Evidence for Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton, gluon and quark at LHC

summary

The gist

Evidence for Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton, gluon and quark at LHC The paper presents an interpretation of CMS data suggesting that observed excesses in four jet final states could arise…

In short

CMS data showing excesses in four jet final states might be explained by Kaluza-Klein excitations of gravitons, gluons, and quarks from a Randall-Sundrum model. The authors propose specific decay chains for these heavy particles, suggesting a new framework for interpreting experimental anomalies and pointing toward future LHC discoveries.

Key concepts

Kaluza-Klein (KK) Excitations
In models with extra dimensions, fundamental particles like gravitons and quarks can have excited states. These excited states are called Kaluza-Klein excitations. They appear as heavier versions of the standard particles that can be produced at the LHC, providing a mechanism to explain unexpected high-energy events.
Randall-Sundrum Model
This is a specific theoretical framework in extra dimension physics. It proposes that gravity propagates in a higher-dimensional spacetime where our four dimensions are warped. This warping causes particles to have different masses and couplings, which influences how heavy KK particles decay and appear at the LHC.
Jet Final States
Jets are sprays of hadrons resulting from the decay of high-energy quarks or gluons. The paper focuses on specific 'four jet final states' observed by CMS. These particular patterns in the data are being interpreted as evidence for KK particle decays, such as heavy KK gluons decaying into pairs of lighter KK quarks.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Evidence for Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton, gluon and quark at LHC · Read on arXiv

Université Paris-Saclay · CNRS/IN2P3

Following our paper showing evidence for a sequence of Kaluza-Klein gravitons, we interpret the massive 4 jet excesses observed by CMS in RUN2 and RUN3 data. They could come from the decay of two heavy KK gluons gkk(3.6TeV) and gkk(8.6TeV) into pairs of KK quarks qkk(1TeV) and qkk(2.1TeV). Present limits on gkk into top pairs seem to exclude gkk(3.6TeV) but these limits assume a dominant decay into top pairs, which can be questioned as was the case in our study of KK graviton decays. The cross section predicted for gkk(8.6) requires a BR into a pair of qkk(2.1TeV) or order 10% which is not unlikely. Prospect for reaching a 6 s.d. level local evidence with RUN3 data are promising for 3 channels. KK excitations of the Z boson are also discussed and appear also promising.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Evidence for Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton, gluon and quark at LHC".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Evidence for Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton, gluon and quark at LHC The paper presents an interpretation of CMS data suggesting that observed excesses in four jet final states could arise from Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton, gluon, and quarks within a model closely related to Randall-Sundrum.

Kai: This finding is significant because it offers a new framework for interpreting experimental anomalies by linking them to extra dimensions and provides prospects for future discovery at the LHC Interpretation of Jet Excesses The authors interpret massive 4 jet excesses observed by CMS in RUN2 and RUN3 data as potentially originating from the decay of two heavy KK gluons gkk(3.6TeV) and gkk(8.6TeV) into pairs of KK quarks qkk(1TeV) and qkk(2.1TeV) They suggest that these excesses could also fit into a Kaluza Klein interpretation involving a KK gluon decaying into a pair of KK quarks Specifically, they propose the process gKK(8600)→qKK(2100)qKK(2100) with a decay of the gluons into two jets This process is noted as being forbidden by Yang’s theorem for gg→ gKK Alternatively, they consider the possibility of gKK(8600)→qKK(2100)qKK(2100) with qKK decaying into two jets Constraints and Model Comparison The interpretation is closely tied to the Randall Sundrum model, noting that the KK graviton resonances have been found in WW/ZZ/hh modes The authors discuss how the decay into a pair of lighter KK gravitons GKKi→GKKjGKKj with GKKj→ WW/ZZ/hh can lead to four jet topologies for hadronic decays of W/Z/h They also address the exclusion of gkk(3.6TeV) based on limits, noting that these limits assume a dominant decay into top pairs, which they question as was the case in their study of KK graviton decays Search Strategies and Predictions The search for the sequence of KK graviton resonances involves looking at predicted VBF differential cross section for KK gravitons→hh The mass spectrum of the KK graviton resonances agrees with the predictions of the Randall Sundrum model as recalled in section I They predict a sequence of masses proportional to 2.45, 5.57, 8.7, 11.84 for KK vectors

5: Furthermore, they predict that the third KK quark is predicted at 3.1 TeV Future Discovery Prospects The prospect for reaching a 6 s.d.

Mira: level local evidence with RUN3 data are promising for 3 channels The most significant indication claimed by CMS, 3.6 s.d.

Kai: local, is seen in a non resonant mode X+X with X→JJ Adding RUN3 data should allow to push the significance of the 4 jet events to more than 6 s.d The evidence for ZKK(3TeV)→VV is weaker and needs to be confirmed with RUN3 data The authors conclude that they have provided a plausible explanation for various excesses observed by CMS in four jet final states They state that the present local significance for the four evidences, 8.6 TeV and 3.6 TeV for KK gluons, 2.1 TeV and 1 TeV for KK quarks, come close to a local 4 s.d.

Title and authors: Kai: So, focusing on the title and authors of "Evidence for Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton, gluon and quark at LHC", it immediately tells us this paper is about finding evidence for these new particle states across different fundamental particles.

Mira: The authors are Le Yaouanc and Richard from Université Paris-Saclay, and their work directly addresses how Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton, gluon, and quark could show up at the LHC.

Lev: That implies they’re looking for signatures related to these higher-dimensional excitations of gravity and matter interactions that we haven't seen before.

Kai: It suggests they are trying to find a consistent picture where these new particles—the KK excitations—could explain the observed data, which is always a big challenge in high energy physics.

Mira: They are essentially proposing an interpretation for the massive four jet excesses by linking them to this Kaluza-Klein framework.

The paper's summary: Kai: The paper summarizes their interpretation of the massive four jet excesses observed by CMS in RUN2 and RUN3 data, suggesting they could originate from the decay of two heavy KK gluons, gkk(3.6TeV) and gkk(8.6TeV), into pairs of KK quarks, qkk(1TeV) and qkk(2.1TeV) <ref:2610.31458#pg1,from the decay of two heavy KK gluons, gkk(3.6TeV) and>.

Mira: They also propose a different possibility where a single heavy KK gluon, specifically gKK(eight thousand six hundred), decays into a pair of lighter KK quarks, qKK(two thousand one hundred) and qKK(two thousand one hundred), which they suggest could produce those four jets.

Lev: If that decay process is what they’re proposing, it means we need to look at the dynamics of how these massive particles couple together, which has huge implications for the effective field theory we use to describe them.

Kai: The paper also mentions that this specific decay process is noted as being forbidden by Yang’s theorem for gg→ gKK, which is a key technical point in their argument about why this interpretation is necessary.

Mira: They are tying it back to the Randall-Sundrum model because they've already seen KK graviton resonances in WW, ZZ, and hh modes within that framework.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper points out a few ways they think this interpretation could improve our understanding of the existing constraints, for example by questioning the exclusion of gkk(3.6TeV) based on LHC searches <ref:2610.31458#pg1>.

Mira: They question that exclusion because those searches assume KK gluons decay dominantly into top pairs, but their study on KK graviton decays suggests that might not be true in this context.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if the decay is instead into lighter KK quarks as they suggest, it changes the expected final state and the kinematics we'd need to simulate to match what we see.

Kai: They also discuss how the decay of a heavier KK graviton into a pair of lighter KK gravitons can lead to four jet topologies for hadronic decays of W, Z, or H bosons.

Mira: They also look at predictions for VBF differential cross section for KK gravitons decaying into hh, and they predict a sequence of masses proportional to two point four five, five point five seven, eight point seven, and eleven point eight four for KK vectors in the Randall-Sundrum model recall section I.

Conclusion: Kai: To wrap up this paper on "Evidence for Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton, gluon and quark at LHC", they conclude that their interpretation provides a plausible explanation for various excesses observed by CMS in four jet final states.

Mira: They state that the local significance for the four evidences, specifically eight point six TeV and three point six TeV for KK gluons, and two point one TeV and one TeV for KK quarks, come close to a local four s-d significance based on their analysis of RUN2 data <ref:2610.31458#pg1>.

Lev: The paper flags that the evidence for the ZKK(3TeV)→VV decay is weaker and needs confirmation with RUN3 data, which is a fair limitation they've acknowledged about the current status of this search <ref:2610.31458#pg1>.

Kai: They predict that we could also observe a gKK(eight point six) decaying into qKK(three point one) plus qKK(three point one), which they claim would be a spectacular final state that is background free, which would be a crucial confirmation of the model <ref:2610.31458#pg1>.

Mira: So, the implication is that if this prediction holds up, it offers a really clear path to confirming this specific Kaluza-Klein interpretation of the data.

Lev: For real hardware running these simulations, seeing something background free like that would require extremely precise detector capabilities to distinguish it from any standard SM background we might not be modeling perfectly.

Kai: So we’ve looked at how this paper interprets the data, what the specific numbers are, and what they think should happen next with RUN3 data for this evidence for Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton, gluon and quark at LHC.

More episodes

← Home