A Minimal Quantitative Model of Perceptual Suppression and Breakthrough in Visual Rivalry
summary
The gist
When conflicting images are presented to either eye binocular fusion is disrupted Rather than experiencing a blend of both percepts, often only one eye’s image is experienced…
In short
This model quantitatively explains visual rivalry disruptions caused by conflicting images, specifically tracking continuous flash suppression (tCFS). It develops a system of four nonlinear differential equations to derive closed-form expressions for dominance and suppression durations and the degree of hysteresis between perceptual thresholds. The model successfully predicts empirically validated results, such as the symmetry in dominance and suppression durations.
Key concepts
- Visual Rivalry
- This occurs when two conflicting images are presented to both eyes simultaneously, disrupting binocular fusion. Instead of seeing a blend, one image dominates while the other is suppressed. This competition between rival images is modeled using dynamical systems theory.
- Hysteresis
- Hysteresis refers to the dependence of a system's state on its history. In this context, it means that the threshold required for a stimulus to break through suppression into awareness (breakthrough) is different from the threshold needed to be suppressed from awareness. This difference is quantified by the depth of suppression.
- Continuous Flash Suppression (tCFS)
- This paradigm involves tracking how a stimulus's dominance and suppression change continuously over time. The model analyzes how the transition between awareness and suppression behaves under these non-stationary, rapidly changing visual conditions, revealing its underlying dynamical mechanisms.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- A Minimal Quantitative Model of Perceptual Suppression and Breakthrough in Visual Rivalry · Paper Radio
The paper
A Minimal Quantitative Model of Perceptual Suppression and Breakthrough in Visual Rivalry · Read on arXiv
Centre for Complex Systems, University of Sydney, Australia · Neuroscience Research Theme, School of Medical Sciences, Faculty of Medicine and Health, University of Sydney · Centre for Vision Research, York University, Toronto · School of Mathematical and Physical Sciences, Macquarie University · Computational Neuroscience Department at Technische Universität Dresden · Department of Computational Neuroscience at Max Planck Institute for Biological Cybernetics · Discipline of Psychology Graduate School of Health, University Technology Sydney · School of Psychology, University of Sydney
When conflicting images are presented to either eye, binocular fusion is disrupted. Rather than experiencing a blend of both percepts, often only one eye's image is experienced, whilst the other is suppressed from awareness. Importantly, suppression is transient - the two rival images compete for dominance, with stochastic switches between mutually exclusive percepts occurring every few seconds with law-like regularity. From the perspective of dynamical systems theory, visual rivalry offers an experimentally tractable window into the dynamical mechanisms governing perceptual awareness. In a recently developed visual rivalry paradigm - tracking continuous flash suppression (tCFS) - it was shown that the transition between awareness and suppression is hysteretic, with a higher contrast threshold required for a stimulus to breakthrough suppression into awareness than to be suppressed from awareness. Here, we present an analytically-tractable model of visual rivalry that quantitatively explains the hysteretic transition between periods of awareness and suppression in tCFS. Grounded in the theory of neural dynamics, we derive closed-form expressions for the duration of perceptual dominance and suppression, and for the degree of hysteresis (i.e. the depth of perceptual suppression), as a function of model parameters. Finally, our model yields a series of novel behavioural predictions, the first of which - distributions of dominance and suppression durations during tCFS should be approximately equal - we empirically validate in human psychophysical data.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Genomics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest computational biology and genomics papers.
Ines: We're looking at the paper: "A Minimal Quantitative Model of Perceptual Suppression and Breakthrough in Visual Rivalry".
Marcus: Here's the gist of the paper. When conflicting images are presented to either eye binocular fusion is disrupted Rather than experiencing a blend of both percepts, often only one eye’s image is experienced, whilst the other is suppressed from awareness Suppression is transient – the two rival images compete for dominance, with stochastic switches between mutually exclusive percepts occurring every few seconds with law-like regularity From the perspective of dynamical systems theory, visual rivalry offers an experimentally tractable window into the dynamical mechanisms governing perceptual awareness In a recently developed visual rivalry paradigm – tracking continuous flash suppression (tCFS) – it was shown that the transition between awareness and suppression is hysteretic, with a higher contrast threshold required for a stimulus to breakthrough suppression into awareness than to be suppressed from awareness Here, we present an analytically-tractable model of visual rivalry that quantitatively explains the hysteretic transition between periods of awareness and suppression in tCFS Grounded in the theory of neural dynamics, we derive closed-form expressions for the duration of perceptual dominance and suppression, and for the degree of hysteresis (i.e., the depth of perceptual suppression), as a function of model parameters Finally, our model yields a series of novel behavioural predictions, the first of which – distributions of dominance and suppression durations during tCFS should be approximately equal - we empirically validate in human psychophysical data.
Ines: Model Development and Dynamics The dynamics of the model are described by a system of four nonlinear ordinary differential equations (ODEs) with reciprocal inhibition between competing monocular populations; selfadaptation; and percept-dependent stimulus contrast ramping These equations involve state variables representing the aggregate excitatory neural activity of orientation-selective monocular populations driven by the mask and stimulus (denoted by the subscripts M and S respectively), and the aggregate slow hyperpolarising adaptation current of each population.
Marcus: The model incorporates reciprocal inhibition between competing monocular populations; selfadaptation; and percept-dependent stimulus contrast ramping For analytic tractability, the transfer function is a simple threshold nonlinearity f(x) = max(x, 0).
Ines: The parameters ε, a, and g are dimensionless and represent the strength of recurrent excitation, competitive inhibition, and adaptation, respectively.
Title and authors: Marcus: The title itself, "A Minimal Quantitative Model of Perceptual Suppression and Breakthrough in Visual Rivalry," suggests they are aiming for something foundational rather than just adding another layer to existing theories.
Ines: They're trying to create the simplest possible mathematical structure that still captures the key features we see in these rivalry experiments, like when a stimulus finally breaks through suppression into awareness.
Yuki: I wonder what that "minimal" model actually means in practice, does it simplify the biology too much to be useful, or is it just focusing on the core competition mechanism?
Marcus: It seems they are using continuous flash suppression tracking, tCFS, as their setup because it captures those periods of suppression and awareness during a dynamic contrast situation.
Ines: In tCFS, one eye gets a high-contrast mask while the target stimulus in the other eye changes its contrast linearly based on what you report seeing. This setup allows them to measure thresholds for both breakthrough and suppression.
Yuki: So they are using this continuous dynamic stimulus rather than static images to probe these dynamical mechanisms, which is a big step because static rivalry is already well understood in some ways.
Marcus: The paper shows that the estimates they get at those points of suppression and breakthrough actually serve as threshold estimates for both awareness and suppression. This is useful for quantifying the dynamics.
Ines: They also mention that they make these estimates quickly so that the effect of adaptation is reduced, which helps keep the model tractable. This is a key engineering choice in their setup to isolate other effects.
Yuki: So they are trying to find a way to measure those thresholds without the system getting too bogged down by slow biological processes, like adaptation.
The paper's summary: Ines: What the paper really summarizes is that their model quantitatively explains the hysteretic transition between periods of awareness and suppression in tCFS. This means there's a difference between what it takes to break out of suppression versus what it takes to get suppressed in the first place.
Marcus: Hysteresis is a crucial finding here because it means the contrast threshold for breakthrough isn't the same as the threshold for being suppressed; you have different barriers depending on your perceptual history.
Yuki: That sounds like a real-world consequence, because it implies that how you've experienced these stimuli before shapes how you react to new ones.
Ines: Right, and they show that this degree of hysteresis depends on the rate of contrast change; faster changes in contrast lead to bigger differences between those two thresholds.
Marcus: They derive closed-form expressions for both the duration of dominance and suppression, and also for the depth of this hysteresis as a function of their model parameters like recurrent excitation strength, competitive inhibition, and adaptation.
Yuki: The idea that the depth of hysteresis is related to how long you've been in either state gives a nice link between dynamics and history.
Ines: They even find a symmetry in the results: the distributions for dominance and suppression durations should be approximately equal, which they have validated against human psychophysical data.
The paper's improvements: Marcus: One of the major improvements suggested by this work is the derivation of closed-form expressions for dominance and suppression duration that are written in terms of the Lambert W function, or product log function.
Ines: That means they can predict how long a state lasts just by plugging in the model parameters, instead of running a full simulation every single time. That’s really powerful for testing hypotheses computationally.
Yuki: It also suggests that these exact solutions provide an excellent fit to the durations derived from numerical simulations across the entire range of contrast rates, which validates their mathematical approach against other methods.
Marcus: They also use these expressions to show a trade-off between the opposing effects of contrast rate on those durations; increasing the rate shortens time but increases the gap between breakthrough and suppression thresholds.
Ines: So they're using this math to show that adaptation has an additive effect on breakthrough threshold but a subtractive effect on suppression threshold, and these two effects work against each other.
Yuki: That’s a neat way to quantify how different dynamical factors—the stationary competition versus the time-dependent adaptation—interact in shaping the perceptual experience.
Conclusion: Marcus: So, to wrap up, this paper provides a quantitative account of awareness and suppression in tCFS by deriving closed-form expressions for dominance and suppression periods and the depth of hysteresis between breakthrough and suppression thresholds.
Ines: The main contribution is explaining this effect quantitatively by framing it in terms of the trade-off between stationary effects from inhibition and external drive, versus time-dependent effects from adaptation.
Yuki: It confirms that these dynamical principles are likely going to be relevant for other rivalry paradigms beyond just tCFS, giving insight into a much wider range of how competing perceptions might arise.
Marcus: And they validated one of their novel predictions: the symmetry between periods of dominance and suppression durations is approximately equal, which they found in human psychophysical data.
Ines: So, this work gives us a quantitative tool to understand the mechanisms governing awareness and suppression in continuous flash suppression, moving beyond just observing the phenomena.
More episodes
- 2610.33881-Sensorimotor behavior from an untrained brain-and-nerve-cord connectome
- 2610.40344-Morphological Features of Murine Pulmonary Arterial Networks for Diagnosing Vascular Disease
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2609.10193-Are You Learning Biological Signal or Shortcuts? Auditing and Mitigating Bias in Protein-Protein Interaction Datasets
- 2610.38236-Generative discovery of chemical reaction networks
- 2507.11176-An Interpretable AI framework Quantifying Traditional Chinese Medicine Principles Towards Enhancing and Integrating with Modern Biomedicine
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-19
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2504.03590-Towards a Unified Framework for Determining Conformational Ensembles of Disordered Proteins
- 2603.15217-A multiscale discrete-to-continuum framework for structured population models