Flavor Tomography of Long-Lived Neutrino-Mass Mediators: Probing the Neutrino Mass Ordering at the HL-LHC

summary

The gist

The neutrino mass ordering remains unresolved because long-baseline oscillation measurements are entangled with the unknown CP phase δCP…

In short

The paper proposes using flavor tomography—counting displaced electrons and muons from long-lived particles—to determine neutrino mass ordering. It shows that a specific flavor ratio, Ne/Nµ, is independent of the unknown CP phase ($\delta$CP) and BSM parameters. A decision criterion based on this ratio allows for 3$\\sigma$ discrimination between Normal Hierarchy (NH) and Inverted Hierarchy (IH) using O(25) events at the HL-LHC.

Key concepts

Flavor Ratio Ne/Nµ
This is the ratio of observed electron to muon counts from time-delayed leptons. The theory predicts distinct values for NH (0.140) and IH (2.11). Crucially, this ratio is fixed by neutrino mixing angles and mass eigenvalues, making it a powerful tool for hierarchy discrimination.
Shared-Coupling Class
This refers to a specific theoretical scenario where the mediator causing Majorana neutrino masses shares the same coupling matrix as the one generating neutrino masses. Within this class, the flavor ratio Ne/Nµ is predicted to depend only on PMNS mixing angles and mass eigenvalues, not on other unknown BSM parameters.
Hierarchy Decision Criterion
The system uses a specific observable criterion: (Ne/Nµ)obs / rε (Normal Hierarchy, > 0.543 => Inverted Hierarchy). This criterion is robust against uncertainties like the CP phase and detector efficiency, allowing for a clear distinction between NH and IH when sufficient events are collected.
Robustness Against Uncertainties
The hierarchy discrimination is highly robust because the efficiency factor cancels out in the ratio of NH to IH predictions. Furthermore, for real Casas–Ibarra R matrices, the prediction remains independent of an unknown CP phase ($\delta$CP), meaning the result is stable even with uncertainties in oscillation parameters.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Flavor Tomography of Long-Lived Neutrino-Mass Mediators: Probing the Neutrino Mass Ordering at the HL-LHC · Read on arXiv

Renjie Wang

Institute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences

The neutrino mass ordering remains unresolved because long-baseline oscillation measurements are entangled with the unknown CP phase δ CP; a collider probe free of this degeneracy would provide a qualitatively different, complementary test. We show that when the long-lived charged particle producing a displaced-lepton signal at the High-Luminosity LHC is also the mediator responsible for Majorana neutrino masses---the shared-coupling condition---the Casas--Ibarra parametrization determines the lepton flavor ratio N e/N μ of time-delayed leptons in terms of Pontecorvo--Maki--Nakagawa--Sakata (PMNS) mixing parameters alone. Within the resulting shared-coupling class of models the ratio is fixed by oscillation data, independent of all beyond-Standard-Model mass and coupling parameters up to calculable corrections bounded by charged-lepton-flavor-violation data, yielding N e/N μ= 0.140 for the Normal and 2.11 for the Inverted Hierarchy---a separation of more than an order of magnitude between the two predictions. This prediction holds identically across the Scotogenic model, the Type-III seesaw, the inverse and linear seesaw, and lepton-portal dark matter, and is stable against oscillation-parameter uncertainties and detector-efficiency variations, which cancel in the ratio. A single efficiency-corrected decision criterion identifies the hierarchy, and explicit signal-yield estimates combined with an exact Poisson test show that O(25) displaced-lepton events suffice for a 3σ discrimination with the timing infrastructure already under construction at CMS and ATLAS---so that a positive long-lived-particle signal would simultaneously resolve the mass ordering, with no dependence on δ CP.

DOI: 10.1088/1674-1137/aea53f

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Flavor Tomography of Long-Lived Neutrino-Mass Mediators".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The neutrino mass ordering remains unresolved because long-baseline oscillation measurements are entangled with the unknown CP phase δCP; a collider probe free of this degeneracy would provide a qualitatively different, complementary test<ref:2609.04761#pg2> The flavor ratio Ne/Nµ of time-delayed leptons is fixed by oscillation data, independent of all beyond-Standard-Model mass and coupling parameters up to calculable corrections bounded by charged-lepton-flavor-violation data, yielding Ne/Nµ = 0.140 for the Normal and 2.11 for the Inverted Hierarchy—a separation of more than an order of magnitude between the two predictions<ref:2609.04761#pg4> A single efficiency-corrected decision criterion identifies the hierarchy, and explicit signal-yield estimates combined with an exact Poisson test show that O(25) displaced-lepton events suffice for a 3σ discrimination with the timing infrastructure already under construction at CMS and ATLAS—so that a positive long-lived-particle signal would simultaneously resolve the mass ordering, with no dependence on δCP <ref:2609.04761#pg7> The Universal Flavor Ratio Prediction The central hypothesis is that when the LLP is the mediator responsible for Majorana neutrino masses, the flavor ratio Ne/Nµ of time-delayed leptons is a δCP-independent hierarchy discriminant fixed entirely by Pontecorvo–Maki–Nakagawa–Sakata (PMNS) mixing angles and neutrino mass eigenvalues<ref:2609.04761#pg9> This prediction is derived within the shared-coupling class where the Yukawa matrix λaα governing the LLP decay is the same matrix that generates the Majorana neutrino mass matrix through a seesaw or radiative mechanism The proposition states that for any model in this class, the inclusive flavor ratio of LLP decays into electrons and muons is a function of PMNS matrix elements Uαi and neutrino mass eigenvalues mi alone, with no dependence on any BSM mass or coupling parameter Evaluating Eq.

Kai: (1) at the NuFit 6.1 best-fit oscillation parameters with mlightest = 0 gives Ne/Nµ theory = (0.140 (NH), 2.11 (IH)) Analytic Origin and Model Verification The analytic origin of the NH–IH separation is traced to two leading-order approximations to the exact result Eq.

Mira: (1) For Normal Hierarchy, with m1 ≈ 0 and m3/m2 ≈ 5.8, the ratio is suppressed by the smallness of reactor mixing: Ne/Nµ NH ≈ sin2θ13 cos squared θ13/2 = 2 tan squared θ13 ≈ 0.046 For Inverted Hierarchy, the ratio is approximated as Ne/Nµ IH ≈ 1 − sin 2θ13 cos squared θ13/2 ≈ 1.91 (θ23 = 45◦) The prediction is verified across four representative BSM models, including the Scotogenic model, Type-III seesaw, inverse and linear seesaw, and lepton-portal dark matter In the Scotogenic model, the total partial width into flavor α, summed inclusively over all Ni final states, reduces to Γ(˜η± → l±α + any Ni) ∝ P i yiα P squared ∝ i i Uαi squared m i Robustness Against Uncertainties Six potential sources of uncertainty leave the hierarchy discrimination intact, including the Dirac CP phase, oscillation-parameter uncertainties, and detector efficiencies For real Casas–Ibarra R

condition (iii): , δCP cancels exactly in Ne/Nµ A scan over 5 × 10 4 points uniformly over the NuFit 6.1 3σ ranges at mlightest = 0 yields NH: Ne/Nµ ∈

0.099, 0.181: and IH:

1.602, 2.490: The discrimination ratio is still as large as R = 8.85 (smaller than earlier estimates that used a single θ23 value for both hierarchies) Detector efficiency cancels identically in the NH–IH separation, meaning (Ne/Nµ)det IH/(Ne/Nµ) NH = R = 15.1 for any rε > 0 Experimental Discrimination at the HL-LHC The hierarchy decision criterion within the shared-coupling class is given by (Ne/Nµ)obs / rε (0.543 ⇒ Inverted Hierarchy) This criterion is valid for mlightest ≲ 15 meV, consistent with current cosmological constraints The signal yield estimates show that O(25) events provide 3σ discrimination in an ideal Poisson counting experiment A complementary binomial test and the Poisson test of Sec.

Kai: V C give ≥ 3σ at O(10) events, confirming that the result is robust to the choice of statistical framework Background considerations show that a flavor-asymmetric residual can only drive the measured ratio toward unity and dilute the discrimination The key structural observation is that the δCP–hierarchy degeneracy is absent in the flavortomography observable: Ne/Nµ depends on Uαi squared, not Uαi, so no value of δCP can shift the NH prediction (0.140) toward the IH prediction (2.

Title and authors: Kai: We’re diving into the paper today, "Flavor Tomography of Long-Lived Neutrino-Mass Mediators: Probing the Neutrino Mass Ordering at the HL-LHC." We want to get straight to what this means for us practically.

Mira: The main thing is that this flavor ratio measurement, which we call Ne over Nmu, becomes a way to distinguish between the Normal Hierarchy and the Inverted Hierarchy without needing any information about the unknown CP phase delta CP.

Lev: That's huge because usually, when you try to pin down mass ordering with oscillation data, you're stuck fighting that delta CP degeneracy. This paper says if we use this specific flavor ratio observable, it’s fixed by the mixing angles and the neutrino masses themselves.

Kai: So it means that if we can measure this ratio at the High-Luminosity LHC, say with twenty five events, we get three sigma discrimination in an ideal counting experiment.

Mira: Exactly what it means for us is that you don't need a perfectly known CP phase to know which way the neutrino mass ordering goes, provided you are in that specific shared-coupling class where this relationship holds.

Lev: The caveat there is the assumption about that coupling being tied to the neutrino mass matrix by that specific Casas–Ibarra identity. If we are outside of that model, this whole clean result might not hold up as well.

Kai: It's like if you try to build a machine out of superconducting qubits, and it only works perfectly if the coolant temperature is below two millikelvin, right? You have to be careful about the environment.

Mira: That's a good way to put it Kai. The result is very clean inside that specific model—it says the flavor ratio measurement itself is robust against many uncertainties, including detector efficiency variations > page two of that work reads: "The remainder of this Letter is organized as follows. Section II defines the shared-coupling class, derives the universal flavor-ratio prediction"

Lev: It's also robust against O one uncertainty in those efficiencies, which means if you have a slight inefficiency in your detector, the hierarchy discrimination doesn't completely break down > page two of that work reads: "Section IV establishes its robustness against the CP phase, oscillation-parameter uncertainties, the absolute neutrino mass scale"

Kai: So for someone who only listens to the show—what this means is that counting these displaced leptons could be a direct window into how light neutrinos are actually behaving when they decay > page two of that work reads: "The implication is that this measurement directly images the underlying neutrino mass spectrum because it's tied to those specific PMNS mixing angles and the neutrino mass eigenvalues themselves"

Mira: It’s an experimental path that bypasses the oscillation data tangle and gives us a new, independent way to settle the mass ordering question > page two of that work reads: "This work is important because it provides a direct experimental path—a collider probe free of this degeneracy"

Lev: We need to keep pushing on building the infrastructure at ATLAS and CMS so we can actually get those event counts up to twenty five for a real test > page two of that work reads: "The real test for us is building the detector infrastructure mentioned, because O(twenty-five) displaced-lepton events suffice for a 3σ discrimination"

The paper's summary: Kai: We've seen how counting those displaced leptons can actually image the neutrino mass spectrum directly in this paper, and now we're going to talk about what that summary means for us practically.

Kai: So it means that if we can measure this ratio at the High-Luminosity LHC, say with twenty five events, we get three sigma discrimination in an ideal counting experiment > page two of that work reads: "O(twenty-five) displaced-lepton events suffice for a 3σ discrimination with the timing infrastructure already under construction at CMS and ATLAS—so that a positive long-lived-particle signal would simultaneously resolve the mass ordering, with no dependence on δCP"

Mira: Exactly what it means for us is that you don't need a perfectly known CP phase to know which way the neutrino mass ordering goes, provided you are in that specific shared-coupling class where this relationship holds > page two of that work reads: "you don't need a perfectly known CP phase to know which way the neutrino mass ordering goes, provided you are in that specific shared-coupling class where this relationship holds"

Lev: The caveat there is the assumption about that coupling being tied to the neutrino mass matrix by that specific Casas–Ibarra identity. If we are outside of that model, this whole clean result might not hold up as well > page two of that work reads: "The paper notes that this universal prediction is only true within a specific shared-coupling class, and it relies on the Casas–Ibarra identity

three four twenty-one–twenty-three: "

Kai: It's like if you try to build a machine out of superconducting qubits, and it only works perfectly if the coolant temperature is below two millikelvin, right? You have to be careful about the environment > page two of that work reads: "It's like if you try to build a machine out of superconducting qubits, and it only works perfectly if the coolant temperature is below two millikelvin, right?"

Mira: That's a good way to put it Kai. The result is very clean inside that specific model—it says the flavor ratio measurement itself is robust against many uncertainties, including detector efficiency variations > page two of that work reads: "the result is very clean inside that specific model—it says the flavor ratio measurement itself is robust against many uncertainties, including those detector efficiency variations"

Lev: It's also robust against O one uncertainty in those efficiencies, which means if you have a slight inefficiency in your detector, the hierarchy discrimination doesn't completely break down > page two of that work reads: "It’s also robust against O one uncertainty in those efficiencies, which means if you have a slight inefficiency in your detector, the hierarchy discrimination doesn't completely break down"

Kai: So for someone who only listens to the show—what this means is that counting these displaced leptons could be a direct window into how light neutrinos are actually behaving when they decay > page two of that work reads: "counting these displaced leptons could be a direct window into how light neutrinos are actually behaving when they decay"

Mira: It’s an experimental path that bypasses the oscillation data tangle and gives us a new, independent way to settle the mass ordering question > page two of that work reads: "It’s an experimental path that bypasses the oscillation data tangle and gives us a new, independent way to settle the mass ordering question"

Lev: We need to keep pushing on building the infrastructure at ATLAS and CMS so we can actually get those event counts up to twenty five for a real test > page two of that work reads: "We need to keep pushing on building the infrastructure at ATLAS and CMS so we can actually get those event counts up to twenty five for a real test"

The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors suggest that one way to make this test even more robust is by looking at how it handles those systematic uncertainties, like detector efficiency variations.

Mira: They are pointing out that the observable itself has a built-in robustness against O one variations in those efficiencies because the efficiency factor cancels out exactly when you compare Normal Hierarchy to Inverted Hierarchy > page two of that work reads: "The remainder of this Letter is organized as follows. Section IV establishes its robustness against the CP phase, oscillation-parameter uncertainties, the absolute neutrino mass scale"

Lev: That means if your detector isn't perfectly efficient, the hierarchy discrimination doesn't completely break down, which is good for us when we think about real hardware running at high luminosity > page two of that work reads: "Section IV establishes its robustness against the CP phase, oscillation-parameter uncertainties, the absolute neutrino mass scale"

Kai: So it’s like if you try to build a machine out of superconducting qubits and it only works perfectly if the coolant temperature is below two millikelvin, you have to be careful about the environment > page two of that work reads: "It's like if you try to build a machine out of superconducting qubits, and it only works perfectly if the coolant temperature is below two millikelvin, right?"

Mira: That's right Kai. The result is very clean inside that specific model—it says the flavor ratio measurement itself is robust against many uncertainties, including those detector efficiency variations we just talked about > page two of that work reads: "The remainder of this Letter is organized as follows. Section IV establishes its robustness against the CP phase, oscillation-parameter uncertainties, the absolute neutrino mass scale"

Lev: It’s also robust against O one uncertainty in those efficiencies, which means if you have a slight inefficiency in your detector, the hierarchy discrimination doesn't completely break down > page two of that work reads: "Section IV establishes its robustness against the CP phase, oscillation-parameter uncertainties, the absolute neutrino mass scale"

Mira: It’s an experimental path that bypasses the oscillation data tangle and gives us a new, independent way to settle the mass ordering question > page two of that work reads: "This work is important because it provides a direct experimental path—a collider probe free of this

Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up on "Flavor Tomography of Long-Lived Neutrino-Mass Mediators: Probing the Neutrino Mass Ordering at the HL-LHC." The main point is that counting those displaced leptons could be a very direct way to image the neutrino mass spectrum.

Mira: Yeah, it boils down to this flavor ratio measurement Ne over Nmu becoming a way to distinguish between Normal and Inverted Hierarchy without needing any information about that unknown CP phase delta CP.

Lev: That's huge because usually when you try to pin down mass ordering with oscillation data, you're stuck fighting that delta CP degeneracy. This paper says if we use this specific flavor ratio observable, it’s fixed by the mixing angles and the neutrino masses themselves.

Kai: So it means that if we can measure this ratio at the High-Luminosity LHC, say with twenty five events, we get three sigma discrimination in an ideal counting experiment.

Mira: Exactly what that means for us is that you don't need a perfectly known CP phase to know which way the neutrino mass ordering goes, provided you are in that specific shared-coupling class where this relationship holds.

Lev: The caveat there is the assumption about that coupling being tied to the neutrino mass matrix by that specific Casas–Ibarra identity. If we are outside of that model, this whole clean result might not hold up as well.

Kai: It's like if you try to build a machine out of superconducting qubits and it only works perfectly if the coolant temperature is below two millikelvin, right? You have to be careful about the environment.

Mira: That's a good way to put it Kai. The result is very clean inside that specific model—it says the flavor ratio measurement itself is robust against many uncertainties, including detector efficiency variations.

Lev: It's also robust against O one uncertainty in those efficiencies, which means if you have a slight inefficiency in your detector, the hierarchy discrimination doesn't completely break down.

Kai: So for someone who only listens to the show—what this means is that counting these displaced leptons could be a direct window into how light neutrinos are actually behaving when they decay.

Mira: It’s an experimental path that bypasses the oscillation data tangle and gives us a new, independent way to settle the mass ordering question.

Lev: We need to keep pushing on building the infrastructure at ATLAS and CMS so we can actually get those event counts up to twenty five for a real test.

Kai: So we wrap up here with "Flavor Tomography of Long-Lived Neutrino-Mass Mediators: Probing the Neutrino Mass Ordering at the HL-LHC." It shows that counting displaced electrons and muons could be a very direct way to image the neutrino mass spectrum.

Mira: It’s a clean prediction based on oscillation data, which gives us those clear separation numbers between Normal and Inverted Hierarchy, provided we are in that shared-coupling class.

Lev: The real test for us is building the detector infrastructure mentioned, because O(twenty-five) events is what they need for that three sigma discrimination.

Kai: What this really changes for the world is that we have a new type of probe available to solve the mass ordering question independently of CP phase measurements.

Mira: It's a major step forward in using collider experiments to constrain neutrino physics, moving beyond just oscillation data analysis.

Lev: The paper sets up a clear goal: to see how this decision criterion holds up as we move toward higher luminosities at the High-Luminosity LHC.

Kai: Next time, we're looking at how inclusive production cross sections play a role in high-energy phenomenology and how that connects to things like jet tagging reliability.

Mira: We’ll talk about how those cross sections are used for precision tests of the Standard Model and where they fit into the broader picture.

More episodes

← Home