Spins do not add: why rotating stars do not help spin-up black holes in binaries

summary

The gist

Spins do not add: why rotating stars do not help spin-up black holes in binaries is shown in this paper because it demonstrates that in black hole–neutron star binaries…

In short

Simulations of black hole-neutron star (BHNS) binaries show that a neutron star's spin does not help spin up the final black hole; instead, the final BH spin decreases as the NS spin increases. This is due to non-linear dynamics during tidal disruption, where angular momentum is lost through dynamical ejecta and accretion disks.

Key concepts

Tidal Disruption Events (TDE)
When a compact object like a neutron star passes too close to a black hole, the intense gravitational forces stretch and tear the star apart. This process creates a large amount of matter that forms an accretion disk, which significantly affects the subsequent evolution of both objects.
Angular Momentum Loss via Dynamical Ejecta
During tidal disruption, the interaction between the orbiting objects causes a substantial loss of orbital angular momentum. This loss is primarily carried away by 'dynamical ejecta'—material violently flung out from the system during the merger process, which dictates how much spin is transferred to the final black hole.
Spin-Orbit Coupling
This describes the physical interaction between a rotating object (like a neutron star) and its gravitational field. In this study, strong spin-orbit coupling causes tidal disruption to occur at larger radii for rapidly rotating stars, leading to more material being ejected and influencing the final remnant's properties.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Spins do not add: why rotating stars do not help spin-up black holes in binaries · Read on arXiv

Institut fur Theoretische Physik, Goethe Universit¨ at · Hamburg Observatory, Department of Physics, University of Hamburg · Frankfurt Institute for Advanced Studies · School of Mathematics, Trinity College, Dublin

It is well-known that in the merger of a black-hole binary with spins aligned with the orbital angular momentum, the spin of the final black hole always increases with the spin of the components. We show that this very intuitive behavior is violated in black hole--neutron star binaries, where the spin of the final black hole actually decreases as the spin of the neutron star increases. Using a large set of binaries with different spins and mass ratios, we identify the mechanism behind this surprising result in the nonlinear dynamics of the tidal disruption, which drives a substantial loss of angular momentum via dynamical ejecta, in some cases comparable to that radiated via gravitational waves. Our results highlight that the spin evolution of stellar-mass black holes involved in binary mergers is different from what normally assumed, far more complex, and interesting.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Spins do not add".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Spins do not add: why rotating stars do not help spin-up black holes in binaries is shown in this paper because it demonstrates that in black hole–neutron star binaries, the spin of the final black hole actually decreases as the spin of the neutron star increases.

Kai: The core finding The central result is that for BHNS binaries with comparable masses, the spin of the final BH decreases as the NS spin increases, which violates a previously intuitive behavior observed in black hole–black-hole binaries where the final spin always increases with component spins.

Mira: This surprising result is driven by nonlinear dynamics during tidal disruption, which causes a substantial loss of angular momentum through dynamical ejecta.

Kai: The authors identify this mechanism as the reason for the observed spin evolution in BHNS mergers.

Title and authors: Kai: So we’re looking at this paper titled "Spins do not add: why rotating stars do not help spin-up black holes in binaries," and the authors are Camilloni, Topolski, Miler, and Rezzolla. They're tackling that really intuitive idea that when you have a black hole and a neutron star merging, the final spin of the black hole just gets bigger based on how fast those components were spinning.

Mira: That intuition comes from binary black hole mergers where it's been measured almost twenty years ago, and in those cases, the final black hole spin always increases with the component spins >

Kai: But this paper shows that this is actually violated in black hole neutron star binaries, where the final black hole spin actually decreases as the neutron star spin increases >

Lev: That's a big shift because it means we can't just rely on those simpler models for these specific systems.

Mira: The core finding they highlight is that this isn't just some weird fluke; it’s driven by the nonlinear dynamics during tidal disruption, which causes a substantial loss of angular momentum through dynamical ejecta >

Kai: So what does that mean practically? It suggests that when those stars interact during a tidal disruption event, there’s a massive amount of angular momentum being blown away in the form of ejected material.

Lev: Yeah, and for real hardware, running simulations like this on a real computer would be tough because you need to capture all that messy fluid dynamics >

Mira: They set up a parameter space focusing on binaries with comparable masses and they use sixteen different BHNS binaries representing a large campaign with realistic equations of state, magnetic fields, and rapid stellar rotation > <ref:2611.14610#pg2>

Kai: They constrain the compactness C by requiring some quantity xi to be greater than or equal to one, which really forces them to use stiffer equations of state like the DD2 EOS >

Lev: That stiff EOS requirement means they're looking at neutron stars with relatively low maximum masses, around one point five solar masses for that constraint > <ref:2611.14610#pg2>

Mira: And they found that for these BHNS binaries with comparable masses, the spin of the final black hole decreases as the NS spin increases, which is exactly what we expected to be wrong >

Kai: But it’s important to note this isn't just about the final mass; it’s about how much angular momentum gets lost during that disruption process >

Mira: They use numerical infrastructure where the neutron star spin significantly affects how much rest mass is outside the apparent horizon, and for rapidly rotating stars, this means stellar disruption happens at larger radii due to a lower stellar compactness and a repulsive spin-orbit interaction >

Title and authors: Lev: That spreading of matter seems to be what causes that significant loss of angular momentum through ejecta that they mention >

Kai: And it leads to the formation of magnetized accretion disks with mass greater than zero point one solar masses, which is enough material to power relativistic jets and short gamma-ray bursts >

Mira: They then compute the final black hole mass and spin using quasi-local measurements at a reference time of t equal to tmer plus ten milliseconds >

Kai: The total angular momentum decomposition shows that the NS spin doesn't actually help spin up the black hole remnants because the net orbital angular momentum imparted to the remnant is smaller due to more compact black holes radiating orbital angular momentum >

Lev: And looking at it on longer timescales, even with disk accretion, they suggest that spins do not add in BHNS mergers, showing that nonrotating NS remnants have larger spins than those with rapidly rotating NSs >

Kai: They also introduced spin corrections to the remnant baryon mass using an improved expression which accounts for the different compactness accompanying rapidly rotating stars >

Mira: That correction compensates for a systematic underestimation in previous fits, showing that the best fit value for epsilon is close to what we predict from quasiuniversal relations >

Lev: So if you're trying to build real hardware, you'd need to be careful with how you estimate those remnant properties because of that correction term >

Kai: The paper also suggests that neutron stars with anti-aligned spins might produce even larger final spins, which is a point worth looking into for future work >

Mira: They extracted the gravitational wave signals from the Weyl scalar psi four on a spherical surface and decomposed them using spinweighted spherical harmonics, where the dominant mode is l equals two and m equals two >

Lev: The waveforms show a long inspiral with a large number of cycles, which makes them suitable for constructing hybrid waveform models to extend the signal in the inspiral phase >

Kai: The aligned NS spins cause a shift in the gravitational wave phase and a tendency to increase the number of gravitational wave cycles, which is consistent with that repulsive spin-orbit coupling >

Mira: Overall, this paper presents what they call their first campaign of numerical relativity simulations systematically investigating black hole spin-up in low-mass BHNS binaries experiencing tidal disruption >

Kai: The most interesting finding is that in BHNS binaries, the spin of the NS does not help spin up BH remnants, which is due to the non-additivity of spins and the crucial role played by matter dynamics in tidal disruptions >

Title and authors: Lev: So they conclude that the spin-up of BH remnants is quenched by a good fraction of angular momentum remaining in the plasma outside the horizon due to strong dynamical ejecta and accretion disks >

Mira: The conclusion is that for all mass ratios, the NS spin does not help spin up BH remnants, with the fastest-spinning black hole remnants descending from irrotational neutron star progenitors and reaching final spins even larger than those of equivalent binary black hole systems >

Kai: The physical origin they found is in the analysis of the angular momentum budget, which reveals that spin-orbit interaction and proximity to the mass-shedding limit lead to large tidal disruption radii, causing significant orbital angular momentum loss via ejection >

Lev: This effect is a qualitative reversal reflecting matter dynamics and spin-orbit coupling in low-mass BHNS systems undergoing tidal disruption >

Kai: The implications are numerous, impacting population synthesis studies and the modeling of multimessenger observations where remnant black hole spins have been incorrectly estimated >

Mira: We're done with this paper, but this work sets a new baseline for how we should model the final state of these mergers because it corrects those estimates >

Lev: For me, as someone building error-correction hardware, knowing that the spin evolution is dominated by those tidal disruption dynamics gives us a better picture of the complexity we need to handle >

Kai: Definitely. It means when we model these events, we can't just look at the initial spins and assume they add up; we have to account for all that messy matter ejection >

Mira: Exactly. And this opens up avenues for us to predict electromagnetic counterparts more accurately because it shows the kilonova gets brighter due to larger ejecta mass linked to the NS spin, and a putative jet can be dimmer due to lower remnant spin >

Lev: That's a concrete link between the dynamics and what we observe in light, which is really useful for connecting the simulations back to telescopes >

Kai: So that’s where we are with this paper on "Spins do not add: why rotating stars do not help spin-up black holes in binaries," showing how matter dynamics quench black hole spin-up in these specific mergers.

Mira: And it's a complex picture where the NS spin doesn't help the BH, and it’s driven by those large tidal disruption radii causing angular momentum loss >

Lev: It really highlights that for low-mass systems undergoing tidal disruption, you can't use the simple intuition from black hole binary mergers >

Kai: Yeah, it shifts our modeling focus toward the full three-body dynamics of these interactions during the merger phase >

The paper's summary: Kai: So, what we're looking at now is summarizing this paper called "Spins do not add: why rotating stars do not help spin-up black holes in binaries."

Mira: Right. Basically, the main point is that for black hole neutron star systems, the spin of the neutron star actually makes it harder for the black hole to spin up.

Lev: So, if you have a spinning neutron star and a spinning black hole together, it doesn't lead to that simple idea where both spins just add up to make the final black hole go faster.

Kai: Exactly. The paper shows that this isn't just some simple addition of angular momentum. It's driven by how the stars interact during the tidal disruption process.

Mira: That loss of angular momentum happens because of a lot of messy stuff—dynamical ejecta and those accretion disks that form around the black hole.

Lev: So, think about it this way: instead of just feeding spin into the black hole, a good chunk of its orbital angular momentum gets blown out by that tidal interaction.

Kai: Right. And because the final black hole is radiating that orbital angular momentum away, it ends up with less net spin than if the neutron star were not spinning at all.

Mira: They also looked at long-term evolution over time, even after those initial merger events are over on viscous accretion timescales.

Lev: That's interesting because it suggests that even if you have a nonrotating neutron star, its remnant black hole will end up with a larger spin than one formed from a rapidly rotating neutron star.

Kai: The authors used some spin corrections to account for how the shape and compactness of the neutron star change when it's spinning fast.

Mira: They found that these corrections are important because they fix an underestimation in earlier fits, bringing them closer to what theory predicts for those types of systems.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this means if you're trying to build a model for the final remnant mass and spin, you need to include that correction term based on the stellar rotation.

Kai: And they also pointed out that if the neutron star spins in an anti-aligned way with the black hole, it might actually lead to even larger final black hole spins.

Mira: It really emphasizes how crucial those detailed dynamics are when you move away from simpler binary black hole models and look at these low-mass systems experiencing tidal disruption.

Lev: It makes you realize that for these specific mergers, the matter itself, not just the initial spins, is really dictating the final spin outcome.

Kai: So what this means for us listening to this show is that when we model a black hole and a neutron star merger, we have to stop assuming simple spin addition and start accounting for all that mass ejection and disk formation.

Mira: And this also helps us predict the electromagnetic side of things better because the amount of material ejected influences how bright the kilonova gets, which is linked to that neutron star spin.

Lev: It's a complex picture where the NS spin doesn't always help, and it’s all about those large tidal disruption radii causing angular momentum loss.

Kai: We'll talk more about how this affects gravitational wave signals in our next segment.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, we're moving on to how these researchers are improving their models of BHNS mergers based on what they found in this paper.

Mira: Essentially, they've taken their initial findings and added some corrections that make the predictions more accurate for real-world scenarios.

Lev: What does that look like for us building hardware? Are we talking about better simulation fidelity or just tighter constraints on the inputs?

Kai: It's both. They introduced an improved expression for the remnant baryon mass, which they call Eq. three, that accounts for how different the neutron star's compactness is when it's spinning fast.

Mira: That correction term really fixes a systematic underestimation in previous fits to their data because it aligns better with what we predict from quasiuniversal relations.

Lev: For us on the hardware side, that means our error analysis for estimating those remnant properties gets much tighter; the uncertainty drops significantly when you use that improved expression instead of the older one.

Kai: And they also have some ideas about how to push this further, like looking at anti-aligned spins for neutron stars.

Mira: That's a good direction because it suggests that those configurations might actually produce even larger final spins for the black hole remnant.

Lev: If we were trying to run these simulations on real hardware, incorporating that anti-aligned spin possibility would add complexity to the error correction algorithms we'd need.

Kai: They also have implications for how we look at the gravitational wave signals themselves, using spinweighted spherical harmonics and focusing on that two by two mode.

Mira: Those waveforms show a long inspiral with many cycles, which makes them really useful for building hybrid waveform models that extend the signal well into the inspiral phase.

Lev: So, when we're designing those waveform models, knowing that the spin-orbit coupling causes a shift in those phases and an increase in cycles helps us predict how to track that evolution accurately.

Kai: Overall, these improvements help refine our understanding of what happens during a tidal disruption event before we even get to the final merger.

Mira: It shows that the physics isn't just about the initial setup; it's about how those two components interact dynamically over time.

Lev: So, moving forward, this work sets a better benchmark for how we should be modeling these complex interactions in our error correction software and waveform templates.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up, we're looking at how this paper "Spins do not add: why rotating stars do not help spin-up black holes in binaries" fundamentally changes how we model these mergers.

Mira: The core message is that for black hole neutron star systems undergoing tidal disruption, the neutron star spin doesn't help the final black hole get spun up.

Lev: It's a major point because it means we can stop relying on simpler models where both spins just add together to predict the final result.

Kai: They show that this isn't due to a simple effect; it comes from the way matter dynamics, like strong dynamical ejecta and accretion disks, actually take away angular momentum during disruption.

Mira: Exactly. The paper explains that these dynamic processes quench the spin-up of the remnant black hole because so much orbital angular momentum is lost through that ejected material.

Lev: If we're talking about building real hardware, this tells us we can't just focus on the initial spins; we have to account for all that messy fluid dynamics during the event.

Kai: They also highlighted how these findings affect our predictions for electromagnetic counterparts, like kilonovae brightness and jet power.

Mira: Right. The amount of ejected material is linked to that neutron star spin, so a rotating neutron star can actually lead to a brighter kilonova than you'd expect based on spin alone.

Lev: It's important because it connects the astrophysics directly to what we observe with telescopes, linking the simulation results back to real light signals.

Kai: Ultimately, this paper shows that for these specific systems experiencing tidal disruption, the spin-up of a black hole is quenched by a good fraction of angular momentum remaining in the plasma outside its horizon.

Mira: The conclusion is that for all mass ratios, the neutron star spin does not help spin up those final black hole remnants, even more so than in binary black hole mergers.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, this means our models need to be very careful about how they estimate that angular momentum budget during the merger phase.

Kai: It's a detailed picture where the NS spin doesn't help the BH, and it’s driven by those large tidal disruption radii causing angular momentum loss.

Mira: It really highlights that for low-mass systems undergoing tidal disruption, you can't use the simple intuition from binary black hole mergers.

Lev: We need to keep pushing on these dynamical effects because that's where the real complexity lies when we try to simulate this stuff on a computer.

Kai: So, this paper "Spins do not add: why rotating stars do not help spin-up black holes in binaries" gives us a much more nuanced way to think about the final state of these mergers.

Mira: It's complex physics where the NS spin doesn't always help, and it’s driven by those large tidal disruption radii causing angular momentum loss.

Lev: And it shifts our modeling focus toward the full three-body dynamics of these interactions during the merger phase.

More episodes

← Home