On the coverage of electroweak-inos within the pMSSM with SModelS -- a comparison with the ATLAS pMSSM study
summary
The gist
The paper compares constraints on electroweak-inos in the pMSSM derived from SModelS against results from a recent ATLAS study to assess how well SModelS reproduces experimental limits and what can…
In short
The study compares constraints on electroweak-inos within the pMSSM model using SModelS against recent ATLAS results. Direct comparisons show good agreement for heavier charginos, but differences exist at lower masses due to track constraints. Combining analyses from both SModelS and ATLAS significantly improves exclusion sensitivity by 20-35%, though limitations remain regarding efficiency maps.
Key concepts
- Electroweak-inos (EWKinos)
- These are the supersymmetric partners of the electroweak gauge bosons (like charginos and neutralinos) within the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM). The paper focuses on setting limits on their masses based on experimental searches for these particles.
- SModelS Database
- This is a comprehensive public software database containing constraints derived from various experiments, including CMS and ATLAS results. It is used to scan the parameter space of the pMSSM model to determine where electroweak-inos are excluded.
- Gluino Constraints
- These constraints arise from searches involving gluino production, which is a supersymmetric partner of the gluon. Including these constraints in SModelS allows for probing regions of parameter space with heavier charginos, up to masses greater than 1 TeV.
- Statistical Combination (Pathfinder Algorithm)
- This method uses the Pathfinder algorithm to statistically combine multiple, approximately uncorrelated experimental analyses. This process maximizes the sensitivity of the overall exclusion by finding the best combination of data points for each parameter setting.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- On the coverage of electroweak-inos within the pMSSM with SModelS -- a comparison with the ATLAS pMSSM study · Paper Radio
- SModelS: a tool for interpreting simplified-model results from the LHC and its application to supersymmetry
- Global LHC constraints on electroweak-inos with SModelS v2.3
- ATLAS Run 2 searches for electroweak production of supersymmetric particles interpreted within the pMSSM
- The Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model: Group Summary Report
- On the coverage of the pMSSM by simplified model results
- Lighting up the LHC with Dark Matter
- SUSY Les Houches Accord: Interfacing SUSY Spectrum Calculators, Decay Packages, and Event Generators
- Mass Splitting between Charged and Neutral Winos at Two-Loop Level
- Precise Estimate of Charged Higgsino/Wino Decay Rate
- SPheno, a program for calculating supersymmetric spectra, SUSY particle decays and SUSY particle production at e+ e- colliders
- Combination of searches for invisible decays of the Higgs boson using 139 fb-1 of proton-proton collision data at sqrt s = 13 TeV collected with the ATLAS experiment
- Combined measurements of Higgs boson production and decay using up to 80 fb-1 of proton-proton collision data at sqrt s = 13 TeV collected with the ATLAS experiment
- Gaugino production in proton-proton collisions at a center-of-mass energy of 8 TeV
- Precision predictions for electroweak superpartner production at hadron colliders with Resummino
- Neutralino/chargino pair production at NLO+NLL with resummation-improved PDFs for LHC Run II
- Electroweak superpartner production at 13.6 TeV with Resummino
- Implications of CTEQ global analysis for collider observables
- Search for charginos and neutralinos in final states with two boosted hadronically decaying bosons and missing transverse momentum in pp collisions at sqrt s =13 TeV with the ATLAS detector
- Search for direct production of electroweakinos in final states with one lepton, missing transverse momentum and a Higgs boson decaying into two b-jets in pp collisions at sqrt s =13 TeV with the ATLAS detector
- Search for electroweak production of charginos and sleptons decaying into final states with two leptons and missing transverse momentum in sqrt s =13 TeV pp collisions using the ATLAS detector
The paper
On the coverage of electroweak-inos within the pMSSM with SModelS -- a comparison with the ATLAS pMSSM study · Read on arXiv
Léo Constantin, Sabine Kraml, Andre Lessa, Théeo Reymermier, Wolfgang Waltenberger
Laboratoire de Physique Subatomique et de Cosmologie (LPSC) · Centro de Ci¡ncias Naturais e Humanas, Universidade Federal do ABC · Universite de Lyon, Universite Claude Bernard Lyon 1 · Marietta-Blau Institut für Teilchenphysik, Osterreichische Akademie der Wissenschafter · University of Vienna
DOI: 10.21468/SciPostPhys.21.1.002
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "On the coverage of electroweak-inos within the pMSSM with SModelS -- a comparison with the ATLAS pMSSM study".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper compares constraints on electroweak-inos in the pMSSM derived from SModelS against results from a recent ATLAS study to assess how well SModelS reproduces experimental limits and what can be gained by combining analyses Comparison with ATLAS Results The authors compare constraints on electroweak-inos (EWKinos) derived with SModelS against the new ATLAS pMSSM results The direct comparison between ATLAS and SModelS is performed by considering only ATLAS EWKino results in the SModelS database and following the same “single-analysis” approach as the ATLAS study They generally observe good agreement between ATLAS and SModelS for chargino masses mχ˜±1 ≳ 360 GeV, albeit there is a slight over-exclusion from SModelS at high mχ˜±1, above 600 GeV For mχ˜±1 ≲ 360 GeV, there is a sizeable difference between the SModelS and the official ATLAS exclusion This difference arises mainly from the disappearing track constraints Using the Full SModelS Database The analysis is extended to consider the full SModelS database, which includes CMS results and in particular constraints from gluino production The EWKino dataset thus includes points for which gluino-pair production and/or gluinoEWKino associated production is within reach In total, we consider 36 Run 2 analyses (20 ATLAS and 16 CMS) and 14 Run 1 analyses (6 ATLAS and 8 CMS) from the SModelS v3.0.0 database for which both observed and expected r-values can be computed The exclusion by the most sensitive analysis in SModelS, considering both EWKino and gluino production, is shown in Fig.
Kai: 6 by the filled stacked histogram The gluino constraints are quite relevant over the full range of considered chargino masses, and they allow to access also a part of the parameter space with mχ˜±1 ≳ 1 TeV Effect of Analysis Combination The authors analyze what can be gained by the statistical combination of (approximately) uncorrelated analyses For SModelS, this means that only analyses with efficiency map (EM) results can be used to build global likelihoods The set of analyses we can use in this study for building global likelihoods comprises 37 analyses: 18 ATLAS and 8 CMS analyses from Run 2, as well as 6 ATLAS and 5 CMS analyses from Run 1 They use the Pathfinder algorithm to determine for each point in the dataset the combination of analyses that maximizes the sensitivity to the signal Overall, combining analyses thus resulted in a 20% (35%) improvement in (expected) exclusion The combination of analyses in SModelS significantly enhances the robustness and sensitivity of statistical tests in the pMSSM scan It mitigates statistical fluctuations, especially in regions with dense analysis coverage, and enables more realistic interpretations when combining ATLAS and CMS results However, the improvement is still limited by the availability of efficiency maps and the granularity of simplified model interpretations To make this and further extensions possible, we urge the ATLAS and CMS collaborations to more systematically provide efficiency maps for the relevant simplified models The combination also allows one to elucidate particularly interesting regions of small but consistent excesses, that should be specially probed with more data Data Availability SModelS is public software distributed under the GPLv3 licence All data and results presented in this work, together with jupyter notebooks to reproduce the paper plots, are publicly available on Zenodo The authors have not yet included the mono-jet results from
72,73: , which also show small excesses Studying their impact in a global likelihood analysis is left for future work The set of these points is depicted in Fig.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper today, "On the coverage of electroweak-inos within the pMSSM with SModelS -- a comparison with the ATLAS pMSSM study." It’s all about checking how well our existing tools, SModelS, match what ATLAS has found about these electroweak-inos in Supersymmetry models.
Mira: Exactly. The paper is essentially taking what ATLAS has done and plugging it into our SModelS database to see where the gaps are in the constraints we have right now for these particles. It sets up a direct comparison between the two approaches to mapping out this parameter space.
Lev: And it starts by looking at a very specific setup, just using only ATLAS results for this electroweak-inos search within SModelS and following their single-analysis method. That’s the first step in their analysis, right?
Kai: Right. They check how well SModelS matches the ATLAS constraints when you only look at those chargino masses around three hundred sixty gigaelectronvolts and above. They see some good agreement there, but then they find a slight over-exclusion from SModelS when the chargino masses get higher than six hundred gigaelectronvolts.
Mira: That’s interesting because it suggests that for very heavy electroweak-inos, our database might be slightly too restrictive compared to the ATLAS results they are using as their baseline. But for lower masses, say below three hundred sixty gigaelectronvolts, there's a noticeable difference because of some things called disappearing track constraints.
Lev: Those disappearing track constraints are key because they really affect the exclusion limits in that lower mass range, and it shows how much experimental detail in tracking data can shift the results. But the paper doesn't just look at chargino masses; it expands the scope.
Kai: They do expand it by moving to use the full SModelS database, which means they are including constraints from both ATLAS and CMS results, especially those coming from gluino production. This opens up a whole new region of parameter space where we can test for these electroweak-inos because they can now consider scenarios where gluino pair production or gluino associated production is within reach.
Title and authors: Mira: And that’s significant because the paper shows that by including those gluino constraints, you can access parameter space with chargino masses greater than one thousand gigaelectronvolts. That pushes the limits way out compared to just looking at the chargino mass alone.
Lev: So, the full database analysis is much more powerful because it lets you see how these different production modes—the electroweak-inos search versus the gluino production constraints—interact across a wider range of masses. It’s about seeing what happens when you combine those different physics signals into one exclusion limit.
Kai: Then they move on to Section four where they talk about combining analyses statistically, which is another big part of this paper <ref:2512.14502#pg1>. They use the Pathfinder algorithm to figure out which combination of approximately uncorrelated analyses gives you the most sensitivity for every single point in the database.
Mira: That combination step is what they show can give a twenty percent or thirty five percent improvement in their expected exclusion limits overall when they combine analyses from SModelS. It really shows that just looking at one analysis doesn't capture all the statistical power available across the different searches.
Lev: That improvement comes from mitigating those statistical fluctuations, especially in areas where you have a lot of data points overlapping, and it gives a more realistic picture of the exclusion strength. But they point out a limitation there too: this combination only works if you use efficiency maps and they need those to build the global likelihoods.
Kai: So what this means for us is that combining analyses isn't just an academic exercise; it’s how we get a more robust statistical test in the pMSSM scan. But it also highlights where our data needs work, specifically mentioning the need for efficiency maps and better detail on certain signal topologies involving h bosons.
Mira: And that leads directly into their suggestions for improvement. The paper points out that to make these combinations more powerful, ATLAS and CMS should provide more systematic efficiency maps for the simplified models they are using. It’s about getting better input data so the AI can build a stronger global likelihood function.
Lev: From an engineering side, it confirms that while the statistical combination is strong, it's still limited by how granular those efficiency maps are and how simplified the model interpretations can be. We need more precise inputs to push this further on real hardware constraints.
Title and authors: Kai: So, to wrap up this paper on "On the coverage of electroweak-inos within the pMSSM with SModelS -- a comparison with the ATLAS pMSSM study," we see that combining analyses significantly enhances the sensitivity of statistical tests in scanning for these particles. It helps mitigate statistical noise and gives more realistic interpretations when you look at combined ATLAS and CMS results.
Mira: But they also show that this improvement is capped by how available those efficiency maps are and the level of simplification in model interpretations. They suggest that more systematic provision of those maps is needed to push these analyses even further into unexplored territory, especially regarding small but consistent excesses.
Lev: And from my side, it confirms that the combination allows you to look at regions with small but consistent excesses, which should definitely be probed with more data down the line. It’s about using the statistical combination to find those subtle hints that single analyses might miss.
Kai: So this paper gives us a clearer picture of how SModelS maps out these electroweak-inos, showing where it aligns well with ATLAS results and where we still have room for improvement through better data input and smarter statistical combinations. It’s a good roadmap for future searches.
Mira: Exactly. The full picture from the paper is that the combination of analyses gives us a more robust statistical test in the pMSSM scan, but we need better inputs to get even more out of it. That's what this comparison with ATLAS really boils down to.
Lev: It confirms that combining searches enhances sensitivity, but you have to be careful about what assumptions you make when doing those combinations. We can't just take any combination; it has to be based on the correct efficiency maps and model simplifications.
Kai: So, looking forward, this paper sets a benchmark for how we should think about combining different experimental constraints in supersymmetric searches. It’s a solid foundation for where we go next in mapping out these particles across the full parameter space of the pMSSM.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, we've seen how SModelS compares to ATLAS results for these electroweak-inos in this paper. The main thing is that they take what ATLAS found and plug it into our database to see where SModelS is strong and where it falls short.
Mira: Exactly. It shows good agreement for the heavier charginos, but then there's a bit of over-exclusion in SModelS when those masses get really high, above six hundred gigaelectronvolts.
Lev: And they point out that for the lower masses, under three hundred sixty gigaelectronvolts, there is a real difference mainly because of these disappearing track constraints. That shows how much experimental detail matters when you're trying to set limits on these particles.
Kai: The big takeaway is that just looking at one analysis doesn't give you the whole picture; combining analyses from SModelS actually gives us about a twenty percent or thirty five percent improvement in the exclusion strength.
Mira: That combination step is what makes the statistical tests more robust, mitigating those statistical fluctuations when you look at dense data regions. But they clearly flag that this combination only works if you use efficiency maps to build those global likelihoods.
Lev: Yeah, and that’s a limitation we have to be aware of; without those efficiency maps, the combination power is limited by what the model interpretation can handle. It's not just a statistical trick; it depends on the quality of the input data you feed into it.
Kai: So what this means for us is that while we have these powerful combinations, we still need better systematic inputs from ATLAS and CMS, especially regarding those efficiency maps for certain signal topologies involving h bosons.
Mira: Right. The paper suggests that to really push these analyses further into unexplored territory—especially around those small but consistent excesses they've seen—we need more systematic provision of those maps.
Lev: I agree, it’s about getting better inputs so the AI can build a stronger global likelihood function for real hardware constraints. It’s not just about the math; it’s about what we can actually measure at a collider.
Kai: So, this paper sets a clear roadmap for how we should think about combining different experimental constraints in supersymmetric searches. It shows us where SModelS aligns well with ATLAS and where we still have room for improvement through better data input and smarter statistical combinations.
Mira: And that's what it boils down to; using the combination to find those subtle hints that single analyses might miss, provided we have the right inputs to make those combinations meaningful.
Lev: It confirms that combining searches enhances sensitivity, but you have to be careful about what assumptions you make when doing those combinations. We can't just take any combination; it has to be based on the correct efficiency maps and model simplifications.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So, we just talked about how SModelS compares to ATLAS results for these electroweak-inos in this paper, focusing on both single analyses and combining them statistically for better exclusion limits. Now we're going to look at what the authors suggest they need to do next.
Mira: They're saying that the real way forward is getting more systematic inputs from ATLAS and CMS collaborations, specifically for those efficiency maps they mention.
Lev: That means providing more detailed information about how these models behave under different experimental conditions, so the AI can build a better global likelihood function. It’s not just a theoretical tweak; it's about making the data we feed into the system more accurate.
Kai: Right, so they want better efficiency maps for simplified models involving h bosons and other signal topologies. That’s how we get those constraints to be as tight as possible on real hardware constraints.
Mira: It seems like they are highlighting that while the statistical combination is powerful, its strength is ultimately limited by the granularity of those input maps. If the inputs are coarse, the combination won't be very good.
Lev: Exactly. For me, it means if we want to run these scans on real hardware without massive overhead from error correction, we need those efficiency maps to be pretty precise so we don't waste compute time looking at things that aren't actually going to happen.
Kai: So the implication is that future work needs to focus on standardizing how ATLAS and CMS present this efficiency data for these simplified models so the AI can leverage it better in the pMSSM scan.
Mira: And it also opens up a path to probing those small but consistent excesses they've seen in data, which would be great for finding new physics that might be hiding in plain sight.
Lev: Yeah, and that’s where we need more data down the line to actually confirm those hints. It's about using these improved scans to guide future experimental design better than just looking at the current exclusion limits.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper on "On the coverage of electroweak-inos within the pMSSM with SModelS -- a comparison with the ATLAS pMSSM study" shows how combining analyses significantly boosts our statistical tests for these particles in supersymmetric models.
Mira: It confirms that even when we look at complex combinations, like using the Pathfinder algorithm to maximize sensitivity, we still need those systematic inputs from ATLAS and CMS to make those results truly reliable.
Lev: I think it’s important because it shows that just having a good statistical method isn't enough; you have to have the right experimental data structure underneath it for it to work on real hardware constraints.
Kai: Right, so the main message is that future work needs to focus on standardizing how efficiency maps are shared so the AI can build better global likelihoods for these searches.
Mira: It also confirms that combining searches enhances sensitivity, but you have to be careful about what assumptions you make when doing those combinations; it has to be based on the correct efficiency maps and model simplifications.
Lev: I agree, and it means we need more precise inputs so we don't waste compute time looking at things that aren't actually going to happen in a real search.
Kai: Overall, this paper gives us a clear picture of how SModelS maps out these electroweak-inos, showing where it aligns well with ATLAS results and where we still have room for improvement through better data input and smarter statistical combinations.
Mira: Exactly; it’s a solid foundation for where we go next in mapping out these particles across the full parameter space of the pMSSM.
Lev: It’s about using these improved scans to guide future experimental design better than just looking at the current exclusion limits for things like gluino production.
More episodes
- 2610.38463-Gauge-parameter cancellation and finite form factors in one-loop quark scattering in the refined Gribov-Zwanziger framework
- 2610.37198-Searches for new particle physics by methods of classical and neutrino astronomy
- 2511.15779-SURFing to the Fundamental Limit of Jet Tagging
- 2505.01492-Photo- and Hadrodisintegration constraints on massive relics decaying into neutrinos
- 2505.20389-Dispersion relation of the neutrino plasma: Unifying fast, slow, and collisional instabilities
- 2511.10731-Keeping It Renormalizable: Minimal Baryogenesis induced Asymmetric Dark Matter
- 2404.04021-Vacuum correlations of the stress-energy-momentum tensor with constituent quarks
- 2503.02931-Relativistic Navier-Stokes description of the quark-gluon plasma radial flow
- 2606.06105-Bulk viscosity of a binary mixture: the role of the intra-species interaction
- 2607.03343-First look at the evaluation of two-loop Feynman integrals for radiative return processes