DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos

summary

The gist

The study focuses on providing precise theoretical predictions for kinematic distributions of charged leptons produced in neutrino-induced charged-current (CC) deep inelastic scattering (DIS)…

In short

The study provides precise theoretical predictions for charged lepton kinematics in neutrino-induced deep inelastic scattering (DIS), crucial for experiments like GRAND and IceCube-Gen2. By including NLO QCD and electroweak corrections, the authors compare fixed-order calculations with parton shower models, revealing that these corrections become significant above 104 GeV due to photon radiation and coherent W-boson production.

Key concepts

NLO QCD+EW
This refers to Next-to-Leading Order Quantum Chromodynamics combined with electroweak corrections. This advanced calculation precisely accounts for the strong force interactions (QCD) and the effects of the weak nuclear force (electroweak) at a high level of accuracy, which is necessary for accurate predictions in high-energy neutrino physics.
Collinear Photon Radiation
This describes radiation where a high-energy lepton emits a nearly parallel photon. The corrections arising from this effect are crucial because they can reach 10% or more and significantly alter the predicted kinematic distributions of the resulting charged leptons, especially at very high neutrino energies.
NLO+PS POWHEG-BOX
This is a specific event generator model that combines Next-to-Leading Order (NLO) calculations with parton showering (PS). The study compares its results against the full fixed-order calculation to see how well the shower handles complex radiation effects, helping researchers choose the best tool for experimental analysis.
Hidden Glashow Resonance
This is a specific high-energy phenomenon involving W-boson production in DIS. The authors investigate how this resonance affects lepton flavor distributions and corrections, noting that electron channel effects are enhanced due to the lepton's mass logarithms.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos · Read on arXiv

Max Planck Institute for Physics · Technische Universität München · Nikhef, Theory Group, Science Park 105

We revisit the impact of electroweak (EW) radiative corrections on the kinematic distributions of charged leptons in neutrino-induced charged-current (CC) deep inelastic scattering (DIS). These corrections are particularly relevant for observables sensitive to collinear photon radiation, such as the energy spectrum of high-energy muons detected in neutrino telescopes. To study these effects, we implement full next-to-leading order (NLO) EW corrections to CC DIS in a flexible Monte Carlo framework, supplemented with higher-order logarithmically enhanced final-state QED radiation and coherent scattering contributions. We compare our results to exclusive NLO QCD plus parton shower (PS) predictions obtained with an existing POWHEG-BOX event generator, examining different PS models and settings. Based on this comparison, we provide recommendations for the use of the POWHEG-BOX event generator in experimental analyses. We further assess the impact of radiative corrections on the correlation between the observed muon energy and the incoming neutrino energy, and on the mean inelasticity averaged over a realistic neutrino flux. These corrections can exceed 10%, and above about 10 4, GeV they receive sizeable contributions from photon-initiated and coherent W-boson production, which are not included in the event generator.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The study focuses on providing precise theoretical predictions for kinematic distributions of charged leptons produced in neutrino-induced charged-current (CC) deep inelastic scattering (DIS), which is crucial for upcoming high-energy neutrino experiments like GRAND and IceCube-Gen2.

Kai: Achieving percent-level theoretical uncertainties necessitates the inclusion of electroweak (EW) corrections, particularly those arising from collinear photon radiation off high-energy leptons, which are enhanced by terms of the form alpha/pi (E/m) and can reach 10% or more.

Mira: The authors implemented a fully differential calculation incorporating both NLO QCD and EW corrections within a dedicated fixed-order Monte Carlo framework.

Kai: This framework is supplemented with higher-order, logarithmically enhanced QED effects through lepton fragmentation functions (FFs) to control terms up to O(alpha squared (mu h/m)).

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now called "DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos." It tackles how to get really precise predictions for what charged leptons look like when they are produced in deep inelastic scattering from neutrino interactions.

Mira: Right, it focuses on those kinematic distributions, and it's crucial because we need that precision for upcoming experiments like GRAND and IceCube-Gen2. It’s about making sure our theory matches what the detectors will actually see at high energy.

Lev: From my side, the core challenge here is getting the math right when you push into those higher orders, especially when you start including those electroweak corrections that involve collinear photon radiation off the leptons.

Kai: Exactly. The authors are pushing for percent-level theoretical uncertainties here, and they say these corrections can be as large as ten percent or more because of terms like alpha over pi times a natural logarithm of the lepton energy over its mass.

Mira: And to handle those logarithmic enhancements, they’re not just doing fixed order math; they’re supplementing it with higher-order QED effects through lepton fragmentation functions up to the order alpha squared times a logarithm involving the hadronic scale and the lepton mass.

Lev: That sounds computationally heavy, but necessary if you want to control those terms up to that alpha squared level when factoring them into the leading order QCD partonic cross sections.

Kai: Plus, they aren't stopping at just the hard scattering; they are incorporating QED contributions from coherent and diffractive nuclear scattering, which includes on-shell W boson production and its subsequent decay.

Mira: That coherence aspect is important because it adds physics that you wouldn't get from a simple parton level calculation, like the hidden Glashow process around one hundred five giga-electron volts <ref:2611.08221#pg1>.

Lev: So what they are doing is comparing this full fixed-order NLO QCD plus EW calculation against an NLO plus parton shower prediction, which is a common way to check if the shower model captures everything correctly.

Kai: And the comparison shows that while the dipole shower handles most of the final state radiation effects, those higher energy phenomena around one hundred five giga-electron volts become more relevant when you look at both fixed order and NLO plus parton shower results <ref:2611.08221#pg1>.

Mira: Interestingly, they find that when you combine their specific NLO QCD plus parton shower calculation with the Pythia eight point three dipole shower, it successfully captures the dominant features of the full fixed order NLO QCD plus EW prediction up to neutrino energies around one hundred four giga-electron volts <ref:2611.08221#pg1,NLO QCD plus parton shower>.

Lev: But then they note that at even higher energies, around one hundred five giga-electron volts, both the fixed order and parton shower predictions agree at a percent level up to about one hundred six giga-electron volts <ref:2611.08221#pg1>.

Title and authors: Kai: That’s where things get tricky because they say the NLO plus parton shower predictions start underestimating that effect at even higher energies, where W boson production in deep inelastic scattering and coherent scattering become phenomenologically relevant.

Mira: They also point out specific kinematic results, showing that electroweak corrections to the mean inelasticity, which is about y, for muon neutrino charged current deep inelastic scattering reach a fifteen percent level at ultra-high energies.

Lev: That fifteen percent level is driven by those collinear photon final state radiation effects and the photon-induced contributions, with relevance starting around energies of one hundred four giga-electron volts or higher <ref:2611.08221#pg1>.

Kai: They also look at flavour dependent NLO EW effects related to that hidden Glashow resonance, noting that corrections are enhanced in the electron channel because of those more pronounced lepton mass logarithms.

Mira: The fixed-order framework is good here because it lets them treat EW and quark mass effects exactly at NLO accuracy, including those contributions from coherent scattering processes.

Lev: So what they show is that the QED final state radiation corrections are positive or negative depending on whether you look at large or small values of inelasticity, and their relative impact grows with the neutrino energy.

Kai: And for the resonant W boson production subprocess, they find a positive correction for energies above one hundred four giga-electron volts, especially pronounced at large inelasticities <ref:2611.08221#pg1>.

Mira: Overall, this calculation gives them a state-of-the-art prediction for double differential distributions and it’s applicable directly to experimental analyses.

Lev: They conclude that EW corrections to the flux averaged mean inelasticity, about y bar, stay below about three percent for neutrino energies under one hundred four giga-electron volts, but they can reach up to twenty percent at one hundred nine giga-electron volts <ref:2611.08221#pg1>.

Kai: That twenty percent value is higher than the QCD theoretical uncertainties at that energy level, although they admit that the current experimental uncertainties limit how much we can actually test this part of it right now.

Mira: So, looking at the full picture from "DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos," it seems like this work gives us a very detailed map of where these corrections become important and how big they get as energy increases.

Lev: For my perspective, this paper is really pushing the modeling boundary by including those coherent scattering effects that other generators might miss when you’re pushing to the high-energy frontier.

Kai: It's a very detailed tool for experimentalists, giving them a solid benchmark against which to test their detector performance and flux models.

Mira: The paper sets a very clear timeline for what physics we need to focus on in future experiments when they push toward those ultra-high energies approaching the zeve scale.

Lev: We’re looking forward to seeing how these NLO QCD plus EW comparisons evolve as the experimental data gets stronger at higher energies.

The paper's summary: Kai: So this paper, "DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos," basically lays out how they got these really tight predictions for what charged leptons look like when they come from neutrino interactions in deep inelastic scattering.

Mira: It’s all about those kinematic distributions, you know, figuring out exactly what the energy spectrum of a muon will be at a detector based on the incoming neutrino's energy.

Kai: Exactly. They’re pushing for percent-level accuracy here because those upcoming experiments like GRAND and IceCube-Gen2 need that kind of precision to really make sense of the data they collect.

Mira: The main hurdle they tackle is those electroweak corrections, specifically the effects from photons radiating off the high energy leptons. They show how these can be as big as ten percent or more because of certain logarithmic terms, like alpha over pi times a natural logarithm involving the lepton energy and its mass.

Kai: And to handle that math, they didn't just stick to fixed order. They used something called lepton fragmentation functions up to the second power of alpha times a logarithm involving the hadronic scale and the lepton mass, which helps control those higher-order effects.

Mira: Plus, they aren't ignoring other physics. They’ve included QED contributions from coherent and diffractive nuclear scattering, which is where you get things like on-shell W boson production and its decay. That adds another layer of complexity to the calculation.

Kai: The paper then does a crucial comparison between their fixed order NLO QCD plus electroweak results and predictions from an NLO plus parton shower event generator, called POWHEG-BOX.

Mira: And what they found is that while the dipole shower captures most of the final state radiation effects, those higher energy things, like resonant hidden Glashow contributions around one hundred five giga-electron volts, start to matter when you look at both methods together.

Kai: They showed that combining their specific NLO QCD plus parton shower calculation with the Pythia eight point three dipole shower successfully captures the main features of the full fixed order prediction up to neutrino energies around one hundred four giga-electron volts.

Mira: But they also found that at even higher energies, around one hundred five giga-electron volts, both methods agree at a percent level up to about one hundred six giga-electron volts. That’s where things get interesting because the parton shower predictions start underestimating those effects when you go even higher.

Kai: They found that for the mean inelasticity, which is that value y bar, the electroweak corrections can reach fifteen percent at ultra-high energies, driven by those collinear photon final state radiation and other photon-induced contributions.

Mira: This relevance starts appearing around neutrino energies of one hundred four giga-electron volts or higher. They also looked at flavor dependent NLO electroweak effects linked to that hidden Glashow resonance, seeing stronger corrections in the electron channel because of those lepton mass logarithms.

Kai: The fixed order method is good for this because it lets them treat the electroweak and quark mass effects exactly at NLO accuracy, including those coherent scattering parts.

Mira: They showed that the QED final state radiation corrections are positive or negative depending on whether you look at large or small values of inelasticity, and their effect gets bigger as the neutrino energy increases.

Kai: For the resonant W boson production subprocess, they found a positive correction for energies above one hundred four giga-electron volts, which is especially noticeable at large inelasticities.

Mira: Overall, this calculation gives them a very precise prediction for double differential distributions and it’s something experimentalists can actually use right now.

Kai: They conclude that the corrections to the flux averaged mean inelasticity stay under about three percent for neutrino energies below one hundred four giga-electron volts, but they can jump up to twenty percent at one hundred nine giga-electron volts.

Mira: That twenty percent value is higher than the QCD theoretical uncertainties at that energy level, though they admit that current experimental uncertainties limit how much we can actually test this part right now.

Kai: So the paper gives a really detailed picture of where these corrections become important and how big they get as you push toward those ultra-high energies.

Mira: It’s a very specific tool for experimentalists to benchmark their detector performance against, especially when they look at realistic astrophysical neutrino fluxes.

Kai: This work sets a clear timeline for what physics we need to focus on in future experiments when we push toward those zeve scale energies.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So we’re looking at what this paper suggests for making these predictions even better by adding more physics to the model.

Kai: They suggest incorporating those lepton fragmentation functions up to a second power of alpha, including both leading and subleading lepton mass logarithms. That’s way more detail on how the radiation affects the particle itself.

Mira: Right, because that allows for a much more accurate description of how those corrections are applied when you factor them into the leading order QCD partonic cross sections. It means better handling of those QED effects.

Kai: And they also propose a more robust way to benchmark parton shower algorithms against fixed order results by comparing the inelasticity distribution across different neutrino energies, including the inclusion of coherent scattering contributions in the generator.

Mira: That lets you directly assess which shower algorithms are best at reproducing those log enhanced QED radiation effects, like the stuff from that hidden Glashow resonance we talked about earlier.

Kai: They also advocate for using a fixed order framework that treats electroweak and quark mass effects exactly at NLO accuracy, including contributions from coherent scattering processes.

Mira: That’s important because it sets the standard for what should be included in the final simulation, giving experimentalists a better target to compare against.

Kai: The main implication is that they are pushing for a state-of-the-art prediction for double differential distributions that can be directly applied to experimental analyses and even simulations involving realistic astrophysical neutrino fluxes.

Mira: So it’s moving the goalpost on what we expect from these high energy experiments, showing exactly where the next big theoretical challenges lie.

Kai: It really shows how crucial it is to have this level of detail when you’re dealing with particle physics at those extreme scales.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper, "DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos," shows how they’ve built a really solid framework for getting those high precision predictions for neutrino interactions.

Mira: Basically, it confirms that when you push the math to include those higher order electroweak effects and fragmentation functions, you get these detailed results for kinematic distributions that are very useful.

Kai: It gives experimentalists a roadmap for what they should expect to see at those upcoming high energy experiments like GRAND and IceCube-Gen2.

Lev: From my side, the main thing this work does is show how heavy the computational overhead gets when you try to run these full NLO QCD plus electroweak calculations on actual hardware.

Mira: The implication is that for any future neutrino experiment aiming for percent level precision, they need to include these kinds of complex QED and EW corrections in their simulation pipeline.

Kai: It’s a huge step forward because it moves us past just the leading order and gives us something we can actually test against real detector data.

Lev: And I think this detailed comparison between fixed order and parton showers is really valuable for figuring out which simulation tools are actually good enough to use for the actual event reconstruction.

Mira: Exactly, because it shows exactly where those approximations in the shower model start to break down at higher energies, like around one hundred five giga-electron volts.

Kai: It’s a very useful tool for anyone trying to design a detector that can actually measure these subtle effects we're predicting.

Lev: The final word is that this paper lays down the groundwork for what high precision neutrino physics looks like when you start looking at those ultra-high energy regimes.

More episodes

← Home