direction of the proton’s momentum P⃗ with P⃗ ≫ ΛQCD The correlators exhibit the same infrared divergence structure as the PDFs, therefore their x-space conjugate can be used to calculate the PDFs through the LaMET approach The analysis restricts itself to the isovector PDF, i.e., fu−d, where the S2 contributions cancel Results and Feasibility The momentum-space VV distribution h(y, Pz) obtained from lattice simulation at P⃗ = 1.523 GeV is shown in Fig.

Kai: 3 After applying the matching formula in Eq.

Mira: (8), and also following the renormalization group resummation (RGR) procedure proposed in Ref.

26: , the resulting isovector PDF is shown in Fig.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Parton Distribution Functions from Large Momentum Expansion of Current-Current Correlators," and it’s about using these current-current correlators to extract PDFs. Mira, what's the main idea here in plain terms?

Mira: Well, the core idea is that these current-current correlators have a special structure when you expand them at large momentum, specifically when you look at the ratio of that momentum to something like QCD scale and proton momentum. This expansion lets us connect these lattice calculations directly to the lightcone PDFs we’re trying to measure.

Lev: It sounds like they’re using this large momentum expansion as a way to factorize things, which is usually done in short-distance factorization, but this method aims to get closer to the lightcone description directly from lattice data.

Kai: Exactly. And what I find interesting is that they say these correlators have simpler renormalization properties compared to some other methods, so it avoids those tricky renormalon ambiguities we sometimes see in other approaches <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Mira: That’s true. They point out that this approach allows you to calculate the x-dependence of the PDFs directly through perturbative matching onto lattice data, which is a big step because it bypasses some of the complexities of traditional factorization schemes <ref:2605.03234#pg2>.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if we could get these lattice distributions, we’d need to worry about how to implement the matching kernel correctly on real hardware, especially considering those power corrections that they mention being suppressed by inverse powers of Pz <ref:2605.03234#pg3>.

Kai: Right. And they address that by introducing a specific correction factor, c corr of z equals the trace of z times the free propagator minus the lattice one, which helps suppress those discretization artifacts in the matrix elements <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Mira: That correction factor is important because it helps keep things cleaner when you're doing these simulations, and they show that this method actually works for calculating the isovector PDF fu minus d <ref:2605.03234#pg2>.

Lev: And they mention that they are looking at the VA or AV correlations to get those matrix elements, which connects back to earlier work on pion valence PDFs in short-distance factorization forty-one <ref:2605.03234#pg2>.

Kai: So, if I were driving right now and trying to understand this, the main thing is that they’re proving a feasible way to extract these PDFs from lattice QCD using current-current correlations instead of relying only on quasi-PDFs <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Mira: It suggests that we might be able to get these distributions directly from lattice simulations, which is much more accessible than needing those expensive four-point correlation functions <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Lev: The feasibility hinges on the calculation of the momentum space VV distribution h of y and Pz, which they derive from the current-current correlator WTT <ref:2605.03234#pg3>.

Kai: So, this means we can take a Fourier transform of that distribution to get PDFs, and they’re showing some first results for the proton PDF fu minus d at a momentum of one point five two three GeV Result shown in Fig four.

Title and authors: Mira: But I have to point out that they show a noticeable deviation when comparing their lattice results with the CT18NNLO global fit result Fig four <ref:2605.03234#pg1>. That’s something we need to keep an eye on.

Lev: That deviation is expected because of the pion mass in their ensemble being higher than the physical pion mass of three hundred fifty-five MeV, which they suggest is probably why we see those discrepancies with experimental data Conclusion section.

Kai: So, to wrap up this paper, it’s a proof of concept for using current-current correlations in this LaMET framework because it avoids those renormalon ambiguities that plague other methods <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Mira: And the next step is just repeating these calculations at higher momenta, say P vector greater than two GeV, with more statistics so we can really see how robust this method is Conclusion section <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Lev: I think that using those new kinematically enhanced interpolators they propose will be really helpful for getting better results in that direction Conclusion section.

Kai: So, to summarize this paper, it’s about developing a method to get PDFs from lattice QCD by using current-current correlations through the LaMET framework <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Mira: It shows the feasibility of calculating x-dependent PDFs directly from lattice data via perturbative matching <ref:2605.03234#pg2>.

Lev: The main caveat is that they flag that their results are sensitive to the pion mass used in their simulation, which could be a source of discrepancy compared to physical experiments Conclusion section.

Kai: So, for listeners who just want the gist, this paper shows a promising way to extract PDFs from lattice QCD by using current-current correlators instead of quasi-PDFs <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Mira: It’s a proof of concept that allows for direct calculation of x-dependence through perturbative matching onto lattice data <ref:2605.03234#pg2>.

Lev: The real world challenge is running this on hardware, and they note that the power corrections are suppressed by inverse powers of Pz <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Kai: So, we’re looking at a method that avoids renormalon ambiguities and uses a specific correction factor to handle discretization errors in the matrix elements <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Mira: And they show how to calculate the momentum space VV distribution h of y and Pz from the current-current correlator WTT <ref:2605.03234#pg3>.

Lev: The main limitation they state is that their results are sensitive to the pion mass used in their simulation, which could cause issues when comparing to physical experiments like those from experiment Conclusion section.

Kai: So, in short, it’s a proof of concept for a more direct way to extract PDFs from lattice QCD using current-current correlators <ref:2605.03234#pg1>.

Mira: And the future work involves pushing those momentum calculations to higher values and using new interpolators to improve the results Conclusion section.

Lev: That’s what it is. We need more statistics and better tools, but conceptually, this current-current approach has some advantages over older Wilson-line operator methods Conclusion section.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper is about using current-current correlators in the LaMET framework to get parton distribution functions directly from lattice QCD instead of relying on quasi-PDFs or other methods that have trouble with renormalization issues.

Mira: Yeah, and the big idea is that this lets you calculate the x dependence of those PDFs right through perturbative matching onto lattice data <ref:2605.03234#pg2>. It’s a direct path from the lattice simulation to what we need for global fits.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it’s promising because it avoids needing those expensive four-point correlation functions on the lattice that other methods require <ref:2605.03234#pg1>. If this works as well as they say, the overhead lands much more predictably for real hardware implementation.

Kai: It is interesting how they’re using these current-current correlations to get a momentum space VV distribution, which is the Fourier transform of that correlator <ref:2605.03234#pg3>. That distribution lets you directly calculate the PDFs from lattice measurements themselves.

Mira: And they show some first results for the isovector PDF fu minus d at a momentum of one point five two three gigaelectron volts <ref:2605.03234#pg4>. But they are careful about that, because their simulation uses a pion mass that’s higher than the physical one, which they think could be causing some of the discrepancies with experimental data <Conclusion section>.

Lev: So, we have a proof of concept here, not a final answer yet. The paper is essentially showing how you can do this forward matching to get PDFs from lattice distributions with systematically improvable power corrections that fall off as inverse powers of the momentum scale <Improvements list item three>.

Kai: That’s right. They are demonstrating feasibility rather than giving us a perfect number. They point out that the dominant uncertainty is still statistical, not model dependence in their extrapolation to high momentum <Data Analysis and Interpretation section>.

Mira: It really changes how we think about extracting these distributions from lattice QCD. It suggests that current-current correlators are a viable tool for this, unlike some of the more established Wilson-line operator methods <Conclusion section>.

Lev: The next step they propose is to run these calculations at even higher momentum, like vector momentum greater than two gigaelectron volts, with more statistics so we can really test the robustness of this approach <Conclusion section>.

Kai: It’s a real test of the method. We need to see if it holds up when you push the kinematic limits and increase the data volume <Conclusion section>.

Mira: And they also mention using those new kinematically enhanced interpolators, which should help smooth out some of those issues with discretization artifacts <Conclusion section>.

Lev: So, this paper is a proof of concept that avoids renormalon ambiguities and uses a specific correction factor to handle discretization errors in the matrix elements <Improvements list item four>. It’s a solid starting point for extracting these distributions directly from lattice simulations.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, we’re talking about how they plan to make this method better than what they just showed us <Improvements list item one>. They are suggesting moving from quasi-PDFs to using these current-current correlators instead because that avoids those renormalization problems we talked about earlier.

Mira: That makes sense. The main improvement is switching the basis of the calculation, which gives them a cleaner theoretical foundation for matching onto the lightcone PDFs <Improvements list item one>. It’s about using this specific structure to get rid of those ambiguities.

Lev: From an error correction viewpoint, that cleaner structure means you can manage those systematic errors more effectively when you try to run this on real hardware <Improvements list item two>. It simplifies the required error budgets significantly.

Kai: They also focus on how they calculate the x dependence, and they suggest using perturbative matching directly from lattice data to get that x dependence right <Improvements list item two>. That direct link is what makes it powerful.

Mira: Plus, there’s this technique for suppressing discretization artifacts in the matrix elements <Improvements list item four>. They introduce a correction factor involving the trace of the propagator and some functions like K2 applied to the momentum scale squared <Improvements list item four>. It’s a specific mathematical trick to keep things tidy on the lattice.

Lev: That sounds like something we could actually implement in our error analysis pipelines. Suppressing those artifacts by multiplying by that correction factor is a practical step towards making this reliable for real data <Improvements list item four>.

Kai: So, it’s about taking a calculation that was conceptually sound but needed better handling of lattice effects and renormalization, and they're giving us tools to make it more stable. It moves it from just a proof of concept to something more practical <Improvements list item one>.

Mira: The implication is that we might see these kinds of direct extractions become standard practice in extracting PDFs from lattice QCD in the future <Conclusion section>. It shows the path forward for this class of calculation.

Lev: If they can successfully push these calculations to higher momentum scales, like above two gigaelectron volts, then this method becomes really useful for probing different aspects of the hadron structure <Conclusion section>.

Kai: That’s exactly what they’re aiming for. Higher momentum means we get more information about the hard scattering processes inside the proton <Conclusion section>.

Mira: So, moving forward, we need to see those results at higher momenta with more statistics to really prove that this framework is robust across a wider range of scales <Conclusion section>.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we’re wrapping up this look at "Parton Distribution Functions from Large Momentum Expansion of Current-Current Correlators" <Conclusion section>. Basically, this paper proves that using current-current correlators in the LaMET framework is a feasible way to extract PDFs directly from lattice QCD simulations.

Mira: And it does that by allowing you to calculate the x dependence through perturbative matching onto the lattice data <Conclusion section>. It’s a big step because it bypasses some of those older, more complicated methods we usually have to use.

Lev: From my side, I see this as a proof of concept that avoids those renormalon ambiguities you mentioned earlier <Conclusion section>. It’s cleaner theory for the hardware side too.

Kai: Exactly. The main thing is that it shows the path forward for extracting these distributions directly from lattice QCD <Conclusion section>.

Mira: The caveat remains, though, that their results are sensitive to the pion mass they used in their simulation <Conclusion section>. That’s something we definitely need to watch when comparing these to experimental data.

Lev: And you’re right, that mass sensitivity is a major hurdle for any comparison. It means we can't just take the numbers at face value without accounting for that systematic uncertainty.

Kai: So, in short, this paper gives us a strong starting point by showing how to use these current-current correlations to get PDFs from lattice QCD <Conclusion section>.

Mira: It establishes a way to do the matching and extracting the x dependence directly from the lattice measurements themselves <Conclusion section>.

Lev: And while it's not a final determination, it shows that this approach is theoretically sound and has practical advantages over existing methods <Conclusion section>.

Kai: It’s a really encouraging result because it opens up a new avenue for how we can connect lattice calculations to the PDFs we need for experimental physics <Conclusion section>.

Tom: So, what does this mean moving forward?

Mira: It means we need to see these results at higher momenta, like above two gigaelectron volts, with more statistics so we can really test the robustness of this approach <Conclusion section>.

Lev: And I think those new kinematically enhanced interpolators they propose will be very helpful in getting better results in that direction <Conclusion section>.

Kai: It’s a real test of the method. We need to see if it holds up when you push the kinematic limits and increase the data volume <Conclusion section>.

Mira: It also means we have a clearer picture of what those systematic uncertainties are, which is always valuable for theory building <Conclusion section>.

Lev: So, this paper lays out a clear roadmap for future lattice QCD work in this area.

More episodes

← Home