Can Effective 4- Quark Operators Describe Signals of a Supersymmetric Diquark Model at the LHC?
summary
The gist
The paper investigates whether effective 4-quark operators can accurately describe signals from an R-parity-violating supersymmetric model at the LHC by analyzing inclusive top pair production events.
In short
The study investigates if effective 4-quark operators can accurately describe signals from an R-parity-violating supersymmetric model at the LHC using inclusive top pair production data. The findings show that these operators only work for very heavy sbottom squarks, and current SMEFT constraints cannot derive meaningful bounds on the RPV model.
Key concepts
- R-parity-violating (RPV) Supersymmetric Model
- This is a theoretical extension of supersymmetry where a symmetry called R-parity is broken. This breaking allows for interactions that violate baryon number, which can lead to new physics signals at the LHC, specifically involving top quarks and sbottom squarks.
- Effective 4-Quark Operators
- These are simplified mathematical terms used in the Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT) framework. They are derived by integrating out a heavy particle (the sbottom squark) from the full RPV model, allowing researchers to study its effects using lower-dimensional operators.
- SMEFT Implementation Failure
- The paper finds that the SMEFT approximation fails to describe the RPV model's signals in many key kinematic regions. This failure occurs because SMEFT ignores important momentum flow through the exchanged sbottom squark, especially when sbottom squarks are heavy.
- Sbottom Squark as Diquark
- In this specific model setup, the lightest supersymmetric particle is assumed to be the sbottom. The analysis treats this sbottom squark as acting like a specific diquark—a combination of quarks—to understand how it interacts with light quarks and top quarks in the RPV interactions.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Can Effective 4- Quark Operators Describe Signals of a Supersymmetric Diquark Model at the LHC? · Paper Radio
- Dimension-Six Terms in the Standard Model Lagrangian
- The Standard Model as an Effective Field Theory
- Results from TopFitter
- Constraining top quark effective theory in the LHC Run II era
- A Monte Carlo global analysis of the Standard Model Effective Field Theory: the top quark sector
- O new physics, where art thou? A global search in the top sector
- Top, Higgs, Diboson and Electroweak Fit to the Standard Model Effective Field Theory
- Top and Beauty synergies in SMEFT-fits at present and future colliders
- The Gauge-Higgs Legacy of the LHC Run II
- Updated Global SMEFT Fit to Higgs, Diboson and Electroweak Data
- Electroweak Sector Under Scrutiny: A Combined Analysis of LHC and Electroweak Precision Data
- Validity of SMEFT studies of VH and VV Production at NLO
- NLO QCD corrections to SM-EFT dilepton and electroweak Higgs boson production, matched to parton shower in POWHEG
- SMEFT analysis of vector boson scattering and diboson data from the LHC Run II
- High- p T dilepton tails and flavour physics
- Studies of Dimension-Six EFT effects in Vector Boson Scattering
- SM EFT effects in Vector-Boson Scattering at the LHC
- A Global Likelihood for Precision Constraints and Flavour Anomalies
- Reactor neutrino oscillations as constraints on Effective Field Theory
- Compilation of low-energy constraints on 4-fermion operators in the SMEFT
The paper
Can Effective 4- Quark Operators Describe Signals of a Supersymmetric Diquark Model at the LHC? · Read on arXiv
Manuel Drees, Cong Zhanga
Bethe Center for Theoretical Physics and Physikalisches Institut, Universit"at Bonn
DOI: 10.1103/g51t-v8px
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Can Effective 4- Quark Operators Describe Signals of a Supersymmetric Diquark Model at the LHC?".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper investigates whether effective 4-quark operators can accurately describe signals from an R-parity-violating supersymmetric model at the LHC by analyzing inclusive top pair production events.
Kai: Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT) is constrained by current LHC data, and extensions of the Standard Model involving heavy particles can be constrained by matching onto the SMEFT <ref:2506.13500#pg2>.
Mira: The authors investigate whether 4-quark operators can accurately capture the effects of an R-parity-violating (RPV) supersymmetric model on top quark pair production for parameters that satisfy all known constraints and lead to measurable effects <ref:2506.13500#pg3>.
Kai: They assume the sbottom is the lightest supersymmetric particle and focus on its interaction with a light quark and a top quark, where the sbottom acts like a specific diquark <ref:2506.13500#pg3>.
Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper titled "Can Effective four- Quark Operators Describe Signals of a Supersymmetric Diquark Model at the LHC <ref:2506.13500#pg1,Can Effective 4- Quark Operators Describe Signals of a Supersymmetric Diquark Model>?" and what they're trying to figure out is whether these four-quark operators can actually describe signals from an R-parity violating supersymmetric model when you look at inclusive top pair production events.
Mira: Right, so the core thesis here is testing if these effective operators can capture the effects of a specific R-parity violating supersymmetric model on top quark pair production for parameters that still fit all the known constraints and actually lead to something we could measure at the LHC.
Lev: It assumes that they take the sbottom to be the lightest supersymmetric particle, focusing its interaction with a light quark and a top quark, where this sbottom acts like a specific diquark. Then they generate these four-quark operators by integrating out that sbottom squark at tree level.
Kai: So, what's the actual claim they make about these operators? What do they find when they compare the R-parity violating model to the SMEFT implementation?
Mira: They find that these four-quark operators can only accurately describe the R-parity violating model’s effects if you consider very heavy sbottom squarks. And for those heavy sbottom squarks, the effects are way below what LHC experiments can see, no matter what the R-parity violating coupling is, as long as it satisfies unitarity constraints.
Lev: That sounds like a strong limitation on how much new physics we can actually probe with these four-quark operators in this context. It means current or near-future bounds on this R-parity violating model just can't be derived from SMEFT analyses at all, according to the paper.
Kai: It seems like they're saying that the SMEFT approximation is fundamentally flawed when trying to capture these specific signals, especially in regions where the sbottom squarks are heavy. So, what's this about R-parity violating superpotential terms they start with?
Mira: They start with baryon number violating terms in the R-parity violating superpotential, like W equal R parity violation equals half X i j k lambda double i j k U c i D c j D c k. They then specifically focus on the term proportional to lambda double three one three.
Paper summary: Lev: And they assume that all other superparticles are heavier than this right-handed sbottom, so they don't play a role for LHC physics in that part of the analysis. But they do have a decay width for the sbottom given by gamma b equals lambda double three one three squared M double tilde b squared minus m square two t squared over eight pi M double tilde b cubed.
Kai: So, when they compare this R-parity violating model to the SMEFT framework, what's the setup for that comparison? What are they looking at in terms of top pair production?
Mira: They compare them using inclusive top pair events from CMS and ATLAS data taken at a collision energy of thirteen TeV <ref:2506.13500#pg1>. They look at three classes of contributions to inclusive top pair production caused by R-parity violating interactions.
Lev: In the SMEFT framework, since they integrate out the sbottom squarks, it leads to two dimension six operators, O one and O eight in the Warsaw basis. And those coefficients are related by C one t d equals negative C eight t d over three which is positive.
Kai: So we're talking about how these two descriptions—the full R-parity violating model versus the SMEFT description via four-quark operators—actually match up when you look at the data. Where do they get their detailed comparisons?
Mira: They perform detailed comparisons between the R-parity violating model and the four-quark operators in terms of differential distributions and what those result in constraints derived from inclusive top pair events.
Lev: They examine several kinematic variables, including the invariant mass of the top pair, the transverse momentum of a top quark or of the whole pair, and charge asymmetry. For instance, figure three shows distributions for transverse momentum thigh at parton level predicted by the R-parity violating model solid line and its SMEFT implementation dashed line.
Kai: That's interesting because it shows that even in these specific distributions, you can see a difference between the two descriptions. So what's their conclusion about the validity of using SMEFT here?
Mira: The study concludes that there is no region of parameter space where the R-parity violating model simultaneously leads to measurable effects at the LHC and can be described well by an SMEFT implementation.
Lev: They point out that the SMEFT implementation overestimates how big BSM contributions are, especially in bins with high transverse momentum or high invariant mass, because it ignores the momentum flow through the exchanged sbottom squark.
Paper summary: Kai: That's a key point—the approximation breaks down because it ignores how momentum moves through that sbottom squark when the energy is high. So how does this change what we can learn from current LHC data?
Mira: This is particularly true for heavy sbottom squarks where perturbation theory breaks down, which means the constraints derived from SMEFT are much stronger than those derived in the full R-parity violating model for all sbottom masses shown.
Lev: They show that for a sbottom mass of three TeV, these data can only exclude scenarios with coupling lambda double three one three greater than two point three which is where the reliability of perturbation theory at the LHC scale is already questionable <ref:2506.13500#pg2>.
Kai: So where do they actually get their strongest upper bound on this R-parity violating coupling? What's the best constraint they find?
Mira: The strongest upper bound on the coupling comes from either the transverse momentum thigh distribution, which is a solid black line depending on sbottom mass, or the transverse momentum trow distribution, which is a solid red line depending on sbottom mass, or the transverse momentum ttbar distribution depending on sbottom mass.
Lev: Since these three bounds come from the same data set, combining them statistically isn't straightforward. But the resulting upper bound on lambda double three one three is stronger than that constraint of two point four we got from high-scale unitarity for a given sbottom mass <ref:2506.13500#pg2>.
Kai: So, when they look at the SMEFT implementation itself, what kind of bounds do they get there? What does that tell us about how good the approximation is?
Mira: The SMEFT implementation yields upper bounds for lambda double three one three over sbottom mass of two point forty-three and zero point eighty-nine when only they include the lambda minus two term and both the lambda minus two plus lambda minus four terms, respectively. And when they only consider the exclusive ttbar channel, these bounds are much stronger than what we get from the R-parity violating model directly.
Lev: The SMEFT bound derived in linear order is coincidentally close to the full R-parity violating constraint for the smallest sbottom mass shown, but it has too steep a slope. It means that once you go to higher sbottom masses, say five TeV, where perturbation theory breaks down, the two predictions only agree to within twenty percent <ref:2506.13500#pg2>.
Paper summary: Kai: It sounds like they are saying that SMEFT just doesn't capture the dynamics of this specific model well enough across all energy scales we care about. So what does this imply for how we use SMEFT generally?
Mira: The authors conclude that there is no region of parameter space where the R-parity violating model simultaneously leads to effects that are measurable at the LHC and can be described well by an SMEFT implementation.
Lev: They also say that once mild constraints on perturbativity are imposed, this is true only for sbottom masses less than or equal to three TeV, where the predictions of the R-parity violating model differ significantly from those by its SMEFT implementation, especially in the tails of distributions which are most sensitive to BSM effects <ref:2506.13500#pg2>.
Kai: So ultimately, what's the big picture here for people who only listen to this show? What does this paper really tell us about searching for new physics beyond the Standard Model?
Mira: The main point is that when you try to use SMEFT to describe these signals from an R-parity violating supersymmetric model, it fails everywhere. The SMEFT implementation doesn't reproduce any of the perturbative signals they studied, and they found that the quality of this approximation really depends on the mass of the sbottom.
Lev: They also noted that direct searches don't seem to constrain this scenario strongly by themselves. The ttjbar channel dominates in the transverse momentum ttbar distribution, and exclusive ttbar production doesn't contribute at leading order there.
Kai: So if you take everything we've covered—the comparison between the R-parity violating model and SMEFT, the constraints from specific distributions like transverse momentum thigh, and how it all depends on the sbottom mass—what is this paper's final statement?
Mira: The authors conclude that there is no region of parameter space where these two models simultaneously lead to effects that are measurable at the LHC and can be described well by an SMEFT implementation.
Lev: They state that the SMEFT implementation fails everywhere, and the bounds derived from it are much stronger than those derived in the R-parity violating model for all sbottom masses less than or equal to three TeV <ref:2506.13500#pg2>.
Kai: So, in short, we don't see a region where this supersymmetric diquark model is testable using current SMEFT tools to describe its signals at the LHC.
Conclusion: Kai: So we've been looking at how these four-quark operators stack up against the full R-parity violating supersymmetric model when we look at top pair production data.
Mira: Exactly, this paper really digs into whether those effective operators can actually capture what happens in a full R-parity violating scenario.
Lev: The authors basically test if integrating out that sbottom squark at tree level gives us the right picture for what's happening at the LHC.
Kai: They found that these four-quark operators only describe the signal well if you assume very heavy sbottom squarks, and even then, it’s still below what we can see in current experiments.
Mira: That suggests that using just SMEFT to model this specific type of new physics isn't working across all the parameter space.
Lev: Which means any limits we put on the R-parity violating coupling from these SMEFT analyses are actually much stronger than what we get from running the full model.
Kai: The authors are really pushing back on using SMEFT here, suggesting it overestimates the effects because it ignores how momentum flows through that sbottom squark.
Mira: That's a crucial assumption they’re making, and they point out that this approximation gets worse as you look at higher transverse momentum or higher invariant mass bins.
Lev: So the paper is saying that for heavy sbottom squarks, the SMEFT tool just breaks down, and the full model gives us better constraints.
Kai: It seems like a warning about relying too heavily on approximations when modeling complex BSM physics at colliders.
Mira: It shows that the quality of that approximation really depends on where you are in terms of the sbottom mass.
Lev: This whole thing suggests that direct searches alone don't constrain this scenario as strongly as they might think, especially in certain channels like top quark jet production.
Kai: It leaves us wondering if we need to look at other experimental signatures to really probe these R-parity violating effects.
More episodes
- 2610.38463-Gauge-parameter cancellation and finite form factors in one-loop quark scattering in the refined Gribov-Zwanziger framework
- 2610.37198-Searches for new particle physics by methods of classical and neutrino astronomy
- 2511.15779-SURFing to the Fundamental Limit of Jet Tagging
- 2505.01492-Photo- and Hadrodisintegration constraints on massive relics decaying into neutrinos
- 2505.20389-Dispersion relation of the neutrino plasma: Unifying fast, slow, and collisional instabilities
- 2511.10731-Keeping It Renormalizable: Minimal Baryogenesis induced Asymmetric Dark Matter
- 2404.04021-Vacuum correlations of the stress-energy-momentum tensor with constituent quarks
- 2503.02931-Relativistic Navier-Stokes description of the quark-gluon plasma radial flow
- 2606.06105-Bulk viscosity of a binary mixture: the role of the intra-species interaction
- 2607.03343-First look at the evaluation of two-loop Feynman integrals for radiative return processes