Unpolarized proton PDF with physical quark masses and large momenta

summary

The gist

The paper presents a lattice quantum chromodynamics (QCD) calculation of the proton isovector (u − d) unpolarized parton distribution function (PDF) at physical quark masses…

In short

This study calculated the proton's unpolarized parton distribution function at physical quark masses using lattice QCD with a specific framework called LaMET. The calculation yielded consistent results with previous work, showing that the extracted PDFs agree with phenomenological models across a wide range of momentum fractions and different renormalization schemes, proving the reliability of this method for precision PDF determination.

Key concepts

Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD)
This is a mathematical approach used to solve the strong nuclear force by discretizing spacetime onto a four-dimensional grid (a lattice). This allows physicists to calculate properties of particles like protons from first principles, using fundamental QCD equations rather than just experimental data.
Quasi-PDFs and LaMET Framework
Quasi-PDFs are derived from equal-time spatial correlations in a boosted hadron, allowing researchers to extract the momentum fraction dependence (x) of partons. The LaMET framework uses these Euclidean lattice observables as the starting point for reconstructing the physical light-cone PDFs.
Next-to-Leading Order (NLO) Matching
This is a perturbative calculation technique used to bridge the gap between the non-perturbative lattice results (quasi-PDFs) and the physical, measurable light-cone PDFs in the standard MS scheme. It involves adding higher-order corrections to ensure accuracy when converting between these two different theoretical descriptions.
Coulomb Gauge Fixed Quark Bilinears
These are specific mathematical operators used within the lattice calculation that help isolate and measure the relevant quark structure of the proton. Fixing them in Coulomb gauge simplifies the extraction of physical observables, making it easier to relate lattice calculations to real-world parton distributions.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Unpolarized proton PDF with physical quark masses and large momenta · Read on arXiv

Xiang Gao, Andrew Hanlon, Jinchen He, Xiangyu Jiang, Swagato Mukherjee, *Peter Petreczky*, Qi Shi

Physics Division, Brookhaven National Laboratory · Center for Nuclear Research, Department of Physics, Kent State University · Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory · Maryland Center for Fundamental Physics, University of Maryland · Physics Division, Argonne National Laboratory · Physics Department, Indiana University

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Lattice. The day in lattice field theory: what the simulations put on the table.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Unpolarized proton PDF with physical quark masses and large momenta".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents a lattice quantum chromodynamics (QCD) calculation of the proton isovector (u − d) unpolarized parton distribution function (PDF) at physical quark masses, using Coulomb-gauge-fixed quark bilinears within the large-momentum effective theory framework The calculation is performed on a (2+1)-flavor ensemble with a lattice spacing of a = 0.076 fm and proton momenta up to 2.3 GeV The light-cone PDF in the MS scheme is obtained from the quasi-PDF through next-to-leading-order (NLO) perturbative matching supplemented by next-to-leading-logarithmic renormalization-group resummation With reduced uncertainties, the resulting PDF is consistent with our previous calculation on a similar lattice ensemble with a = 0.06 fm and a valence pion mass of 300 MeV Notably, despite the reduced uncertainties, the agreement with the phenomenological PDF persists over the longitudinal momentum fraction range 0.25 <∼ x <∼ 0.75, where the lattice calculation is expected to be reliable Lattice Framework and Methodology The study employs a (2+1)-flavor gauge ensemble generated by the HotQCD Collaboration with the highly improved staggered quark (HISQ) action The Coulomb-gauge correlators are used as the large-momentum Euclidean observable in the LaMET framework The bare matrix elements are renormalized using both the static regularization-independent momentum subtraction (SRI′ -MOM) scheme and a hybrid scheme The renormalization of the bare CG quasi-PDF matrix elements is multiplicative, relating the bare and renormalized operators through a quark-field renormalization factor Matrix Element Extraction The ground-state bare matrix elements hB(z, Pz, a) are extracted by evaluating two-point and three-point correlation functions The extraction of the ground-state bare matrix element hB using two complementary methods—a two-state fit and an exponential summation fit—is performed to isolate the ground-state contribution The ratio R(P; τ, ts; z) is constructed from the three-point function and the two-point correlation function to extract hB Renormalization and Matching The renormalized matrix elements are obtained using SRI′ -MOM followed by perturbative conversion to the MS scheme at µ = 2 GeV, with ZMS(a, 2 GeV) = 0.9114(89) The comparison is performed directly on the Euclidean observables entering the subsequent quasi-PDF reconstruction The quasi-PDFs are obtained by Fourier transforming the extended correlator, where an NLA-inspired parametrization is used to control the long-distance contribution Phenomenological Comparison The resulting light-cone PDFs are matched to the light-cone PDFs following Sec.

Kai: II D using a perturbatively calculable matching coefficient The NLO+NLL results are compatible with all three phenomenological determinations over 0.25 <∼ x <∼ 0.75, extending to moderately large x, within the displayed uncertainty envelopes The agreement in the imaginary part of the matrix element was observed for the first time in a lattice calculation of the proton isovector unpolarized PDF Together with our previous work, these encouraging results demonstrate the robustness of the CG method for precision PDF calculations and motivate further systematic improvements toward a more stringent benchmark against phenomenology The compatibility of the PDF results at the two momenta and with the two renormalization prescriptions provides additional checks within the present analysis The agreement with phenomenology in coordinate and momentum space provides compelling evidence for the reliability of the CG approach to lattice calculations of the proton isovector unpolarized PDF The paper calculates the proton isovector (u − d) unpolarized PDF at physical quark masses within the LaMET CG framework, using a lattice spacing of a = 0.076 fm and proton momenta Pz = 1.8 and 2.3 GeV The light-cone PDF in the MS scheme is obtained from the quasi-PDF through next-to-leading-order (NLO) perturbative matching supplemented by next-to-leading-logarithmic renormalization-group resummation With reduced uncertainties, the resulting PDF is consistent with our previous calculation on a similar lattice ensemble with a = 0.06 fm and a valence pion mass of 300 MeV We have calculated the proton isovector (u − d) unpolarized PDF at physical quark masses within the LaMET CG framework, using a lattice spacing of a = 0.076 fm and proton momenta Pz = 1.8 and 2.3 GeV Kinematically enhanced interpolating operators improve the signal quality at large boosts, while CG quark bilinears Phenomenological Comparison The resulting light-cone PDFs are matched to the light-cone PDFs following Sec.

Mira: II D using a perturbatively calculable matching coefficient The NLO+NLL results are compatible with all three phenomenological determinations over 0.25 <∼ x <∼ 0.

Title and authors: Kai: So we’re starting with the title of this paper, "Unpolarized proton PDF with physical quark masses and large momenta". It immediately tells you what they are aiming for.

Mira: It says they are calculating the unpolarized parton distribution function for the proton, but crucially, it specifies that they are using physical quark masses and large momenta. That’s a key distinction from older calculations where you often had to use heavier quarks or approximations to keep the math manageable.

Lev: When you talk about physical quark masses, you’re talking about using the actual mass of up and down quarks in your simulation, which makes it much closer to reality for what we are trying to understand.

Kai: Exactly. And the large momenta part is important because it lets them probe different parts of the proton structure that were previously inaccessible or poorly measured by other methods.

Mira: So, they are pushing the boundaries of what’s possible with lattice QCD calculations, trying to get a better picture of how quarks and gluons interact at high momentum scales.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, probing large momenta means you need very fine lattice spacings to avoid discretization errors that mess up the physics we’re trying to measure.

Kai: That's where the lattice spacing comes in: they used zero point zero seven six femtometers for their calculation on a two plus one flavor ensemble.

Mira: And that spacing is relatively small, which helps keep those discretization errors under control, but it still means they are doing a lot of computation.

Lev: The computation time scales badly with the lattice size and the precision you demand; so getting that fidelity for those high momenta is always a challenge for hardware.

Kai: They are also looking at proton momenta up to two point three giga electron volts in their calculation, which is pushing the kinematic limits of what they can measure reliably.

Mira: Pushing that energy scale means they are testing the applicability of their theoretical framework where it might not have been fully tested before.

Lev: When you push those scales, you need very careful analysis to make sure you aren't just seeing noise or artifacts from the calculation itself rather than real physics.

Kai: So, they are using this setup to get a high-resolution look at the proton structure across a wide range of momentum fractions.

Mira: This is important because it helps constrain the models that try to describe the proton’s internal dynamics, like those in global fits.

Lev: If they can do this reliably, it gives us much better data to test those models against than what we have today.

The paper's summary: Kai: Now let’s go over the summary section of "Unpolarized proton PDF with physical quark masses and large momenta" to see how they describe their main findings.

Mira: The summary says they calculated the proton isovector unpolarized parton distribution function at physical quark masses using Coulomb-gauge fixed quark bilinears within the large-momentum effective theory framework.

Lev: That’s the method—the core idea is using those specific quark bilinears in a way that respects gauge invariance on the lattice, which is what makes it unique.

Kai: And they performed this calculation on a two plus one flavor ensemble with a lattice spacing of zero point zero seven six femtometers and proton momenta up to two point three giga electron volts.

Mira: They also mention obtaining the light cone PDF in the modified minimal subtraction scheme from the quasi-PDF via next-to-leading order perturbative matching supplemented by next-to-leading logarithmic renormalization group resummation.

Lev: So, they are showing a sophisticated way to translate their lattice results into a physical PDF using that NLO plus NLL procedure.

Kai: The key takeaway is that the resulting PDF is consistent with previous calculations on a similar ensemble but with slightly different parameters, suggesting the method is stable and reliable.

Mira: And they point out that even though their uncertainties are reduced, the agreement with phenomenological PDFs holds over zero point two five less than x less than zero point seven five.

Lev: That range of x values is where you expect the lattice calculation to be most trustworthy, which is exactly where we want to see reliable physics.

Kai: So they’re claiming that this method delivers a result that is not just numerically correct but also has the right physical behavior in the region it’s supposed to cover.

Mira: This means they are providing a direct first-principles input for deep inelastic scattering experiments, which is what we need to move forward.

Lev: That direct link between lattice QCD and phenomenology is exactly what makes this work interesting for us as error correction people building hardware.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper talks about the improvements they made in their approach to get those results, which are quite a lot of methodological details.

Mira: They highlight using kinematically enhanced nucleon interpolating operators, which is designed to improve the signal quality when you boost the hadron to large momenta.

Lev: Kinematically enhanced operators are important because they help amplify the signal you get when you’re trying to measure something at high boost, which is where this paper is focusing.

Kai: They also use two complementary methods for extracting the ground state bare matrix element, like a two state fit and an exponential summation fit, to isolate that ground state contribution from the noisy lattice data.

Mira: Isolating the true ground state signal from all the noise in those correlation functions is a tough job because excited states always muddy the water.

Lev: Combining those different extraction methods is smart because it mitigates dependence on any single method, which makes the final bare matrix element more reliable for running on actual hardware.

Kai: They also use an NLA inspired parametrization to control the long distance contribution when transforming those extended correlators into quasi-PDFs.

Mira: Controlling that long distance part is essential because if you don't, your reconstruction of the distributions will be dominated by things you can’t resolve on the lattice anyway.

Lev: And constraining it with a field theory motivated form means they are saying they are making a necessary theoretical assumption to stabilize the reconstruction, and we have to be careful about that assumption.

Kai: They compare results across different renormalization schemes, specifically SRI minus MOM and hybrid schemes, to see if the final result depends on which specific prescription you choose.

Mira: Checking those comparisons is vital because it tells us how much residual dependence there is left at the lattice spacing and perturbative order used.

Lev: It’s a good way to probe the robustness of this whole method, because if it's not robust across those different schemes, then we have a bigger problem.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up on "Unpolarized proton PDF with physical quark masses and large momenta", the authors show that they’ve achieved a result that is consistent with phenomenology over the range zero point two five less than x less than zero point seven five.

Mira: They also confirmed consistency across different momentum scales and schemes, which provides strong internal consistency checks on their calculation.

Lev: The main implication for us is that this lattice approach can serve as a solid benchmark for precision PDF calculations when we need to move toward real hardware.

Kai: This paper gives us a direct way to get first-principles inputs into deep inelastic scattering experiments without relying solely on the existing phenomenological fits.

Mira: It shows that with careful methodology, you can actually get results that are comparable to what global analyses provide, which is encouraging for the future of lattice QCD in this area.

Lev: We'll be watching how they push those systematic improvements because getting better control over those uncertainties is always the next big hurdle when we want to make these calculations practical.

More episodes

← Home