Multi-TeV vector dark matter in the U(1) X Higgs portal model

summary

The gist

Multi-TeV vector dark matter in the U(1)X Higgs portal model investigates heavy-mass vector dark matter within a U(1)X gauge Higgs portal vector model by jointly integrating experimental constraints…

In short

This study investigates multi-TeV vector dark matter within a U(1)X Higgs portal model by combining relic density, direct detection, and indirect detection constraints with perturbativity requirements. The research found that resonant annihilation is viable up to 2.43 TeV for a specific mixing angle, while the non-resonant mechanism is largely excluded in the heavy mass regime.

Key concepts

U(1)X Gauge Symmetry
This extends the Standard Model by adding a new gauge symmetry, U(1X), which governs the interactions of a new dark sector. This symmetry introduces a dark gauge field (Vµ) and is crucial for describing how the vector dark matter candidate interacts with Standard Model particles.
Vector Dark Matter (VDM)
The VDM candidate is a heavy, multi-TeV particle that acts as the mediator between the Standard Model and the dark sector. Its properties are studied by examining its annihilation cross section to explain why we observe the current amount of dark matter in the universe.
Perturbativity Criterion
This is a theoretical constraint ensuring that all coupling strengths in the model remain small enough to allow for reliable calculations across different energy scales, up to the Planck scale. If couplings become too large, the mathematical framework breaks down, setting limits on where the model can be physically valid.
S-channel Resonance
This occurs when a particle's mass is close to half the sum of two other particles' masses (mV ≈ mh2 / 2). In this specific energy configuration, the interaction between dark matter particles can be greatly enhanced, allowing the model to successfully reproduce the observed relic density with relatively weak gauge couplings.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Multi-TeV vector dark matter in the U(1) X Higgs portal model · Read on arXiv

Kun-Peng Chen, Han Hu, Hao-Yu Luo, Yun Wei, Ming Zhong

National University of Defense Technology

We investigate heavy-mass vector dark matter within the framework of the U(1) X gauge Higgs portal vector model, by jointly integrating experimental constraints from relic density measurements, direct detection searches, and indirect detection observations alongside the perturbative criterion to derive bounds on the model parameter space. Within the weakly interacting massive particle scenario, we assess the relative contributions of s-channel and t/u-channel processes to thermal dark matter annihilation. For parameter configurations lying in the s-channel resonance region, each fixed value of the scalar mixing angle α corresponds to a well-defined upper limit on the heavy dark scalar mass m h 2. This upper limit decreases monotonically with increasing α, with a critical threshold of α 0.05 beyond which perturbative constraints entirely exclude the full resonance corridor. By contrast, the non-resonant parameter regime dominated by t/u-channel annihilation processes is found to be excluded for m V 1 TeV and above under the combined joint constraints from relic density requirements and perturbative consistency. Our results indicate that the perturbative consistency of the scalar sector, enforced via the two-loop renormalisation group equations, imposes bounds on the parameter space in the heavy mass regime that are comparable to, and in some benchmark regions more restrictive than, current experimental limits. Nevertheless, even under the application of these stringent perturbativity constraints, the model still admits a viable set of parameter points spanning a broad multi-TeV mass range.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Multi-TeV vector dark matter in the U(1) X Higgs portal model".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Multi-TeV vector dark matter in the U(1)X Higgs portal model investigates heavy-mass vector dark matter within a U(1)X gauge Higgs portal vector model by jointly integrating experimental constraints from relic density measurements, direct detection searches, and indirect detection observations alongside the perturbative criterion to derive bounds on the model parameter space Model Framework and Parameters The VDM candidate is introduced within a framework that extends the Standard Model by adding a complex scalar singlet S obeying a U(1)X gauge symmetry, alongside a gauge field Vµ corresponding to the VDM candidate The stability of the VDM candidate is ensured by an imposed discrete Z2 symmetry, which concurrently forbids kinetic mixing between the dark gauge sector and the SM gauge sector The complete Lagrangian of the model can be written as L = LSM − 1/4 VµνVµν + (DµS)†(DµS) − V (H, S), where LSM is the Lagrangian of the SM after excluding the Higgs potential term The most general renormalizable scalar potential that remains invariant under the gauge groups and the Z2 symmetry is given by V = −µ/2 HH2 + λHH4 − µ/2 SS4 + λSS4 + λSHSH squared, in which H denotes the SM Higgs doublet Both the electroweak and U(1X) gauge symmetries undergo spontaneous breaking The imaginary component of S, which corresponds to the Goldstone mode associated with the spontaneous breaking of the U(1X) gauge symmetry, is absorbed by the dark photon Vµ as its longitudinal degree of freedom, thereby endowing the dark photon with a non-vanishing mass mV = gV vS The last term in Eq.

Kai: (4) gives rise to a bilinear cross term between ΦH and ΦS, which results in a non-diagonal mass matrix of the scalars Experimental Constraints Integration The viable parameter space is primarily constrained by multiple experimental and observational inputs, including the dark matter (DM) relic abundance, direct detection, indirect detection, and collider searches from invisible Higgs decays For light DM populating the sub-GeV to GeV mass interval, the permissible parameter space is further compressed by supplementary experimental bounds encompassing cosmic microwave background (CMB) constraints on the low-velocity s-wave annihilation cross section, rare decay channels of light scalar states, and published measurements from beam-dump experiments For DM in the intermediate mass regime spanning from the GeV scale to the sub-TeV range, low-energy constraints—such as those imposed by invisible Higgs decays and rare decays of light scalar states—progressively become kinematically inaccessible, rendering the relic density requirement and direct detection bounds as the dominant constraining factors As the DM mass extends into the multi-TeV heavy mass regime, the overall stringency of applied experimental constraints is substantially attenuated Perturbativity and Renormalization Group Analysis The analytical framework for evaluating vacuum stability and perturbativity constraints via the renormalisation group evolution of scalar couplings was systematically examined for the SM This framework has subsequently been generalized to the VDM model, within which a stringent perturbativity criterion has been formally established: all model couplings are required to remain below the 2π threshold across the full energy scale range extending to the Planck scale The renormalization group equations (RGEs) describing the scale evolution of all model parameters for the VDM are derived with the SARAH package In line with the methodology established in Ref.

6: , the boundary initial conditions for the renormalization group running are fixed at the top-quark mass scale µ = mt, with all coupling parameters numerically evolved along the renormalization scale up to the Planck scale MPl ≃ 1.22 × 1019 GeV Throughout the present work, we implement the perturbativity requirement stipulating that all model coupling parameters remain bounded below 2π across the full renormalization scale range up to MPl

6: Key Findings on Annihilation Mechanisms The study demonstrates that two distinct annihilation mechanisms are capable of accounting for the cosmologically observed DM relic abundance Within the s-channel resonant parameter region defined by the condition mV ≈ mh2 /2, the Breit–Wigner resonant enhancement enables the observed relic density to be reproduced with a gauge coupling as small as gV ∼ O(10−2) Upon incorporating the perturbativity constraint, we demonstrate that this resonant mechanism remains fully viable up to mh2 ≃ 2.43 TeV for a fixed scalar mixing angle sin α = 0.05, and its viable parameter reach can be extended to mh2 ≃ 12.15 TeV by reducing the mixing angle to sin α = 0.01 In the non-resonant parameter regime defined by mh2 ≲ mV, the t/u-channel-mediated annihilation of dark vector pairs into dark scalar pairs represents the dominant process governing the thermally averaged annihilation cross section Nevertheless, the gauge coupling required to match the observed relic abundance exceeds 19 for all DM masses exceeding approximately 1 TeV Accordingly, this annihilation mechanism is almost entirely excluded across the heavy-mass regime, with only a narrow marginally allowed parameter window persisting at the low-mass boundary of this regime, which is ultimately ruled out under the combined constraints of relic density consistency and perturbativity The phenomenologically viable parameter space of the VDM model within the multi-TeV mass regime is jointly bounded by complementary theoretical consistency constraints and experimental observational bounds The perturbativity requirement for the scalar sector, enforced via two-loop RGE calculations, constitutes the decisive constraint that truncates the allowed parameter extents of both the s-channel resonant corridor and the t/u-channel dominated non-resonant region, thereby establishing a robust upper bound on the mass scales permittable within this DM framework Notwithstanding the stringent perturbativity constraints applied across our analysis, we find that the model retains a sizable viable parameter space spanning the broad DM mass interval 1 TeV ≤ mV ≤ 10 TeV, provided the scalar mixing angle α is sufficiently small This surviving viable parameter space is governed by the resonant annihilation mechanism, with the associated gauge coupling gV taking values in the range from 10−1 to 10−2 Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The analysis shows that for each fixed sin α value, a well-defined upper limit mmax h2 on the dark scalar mass is identified For all dark scalar masses satisfying mh2 < mmax h2, a resonant valley emerges in the parameter region mV ≃ mh2 /2; the fraction of this valley excluded by the perturbativity requirement grows progressively as mh2 approaches mmax h2, until the entire parameter range of the valley is fully excluded when mh2 reaches its upper bound The nontrivial character of the large dark scalar mass regime arises directly from the dependence of the resonance width on mh2, as this quantity modulates the depth of the resonant valley Extrapolation of the derived parameter scaling indicates that smaller mixing angle values, which yield mmax h2 > 20 TeV, permit DM mass solutions that satisfy both experimental constraints and perturbativity requirements across an extended multi-TeV interval How the training signal is built The analysis involves constructing a suite of discretized benchmark parameter configurations specified by sin α = 0.01, 0.02, 0.03 and mh2 = 2.5, 4, 6 TeV For each of the nine benchmark parameter combinations, we carry out a grid-based parameter scan: the mV dimension is sampled via uniform linear discretization, while the gV dimension is sampled via uniform logarithmic discretization The relic abundance contour satisfying omegah2 = 0.12 and the 2π perturbativity boundary are independently resolved using iterative numerical bisection Where the gains come from The combined experimental and perturbativity constraints define a region where the model preserves a viable parameter space covering the broad DM mass interval 1 TeV ≤ mV ≤ 10 TeV, provided the scalar mixing angle α remains sufficiently small The final result is that the resonant annihilation mechanism remains fully viable up to mh2 ≃ 2.43 TeV for a fixed scalar mixing angle sin α = 0.05 This demonstrates that even when the stringent perturbativity requirement is enforced, the admissible DM mass range of the considered model spans the broad interval from 1 TeV to 10 TeV The present study reports a systematic dedicated analysis of the heavy-mass parameter space for VDM realizations embedded within the U(1)X gauged scalar Higgs portal model Subject to the complete set of applied experimental constraints, two distinct annihilation mechanisms are capable of accounting for the cosmologically observed DM relic abundance Within the s-channel resonant parameter region defined by the condition mV ≈ mh2 /2, the Breit–Wigner resonant enhancement enables the observed relic density to be reproduced with a gauge coupling as small as gV ∼ O(10−2) Upon incorporating the perturbativity constraint, we demonstrate that this resonant mechanism remains fully viable up to mh2 ≃ 2.43 TeV for a fixed scalar mixing angle sin α = 0.

Title and authors: Kai: So we've covered the basics of what this paper is about—the title "Multi-TeV vector dark matter in the U(oneX Higgs portal model"—and how they are using experimental data to constrain it, which leads us into what they actually found <ref:2611.13023#pg1,Multi-TeV vector dark matter in the U>.

Mira: The paper starts by setting up this framework, introducing the complex scalar singlet S and the gauge field V mu that represents our vector dark matter candidate within the Standard Model extension.

Lev: They establish a discrete Z two symmetry to ensure that kinetic mixing between the dark sector and our SM gauge sector is forbidden, which is a standard way to keep these sectors somewhat separate.

Kai: But then they build in that scalar S, and crucially, they show how its imaginary component gets absorbed by the dark photon V mu as its longitudinal degree of freedom.

Mira: That absorption gives the dark photon a mass term, mV equals gV vS, which is the key connection between the dark sector and what we see in experiments.

Lev: And that interaction portal term in their scalar potential, specifically that last term involving H and S, it creates a non-diagonal mass matrix for those scalars.

Kai: Which means you can't just treat them as independent particles; they are mixed together, which makes the phenomenology much richer.

Mira: So this entire construction is designed to be a minimal realization of vector dark matter while also potentially addressing other issues like vacuum stability and the first-order electroweak phase transition.

Lev: The paper notes that this construction can accommodate a strongly first-order electroweak phase transition that gives rise to cosmic baryon asymmetry and stochastic gravitational waves.

Kai: That’s ambitious stuff, linking particle physics to cosmology in one model, which is always exciting when you're looking for new physics at these scales.

Mira: So we see this minimal realization isn't just a theoretical exercise; it has the potential to explain some of the bigger puzzles in cosmology.

Lev: And that’s why we need to focus on how those specific interactions work when we push the masses into the multi-TeV range, as that’s where these features start to matter most.

The paper's summary: Kai: Moving on from the setup, the main thrust of this paper is testing whether this model can actually reproduce the dark matter relic abundance we observe in our universe.

Mira: They assess both s-channel and t over u channel processes for thermal dark matter annihilation to see which one dominates how we get that observed density.

Lev: The results show two distinct annihilation mechanisms are capable of accounting for the cosmologically observed dark matter relic abundance, so it’s not just one thing doing all the work.

Kai: Specifically, in the s channel resonant parameter region where mV is roughly equal to mh2 over two, they find that a Breit-Wigner enhancement can reproduce the relic density with a gauge coupling as small as gV around zero point ten to negative two.

Mira: That's quite good for us because it shows this resonance mechanism is viable up to a dark scalar mass of mh2 around two point four three teravolt for a fixed scalar mixing angle of sin alpha equal zero point zero five <ref:2611.13023#pg2>.

Lev: That upper limit on the dark scalar mass, mh2, decreases as the mixing angle increases, which tells us that smaller mixing angles open up more room for heavier dark scalars before we hit those perturbative problems.

Kai: If you decrease that mixing angle down to sin alpha equal zero point zero one, they find the viable reach can extend all the way out to a dark scalar mass of twelve point fifteen teravolt.

Mira: That is a substantial extension, moving from around two point four three teravolt up to twelve point one five teravolt just by tuning that mixing angle parameter.

Lev: But they also look at the non-resonant regime where the dark scalar mass is less than or equal to mV, and in that case, the t over u channel mediated annihilation into dark scalar pairs is dominant.

Kai: And here’s the catch for that non-resonant process: to match the relic density, you need a gauge coupling that goes above nineteen for any dark matter mass exceeding around one teravolt.

Mira: So they conclude that this non-resonant mechanism is almost entirely excluded across the heavy-mass regime, with only a very narrow window left near the low-mass boundary of this regime.

The paper's improvements: Lev: What’s interesting here is how they use these constraints to systematically prune the parameter space, and they do that by looking at how the resonance width changes with mh2.

Kai: They map out a well-defined upper limit, m max h2, for every fixed value of sin alpha, which shows where the resonant valley emerges in this parameter region.

Mira: As mh2 gets closer to that m max h2 limit they find, the fraction of that valley excluded by the perturbative requirement grows progressively until the whole parameter range of the valley disappears entirely when mh2 hits that upper bound.

Lev: That dependence on resonance width modulation with mh2 is a key feature, because it shows how much freedom we lose as we increase the dark scalar mass.

Kai: And they extrapolate this scaling to find that smaller mixing angle values, which give them m max h2 greater than twenty teravolt, still permit solutions that satisfy both the experimental constraints and those perturbative requirements across a broad multi-TeV interval.

Mira: So the implication is that if we keep the mixing angle small enough, say below zero point zero one, we can have viable dark matter masses spanning from one teravolt to ten teravolts.

Lev: That surviving region is governed by that resonant annihilation mechanism, with the gauge coupling gV taking values between zero point one and zero point two.

Kai: So they’re not just finding a single mass; they're defining a whole broad swath of viable parameter space based on these joint constraints.

Conclusion: Mira: So to wrap up the "Multi-TeV vector dark matter in the U(oneX Higgs portal model," the main point is that we have found a sizable region where this model is consistent with everything we know <ref:2611.13023#pg1,Multi-TeV vector dark matter in the U>.

Kai: It’s this combination of relic density requirements, direct detection limits, and that crucial two-loop renormalisation group evolution constraint that defines the viable parameter space.

Lev: The perturbative requirement ended up being the decisive constraint because it’s what truncates both the s channel resonance corridor and the non-resonant region we discussed.

Mira: So they conclude there is a viable parameter space covering a broad dark matter mass interval of one teravolt to ten teravolts, provided that the scalar mixing angle remains sufficiently small.

Kai: That surviving space is entirely governed by that resonant annihilation mechanism, with the gauge coupling gV being in the range of zero point one to zero point two.

Lev: I just want to say that even when you push these constraints this hard, they still manage to find a way for this model to work over that wide mass range.

Mira: It’s definitely a solid result demonstrating how theory and experiment can cooperate to define limits on new physics at these high energy scales.

Kai: We'll keep an eye on those results as we look at other potential dark matter candidates, but for now, this paper gives us a clear map of what’s allowed in this specific portal model.

More episodes

← Home