Challenging the hoop conjecture with spinning pancakes and baguettes

summary

The gist

Understanding when gravitational collapse produces a black hole remains a central challenge in general relativity The hoop conjecture offers such a criterion by relating the enclosed mass to the…

In short

The paper tests the hoop conjecture using rotating dust configurations, modeling them as 'spinning pancakes and baguettes.' It finds that for rotating systems, using a quasilocal mass that includes rotational energy makes the conjecture hold within 14% of unity. For horizonless objects, only the contained mass satisfies the condition; using total ADM mass causes significant violations. This suggests rotation plays a key role in horizon formation criteria.

Key concepts

Hoop Conjecture
This conjecture proposes that a black hole forms if you cannot fit a hoop of circumference $4 imes$ enclosed mass ($4 imes M$) around the matter in every direction. It provides an alternative criterion to singularity theorems for predicting horizon formation based on the geometry and mass distribution of matter.
Quasilocal Mass
This is a measure of mass calculated within a specific, finite region of spacetime rather than the total mass of the entire universe (ADM mass). The paper finds that for rotating systems, this specific type of local measurement must include rotational energy to correctly test the hoop conjecture.
Irreducible Mass
This is a measure of the mass associated with an apparent horizon—the boundary where light can no longer escape. When used in the hoop inequality for rotating black hole analogs, this mass shows deviations that increase as the spin increases, mirroring behavior seen in actual Kerr black holes.
ADM Mass
The ADM mass is the total conserved mass of an isolated system calculated at spatial infinity. The paper notes that using this global measure for horizonless configurations leads to apparent violations of up to 25% when testing the hoop conjecture.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Challenging the hoop conjecture with spinning pancakes and baguettes · Read on arXiv

Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza University of Rome · INFN Sezione di Roma

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Challenging the hoop conjecture with spinning pancakes and baguettes".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Understanding when gravitational collapse produces a black hole remains a central challenge in general relativity The hoop conjecture offers such a criterion by relating the enclosed mass to the compactness of a matter distribution in every direction The paper constructs axisymmetric families of initial data describing rotating dust and tests a formulation of the conjecture adapted to this setting It finds that the conjecture holds for rotating configurations, with a coefficient within 14% of unity as in the nonrotating case, provided the quasilocal mass includes the rotational energy The Hoop Conjecture Formulation The hoop conjecture proposes that a black hole forms if and only if a hoop of circumference 4πM, where M represents the mass that is enclosed in the region, can be passed around the matter in every direction The conjecture has two implications regarding horizon formation "The if part states that if a hoop of circumference C ≲ 4πM can be placed around the matter in every direction, then a horizon forms" "Equivalently, if no horizon is present, there must be at least one direction in which no such hoop fits around the matter." The conjecture is ambiguous due to issues like the non-localizability of energy and the subtle nature of horizons The authors address this by focusing on axisymmetric spheroids of rotating dust Numerical Methodology and Results The numerical solution involves solving the GR initial constraints for a self-gravitating axisymmetric rotating cloud of dust using a 3+1 decomposition The constraints are solved by promoting the elliptic PDEs to parabolic diffusion-like PDEs in pseudo-time t The numerical solver employs a multigrid method with full approximation storage to achieve convergence, reaching residuals below 10-9 "Both elliptic PDEs are promoted to parabolic diffusion-like PDEs by adding a dependence of ψ and W on the pseudo-time t, and adding the terms −∂tψ and −∂tW on the left-hand side of Eqs.

Kai: (2.28)–(2.50)" The numerical results show that for nonrotating configurations, the only if part of the hoop conjecture is satisfied within 14% For rotating dust, when a horizon is present, two different masses can be associated with the apparent horizon: the Hawking (irreducible) mass or the total mass which includes a contribution from angular momentum The authors conclude that the quasilocal mass entering the hoop inequality should include a rotational contribution Analysis of Rotating Configurations In rotating cases, the irreducible mass of the apparent horizon is used, and it leads to deviations that grow with spin, similar to Kerr black holes The total mass is found to be a more sensible candidate for the hoop conjecture because it includes rotational energy For horizonless configurations, using the contained mass Mcont satisfies the conjecture, whereas using the ADM mass leads to apparent violations of up to ≃ 25% Rotation can also cause apparent horizons to disappear even at fixed rescaled density in certain configurations The study confirms that the quasilocal mass entering the hoop inequality should include a rotational contribution for rotating configurations The results support the expectation that ADM mass satisfies χADM ≤ 1 for configurations close to horizon formation, aligning with weak cosmic censorship The paper suggests that rotation and differential rotation may help very compact configurations avoid horizon formation Future work could investigate the role of gravitational waves in defining a mass contained in a region The authors note that for the if part, using the contained mass Mcont satisfies the conjecture in all horizonless configurations Appendix Details Computational details are collected in appendices, including A detailing the York–Lichnerowicz decomposition, B deriving the boundary conditions used in the shooting method, C showing how the relaxation-flow algorithm converges to the Schwarzschild horizon for nearby initial guesses, and D presenting the numerical convergence of the multigrid solver The authors also compare their results with known solutions, such as those for a nonrotating constant density sphere The convergence tests show that the numerical solution agrees well with analytic approximations computed to leading order in epsilon The final conclusion is that the two mass definitions now give noticeably different results for rotating configurations, with the shift growing monotonically with spin The paper also explores whether it is possible to find reasonable initial data (that do not violate energy conditions) that violate this inequality The authors report that for all the configurations with an apparent horizon, the only if part of the inequality entering the conjecture is satisfied in all the cases within 14% The authors also note that for rotating configurations, larger values of χH cannot be reached without the dust becoming superluminal The results support such conjecture which we recall, up to now has only been proved in vacuum and some plausibility arguments have been given for fluid spheroids The paper also has potential implications for horizonless exotic compact objects The time evolution of the configurations that we have constructed is also an interesting question, in particular regarding their interplay with weak cosmic censorship The paper also has potential implications for horizonless exotic compact objects.

Paper summary: Kai: So we've covered the basic setup of this paper, which is testing the hoop conjecture with rotating dust to see how well it works in practice. The authors start by setting up axisymmetric families of initial data describing this rotating dust and then test their formulation against those specific setups >

Mira: They are looking at highly prolate and oblate configurations, trying both constant and differential rescaled angular-velocity profiles, including those near the threshold for apparent horizon formation >

Lev: The methodology involves solving the general relativity initial constraints using a three plus one decomposition <ref:2611.13266#pg2>. They promote the elliptic partial differential equations into parabolic diffusion like equations by adding terms dependent on pseudo-time t >

Kai: The numerical solver they used is a multigrid method with full approximation storage, and they got residuals below one point nine times ten to the negative nine >

Mira: The results show that for nonrotating configurations, the 'if' part of the hoop conjecture is satisfied within fourteen percent of unity > <ref:2611.13266#pg2>

Lev: For rotating dust, when a horizon is present, there are two different masses associated with it: the Hawking irreducible mass and the total mass which includes angular momentum >

Kai: The authors conclude that for those rotating cases, using the quasilocal mass entering the hoop inequality should include a rotational contribution >

Mira: If they use the irreducible mass of the apparent horizon instead, they find deviations that grow with spin, similar to Kerr black holes >

Conclusion: Kai: The paper, "Challenging the hoop conjecture with spinning pancakes and baguettes," really boils down to how we should define mass when gravitational collapse is rotating. It shows that if you're dealing with rotating systems, you can't just use the standard mass definitions >

Mira: You have to include rotational energy in your definition of the quasilocal mass for the hoop conjecture to work, otherwise, the deviations become significant and grow with spin >

Lev: And for configurations that don't form a horizon at all, they found that sticking to just the contained mass works better than using something like ADM mass which brings in energy from outside the matter surface >

Kai: So what does this mean practically? It supports the idea that rotation plays a role in avoiding horizon formation for some compact objects >

Mira: And it suggests that differential rotation might be a way to push those configurations away from forming a horizon, even at fixed densities >

More episodes

← Home