Can n s hint at a parity-odd sector of gravity?

summary

The gist

We study slow-roll inflation in the context of metric-affine gravity to investigate whether spectral index hints at a parity-odd sector of gravity The third-order poles require the parity-odd sector…

In short

The study investigates slow-roll inflation within metric-affine gravity to see if spectral index data suggests a parity-odd sector of gravity. The analysis shows that third-order poles in the kinetic term require such a sector. These third-order poles can be distinguished from second-order poles using current and future Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) data.

Key concepts

Metric-Affine Gravity
This is a type of gravity theory where the spacetime geometry is described by an independent affine connection, meaning the connection isn't necessarily the Levi-Civita connection derived purely from the metric. This allows for torsion and non-metricity, which are encoded in a distortion tensor.
Kinetic Function k(ϕ)
When integrating out the non-dynamical distortion field, a correction appears in the kinetic term of the scalar field, $k(\phi)$. This new term can develop poles at specific field values where the equations governing the distortion degenerate. The order of these poles is limited by how many independent distortion modes are excited.
Parity-Odd Sector
The paper explores whether a parity-odd sector of gravity is necessary to generate third-order poles in the kinetic function. While second-order poles can arise from the parity-even sector, third-order poles fundamentally require the inclusion of parity-odd operators in the gravitational theory.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Can n s hint at a parity-odd sector of gravity? · Read on arXiv

Laboratory of High Energy and Computational Physics, National Institute of Chemical Physics and Biophysics

We study slow-roll inflation in the context of metric-affine gravity. We consider the most general projectively invariant metric-affine theory at most quadratic in the distortion and linear in curvature with no propagating torsion and non-metricity and couple it non-minimally to a scalar field. We focus on the class of ξ-attractors, in which a single function f(ϕ) fixes the whole scalar sector. Integrating out the non-dynamical distortion generates a correction to the kinetic term k(ϕ) which is f'(ϕ) squared times a ratio of polynomials in f(ϕ). The new kinetic term can develop poles at finite field values, where the distortion field equations degenerate. We classify the poles and derive the conditions on the effective couplings for poles of order p=2 and p=3, the maximal order allowed in this setting. We then proceed to study inflation. Second-order poles realize α-attractors with α fixed by the residue and are already available in the parity-even sector of the theory. Third-order poles instead require the parity-odd sector: whenever the parity-odd quadratic couplings vanish, the kinetic function splits into two independent terms with poles of order at most p=2. Third-order pole-inflation, as we confirm numerically for f(ϕ) proportional toϕ squared, yields r proportional to N*-3/2 with a tunable amplitude and n s 1- 2N*, a spectral index mildly larger than the α-attractor prediction and well centered in the region preferred by the current combination of ACT, SPT and DESI data. Moreover, when inflation happens far away from the pole we also find a further universal attractor, an inverse-linear plateau, with n s 1-4 over 3N* and r proportional to N*-4/3, testable with the forthcoming BICEP/Keck observations.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Can n s hint at a parity-odd sector of gravity?".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We study slow-roll inflation in the context of metric-affine gravity to investigate whether spectral index hints at a parity-odd sector of gravity The third-order poles require the parity-odd sector, and their predictions can be distinguished from second-order poles by current and future CMB data.

Kai: The Projective Invariant Model The paper considers a four-dimensional non-Riemannian manifold with an independent affine connection, splitting it into the Levi-Civita connection and the distortion tensor, which is encoded in torsion and non-metricity The most general projectively invariant action at most quadratic in the distortion and linear in the curvature is studied, coupled nonminimally to a real scalar field.

Mira: This action contains eighteen free functions of the scalar field, including the potential V(ϕ).

Kai: The distortion appears only algebraically in the Lagrangian, with its field equations being linear and sourced by ∂µϕ alone.

Paper summary: Kai: So what they're claiming here is that those third-order poles require a surviving parity odd quadratic sector to exist in the gravity theory.

Mira: Exactly, and they show that when those terms are vanishing, the kinetic function splits into two independent terms with poles of order at most two.

Lev: They do this by looking at specific conditions for these second- and third-order poles, which involve a double root of a certain equation at a value called f naught.

Kai: For the second-order poles, they need that double root to exist at f naught greater than zero with the function N of f not being zero.

Mira: And for the third-order poles, they state that the denominator has to be a perfect cube, but that's impossible unless there are parity odd operators involved in the theory.

Lev: They also look at how this plays out when E equals H equals zero, where the kinetic function splits additively into a quadratic term and a linear term.

Kai: Which leads to poles of order at most two in that case, meaning third-order poles are only possible if you include the parity odd sector.

Mira: The parameter scan they run shows that all four types of attractors, including pole inflation and linear inflation, are independent of the choice of f of phi.

Lev: For large xi and beta bars i less than xi, their predictions converge to an inverse-linear plateau which predicts n s is about one minus four over three times N star.

Kai: And the paper suggests that third-order pole inflation could explain the observed shift in n s, and since these poles can only come from switching on the parity odd sector in this type of metric affine gravity, it's a strong hint.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this study on "Can ns hint at a parity-odd sector of gravity?", the main point is that second-order poles are in the parity even sector already.

Mira: And third-order poles only show up if you include the parity odd sector, which is what makes them possible in this framework.

Lev: The paper shows that these pole inflation predictions don't depend on f of phi; they are fixed by the residue of the pole and the slope of the potential at that pole.

Kai: And when you compare this to data, they find that second-order poles are favored by CMB only data for N star between fifty and sixty.

Mira: But when you include BAO data from DESI, then third-order poles become preferred in the analysis.

Lev: So the implication is that if we see those third-order pole predictions, it strongly suggests that parity odd operators must be present in the gravitational sector.

Kai: It means recent observations might be hinting at those operators being there, especially within the xi attractor class and for any function f of phi.

More episodes

← Home