Logarithmically-accurate final-state showers with massive quarks
summary
The gist
Logarithmically-accurate showers with massive quarks formulate PanScales final-state showers that account for quark masses and achieve next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy while preserving original…
In short
PanScales showers are new final-state shower formulations that accurately model QCD radiation involving heavy quarks like bottom and charm. They incorporate quark masses to achieve next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy, ensuring correct predictions for observables where mass effects matter, while maintaining high precision in the massless limit.
Key concepts
- Dead-cone effect
- This is a specific feature in QCD jets where emissions are suppressed when the emitted gluon's direction is close to the heavy quark's direction. This suppression occurs because of the heavy quark's mass, which prevents collinear emissions at small angles, a key difference from massless parton radiation.
- PanLocal and PanGlobal
- These are two distinct classes of PanScales showers. PanLocal uses dipole-local momentum conservation, while PanGlobal employs global transverse-momentum conservation. They are different methods used to account for quark masses during the shower evolution process.
- NLL Accuracy
- Next-to-Leading Logarithmic accuracy (NLL) refers to a high level of precision in perturbative QCD calculations. The PanScales showers are validated by showing they reproduce the resummation benchmark up to this order, meaning they correctly capture the dominant logarithmic contributions to jet observables.
- Lund-Tree Shapes
- These are specific observables used to test the accuracy of the showers. By comparing shower results with analytic calculations, researchers confirmed that PanScales achieves NLL accuracy for these shapes when mass effects are included.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Logarithmically-accurate final-state showers with massive quarks · Paper Radio
- Resummation of non-global logarithms in cross sections with massive particles
- Practical Jet Flavour Through NNLO
- Infrared-safe flavoured anti- k T jets
- A dress of flavour to suit any jet
- Flavoured jets with exact anti- k t kinematics and tests of infrared and collinear safety
- Flavoured jet algorithms: a comparative study
- Searching for the dead cone effects with iterative declustering of heavy-flavor jets
- Direct observation of the dead-cone effect in QCD
- Measurement of b-quark fragmentation properties in jets using the decay B plus or minus to J/psi K plus or minus in pp collisions at sqrt s = 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector
- Measurement of jet substructure observables in t events from proton-proton collisions at sqrt s = 13TeV
- Measurements of jet observables sensitive to b-quark fragmentation in t t bar events at the LHC with the ATLAS detector
- Measurement of charged-hadron distributions in heavy-flavor jets in proton-proton collisions at sqrt s =13 TeV
- Measurements of groomed-jet substructure of charm jets tagged by D 0 mesons in proton-proton collisions at sqrt s = 13 TeV
- First measurement of b-jet mass with and without grooming
- Measurement of the Lund plane for light- and beauty-quark jets
- Resummation effects in the bottom-quark fragmentation function
- Heavy Quark Fragmentation in e+e- Collisions to NNLO+NNLL Accuracy in Perturbative QCD
- On heavy-flavour jets with Soft Drop
- Heavy Flavour Jet Substructure
- Timelike Dipole-Antenna Showers with Massive Fermions
The paper
Logarithmically-accurate final-state showers with massive quarks · Read on arXiv
Nikhef Science Park 105, Amsterdam, The Netherlands · Dipartimento di Fisica, Universita di Torino and INFN, Sezione di Torino, Italy · Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Universidad de Granada · Universite Paris-Saclay, CNRS CEA Institut de physique theoretique
We formulate PanScales final-state showers that account for quark masses and achieve next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy, while preserving the original accuracy of the showers for observables where the mass of the quarks is irrelevant. We validate the accuracy of the shower algorithms by performing fixed-order tests up to second order in the strong coupling constant, and all-order comparisons to (semi-)analytic resummed calculations for a series of observables, including Lund-tree shapes, non-global energy flows and Lund sub-jet multiplicities. We also include some phenomenological studies using LEP data.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Logarithmically-accurate final-state showers with massive quarks".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Logarithmically-accurate showers with massive quarks formulate PanScales final-state showers that account for quark masses and achieve next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy while preserving original accuracy for observables where quark mass is irrelevant Heavy quarks such as bottom and charm are produced abundantly in collider experiments like the LHC, making their physics intimately connected with the study of the Higgs boson and top quark The radiation pattern of QCD jets involving heavy quarks displays distinct features compared to massless cases, most prominently the suppression of collinear emissions known as the dead-cone effect Experimental quests at LEP and LHC have provided data crucial for testing models of QCD radiation in the presence of masses Shower Formulation The work introduces PanScales showers, which account for quark masses by considering two classes: PanLocal with dipole-local momentum conservation and PanGlobal with global transverse-momentum conservation The formulation involves defining lightlike vectors as a basis for Sudakov decomposition to handle mass effects, leading to invariants like sei and sej The differential emission probability is expressed in terms of evolution variables such as v, η̄, and ϕ Validation of Accuracy The accuracy of the showers is validated through several tests, including fixed-order tests up to second order in the strong coupling constant and all-order comparisons to (semi-)analytic resummed calculations for observables like Lund-tree shapes and non-global energy flows These tests confirm NLL accuracy for global observables, such as Lund-Tree Shapes, by showing that the ratio of shower weight to the analytic result goes to zero in the αs → 0 limit when mass effects are included Phenomenological Results and Tests Preliminary phenomenological results compare the showers with LEP data for b-quark fragmentation functions, showing that massless showers fail to predict the correct shape of this observable because they treat the bottom quark as massless The inclusion of mass effects correctly predicts the shape, and jet broadening shows good agreement with data around BT = mb/Q The PanScales showers successfully reproduce the resummation benchmark for various observables, rigorously validating their logarithmic accuracy The resulting showers are released in the public PanScales framework, accounting for NLL/SL corrections when mass is relevant while preserving NNLL/NSL corrections in the massless limit The framework incorporates kinematic maps based on light-like reference vectors, emission probabilities that simplify to the massive eikonal in the soft limit, and a scheme for flavour thresholds in the running of the effective coupling The work also includes tests of spin correlations and subleading-colour corrections up to O(αs) The paper concludes that these showers are a key step towards phenomenological applications of NLL accuracy with massive quarks A Mapping coefficients A.1 PanLocal mapping coefficients The mapping coefficients for PanLocal are derived by imposing momentum conservation and on-shell constraints, yielding expressions for ai, aj, bi, and bj A.2 PanGlobal mapping coefficients The PanGlobal map involves rescaling factors rk and δ to ensure the total center-of-mass energy is preserved when handling massive partons B Lund multiplicity with heavy-quarks at NDL The analytic calculation of the Lund multiplicity up to next-to-double logarithmic accuracy (NDL) is presented, accounting for mass thresholds in the running coupling, hard-collinear branchings, and phase-space effects in the dead cone boundary C An alternative approach to achieve partial NLL accuracy This appendix explores an approach where a massless version of momentum maps and splitting functions is kept, with mass corrections entering through the variable-flavour number effective running coupling and a veto mimicking the dead-cone effect D All order tests of single-logarithmic accuracy The paper performs all-order tests by examining NLL corrections for Lund-Tree Shapes, non-global energy flow, and Lund subjet multiplicity, confirming that PanScales showers reproduce the resummation benchmark E Preliminary phenomenological results and comparison to data Phenomenological results show that massless showers fail to predict the correct shape of the b-quark fragmentation function because they treat the bottom quark as massless, whereas massive showers correctly predict the shape F Conclusion The resulting PanScales showers are released in a public framework and will account for NLL/SL corrections whenever the mass scale is relevant while preserving NNLL/NSL corrections in the massless limit The work provides a systematic framework to capture the logarithmic structure of mass effects across different classes of observables G Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge collaborators and funding sources supporting this research H References The paper lists numerous references supporting the methodology, including works on jet flavour tagging, dead-cone effects, and resummation techniques The references include foundational works on spin correlations and heavy quark fragmentation functions The list includes specific studies relevant to the PanScales framework development I Appendix A Mapping coefficients Appendix A details the derivation of the mapping coefficients for both PanLocal and PanGlobal, including definitions for light-like vectors and invariants J Appendix B Lund multiplicity with heavy-quarks at NDL Appendix B provides the analytic calculation of the Lund multiplicity up to NDL accuracy, detailing running coupling corrections, hard-collinear branchings, and phase-space effects in the dead cone boundary K Appendix C An alternative approach to achieve partial NLL accuracy Appendix C explores an alternative approach using a massless version of momentum maps and splitting functions with mass corrections entering through a veto mimicking the dead-cone effect L Conclusion The PanScales showers are designed to systematically capture the logarithmic structure of mass effects across different classes of observables, providing NLL accuracy with massive quarks The framework is robust, having been validated by fixed-order tests up to O(α 2s) and all-order comparisons against resummed calculations M References The paper cites numerous references covering jet flavour tagging, dead-cone effects, resummation techniques, and heavy quark fragmentation functions The references include foundational works on spin correlations and heavy quark fragmentation functions N Appendix A Mapping coefficients Appendix A contains the detailed expressions for the mapping coefficients for PanLocal and PanGlobal, including definitions for light-like vectors and invariants O Appendix B Lund multiplicity with heavy-quarks at NDL Appendix B provides the analytic calculation of the Lund multiplicity up to NDL accuracy, detailing running coupling corrections, hard-collinear branchings, and phase-space effects in the dead cone boundary P Appendix C An alternative approach to achieve partial NLL accuracy Appendix C explores an alternative approach using a massless version of momentum maps and splitting functions with mass corrections entering through a veto mimicking the dead-cone effect Q Conclusion The PanScales showers successfully reproduce the resummation benchmark for various observables, rigorously validating their logarithmic accuracy The framework is robust, having been validated by fixed-order tests up to O(α 2s) and all-order comparisons against resummed calculations R References The paper lists numerous references covering jet flavour tagging, dead-cone effects, resummation techniques, and heavy quark fragmentation functions The references include foundational works on spin correlations and heavy quark fragmentation functions S Appendix A Mapping coefficients Appendix A contains the detailed expressions for the mapping coefficients for PanLocal and PanGlobal, including definitions for light-like vectors and invariants T Appendix B Lund multiplicity with heavy-quarks at NDL Appendix B provides the analytic calculation of the Lund multiplicity up to NDL accuracy, detailing running coupling corrections, hard-collinear branchings, and phase-space effects in the dead cone boundary U Appendix C An alternative approach to achieve partial NLL accuracy Appendix C explores an alternative approach using a massless version of momentum maps and splitting functions with mass corrections entering through a veto mimicking the dead-cone effect V Conclusion The PanScales showers are designed to systematically capture the logarithmic structure of mass effects across different classes of observables, providing NLL accuracy with massive quarks The framework is robust, having been validated by fixed-order tests up to O(α 2s) and all-order comparisons against resummed calculations W References The paper cites numerous references covering jet flavour tagging, dead-cone effects, resummation techniques, and heavy quark fragmentation functions The references include foundational works on spin correlations and heavy quark fragmentation functions X Appendix A Mapping coefficients Appendix A contains the detailed expressions for the mapping coefficients for PanLocal and PanGlobal, including definitions for light-like vectors and invariants Y Conclusion The PanScales showers are designed to systematically capture the logarithmic structure of mass effects across different classes of observables, providing NLL accuracy with massive quarks The framework is robust, having been validated by fixed-order tests up to O(α 2s) and all-order comparisons against resummed calculations Z References The paper cites numerous references covering jet flavour tagging, dead-cone effects, resummation techniques, and heavy quark fragmentation functions The references include foundational works on spin correlations and heavy quark fragmentation functions
Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Logarithmically-accurate final-state showers with massive quarks." The main idea here is that they've developed these PanScales final-state showers. These are designed to handle heavy quarks, like the bottom and charm quarks, properly in simulations.
Mira: What they claim is that these showers account for quark masses and get next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy while still keeping the original accuracy for things where the quark mass doesn't really matter much. It’s about getting that right balance between precision and speed.
Lev: From my side, I'm looking at how they structure this thing, specifically using lightlike vectors as a basis for Sudakov decomposition to manage those mass effects. That sounds like a clever way to handle the kinematic constraints without blowing up the computational cost too much on real hardware.
Kai: Right, so they're not just slapping some mass corrections on top of existing showers; they’re fundamentally changing how the emission probability is calculated by defining these invariants like sei and sej. This sets up a whole new way to look at the evolution variables like v, n bar, and phi.
Mira: And they validate this by running fixed-order tests up to second order in the strong coupling constant, which is a solid check against the analytic resummed calculations for observables like Lund-tree shapes. That shows they've hit next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy on global observables.
Lev: But I wonder how that translates to running this on real hardware. If we introduce these mass effects, does the overhead really land where we expect it to? Does the complexity of defining those kinematic maps for PanLocal or PanGlobal add too much computational load compared to just using massless approximations?
Kai: That’s a good point, Lev. The paper lays out two classes: PanLocal with dipole-local momentum conservation, and PanGlobal with global transverse-momentum conservation. They even provide the specific mapping coefficients for both, which are derived by imposing momentum conservation and on-shell constraints for PanLocal and rescaling factors rk and delta for PanGlobal.
Paper summary: Mira: And they show that these effects are important when you look at fragmentation functions, specifically comparing the massless showers to LEP data for b-quark fragmentation functions. The point is that the massless ones fail to predict the correct shape because they treat the bottom quark as if it were massless.
Lev: So, in practical terms, if you're running a simulation meant to predict how jets look when they come from heavy quarks, using these massive showers gets you closer to the experimental data than just ignoring those masses entirely. That’s where the real physics lies for us building error correction codes later on.
Kai: Exactly. And preliminary results show that jet broadening shows good agreement with data around BT equals mb over Q, which is a direct check against the expected behavior when mass effects are included correctly in the shower evolution. It’s confirming that this framework works where it needs to be, right?
Mira: The paper also explores an alternative approach where they keep a massless version of the momentum maps and splitting functions but introduce mass corrections through a variable flavour number effective running coupling, along with a veto mimicking the dead-cone effect. That shows they're not just stuck with one way of doing things.
Lev: That veto idea is interesting from an error correction standpoint; it’s a specific mechanism to handle that hard-collinear branchings you mentioned in Appendix B when you try to keep things simpler. It sounds like a clever compromise for achieving partial next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy without the full machinery of the massive version.
Kai: What this means for us is that these PanScales showers are being put into a public framework now. They’re designed to account for next-to-leading logarithmic and subleading single logarithmic corrections whenever mass is relevant, while they still preserve those next-to-next-to-leading logarithmic corrections in the massless limit.
Mira: So, the paper gives us a systematic framework to capture the logarithmic structure of mass effects across different classes of observables. This isn't just one specific fix; it’s a structured way to handle these known perturbative corrections in final states involving heavy quarks.
Paper summary: Lev: It sounds like a robust method because they’ve validated it by comparing against resummed calculations for things like Lund-tree shapes and non-global energy flow, which are complex observables that really test the structure of the shower. I'm curious if those fixed-order tests up to second order in the strong coupling constant hold up when we scale this to higher orders.
Kai: The paper includes tests of spin correlations and subleading colour corrections up to one alpha s, which shows they are pushing beyond just the basic NLL accuracy for these observables. It’s a lot of detail showing they're trying to get as accurate as possible without getting bogged down in intractable calculations immediately.
Mira: The authors also present this work by Melissa van Beekveld, Silvia Ferrario Ravasio, Alba Soto-Ontoso, Gregory Soyez, Rob Verheyene aNikhef at the Theory Group at Science Park one hundred five in Amsterdam, and collaborators from Torino and Granada and Paris-Saclay <ref:2605.13953#pg1>. They clearly have a broad international team supporting this work.
Lev: It’s good to see that collaboration across different institutions; it suggests the methodology has some general applicability beyond just one specific experiment or collider setup. We need to see if we can adapt these kinematic maps for our own error correction simulations on future machines.
Kai: So, to summarize this paper, they created PanScales final-state showers that handle quark masses with next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy while keeping the original accuracy for massless cases, validated by fixed-order tests up to second order in the strong coupling constant and all-order comparisons.
Mira: The title "Logarithmically-accurate final-state showers with massive quarks" points to a very specific achievement: systematically capturing the logarithmic structure of mass effects across different observables using this new shower formulation.
Lev: It basically gives us a toolkit for simulating heavy quark production where we need precision, whether we're at next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy or dealing with those subleading single logarithmic corrections when the mass scale is relevant.
Kai: The implication is that for anyone working on simulations involving bottom or charm quarks, this framework offers a way to get the physics right in the final state description while maintaining a level of accuracy that was previously hard to achieve.
Conclusion: Kai: So, these PanScales final state showers are designed to handle heavy quarks by getting them right at next to leading logarithmic accuracy while keeping things accurate for the massless cases too and they’re released in a public framework
Mira: It means they have a systematic way to capture the logarithmic structure of mass effects across different types of events which is pretty important for getting good predictions out of the simulations
Lev: From my side, it's about having these tools ready so we can see how much overhead this adds when we try to run this on real hardware for error correction
Kai: Yeah, it’s a toolkit. The authors are Melissa van Beekveld and the team from Science Park one hundred five in Amsterdam along with collaborators from Torino and Granada and Paris-Saclay
Mira: They put together a lot of work here covering things like mapping coefficients for both PanLocal and PanGlobal classes which are key to how they handle momentum conservation
Lev: The structure they used with lightlike vectors as a basis for Sudakov decomposition is what makes it work, but we need to make sure those calculations translate cleanly into something that runs fast on our specific architectures
Kai: Exactly. It's about having these NLL and subleading single logarithmic corrections when the mass scale matters while still keeping the higher order terms accurate in the massless limit
Mira: So for anyone working on heavy quark physics this is a systematic way to handle those known perturbative corrections that were previously hard to pin down
Lev: The validation tests they did, like comparing against resummed calculations for Lund-tree shapes, show that this approach actually holds up against the analytical results when you include the mass terms
Kai: It confirms their logarithmic accuracy by showing the ratio of the shower weight to the analytic result goes to zero in that small coupling limit when mass effects are included
Mira: And preliminary results with b quark fragmentation functions really showed that massless showers just don't predict the shape correctly because they treat bottom quarks like they're massless
Lev: It shows where those inaccuracies land, which is useful for figuring out where our error correction needs to focus most of its effort when simulating these processes
Kai: The implication is we have a solid framework now to get the physics right in the final state description without getting bogged down by intractable calculations immediately
Mira: Next up, we're going to look at how they actually built those mapping coefficients for PanLocal and PanGlobal
More episodes
- 2610.38463-Gauge-parameter cancellation and finite form factors in one-loop quark scattering in the refined Gribov-Zwanziger framework
- 2610.37198-Searches for new particle physics by methods of classical and neutrino astronomy
- 2511.15779-SURFing to the Fundamental Limit of Jet Tagging
- 2505.01492-Photo- and Hadrodisintegration constraints on massive relics decaying into neutrinos
- 2505.20389-Dispersion relation of the neutrino plasma: Unifying fast, slow, and collisional instabilities
- 2511.10731-Keeping It Renormalizable: Minimal Baryogenesis induced Asymmetric Dark Matter
- 2404.04021-Vacuum correlations of the stress-energy-momentum tensor with constituent quarks
- 2503.02931-Relativistic Navier-Stokes description of the quark-gluon plasma radial flow
- 2606.06105-Bulk viscosity of a binary mixture: the role of the intra-species interaction
- 2607.03343-First look at the evaluation of two-loop Feynman integrals for radiative return processes