Connecting B to K nu nu and K to pi nu nu decays with neutrino physics
summary
The gist
The paper investigates how Lepton Number Violating (LNV) effective operators modify the kinematic distributions in rare decays B → K(∗)νν and K → πνν…
In short
The study investigates Lepton Number Violating (LNV) operators in rare decays like B → K(∗)νν and K → πνν. While these operators can modify kinematic distributions, they require significant fine-tuning in neutrino masses to explain observed excesses. The authors propose a minimal extension of the Standard Model with a light right-handed Majorana neutrino to provide a theoretically robust framework that reconciles these EFT effects with existing neutrino physics constraints.
Key concepts
- Lepton Number Violating (LNV) Effective Operators
- These are mathematical terms used in the Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT) that describe potential interactions where lepton number is not conserved. They are studied because they can change the way rare decays, such as B to K or K to pi, behave kinematically, offering a window into physics beyond the Standard Model.
- Renormalization-Group (RG) Analysis
- This mathematical technique tracks how the strength of physical interactions changes as you look at different energy scales. The RG analysis is used here to see how dimension-seven operators affect neutrino masses and other processes, helping determine if these new physics effects are compatible with observed neutrino properties.
- Light Right-Handed Majorana Neutrino (N)
- This is a hypothetical particle introduced into the Standard Model extension. It is a sterile neutrino that can be light enough to be produced in meson decays. Its inclusion allows the SMEFT to generate operators that are more compatible with experimental data, offering a way to circumvent constraints imposed by neutrino mass fine-tuning.
- SMEFT Operators (Dimension-Six and Seven)
- These are terms within the SMEFT that describe possible new interactions at different levels of complexity. Dimension-six operators represent the simplest new physics effects, while dimension-seven operators are more complex. The paper analyzes how these specific operators influence rare decays and how they relate to neutrino mass generation.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Connecting B to K nu nu and K to pi nu nu decays with neutrino physics · Paper Radio
- Evidence for B+ to K+ nu nu bar decays
- New measurement of K+ to pi+ nu nu branching ratio at the NA62 experiment
- Observation of the K+ to pi+ nu nu bar decay and measurement of its branching ratio
- B to K(*) nu nu decays in the Standard Model and beyond
- Understanding the first measurement of B(B to K nu nu bar)
- Implications of an enhanced B to K nu nu branching ratio
- Probing third-generation New Physics with K to pi nu nu and B to K(*) nu nu
- Implications of B to K nu nu bar under Rank-One Flavor Violation hypothesis
- Light New Physics in B to K(*) nu nu ?
- Decoding the B to K nu nu excess at Belle II: kinematics, operators, and masses
- FCNC portals to the dark sector
- Signatures of Light New Particles in B to K(*) E miss
- Impact of new invisible particles on B to K(*) E miss observables
- Gauged tau-lepton chiral currents and B to K(*) E miss
- FCNC B and K Meson Decays with Light Bosonic Dark Matter
- Revisiting models that enhance B+ to K+ nu nu in light of the new Belle II measurement
- When Energy Goes Missing: New Physics in b to s nu nu with Sterile Neutrinos
- The Anatomy of K+ to pi+ nu nu Distributions
- Disentangling new physics in K to pi nu bar nu and B to K(K*) nu bar nu observables
- Disentangling left and right-handed neutrino effects in B to K(*) nu nu
The paper
Connecting B to K nu nu and K to pi nu nu decays with neutrino physics · Read on arXiv
Université Paris-Saclay · Institut Universitaire de France (IUF) · Departamento de Física Matemática, Instituto de Física Universidade de São Paulo
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Connecting B to K nu nu and K to pi nu nu decays with neutrino physics".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper investigates how Lepton Number Violating (LNV) effective operators modify the kinematic distributions in rare decays B → K(∗)νν and K → πνν, providing probes of physics beyond the Standard Model.
Kai: Investigation of LNV SMEFT Operators The study investigates the contributions of Lepton Number Violating (LNV) effective operators to the rare decays B → K(∗)νν and K → πνν.
Mira: These operators can modify the kinematic distributions of these processes, providing distinctive probes of physics beyond the Standard Model.
Kai: Through a renormalization-group analysis, the Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT) operators responsible for these effects are subject to stringent indirect constraints from neutrino physics.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at a paper called Connecting B to K nu nu and K to pi nu nu decays with neutrino physics. This study is all about how lepton number violating operators mess with the way these rare decays happen and that gives us clues about physics beyond the Standard Model.
Mira: Exactly. It’s taking those rare B to K and K to pi decays, which are super sensitive, and seeing how they change when you add these lepton number violating terms. The authors are using a renormalization group analysis to see what constraints neutrino physics puts on the Standard Model Effective Field Theory operators causing these effects.
Lev: From my side, it’s interesting that they're looking at dimension-seven operators specifically because those can be quite important in specific UV completions, even if the dimension-six ones are the leading SMEFT contributions for di to dj nu nu transitions on page three <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Kai: Right, and what the paper points out immediately is that these SMEFT operators have some pretty strict indirect constraints coming from neutrino physics. They find that if you want to avoid having a lot of fine-tuning in neutrino masses, those dimension-seven contributions to B plus K plus inverse decays just don't show up on page two <ref:2607.13142#pg2>.
Mira: That’s the core tension they’re addressing here: how do we reconcile these potential new physics effects with the known constraints from neutrino mass measurements? They are essentially saying that for a mild excess seen by Belle-II in B plus K plus inverse decays, you need significant fine-tuning unless you introduce some specific UV structure.
Lev: And they suggest that a minor extension of the SMEFT, adding a light Standard Model singlet Majorana neutrino, say N, can actually fix this problem. This light sterile neutrino is what they call nu SMEFT and it allows for dimension-six operators to contribute to di to dj nu N and di to dj nu N transitions on page twenty <ref:2607.13142#pg2>.
Kai: So the improvement here is that the paper goes beyond just setting constraints; they propose a specific way—this light sterile neutrino—to make the model work, which is something we really want to see in practice.
Title and authors: Mira: And they also look at how these constraints from B to K and K to pi decays set lower bounds on the scale of New Physics. They use the simplest scenario, like vector coefficients CVXL, which are generated by dimension-six SMEFT operators on page eighteen <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Lev: Those bounds are interesting because they help us understand how high that New Physics scale could be before we start seeing deviations in these meson decays on page nineteen <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Kai: And then there’s the discussion about UV completions for those dimension-seven operators, and they find that scalar leptoquarks are one of the few exceptions where they can work, but only if you use a specific flavor structure to suppress the dimension-six coefficients on page thirty <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Mira: It seems like the paper is really trying to map out a path from these abstract EFT operators down to concrete models, which is crucial for us theorists working on UV completions on page thirty-one <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Lev: And they also do a numerical analysis showing how RG evolution affects the neutrino masses, and they find that the RG-induced contributions to the active neutrino masses are proportional to two times the Dirac mass term multiplied by some power of N and scaled by some combination of Yukawa couplings on page forty-two <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Kai: That scaling looks very specific, linking it directly back to how those Yukawa couplings behave under renormalization group evolution. It connects the low-energy measurements to high-energy scales in a quantifiable way on page forty-two <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Mira: And they show that diagonalizing the neutrino mass matrix using a rotation involving nu L gives them this result for the RG-induced contribution to active neutrino masses, which is proportional to m times some Dirac mass term times N plus some terms of the Dirac mass squared divided by N on page forty-two <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Lev: That diagonalizing part is key because it shows how the mixing between active and sterile neutrinos gets influenced by the RG running in a way that depends on the scale of N on page forty-three <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Title and authors: Kai: So what this all means for us listening now is that we can’t just throw these SMEFT operators at the wall without having massive fine-tuning in neutrino masses, unless we adopt this minimal extension with a light sterile neutrino N on page thirty-two <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Mira: If you listen to this, you should think about how the constraints from B to K and K to pi decays can probe much higher New Physics scales than just the simple B meson decays discussed earlier because they are suppressed within the Standard Model on page eighteen <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Lev: For real hardware running, that means if we were building a detector looking for this, we'd need to be sensitive to sterile neutrino masses m in the range of over one hundred MeV on page thirty-four <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Kai: Exactly. And those constraints from sterile neutrinos above a few MeV are interesting because they could also affect the thermal history of the early universe even if they don't decay during Big Bang Nucleosynthesis on page thirty-four <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Mira: So to wrap up this paper, Connecting B to K nu nu and K to pi nu nu decays with neutrino physics, it shows that measurable lepton number violating contributions in the SMEFT are tied to fine-tuning unless you introduce a light right-handed Majorana neutrino N on page thirty-two <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Lev: I just want to add that the analysis is robust because they do a complete renormalization group analysis, which is what we need when we're trying to constrain these operators properly on page thirteen <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Kai: It’s clear they are building a framework where the EFT doesn't immediately lead to an impossible scenario, and they show how this light sterile neutrino extension provides a theoretically robust way to generate those scalar operators in the neutrino sector on page thirty-four <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Mira: The main point is that we can use these rare meson decays as probes, but we have to be careful about what scale of New Physics we are probing because of the inherent structure in the neutrino sector on page eighteen <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Lev: And that structure is what makes this light sterile neutrino extension a theoretically robust framework for generating those scalar operators we care about in the neutrino sector on page thirty-four <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, to wrap up this part, the main thing they're saying is that if you look at these rare decays in B and K mesons with lepton number violating terms in the Standard Model Effective Field Theory, you're running into a big problem with fine-tuning in neutrino masses.
Mira: Right. They show that these specific operators cause a huge fine-tuning issue unless you introduce this light sterile neutrino, N into the spectrum. It's not just theoretical; it's necessary to keep the math from breaking against the known constraints from how heavy neutrinos affect active neutrino masses and cosmology on page thirty-two <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, adding this light sterile neutrino changes the operator structure significantly. It allows for these dimension-six operators to actually contribute to di to dj nu N transitions, which is a concrete path for building some kind of model instead of just sticking with the abstract EFT terms on page twenty <ref:2607.13142#pg2>.
Kai: So what this means for us practically is that we can't just assume these SMEFT operators are there without having a very specific fine-tuning in neutrino masses unless we have this light sterile neutrino N around one hundred megaelectron volts.
Mira: And that scale, around one hundred megaelectron volts, opens up another door for experimentalists. They suggest that searches for sterile neutrinos in the few megaelectron volt range are really important because they can mess with the thermal history of the early universe even if they don't decay during Big Bang Nucleosynthesis on page thirty-four <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Lev: That links back to what we see in other papers, like those looking at NINJA-like detectors; these constraints from B and K decays give us a way to set lower bounds on where that sterile neutrino mass has to be for the theory to stay consistent.
Kai: So the whole point is they’ve done a complete renormalization group analysis and determined whether this scenario can actually live up to the requirements of both neutrino physics and general ultraviolet consistency on page thirteen <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Mira: It shows that these rare decays are powerful probes, but you have to be very careful about the scale of New Physics you're probing because of the specific structure in how the neutrino sector runs under renormalization group evolution on page eighteen <ref:2607.13142#pg3>.
Kai: It’s a solid piece of work showing exactly how to reconcile these EFT scenarios with the known constraints, and it points us toward needing searches for sterile neutrinos in that specific mass window.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So, looking at what they suggested for improvements, they're basically saying that if you want to get better constraints on this stuff, you need to incorporate a more complete renormalization group analysis into the whole SMEFT framework.
Mira: Yeah. They’re stressing that you can't just look at one type of operator in isolation; you need to integrate all the one-loop anomalous dimension matrices together so they actually constrain both neutrino masses and those rare decays simultaneously.
Lev: From a hardware perspective, that means for error correction, we need to account for how these different SMEFT operators mix under running, which is going to be more complex than just treating them as independent terms.
Kai: So what this means is that the next step isn't just finding one operator; it’s building a framework where all these dimension-six and dimension-seven terms interact in a way that respects the running of the couplings.
Mira: Exactly. It pushes us to think about how to systematically map out all possible contributions, not just find some lucky cancellation for one term. They want to be able to predict effects more reliably based on the underlying theory, not just fitting data points.
Lev: If we are trying to build a detector that looks for these effects, this suggests our simulations need a much more detailed accounting of the running across different energy scales than what we might currently have for standard SMEFT operator matching.
Kai: It seems like they're moving from just finding constraints on a single scenario to building a more comprehensive map of the EFT landscape itself.
Mira: And that leads into something else they touch on, which is how these constraints help us narrow down the possible UV completions—the actual particle physics models that could generate these operators in the first place.
Lev: That’s where it gets interesting; if we can constrain the coefficients from meson decays, we can actually start to distinguish between different UV completions of those dimension-seven operators, like scalar leptoquarks versus other scenarios.
Kai: So the paper is suggesting that by improving the analysis, we move closer to a concrete model identification rather than just having an abstract set of constraints.
Mira: It’s about moving from saying "this works if we have this sterile neutrino" to understanding "this works because of this specific flavor structure."
Lev: And that's really important for us building real hardware, because knowing the UV completion helps us predict what kind of signals we might expect from those sterile neutrinos at different masses.
Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up on "Connecting B to K nu nu and K to pi nu nu decays with neutrino physics," summarizing that these rare meson decays are tied to fine-tuning unless you introduce a light sterile neutrino N, and that this is a necessary step for UV consistency.
Mira: Exactly. The big picture here is that we need this light sterile neutrino extension to make sense of the constraints coming from how heavy neutrinos affect active neutrino masses and cosmology simultaneously.
Lev: For us building the actual hardware, it means our simulations have to account for this running across different energy scales, which is a lot of overhead if you're trying to run that on real equipment without proper error correction.
Kai: It really shows how these decay channels can be used as probes, but only if you acknowledge this inherent structure in the neutrino sector when setting the scale for New Physics.
Mira: We've seen that zero nu beta beta decays can be almost as competitive as these FCNC processes if you are looking at sterile neutrino masses in the one hundred megaelectron volt range.
Lev: That resonant enhancement is a big deal; it means we have to keep an eye on those specific mass ranges when planning future searches, like with experiments such as NINJA-like detectors.
Kai: So the final word is that this paper provides a theoretically robust framework showing how this light sterile neutrino can generate these scalar operators in the neutrino sector.
Mira: It confirms that we can reconcile these rare decay constraints with general ultraviolet consistency requirements by introducing this specific type of light right-handed Majorana neutrino N.
Lev: And it gives us a concrete direction for where to look next, specifically pointing toward those sterile neutrino masses above one hundred megaelectron volts for experimental searches.
More episodes
- 2610.38463-Gauge-parameter cancellation and finite form factors in one-loop quark scattering in the refined Gribov-Zwanziger framework
- 2610.37198-Searches for new particle physics by methods of classical and neutrino astronomy
- 2511.15779-SURFing to the Fundamental Limit of Jet Tagging
- 2505.01492-Photo- and Hadrodisintegration constraints on massive relics decaying into neutrinos
- 2505.20389-Dispersion relation of the neutrino plasma: Unifying fast, slow, and collisional instabilities
- 2511.10731-Keeping It Renormalizable: Minimal Baryogenesis induced Asymmetric Dark Matter
- 2404.04021-Vacuum correlations of the stress-energy-momentum tensor with constituent quarks
- 2503.02931-Relativistic Navier-Stokes description of the quark-gluon plasma radial flow
- 2606.06105-Bulk viscosity of a binary mixture: the role of the intra-species interaction
- 2607.03343-First look at the evaluation of two-loop Feynman integrals for radiative return processes