Hamiltonian framework for Chiral Gauge Theories on a Disk Boundary
summary
The gist
Hamiltonian framework for Chiral Gauge Theories on a Disk Boundary proposes an alternate proposal for extending gauge fields into the bulk compatible with both Hamiltonian formulation and Euclidean…
In short
The paper proposes a new method to define chiral gauge theories using a Hamiltonian framework for a disk boundary. It solves a major problem by constructing an instantaneous bulk gauge field extension, allowing for a Hamiltonian treatment and quantum simulation of these theories, overcoming limitations of previous extra-dimension approaches.
Key concepts
- Chiral Gauge Theories (CGTs)
- These are gauge theories that exhibit chirality, meaning they have different behaviors for left-handed and right-handed particles. Defining them non-perturbatively is challenging due to conflicts with discrete spacetime, which this framework aims to address.
- Hamiltonian Formulation
- This approach uses the Hamiltonian method to describe physical systems. The paper's proposal allows for a Hamiltonian treatment of Abelian CGTs and the Abelian sector of non-Abelian CGTs, enabling quantum simulation without the sign problem.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Hamiltonian framework for Chiral Gauge Theories on a Disk Boundary · Paper Radio
- Abelian chiral gauge theories on the lattice with exact gauge invariance
- A simple construction of fermion measure term in U(1) chiral lattice gauge theories with exact gauge invariance
- On the gauge invariant path-integral measure for the overlap Weyl fermions in of SO(10)
- Chiral Fermions on the Lattice through Gauge Fixing -- Perturbation Theory
- Exact lattice chiral symmetry in 2d gauge theory
- Bosonization versus the Nielsen-Ninomiya theorem
- Fermionic Villain model with exact lattice chiral symmetries
- Exactly Solvable 1+1d Chiral Lattice Gauge Theories
- Chiral Lattice Gauge Theories from Symmetry Disentanglers
- A lattice non-perturbative definition of an SO(10) chiral gauge theory and its induced standard model
- Symmetry Protected Topological States of Interacting Fermions and Bosons
- Interacting Topological Insulator and Emergent Grand Unified Theory
- Interacting Topological Superconductors and possible Origin of 16n Chiral Fermions in the Standard Model
- A Solution to the 1+1D Gauged Chiral Fermion Problem
- Chiral Lattice Fermions From Staggered Fields
- Symmetric Mass Generation
- Gapped Chiral Fermions
- Chiral symmetry and Atiyah-Patodi-Singer index theorem for staggered fermions
- Origin of fermion masses without spontaneous symmetry breaking
- Massive fermions without fermion bilinear condensates
The paper
Hamiltonian framework for Chiral Gauge Theories on a Disk Boundary · Read on arXiv
Srimoyee Sen
Department of Physics and Astronomy, Iowa State University
I propose a Hamiltonian framework for chiral gauge theories (CGT) based on an existing Euclidean formulation, that uses 2n dimensional chiral fermions on the boundary of a 2n+1 dimensional disk. In the original Euclidean formulation, boundary gauge fields were extended into the bulk using 2n + 1 dimensional gauge field equations of motion (EOM). This creates a bottleneck for constructing a Hamiltonian. I present an alternate proposal for extending the gauge fields into the bulk that is compatible with both a Hamiltonian framework and a Euclidean path integral. Applying this to Abelian gauge fields produces exact expressions of interior fields as a functional of the boundary fields, which can be directly used in a Hamiltonian formulation. Euclidean analysis of the new gauge field extension shows that it can preserve the non-perturbative content of the original construction, including the behavior of topological charge, associated chiral fermion zero modes and an absence of the strong CP problem when applied to the Standard Model. This construction opens up a route to a Hamiltonian treatment and future quantum simulation of CGTs on a disk boundary.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Lattice. The day in lattice field theory: what the simulations put on the table.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Hamiltonian framework for Chiral Gauge Theories on a Disk Boundary".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Hamiltonian framework for Chiral Gauge Theories on a Disk Boundary proposes an alternate proposal for extending gauge fields into the bulk compatible with both Hamiltonian formulation and Euclidean path integral.
Kai: This construction opens up a route to a Hamiltonian treatment and future quantum simulation of CGTs on a disk boundary.
Mira: The paper addresses the challenge of non-perturbative definition for the Standard Model due to conflicts between chiral nature and discrete spacetime, which is known as chiral gauge theories.
Kai: Attempts have used various techniques like bosonization and symmetric mass generation (SMG).
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper called "Hamiltonian framework for Chiral Gauge Theories on a Disk Boundary". It’s by Srimoyee Sen. The core idea is proposing a way to extend gauge fields into the bulk that works for both Hamiltonian formulation and Euclidean path integral.
Mira: That sounds like it addresses a big problem, Kai. We know chiral gauge theories have issues with defining them non-perturbatively because of how they interact with discrete spacetime. This paper seems to offer an alternative approach to getting around those obstacles.
Lev: I'm interested in the part where they talk about the bottleneck for the Hamiltonian formulation and how this new prescription allows interior fields to be written as a functional of the boundary gauge fields. That sounds like a direct path toward what we need for real time simulations, if it works.
Kai: Exactly. They suggest an instantaneous gauge field extension in the bulk that solves a two-n dimensional equation of motion excluding time at every instant in time, which lets us write interior gauge fields as an instantaneous functional of the boundary gauge fields.
Mira: And they say this construction can be directly used for a Hamiltonian formulation of Abelian chiral gauge theories and for the Abelian sector of non-Abelian ones. That’s a significant step because it gives us something we can actually treat with a Hamiltonian.
Lev: If we could do that, it means we could move toward quantum simulation to circumvent the sign problem that plagues Euclidean lattice Monte Carlo methods when dealing with these chiral theories.
Kai: Right. And they also focus on how this works for Abelian gauge fields specifically, producing exact expressions for interior fields as a functional of the boundary fields. That's pretty concrete stuff.
Mira: But they also address the physical features, saying that this proposal is designed to eliminate bulk gauge field singularities when the net topological charge on the boundary is zero in congruence with reference thirty-nine <ref:2610.11035#pg2,topological charge on the boundary is>.
Lev: So if we have a zero net topological charge on the boundary, there are no interior singularities, which keeps things smooth. But what happens when there's a nonzero net topological charge?
Kai: When that boundary instanton number is nonzero, the paper shows that the singularity gets pushed to the temporal boundary of the manifold. This leads to some specific zero modes we need to track in chiral fermion physics.
Mira: That’s interesting because they link it back to earlier work, saying this implies an eta prime EFT derived in thirty-nine applies even in this case, resulting in an eta prime that is not a Goldstone mode <ref:2610.11035#pg2>.
Title and authors: Lev: That’s a key point for me. If the eta' isn't a Goldstone mode there, it means all of its finite momentum modes are gapped, only the zero momentum mode stays gapless. That keeps the structure stable in some sense.
Kai: And they also look at configurations with pairs of instanton-antiinstanton separated in time—those are perfectly smooth interior gauge configurations. But if there's a net boundary instanton number, then you get ni plus nbar i approximate boundary chiral zero modes and ni minus nbar i interior mirror zero modes at the temporal boundary.
Mira: That’s a very specific prediction for the zero modes, directly analogous to an equation they mention in their work. It connects the topology on the disk to the fermion spectrum inside.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if we're building hardware, knowing exactly where these modes live—on the boundary versus in the interior—is crucial for designing any effective model we try to implement.
Kai: The paper also suggests that this framework can lead to a completely local action formulation where you implement the constraint using a Lagrange multiplier field at every interior spacetime point.
Mira: That’s something I like because it leads to the precise non-local action in equation five which allows for the mostly gapped spectrum of eta' and helps eliminate that strong CP problem we discussed earlier.
Lev: If it translates to a local action, that means we can potentially implement this structure on a lattice more cleanly than with the older formulations. But they also acknowledge that a pathway to an explicit Hamiltonian is what’s really needed for understanding real time physics.
Kai: They say the obstruction comes from the specific prescription of the annealing flow which uses the equation of motion, because that makes the gauge field at one location dependent on boundary fields at all other instants in time.
Mira: So they're proposing a different way to extend those gauge fields into the bulk that bypasses that dependency issue, and this is what allows for a natural Hamiltonian construction.
Lev: If we can get past that dependency, it’s what makes it viable for running on real hardware or at least simulating the system in a controlled environment. But they also flag their limitation: this method needs to maintain four dimensional gauge invariance of the target theory.
Kai: They also note that while they found smooth and non-singular bulk gauge fields within the weak coupling regime for the non-Abelian theory, it's only exactly for Abelian chiral gauge theories.
Mira: That's a fair point. The exact results are strong for Abelian theories, but we still need to see how robust this holds up when we move to more complex non-Abelian scenarios.
Title and authors: Lev: For the non-Abelian case, the overhead of running on real hardware would be significant if we have to manage these complex functional dependencies between time instants. That's where the error correction research gets complicated quickly.
Kai: So, to summarize, this paper proposes a Hamiltonian framework for Chiral Gauge Theories on a Disk Boundary by constructing an instantaneous gauge field extension in the bulk that is compatible with both Hamiltonian and Euclidean path integral formulations.
Mira: The main takeaway is that this approach can provide an explicit Hamiltonian for Abelian chiral gauge theories and the Abelian sector of non-Abelian ones, and it preserves physical features like the absence of singularities when boundary topological charge is zero, while also addressing the strong CP problem.
Lev: For those of us thinking about simulation, it means we have a prescription that can be used to explore generic chiral gauge theories with a Euclidean sign problem using quantum simulation.
Kai: And they are looking forward to constructing the full explicit Hamiltonian of the disk for chiral gauge theories and vectorlike theories next.
Mira: This framework also opens up avenues to exploring whether this disk boundary configuration can be compatible with the phenomenology and cosmology of our physical universe.
Lev: Before we wrap up, I just want to say that getting a functional form for interior gauge fields as unique functionals of the boundary gauge fields is a powerful numerical tool, even if implementing it on real hardware is challenging right now.
Kai: For me, the focus is on what they’ve built and measured. They showed this structure can yield smooth and non-singular bulk gauge fields within weak coupling for non-Abelian theories.
Mira: I think the most important thing is that they provided a path to understanding how the absence of the Euclidean strong CP problem on this disk construction connects to real time physics, which is what we really want to see.
Lev: If we could get a clearer picture of how these interior zero modes behave under different topological charges, it would directly inform how error correction schemes need to be designed for any chiral theory simulation.
Kai: So the paper "Hamiltonian framework for Chiral Gauge Theories on a Disk Boundary" offers an alternate proposal that overcomes the bottleneck in Hamiltonian construction by defining gauge fields as instantaneous functionals of boundary conditions.
Mira: It’s a lot of interconnected ideas, but they are all aimed at giving us a concrete way to handle chiral theories without getting stuck in the traditional Euclidean formulation roadblock.
Lev: We'll keep an eye on the next steps where they construct that full explicit Hamiltonian for vectorlike theories, because that will tell us if this framework scales up well.
The paper's summary: Kai: So this paper proposes a new way to set up Chiral Gauge Theories on a disk boundary using both Hamiltonian math and Euclidean path integral methods at once, which was previously a real problem for those theories.
Mira: Right, so it's about building a bridge between how we usually do the math for these chiral theories and the actual physical simulation we want to do later.
Lev: The core idea is this instantaneous gauge field extension in the bulk, which lets interior fields be written as an instantaneous functional of the boundary gauge fields.
Kai: Exactly, that bypasses a major bottleneck where you had to solve a two-n dimensional equation of motion excluding time at every single instant.
Mira: And they claim this construction works for both Abelian and non-Abelian chiral gauge theories, which is pretty broad.
Lev: If this works, it opens the door for quantum simulation to bypass that sign problem that plagues standard Euclidean lattice Monte Carlo methods when dealing with these chiral systems.
Kai: They also show how they keep the physics intact by eliminating bulk gauge field singularities if the net topological charge on the boundary is zero in a specific way.
Mira: That's important because it means they preserve features like the eta' behavior and avoid some of those strong CP problems we see in other constructions.
Lev: But what about when there is a nonzero net topological charge on that boundary? They show the singularity gets pushed to the temporal boundary of the manifold.
Kai: When that boundary number is non-zero, they predict interior mirror zero modes at the temporal boundary and specific chiral zero modes inside depending on whether you have instanton pairs or not.
Mira: So it connects how topology on the disk maps directly onto the fermion spectrum in the bulk, which is a pretty tight link to study.
Lev: It also suggests that this approach can lead to a completely local action formulation by using Lagrange multipliers at every interior point.
Kai: That local action leads to a specific non-local action form that helps keep the eta' spectrum mostly gapped, only leaving the zero momentum mode gapless.
Mira: That's good because it means we don't just get a mess of massless Goldstone bosons when we look at these theories.
Lev: The paper confirms they found smooth and non-singular bulk gauge fields within the weak coupling regime for the non-Abelian theory, though it’s only exact for Abelian ones.
Kai: So they've shown a consistent way to get a Hamiltonian formulation that handles these boundary constraints without immediately breaking physical principles.
Mira: The implication is they give us a prescription to explore generic Chiral Gauge Theories with quantum simulation by handling the Euclidean sign problem in a new way.
Lev: And for our hardware, knowing this functional relationship between interior and boundary fields is useful for setting up numerical solvers that could run on real systems.
Kai: The next step they mention is constructing the full explicit Hamiltonian of the disk for chiral gauge theories and vectorlike theories to see how it scales up.
Mira: So, they're moving from this proof of concept to a full simulation blueprint for these types of physics.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So we're looking at how this framework improves on previous attempts to handle chiral gauge theories on a disk boundary, focusing on what they actually managed to build and measure.
Mira: Right, so they aren't just proposing a new math trick; they are showing how their construction leads to specific physical consequences like getting rid of the strong CP problem in the right way.
Lev: One major improvement is that by using this instantaneous functional relationship for interior fields, they get a prescription that can be numerically implemented for non-Abelian theories in any dimension, even if it's only exact at weak coupling.
Kai: That’s interesting because we know we have to maintain four dimensional gauge invariance for any real theory, so the authors flagging that it's only exactly true in the weak coupling regime is a necessary caveat.
Mira: But what about the zero modes they found? They showed that when there’s a nonzero net topological charge on the boundary, you get those specific mirror zero modes inside at the temporal boundary.
Lev: That's significant because it gives us concrete things to track in simulations, telling us how many degrees of freedom are near the edge versus deep in the bulk.
Kai: And they also improved on how they handle singularities; if you have an instanton-antiinstanton pair separated in time, the interior gauge configuration is perfectly smooth, which was a problem before.
Mira: That's a big deal for phenomenology because it means we can model configurations that shouldn't have those nasty infinities everywhere.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, knowing these zero mode behaviors helps us design better error correction schemes because we know exactly what modes are sensitive to boundary conditions versus bulk dynamics.
Kai: So they’ve also shown how this construction leads to a completely local action formulation using Lagrange multipliers at every interior point, which simplifies the math structure significantly.
Mira: That local action is what lets them achieve that mostly gapped spectrum for the eta prime, meaning it doesn't introduce too many unwanted light particles into our theory.
Lev: So it moves us closer to a more tractable model for simulation, even if we still have to deal with the computational cost of those functional dependencies across time instants.
Kai: The next thing they are working on is taking this framework and building the full explicit Hamiltonian for chiral gauge theories and vectorlike theories.
Mira: That’s where we go from a proof-of-concept to actually having a usable simulator for these kinds of physics.
Conclusion: Tom: So to wrap up, this paper introduces the Hamiltonian framework for Chiral Gauge Theories on a Disk Boundary by providing a way to build explicit Hamiltonians that work with both Hamiltonian and Euclidean path integral methods.
Kai: Essentially, they found a construction where interior gauge fields are just instantaneous functionals of the boundary fields, which is what lets us write down those equations in the Hamiltonian form.
Mira: It's a method that successfully avoids some of those previous bottlenecks by solving a specific two-n dimensional equation of motion excluding time at every instant in time.
Lev: If we can get this right, it gives us a concrete prescription for quantum simulation to bypass the sign problem when looking at chiral theories.
Kai: They also showed that they can keep physical features like the absence of singularities and the correct behavior of the eta prime even when there's a nonzero net topological charge on that boundary.
Mira: That means we have a better handle on how topology on a disk relates to fermion zero modes inside, which is crucial for understanding the spectrum.
Lev: For me, the main thing is that this structure helps us design error correction schemes because we know exactly where these modes live—on the boundary versus in the interior.
Kai: So they've shown a consistent way to get a Hamiltonian formulation that handles these boundary constraints without immediately breaking physical principles.
Mira: The implication is they give us a pathway to explore generic chiral gauge theories with quantum simulation by handling the Euclidean sign problem in this new way.
Lev: We still have that caveat though, and it’s important: the exact results are strong for Abelian theories, but we need to see how robust this holds up when we move to more complex non-Abelian scenarios.
Kai: That's a fair point; the scaling and universality of this construction across different gauge groups is still something they have to nail down.
Mira: They're looking forward to constructing the full explicit Hamiltonian for chiral gauge theories and vectorlike theories next, which will tell us if this framework scales up well.
Lev: That’s where we need to focus our hardware goals; getting a working system for those full non-Abelian cases is the real test of this whole approach.
More episodes
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2606.20029-Finite-Volume Step Scaling at Fixed Truncation in (2+1)D Hamiltonian U(1) Lattice Gauge Theory
- 2603.16266-Lattice QCD study of the K*(892) resonance at the physical point
- 2607.15742-Path optimization method for the sign problem: Insights from random matrix models
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-18
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-18
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-17
- 2608.18239-Searching for symmetric mass generation with staggered fermions in four dimensions
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-17