Dimension-8 SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory

summary

The gist

Dimension-8 SMEFT matching conditions for the low-energy effective field theory are presented to determine how low-energy measurements depend on underlying new physics The momentumindependent…

In short

This work computes momentum-independent matching conditions for low-energy operators (LEFT) up to dimension 8 when matched to Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT). The analysis determines how low-energy measurements depend on underlying new physics by calculating direct and indirect contributions from both dimension 6 and dimension 8 SMEFT operators, providing a complete framework for precision tests.

Key concepts

LEFT Operators
These are the low-energy effective field theory operators describing physics below the W mass. They arise when heavy Standard Model particles are integrated out. The paper focuses on matching these to higher-dimensional SMEFT operators to understand how new physics influences observable quantities.
SMEFT Operators
These are the operators forming the low-energy effective field theory, organized by their dimensionality (up to dimension 8). They describe potential deviations from the Standard Model and are characterized by Wilson coefficients that quantify the strength of these new effects.
Momentum-Independent (MI) Matching Conditions
These conditions relate LEFT operators to SMEFT operators without considering momentum dependence. This simplification allows for a more direct comparison between low-energy observables and high-energy new physics, focusing on the scale of new physics rather than specific kinematic details.
Direct and Indirect Contributions
Matching conditions are analyzed by separating contributions into direct terms (from tree-level SMEFT operators) and indirect terms (arising from boson exchange, like Z-exchange). This separation helps isolate how different parts of the new physics manifest in the low-energy theory.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Dimension-8 SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory · Read on arXiv

Physique des Particules, Université de Montréal · Institute for Advanced Study, Technical University Munich

In particle physics, the modern view is to categorize things in terms of effective field theories (EFTs). Above the weak scale, we have the SMEFT, formed when the heavy new physics (NP) is integrated out, and for which the Standard Model (SM) is the leading part. Below M W, we have the LEFT (low-energy EFT), formed when the heavy SM particles (W plus or minus, Z 0, H, t) are also integrated out. In order to determine how low-energy measurements depend on the underlying NP, it is necessary to compute the matching conditions of LEFT operators to SMEFT operators. These matching conditions have been worked out for all LEFT operators up to dimension 6 in terms of SMEFT operators up to dimension 6 at the one-loop level. However, this is not sufficient for all low-energy observables. In this paper we present the momentum-independent matching conditions of all such LEFT operators to SMEFT operators up to dimension 8 at tree level.

DOI: 10.1007/JHEP03(2023)157

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Dimension-8 SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory".

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at the paper "Dimension-eight SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory" <ref:2207.08856#pg1,Dimension-8 SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory>. It's by Serge Hamoudou, Jacky Kumar, and David London. They are digging into how low-energy measurements depend on new physics by matching operators in the LEFT EFT to SMEFT operators up to dimension eight <ref:2207.08856#pg1,how low-energy measurements depend on>.

Mira: That sounds heavy. Basically, they are figuring out how those things we measure down here in the low energy world connect to the high scale new physics we're integrating out. It's about finding those connections through matching conditions.

Lev: It’s about connecting the low energy theory, which is what you see right now, to the SMEFT operators that come from heavy particles being integrated out above the electroweak scale.

Kai: Right, and they specifically look at operators up to dimension eight <ref:2207.08856#pg1>. They've already done this for dimension six at one loop, but they feel that's not enough for everything we need to know about low energy observables <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Mira: Exactly. The paper points out that dimension six matching isn't sufficient because you need those higher order terms, the dimension eight operators, to get a complete picture of how the new physics shows up in things like electroweak precision data <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Lev: And they address a few different types of contributions when they do this: direct, indirect, and momentum-dependent ones. They focus specifically on the momentum-independent ones for this work.

Kai: So, what does that mean practically? It means they're trying to find a way to calculate those connections without getting bogged down in all the complicated momentum dependence right away.

Mira: The paper claims that for all four-fermion LEFT operators, they have determined these momentum-independent matching conditions up to dimension eight within SMEFT <ref:2207.08856#pg1>. They used techniques for computing both direct and indirect contributions to get there.

Lev: That's a significant step because it gives us a solid foundation for understanding how those dimension eight SMEFT operators affect the low energy physics we observe, without having to deal with the full momentum dependence yet <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Kai: It sounds like they’ve covered a lot of ground by matching these conditions up to dimension eight for all four-fermion LEFT operators <ref:2207.08856#pg1>. It's a lot of work, especially when you have those complex expressions involving Wilson coefficients and physical parameters like g over gZ.

Title and authors: Mira: Those expressions are dense, but the authors show how they agree with previous analyses of matching conditions to dimension-eight SMEFT operators already <ref:2207.08856#pg1>. They also examine how these dimension-eight SMEFT operators contribute to the Standard Model parameters themselves <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Lev: That part about looking at the contributions of those dimension eight operators back onto the SM parameters is important for checking consistency, especially when you're thinking about things like electroweak precision data from LEP and lepton flavor violating processes <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Kai: So, if we boil it down, they've worked out how these low energy measurements depend on the underlying new physics by computing the momentum-independent matching conditions to SMEFT operators up to dimension eight for all four-fermion LEFT operators <ref:2207.08856#pg1,low energy measurements depend on the underlying>.

Mira: And what they're suggesting is that this level of calculation is necessary because dimension six matching isn't enough for all low energy observables <ref:2207.08856#pg1,for all low energy observables>. They’ve shown how those dimension eight terms matter <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Lev: That means we need these calculations to accurately predict electroweak precision data and processes like lepton flavor violating ones, which often involve those subdominant dimension eight operators that might otherwise be ignored <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Kai: So, the main thing here is providing a complete set of matching conditions for these low energy operators up to dimension eight without getting completely lost in the momentum dependence right now <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Mira: And they've done this by combining direct and indirect contributions, which is a clever way to tackle that. It shows how we can systematically approach this problem.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, having these calculated conditions helps us figure out where the overhead really lands when we try to run this on real hardware, because you know what kind of effects you are trying to model.

Kai: So the result is that they've worked out these momentum-independent matching conditions for all four-fermion LEFT operators up to dimension eight <ref:2207.08856#pg1,LEFT operators up to dimension>. It’s a big piece of the puzzle for understanding how new physics affects our low energy world.

Mira: And they’ve confirmed their results align with what other people have found when they look at matching conditions to dimension-seven SMEFT operators, which gives us some confidence in the method <ref:2207.08856#pg3>.

Title and authors: Lev: That agreement with dimension seven results is a good sign, because it suggests the general approach for computing these contributions is sound <ref:2207.08856#pg3>.

Kai: So, we're looking at how this work impacts our understanding of physics below the electroweak scale by providing these detailed matching conditions up to dimension eight for the LEFT operators <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Mira: And what it implies is that we need to include those higher order terms in our calculations if we want to have a full picture of low energy observables and their dependence on new physics.

Lev: It sets the groundwork for how we can predict electroweak precision data more accurately by accounting for these subdominant dimension eight operators, which is crucial when you're looking at LEP data <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Kai: And they also touch on how these things affect B physics and lepton number violating processes, specifically by looking at those odd-dimensional SMEFT operators like the dimension five operator <ref:2207.08856#pg2>.

Mira: That’s an interesting point because extending the analysis to include those dimension five operators would give us even more predictive power beyond what we can get from just dimension six SMEFT.

Lev: If we could correctly calculate matching conditions involving those odd-dimensional SMEFT operators, it would extend our predictive power in B physics and lepton number violating processes significantly.

Kai: So, the authors have worked out these momentum-independent matching conditions for all four-fermion LEFT operators up to dimension eight and pointed out that this is a necessary step for getting a complete picture <ref:2207.08856#pg1,LEFT operators up to dimension>.

Mira: And they’ve provided detailed expressions in Appendix D showing exactly how these matching conditions look, including terms like those involving g over gZ squared and MZ squared multiplied by some effective couplings.

Lev: Those detailed expressions are what we need to see when we try to run this on real hardware, because you have to know the exact structure of the correction you are trying to model.

Kai: So, if you're looking at how this paper changes things for someone who only listens to the show, it means that understanding low energy physics requires accounting for these dimension eight SMEFT effects through these matching conditions <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Title and authors: Mira: And they've set a solid benchmark by confirming their results agree with previous analyses of dimension-eight SMEFT operators, which is important validation for the method used <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Lev: That validation helps us know that the techniques used to compute direct and indirect contributions are robust enough to handle these higher order terms correctly.

Kai: So, it’s a comprehensive study on the matching conditions for Dimension-eight SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory <ref:2207.08856#pg1,Dimension-8 SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory>. It gives us the tools to connect low energy measurements down to dimension eight in SMEFT <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Mira: And they've laid out a clear path forward by showing what needs to be done next, especially concerning those momentum-dependent contributions that they focused on only partially.

Lev: That momentum-dependent part is where the real challenge for experimentalists and theorists lies, figuring out when you can safely ignore it or when it becomes numerically important depending on the scale you're looking at.

Kai: So, to wrap up this discussion, we have looked at how this paper tackles the matching conditions for the low energy effective field theory by calculating the momentum-independent matching conditions to SMEFT operators up to dimension eight <ref:2207.08856#pg1,matching conditions for the low energy effective field theory>.

Mira: And they’ve shown that this calculation is necessary because dimension six matching isn't sufficient for all low energy observables, and they've confirmed that their results align with previous analyses of dimension-eight SMEFT operators <ref:2207.08856#pg1,sufficient for all low energy observables>.

Lev: And the implication is that we need these detailed calculations to accurately predict electroweak precision data and lepton flavor violating processes by accounting for those subdominant dimension eight operators <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Kai: So, the paper "Dimension-eight SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory" gives us a complete set of momentum-independent matching conditions up to dimension eight for all four-fermion LEFT operators <ref:2207.08856#pg1,Dimension-8 SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory>.

Mira: And they've laid out that this is a necessary step because dimension six matching isn't enough, and they’ve shown how these dimension eight terms matter for low energy observables <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

Lev: And the implication is that we need these detailed calculations to predict electroweak precision data and lepton flavor violating processes by accounting for those subdominant dimension eight operators <ref:2207.08856#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, this paper boils down to them figuring out exactly how the low energy world connects to whatever new physics is happening at a higher scale, specifically up to dimension eight operators in SMEFT.

Mira: Right, so they’ve done this matching for all four-fermion operators using both direct and indirect contributions and focused on the momentum independent ones. It’s like they’re building a map between the high energy stuff and what we can actually measure here.

Lev: From an engineering side, that means they are defining the structure of the correction terms so you know exactly what kind of effects to model when you run this on real hardware, not just some abstract number.

Kai: They’re showing that these momentum independent matching conditions agree with previous work on dimension seven operators, which gives them a solid check on their method. It makes us trust the approach for dimension eight as well.

Mira: But they really push it by showing how these dimension eight SMEFT operators actually contribute to the Standard Model parameters themselves. That’s important because we want to see if these higher order terms mess with things we already think are stable in the SM.

Lev: And they also look at how those dimension eight operators affect B physics and lepton number violating processes, specifically mentioning the dimension five operator too. That’s extending the predictive power beyond just looking at dimension six stuff.

Kai: So, what this means for us is that if we want to accurately predict electroweak precision data or lepton flavor violating processes, we absolutely have to include these dimension eight effects in our calculations. It’s not optional anymore when you go up to that order.

Mira: Exactly. The naive question would be how much does this change our predictions? The answer is they’ve calculated the specific structure of that change, so you can quantify the uncertainty better than before.

Lev: On a hardware side, it means we can start designing experiments with a clearer idea of the systematic errors coming from these higher order terms. It tells us where to focus our efforts for better control over those effects.

Kai: So they’ve laid out this complete set of momentum independent matching conditions up to dimension eight for all four-fermion operators, setting a benchmark that shows how new physics impacts low energy observables at this level of detail.

Mira: And the next challenge is that they focused on the momentum independent parts; now we need to figure out how those momentum dependent contributions scale and when we can safely ignore them. That’s where the real work for experimentalists will be.

Lev: Yeah, figuring out that scaling is crucial for deciding if you need to include that extra complexity in your simulations or if you can just treat it as noise at a certain energy scale.

Kai: So, this paper gives us the tools to connect low energy measurements down to dimension eight in SMEFT, and the next step is dealing with those momentum dependent terms.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, we’re talking about how they suggest improving this matching work for dimension eight operators in SMEFT to get a more complete picture of low energy physics.

Mira: They point out that the current focus on momentum independent terms isn't enough because we need to properly account for those momentum dependent contributions too. It’s about understanding when you can safely ignore those effects versus when they become numerically important depending on the scale you're looking at.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, if we don’t know how that momentum dependence scales, it means our simulations for real hardware will have a bigger uncertainty budget than we think. It makes predicting those subdominant effects much harder to manage.

Kai: They suggest that by analyzing the scaling of different operators, we can see exactly when those momentum dependent contributions are negligible and when they start becoming comparable to the leading terms. That’s a practical way for us to design better experiments or simulations.

Mira: They also mention how including those dimension five operators—the odd dimensional ones—can give us even more predictive power in B physics and lepton number violating processes than just focusing on the dimension six stuff. That expands our reach significantly beyond what we can get from standard dimension six SMEFT analyses.

Lev: If you can correctly calculate matching conditions involving those dimension five operators, it’s a big deal for testing models that predict those specific decay modes. It means you aren't just looking at the leading corrections anymore.

Kai: They also touch on how these things affect the Standard Model parameters themselves, which helps us check if these higher order terms are actually consistent with what we know about our basic particles. That’s a good consistency check for any new physics model.

Mira: So, the improvement here is moving from just finding the leading structure to understanding the full hierarchy of contributions, including both momentum dependent and odd dimensional operators. It makes the low energy effective field theory much more robust.

Lev: Robustness is key when you're building for real hardware; it means your error analysis won't break down when you hit those subtle effects at different scales. You get a better handle on the overhead landing for those complex corrections.

Kai: The main implication is that we need this more detailed view to truly predict electroweak precision data accurately, especially when we're looking at things like lepton flavor violating processes where those subdominant operators matter a lot.

Mira: It’s about getting a better handle on the underlying assumptions; they are saying that if you only look at the momentum independent parts, you miss the full picture of how new physics couples to our low energy world.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up this discussion on "Dimension-eight SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory". Basically, they’ve successfully worked out how low energy measurements connect to new physics up to dimension eight operators in SMEFT.

Mira: That means we have a much more complete map of how new physics shows up in things we measure here at low energies. It confirms that dimension six matching wasn't enough for a full picture.

Lev: It’s important because it sets the benchmark for what we need to model when running this on real hardware; you know the structure of the correction now.

Kai: And they did it by combining direct and indirect contributions, which gives us confidence in the method used, especially since their results line up with previous analyses on dimension seven operators.

Mira: They also showed how those dimension eight operators actually impact Standard Model parameters, which is a critical consistency check for any new physics model we are testing.

Lev: I just want to say that getting these detailed matching conditions is what allows us to move from theoretical predictions to something you can actually test in an experiment.

Kai: Absolutely. It’s about making the transition from theory to measurement as smooth as possible, especially when we're dealing with those subtle dimension eight effects.

Mira: So, the big picture is that this work gives us the necessary tools to predict electroweak precision data and lepton flavor violating processes more accurately by accounting for those subdominant dimension eight operators.

Lev: It shows where the real experimental overhead will land when you try to model all of these higher order effects together.

Kai: To sum it up, "Dimension-eight SMEFT Matching Conditions for the Low-Energy Effective Field Theory" provides a complete set of momentum independent matching conditions up to dimension eight for all four-fermion LEFT operators.

Mira: It’s a solid step forward in understanding the low energy EFT, showing how those higher order terms matter.

Lev: And we still have that momentum dependent part to tackle next, which is where the real challenge lies for experimentalists and theorists figuring out when to ignore it versus when it matters.

More episodes

← Home