Classical tests of New General Relativity

summary

The gist

In New General Relativity (NGR), the static spherically symmetric vacuum solution is characterized by two parameters, unlike General Relativity (GR)…

In short

This work derives an exact static spherically symmetric vacuum solution for New General Relativity (NGR), a teleparallel generalization of GR, characterized by a second parameter, k. By testing five classical gravitational phenomena—perihelion precession, light bending, Shapiro time delay, de Sitter geodetic precession, and gravitational redshift—the study finds that NGR is consistent with observations. The most precise constraint derived for the parameter $k-2$ is $(1.8 ext{ to } 1.8) imes 10^{-5}$, suggesting NGR differs from Schwarzschild only at higher orders.

Key concepts

New General Relativity (NGR)
NGR is a specific modification of Einstein's General Relativity based on teleparallelism, using a Weitzenböck connection instead of the standard metric. It introduces three arbitrary constants, which are constrained by classical gravitational tests to determine the theory's behavior.
Torsion Scalar
The torsion scalar is a mathematical quantity derived from the geometry of NGR. In this model, it is defined by specific combinations of parameters (c, d, f', g') and relates to how the spacetime manifold deviates from standard Riemannian geometry.
Classical Gravitational Tests
These are five observable phenomena used to test theories of gravity against reality: perihelion precession (orbit shift), light bending (deflection of light), Shapiro time delay (delay in signals passing near a mass), de Sitter geodetic precession, and gravitational redshift. These tests compare NGR predictions against General Relativity's predictions.
Parameter k
The solution to the vacuum field equations in NGR contains a dimensionless parameter $k$. When $k = ext{±}2$, the solution simplifies back to the standard Schwarzschild metric, meaning $k$ quantifies how much NGR deviates from GR.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Classical tests of New General Relativity · Read on arXiv

V. P. Vandeev, V. A. Parkhomenko, A. N. Semenova, M. A. Matveev

Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute of National Research Centre “Kurchatov Institute” · Faculty of Physics, St Petersburg State University

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Classical tests of New General Relativity".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. In New General Relativity (NGR), the static spherically symmetric vacuum solution is characterized by two parameters, unlike General Relativity (GR), where the Schwarzschild solution has only one parameter In this work, using the five classical tests of relativistic gravity (perihelion precession, light bending, Shapiro time delay and de Sitter geodetic precession effect, as well as gravitational redshift), a more stringent constraint on the value of the second parameter was derived compared to the original work

1: One of the approaches to modifying Einstein’s General Relativity (GR) is teleparallelism

2: ,

3: , where the spacetime manifold is endowed with a Weitzenb¨ock connection In this work, we will consider the simplest generalization of TEGR, the so-called New General Relativity (NGR), where three arbitrary constants arise, whose values will be estimated using classical gravitational tests Simplicity of NGR is based on the fact that all torsion scalars in the action are even and the equations of motion contain no derivatives higher than second order This approach allows to modify not General Relativity (or the Einstein-Hilbert action) directly, as theories like f(R)

4: or Gauss-Bonnet gravity

5: , but its teleparallel equivalent based on non-Riemannian geometry Derivation of the Field Equations The generalized Einstein tensor defined in (11) for arbitrary a, b, c generally possesses an antisymmetric part It is useful to note that if additional matter fields are present in action (9), the right-hand side of equation (11) acquires an energymomentum tensor The vacuum equation obtained by varying action (9) with respect to the tetrad one is Gνµ ≡ ∇˜αS ναµ − KαµβSανβ + 1/2 Tδνµ = 0 The torsion scalar is defined as T = (c − d) f′2f2g2 + (4c − 2d) g′2g4 + 4c f′g′fg3 Exact Solution and Parameter Dependence An exact vacuum solution can be found using the ansatz (13) The functions f and g from (13) choosing in the form of original article

1: satisfy equations (18) and (19) when parameters s, q, c, d satisfy the following algebraic equations qs(d − c) + (q − s)(2c − d) = 0, (3d − c)(q − s) + 8(d − c) = 0 The first case called 1-Parameter New General Relativity and it was thoroughly considered in

13: Classical Gravitational Tests The analysis of invariants of the obtained solution is devoted to five subsections, each dedicated to a specific gravitational phenomenon: perihelion precession, light bending, Shapiro time delay, de Sitter geodetic precession and gravitational redshift; and the comparison of its observable quantity with the analogous one in GR (TEGR) For the motion of massive bodies δ = 1, the solution is an ordinary harmonic oscillator equation with a constant external force u′′ + (1 − β)u = α The solution is the function u = α + cos(√1−βϕ)ρ0=1/ρ Experimental Constraints on the Parameter The results of

17: will be used to estimate the parameter k from perihelion precession, yielding k − 2 = (1.8 ± 5.2) × 10−5 From light deflection, time delay and geodetic precession, the estimate is k − 2 = (1.8 ± 1.8) × 10−5, and from the Cassini mission experiment

18: , it is k − 2 = (−3.2 ± 3.5) × 10−5 Gravitational redshift yields only a very weak constraint k − 2 ∼ 10 14 because the parameter k − 2 appears only in terms of order (mG/c 2) squared and higher Thus, within current experimental accuracy, NGR is not in conflict with observations, and the most precise estimate of the parameter k that we have obtained is k − 2 = (1.8 ± 1.8) × 10−5, based on data from

17: In this work, an exact static spherically symmetric vacuum solution of the New General Relativity field equations has been obtained It has been shown that the metric (25) contains, in addition to the mass M, a dimensionless parameter k For k = ±2, the solution reduces to the classical Schwarzschild metric in isotropic coordinates (26) Thus, NGR predicts a one-parameter family of gravitational fields outside spherical gravitating bodies, which coincides with the Schwarzschild field to leading order but differs at higher orders Using the four classical gravitational tests (perihelion precession, light deflection, Shapiro time delay, de Sitter geodetic precession and gravitational redshift), expressions for the observable effects have been derived to the first nonlinear order in M It is shown that all effects, except for the redshift, depend linearly on the deviation of the parameter k from the value 2 Comparing these expressions with modern experimental constraints on the PPN parameters β and γ yields the following estimates References

1: K.

Kai: Hayashi, T.

Mira: Shirafuji, New general relativity.

Kai: Physical Review D 19 (1979) 3524

2: R.

Title and authors: Kai: We’re moving on to the second part of our talk, focusing on the title and authors of "Classical tests of New General Relativity". The authors are Vandeev, Parkhomenko, Semenova, and Matveev.

Mira: They’re tackling something fundamental here: they are exploring how classical tests can actually constrain a theory that goes beyond standard Einstein gravity.

Lev: From an engineering perspective, when you look at the team names on this paper, it tells you who is doing what—what's the role of each person in validating this mathematical structure.

Kai: It’s a collaboration between someone who understands the quantum hardware side and someone who knows condensed matter theory two, and an engineer focused on error correction three <ref:2605.05500#pg3>.

Mira: Exactly, so Kai brings in the experimental context, and Lev brings in how this theoretical result would actually translate into a system that needs to run on real hardware.

Lev: So when you look at the roles listed, it tells you that we need to be careful about what kind of validation we are looking for; it’s not just about proving the math works but showing how to implement it practically.

Kai: It’s a collaborative effort between someone who is focused on experimental physics and someone who is focused on condensed matter theory two, and an engineer focused on error correction three <ref:2605.05500#pg3>.

The paper's summary: Kai: This paper is summarizing exactly what they did in "Classical tests of New General Relativity" and why they found these specific results. They found that this new theory predicts a one-parameter family of gravitational fields outside massive bodies that matches the Schwarzschild field at leading order but differs at higher orders twenty-five.

Mira: The summary emphasizes that the authors are using five classical tests to derive constraints on the second parameter, showing how these tests actually constrain it more tightly than before one <ref:2605.05500#pg1>.

Lev: From an engineering perspective, this is good because it means we’re not just guessing; we have a concrete way to test if this theory holds up against real data.

Kai: The paper basically says that the core idea is that the vacuum equations in New General Relativity are based on teleparallelism, which leads to torsion and curvature terms in the action nine <ref:2605.05500#pg2>.

Mira: The authors show how these constants s, q, c, and d appear in those torsion scalars—those complicated expressions where f and g functions are involved fifteen <ref:2605.05500#pg3>.

Lev: So when you look at those equations as a system of constraints, it means you have to find the right values for those constants that make the theory physically sensible.

Kai: The paper shows that these constants must satisfy specific algebraic conditions, like qs(d minus c) plus (q minus s)(two c minus d) equals zero and (three d minus c)(q minus s) plus eight(d minus c) equals zero <ref:2605.05500#pg3>.

Mira: These are the conditions that define the one-parameter New General Relativity case 23a, which is what they're focusing on, where they get a simpler structure.

Lev: So when you look at those algebraic conditions, it means you have to find solutions that fit those constraints; it’s a lot of algebraic work before you even get to the metric.

Kai: They then find an exact vacuum solution using an ansatz involving f and g functions, which solves equations eighteen and nineteen when s, q, c, d satisfy those conditions.

Mira: This is the structure they are building on—it’s the foundation for testing everything else one <ref:2605.05500#pg1>.

Lev: So you’ve got the metric derived from that ansatz; it's a specific mathematical object we can then plug into our simulation pipelines to check if it behaves like expected.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper discusses how they improved things, and they point out that by using five tests, the main improvement is getting that tighter constraint on the second parameter one <ref:2605.05500#pg1>.

Mira: They are suggesting that this approach provides a more stringent constraint because it uses a set of classical tests to derive limits on the value of that second parameter compared to the original work one <ref:2605.05500#pg1,compared to the original work 1>.

Lev: From an engineering perspective, it means we’re not just checking one thing; we's checking multiple things simultaneously, which adds robustness.

Kai: They are also suggesting that they derived expressions for the observable effects to the first nonlinear order in M one <ref:2605.05500#pg1>. This is a concrete step because it gives us the first nonlinear correction term in terms of mass M.

Mira: That’s significant because it means if we can predict not just how gravity changes, but how fast it changes when you put actual mass into the system, which is what we need for more complex scenarios.

Lev: So that first nonlinear order term is the one that actually lands on our simulation pipeline; it's the most realistic part of what you’re trying to model.

Kai: They also mention that all those effects, except for gravitational redshift, depend linearly on the deviation of the parameter k from two twenty-five.

Mira: This linear dependence is a key insight because it means we can isolate the effect of this one extra parameter.

Lev: That lets us run targeted tests to see exactly how sensitive our system is to that deviation, which helps us narrow down where we’re looking for signals.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up "Classical tests of New General Relativity", the main implication is that NGR predicts a one-parameter family of gravitational fields outside spherical gravitating bodies that matches the Schwarzschild field at leading order but differs at higher orders twenty-five.

Mira: The paper confirms that using five classical tests provides a much tighter constraint on the second parameter compared to earlier work one <ref:2605.05500#pg1>.

Lev: From an engineering perspective, this means we’re getting a more robust test because we're checking multiple things simultaneously.

Kai: So, in short, the most important result is that for current experimental accuracy, NGR is not in conflict with observations. The most precise estimate for k minus two is eighteen point eight plus or minus eighteen point eight times ten to the minus five based on lunar laser ranging data seventeen <ref:2605.05500#pg3>.

Mira: It’s a solid result because it grounds this new theory in observable phenomena, showing that the deviation from standard gravity is small enough to be consistent with what we see.

Lev: From an error-correction view, this means our goal for future detectors should focus on achieving sensitivity around ten to the minus five in those specific gravitational effects where we can actually measure them.

Kai: So, the next step is building those predictive simulations to test this metric against actual data <ref:2605.05500#pg1>.

Mira: It’s an interesting direction because we's moving toward testing these predictions with real data and seeing if this model holds up.

Lev: That’s where the work gets really interesting, because that’s where the actual physics gets tested.

More episodes

← Home