Analytic parametrisations of the scale dependence of proton parton distributions

summary

The gist

Proton parton distribution functions are non-perturbative inputs whose scale dependence is governed by the Dokshitzer–Gribov–Lipatov–Altarelli–Parisi (DGLAP) equations…

In short

The paper develops an explicit analytic representation for proton parton distribution functions (PDFs) by turning standard parametrization parameters into scale-dependent functions. This method successfully reproduces integrated distributions at subpercent accuracy, with minor deviations in the strange quark reaching about 1.5% at high scales. The resulting ML-PDFs are computationally faster than original grid methods.

Key concepts

Proton Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs)
These are non-perturbative inputs describing the probability of finding a specific type of parton (like a quark or gluon) carrying a certain fraction of the proton's total momentum. Their behavior changes depending on the energy scale at which they are measured.
DGLAP Equations
These equations govern how PDFs evolve with respect to the energy scale, known as DGLAP evolution. They describe how the parton distributions change as you probe them at different levels of resolution.
Analytic Representation
This involves creating a direct mathematical formula for PDFs that depends on both the momentum fraction (x) and the energy scale ($Q^2$). Instead of using pre-calculated grids, this approach allows PDFs to be evaluated directly using the analytic formula.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Analytic parametrisations of the scale dependence of proton parton distributions · Read on arXiv

Instituto de Fsa Corpuscular, Universitat de Valncia--Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientfica

Parton distribution functions (PDFs) are non-perturbative inputs whose scale dependence is governed by the Dokshitzer-Gribov-Lipatov-Altarelli-Parisi (DGLAP) equations. Their numerical evaluation commonly relies on interpolation of tabulated grids. We discuss an analytic representation of collinear proton PDFs in (x,Q 2), obtained by promoting the parameters of a standard x-space parametrisation to functions of the scale. The coefficients are reconstructed from the HERAPDF2.0 NLO set using machine-assisted fitting techniques, with sampling in 10-4 at most x at most 0.65 and scales up to 1 TeV. The resulting ML-PDFs reproduce integrated distributions at the sub-percent level for most flavours, with deviations reaching about 1.5% for the strange quark at the highest scales. They satisfy valence and momentum sum rules at the percent level and reproduce representative pp toπ and pp toγπ cross sections within approximately 2% and 5%, respectively, in the kinematic regions studied. Compared with grid interpolation through LHAPDF, direct evaluation of the analytic expressions reduces the total Monte Carlo run time by about 11% and 30% in these two applications.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Analytic parametrisations of the scale dependence of proton parton distributions".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Proton parton distribution functions are non-perturbative inputs whose scale dependence is governed by the Dokshitzer–Gribov–Lipatov–Altarelli–Parisi (DGLAP) equations, and this paper presents an analytic representation of collinear proton PDFs obtained by promoting the parameters of a standard x-space parametrisation to functions of the scale The resulting ML-PDFs reproduce integrated distributions at the subpercent level for most flavours, with deviations reaching about 1.5% for the strange quark at the highest scales Analytic Representation and Fitting Procedure Proton PDFs are commonly parametrised at an initial scale Q 2 0 using a functional form that captures their small- and large-x behaviour, supplemented by a factor that provides additional flexibility A representative form is f i(x, Q 2 0) = N i x alpha i (1 - x) beta i P(x, c ij), where i denotes the parton flavour, x is the fraction of the proton’s longitudinal momentum carried by the parton, and N i is a normalisation factor The aim is to construct an explicit analytic representation in (x, Q 2) that can be evaluated without interpolating PDF grids The coefficients are determined in two steps

4: First, the HERAPDF2.0 NLO set

2: is sampled at O (5000) randomly selected points with x ∈

10−4, 0.65: and Q ∈

Qmin, 1000: GeV The x dependence is fitted at fixed Q to determine the coefficients Second, the Mathematica routine FindFormula suggests functional forms for their scale dependence, which are used to construct the final analytic parametrisations

4: Distribution Accuracy and Consistency Checks The resulting analytic approximations, denoted ML-PDFs, reproduce the output of DGLAP evolution embodied in the reference set; they are not new analytic solutions of the evolution equations The integral error Δ i(Q 2) = I

f ML i, Q 2: − I

f HERA i, Q 2: / I

f HERA i, Q 2: measures differences between integrated distributions and is less sensitive than point-wise relative errors to fluctuations where the PDF is small Most distributions have deviations below 0.5%, while charm reaches roughly 0.7% and the strange-quark distribution exhibits the largest deviation, approximately 1.5% at Q ≈ 1000 GeV The valence and momentum sum rules hold at the percent level, and the two hadronic benchmarks agree with the reference predictions within about 2% and 5% in the respective regions considered Hadronic Observables and Computational Performance The predictions obtained with ML-PDFs are compared with those using the original HERAPDF2.0 grids in Fig.

Kai: 3 For single-inclusive pion production, the differences remain well below 2% and are mostly contained within the HERAPDF2.0 uncertainty band For photon–pion production, the deviations are within 5% for pT ≤ 10 GeV, where the cross section is largest The execution times obtained for both processes are summarised in Table 1 Relative to LHAPDF, the analytic ML-PDFs reduce the total run time by approximately 11% for p p → π and 30% for p p → γπ

4: We have presented an explicit analytic approximation to the (x, Q 2) dependence of collinear proton PDFs Most integrated distributions agree with the reference set at the subpercent level, while the strange-quark deviation reaches approximately 1.5% at Q ≈ 1000 GeV The valence and momentum sum rules hold at the percent level, and the two hadronic benchmarks agree with the reference predictions within about 2% and 5% in the respective regions considered Direct ML-PDF evaluation also reduces the total Monte Carlo run time by 11% and 30% in these benchmarks The same strategy could be explored for other PDF sets and fragmentation functions REFERENCES

1: G.

Mira: Altarelli and G.

Kai: Parisi, Asymptotic freedom in parton language, Nucl.

Paper summary: Kai: Right. And what they claim is that by taking the parameters from a standard x space parametrisation and making them functions of the scale itself, they can get an analytic expression that you don't have to interpolate for >

Mira: That's what David F. Rentería-Estrada and his team did. They used machine-assisted fitting techniques on the HERAPDF2 point 0 NLO set, sampling points in x from ten to negative four up to zero point six five and scales all the way up to one tera electron volt > <ref:2611.08272#pg1,the HERAPDF2.0 NLO set>

Lev: So they are using a standard set as a reference point for their fitting, which makes sense for getting those coefficients right before you even look at the scale dependence part >

Kai: Exactly. The resulting ML-PDFs they create reproduce integrated distributions at the subpercent level for most of the flavors, but there's a deviation reaching about one point five percent specifically for the strange quark as they go to the highest scales, around one thousand electron volt >

Mira: That one point five percent deviation is worth watching because it points to where their analytic form might need more refinement at those higher energies >

Lev: From an engineering side, getting that level of accuracy across such a wide range of x and Q two without the heavy computational cost of grid interpolation sounds like a real win for simulation times >

Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at "Analytic parametrisations of the scale dependence of proton parton distributions". The core idea is moving from grids to an explicit analytic description that accounts for the scale change >

Mira: It seems like the authors are focused on how much more accurate this direct representation is compared to simply interpolating those existing HERAPDF2 point 0 grids > <ref:2611.08272#pg1>

Lev: What this means practically, if you're running Monte Carlo simulations for something like high energy colliders, having an analytic expression instead of an interpolation routine could seriously cut down the total run time >

Kai: And the paper shows that for single inclusive pion production and photon to pion production, those differences stay well below two percent >

Mira: But they also flagged that this direct analytic method isn't a new solution to the DGLAP evolution equations; it's an approximation based on fitting existing data >

Lev: And they did admit there are cutoffs for the gluon and other heavy quarks, like a step function, which is important because those choices influence how the result behaves in regions where x is small >

More episodes

← Home