On Legacy of Starobinsky Inflation

summary

The gist

Alexei Alexandrovich Starobinsky was one of the greatest cosmologists who made fundamental contributions to gravitational theory and cosmology based on geometrical ideas in physics…

In short

This paper systematically reviews Starobinsky inflation, a geometrical model of cosmology based on modified gravity. It explores extensions to include primordial black hole production, quantum corrections from superstring theory and the Swampland Program, and universal reheating mechanisms. The review assesses its consistency with modern theoretical constraints and predicts observable cosmological parameters.

Key concepts

Starobinsky Inflation Model
This is a specific type of modified gravity theory where the action is a combination of Einstein-Hilbert gravity and a quadratic term in the Ricci scalar curvature (R). It serves as a simple, geometrical framework for describing the period of rapid expansion in the early universe.
Primordial Black Holes (PBH) Production
This deformation suggests that by engineering the function F(R) in modified gravity, large density perturbations during inflation can collapse gravitationally to form PBHs. The model predicts asteroid-sized black holes, which could be observable through specific CMB signatures.
Swampland Program
This set of conjectures in quantum gravity suggests constraints on effective field theories derived from string theory. It implies that certain features, like the absence of global symmetries or the weak-gravity conjecture, might rule out models like Starobinsky inflation when viewed through a quantum gravity lens.
Universal Reheating Mechanism
This mechanism describes how energy from the inflationary phase is transferred into particles after inflation ends. When coupled to Starobinsky gravity, it predicts a specific reheating temperature around $10^9$ GeV, which sets the stage for subsequent particle production and baryogenesis.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

On Legacy of Starobinsky Inflation · Read on arXiv

Sergei V. Ketov

Tokyo Metropolitan University · Tomsk State University · Kavli Institute for the Physics and Mathematics of the Universe (WPI)

Alexei Alexandrovich Starobinsky was one of the greatest cosmologists of all times, who made fundamental contributions to gravitational theory and cosmology based on geometrical ideas in physics, in the spirit of Einstein. One of his big achievements is the famous Starobinsky model of cosmological inflation in the early universe, proposed in 1979-1980. In this memorial paper, the Starobinsky inflation model is systematically reviewed from the modern perspective. Its deformation to include production of primordial black holes is proposed, and possible quantum corrections in the context of superstring theory and the Swampland Program are discussed. Starobinsky inflation also leads to the universal reheating mechanism for particle production after inflation.

DOI: 10.1007/978-3-032-15703-4_1

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "On Legacy of Starobinsky Inflation".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Alexei Alexandrovich Starobinsky was one of the greatest cosmologists who made fundamental contributions to gravitational theory and cosmology based on geometrical ideas in physics, in the spirit of Einstein In this memorial paper, the Starobinsky inflation model is systematically reviewed from the modern perspective Its deformation to include production of primordial black holes is proposed, and possible quantum corrections in the context of superstring theory and the Swampland Program are discussed Starobinsky inflation also leads to the universal reheating mechanism for particle production after inflation Review of the Starobinsky Inflation Model The Starobinsky model of inflation is described as a generally covariant and non-perturbative modified gravity theory whose Lagrangian is a sum of two terms, the Einstein-Hilbert (EH) term and the term quadratic in the Ricci scalar curvature R with a positive coefficient All the curvature-dependent terms beyond the EH one are irrelevant in the Solar system, while they may also be negligible during reheating after inflation in the weak-gravity regime The Starobinsky model can be treated as a particular example of modified F(R) gravity theories that are geometrical because only gravitational interactions or General Relativity (GR) are used The action SStar is given by SStar.

Kai: = α Z d 4x √−gR2 + M2 Pl 2 Z d 4x √−gR, where α ≡ M2 Pl 12M2, (1) Deformation and Primordial Black Hole Production A phenomenological deformation of the Starobinsky inflation model in the framework of modified F(R) gravity is given to accommodate production of primordial black holes (PBH) during inflation This extension involves engineering the function F(R) leading to a near-inflection point in the inflaton potential below the scale of inflation, resulting in large density perturbations whose gravitational collapse leads to production of primordial black holes (PBH) The model is an extension of the singularity-free ApplebyBattye-Starobinsky (ABS) model with other parameters whose fine-tuning leads to efficient production of PBH having asteroid-size masses between 10 16 g and 10 20 g The CMB observables with the model best fit are given by ns ≈ 0.965, r ≈ 0.0095, MPBH ≈ 1.0 · 10 20 g Quantum Corrections and Swampland Conjectures The basic conjectures of the Swampland Program are briefly discussed in application to Starobinsky inflation No global symmetries in quantum gravity claims that only local (or gauge) symmetries are possible in quantum gravity The weak-gravity conjecture is argued not to be contradicted because, in the Einstein frame, Starobinsky inflation is mainly due to the inflaton selfinteraction described by the scalar potential The no-de-Sitter conjecture is destabilized by higher-order terms with respect to the spacetime curvature, which are certainly present in any UV-completion of the Starobinsky action The distance conjecture imposes constraints on the inflaton range ∆φ during inflation and, hence, on the CMB tensor-to-scalar ratio r Quantum Gravity and String Theory Implications Superstring theory is a good candidate for the theory of quantum gravity to provide an UV completion of the Starobinsky model The leading (α′)3-correction beyond the EH term in closed (type II) superstrings is given by terms quartic in the space-time curvature Combining the Starobinsky model with the GZ correction gets the StarobinskyGrisaru-Zanon (SGZ) gravity defined by the action SSGZ

g: = M2 Pl 2 Z d 4x √−g R + 1/6M2 R squared − 72γ M6 Z, where the GZ superstring correction reads

79: 72Z = R µρσνRλρστ + 1/2R µνρσRλτ ρσ R αβλ µ R τ αβν (36) Demanding the absence of ghosts and negative energy fluxes implies the upper bound γ ≤ 1.12 × 10−6 Universal Reheating Mechanism Starobinsky inflation also implies the universal reheating mechanism, as an additional bonus, when matter is coupled to Starobinsky gravity in the Jordan frame Reheating took place after inflation but before the Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) and radiation domination The reheating temperature after Starobinsky inflation is given by Treh ∝ s MPlΓtotal (10 9 GeV) The specific predictions of Starobinsky inflation for the cosmological tilts are dependent upon the e-folds number N∗ that is also affected by the amount of reheating at the end of inflation Should those measurements confirm Eq.

Mira: (23), this would be a triumph of Starobinsky inflation The Starobinsky model is just the simplest large-single-field model of inflation, which has solid theoretical motivation and well fits the current CMB measurements 45 years after the pioneering paper

38: There exist no obstruction toward generalizations of single-field models to multi-field models of inflation preferred by supergravity and string theory Should the primordial non-Gaussianity be detected, it would be another crucial test of Starobinsky inflation because a contribution of the nonlinear (NL) 3-point correlation function of primordial curvature perturbations to the amplitude of primordial non-Gaussianity is fixed by the Maldacena relation fNL = 5/12(1−ns) in all single-field models of inflation

98: The upcoming CMB measurements by CORE Collaboration

91: , S4 Collaboration

92: , LiteBIRD Collaboration

93: , NASA PICO Collaboration

94: , the Simons Observatory survey

95: and EUCLID Collaboration

96: are expected to probe the tensor-to-scalar ratio r in the range of 10−3 and improve the precision value of ns The Starobinsky model is sensitive to quantum ultra-violet (UV) corrections because of its high inflation scale and the inflaton field values near the Planck scale during inflation Acknowledgements The author (SVK) is grateful to Ignatios Antoniadis, Robert Brandenberger, Michael Duff, Gia Dvali and Dmitry Gorbunov for discussions SVK was supported by Tokyo Metropolitan University, the Japanese Society for Promotion of Science under the grant No.

Kai: 22K03624, the World Premier International Research Center Initiative (MEXT, Japan), and Tomsk State University References

1: S.

Title and authors: Kai: The paper starts by just naming the focus: "On Legacy of Starobinsky Inflation," and it brings Alexei Alexandrovich Starobinsky back into a modern discussion.

Mira: It’s important because he was this foundational figure in using geometrical ideas to build inflation, so looking at his legacy is essential for understanding where we are now.

Lev: I mostly wonder how they handle the transition from that old picture to what we actually can measure with current tools, you know, real experimental constraints.

Kai: Exactly. Mira and I were looking at the authors—Ketov and Starobinsky—and it shows this deep connection between theoretical cosmology and the actual quantum gravity stuff we deal with in our labs every day.

Mira: It really highlights how theoretical models like this one don't exist in a vacuum; they have to interface with things like string theory and the Swampland Program to be meaningful today.

Lev: Yeah, because if you’re building real error correction hardware, you need those constraints on the effective field theory stuff, not just beautiful math that works in a vacuum.

The paper's summary: Kai: The paper summarizes the Starobinsky inflation model by explaining it as this generally covariant and non-perturbative modified gravity theory.

Mira: They point out the Lagrangian is just two terms: the standard Einstein-Hilbert term, and this quadratic term in the Ricci scalar curvature R with a positive coefficient.

Lev: It makes sense that they stress that all those higher curvature terms beyond the EH one are irrelevant in our Solar system, but they might be important during reheating after inflation when gravity is weak.

Kai: Right, and they frame it as a specific example of modified F(R) gravity because it only uses gravitational interactions or General Relativity.

Mira: They then introduce this deformation to include the production of primordial black holes during inflation, which they link to engineering the function F(R) to create a near-inflection point in the inflaton potential.

Lev: Primordial black holes—that’s a big extension—so they’re looking at how that specific modification affects the density perturbations and what kind of asteroid-size masses we might see, between one hundred sextillion grams and two hundred quintillion grams.

The paper's improvements: Kai: They suggest some real improvements to this model, specifically looking at how to fit in primordial black hole production within the modified F(R) gravity framework.

Mira: This extension is described as building on the singularity-free ApplebyBattye-Starobinsky model by adding other parameters that fine-tune the process for efficient production of these PBHs.

Lev: So, when you talk about those asteroid-size masses, that means we’re talking about a very specific window for gravitational collapse during inflation. That needs a lot of tuning to get right.

Kai: And it connects this to CMB observables by giving some specific values they found fit well, like the scalar tilt ns being approximately zero point nine six five and the tensor-to-scalar ratio r around zero point zero zero nine five.

Mira: Those are concrete numbers that help test the model against what we see in cosmic microwave background data.

Lev: But I want to ask about those numbers—how do you translate those specific e-fold number predictions into actual hardware constraints for running any kind of inflation simulation, Kai.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up the "On Legacy of Starobinsky Inflation" paper, they emphasize that if we confirm these specific CMB measurements, like the scalar tilt ns being around zero point nine six five and r around zero point zero zero nine five, it would be a big win for this model.

Mira: They also mention that primordial non-Gaussianity is another crucial test because of the Maldacena relation, which fixes the contribution of the nonlinear three-point correlation function to primordial non-Gaussianity at five over twelve minus ns in all single-field models.

Lev: That’s a strong constraint, linking those early universe features directly to how we model non-linearities in perturbation theory. But I wonder if that relation holds up when you introduce the quantum gravity corrections we discussed earlier.

Kai: They also touch on the impact of quantum ultra-violet corrections because the high inflation scale and inflaton field values near the Planck scale during inflation mean this model is sensitive to those high-energy effects.

Mira: And they explore superstring theory as a good candidate for this, looking at how string corrections, like the leading alpha prime correction being quartic in spacetime curvature, combine with the Starobinsky model to create something called SGZ gravity.

Lev: That leads us into some very specific constraints on parameters—demanding that the ghost-free metric-affine parity-violating scalar-torsion theory has an upper bound on gamma of one point one two times ten to the minus six.

Kai: And they also discuss the universal reheating mechanism, which means after inflation, matter couples to this Starobinsky gravity and you get particle production before Big Bang Nucleosynthesis.

Mira: The predicted reheating temperature Treh is around ten to nine gigaevels, which gives us a specific energy scale for generating the initial conditions for baryogenesis and dark matter abundance.

Lev: So they’ve given us the classical prediction, but I wonder how much that temperature calculation depends on the amount of reheating at the end of inflation; it seems like a bit sensitive.

More episodes

← Home