A class of decelerating inhomogeneous cosmological models giving rise to accelerating FLRW universes at large scales

summary

The gist

A class of decelerating inhomogeneous cosmological models giving rise to accelerating FLRW universes at large scales is developed by investigating how backreaction effects can reconcile a…

In short

The study develops inhomogeneous cosmological models that are fundamentally decelerating locally but appear accelerating when viewed on large scales. This apparent contradiction arises because global time coordinates in the large-scale description do not match local observer proper time, leading to an effective dark energy term that mimics acceleration.

Key concepts

Inhomogeneous Relativistic Cosmological Models
These are cosmological models where space is not uniform everywhere. The model includes observers who experience a standard, uniform (homogeneous and isotropic) expansion, contrasting with the potentially complex local geometry experienced by other observers.
Backreaction Effect
This effect describes how the average influence of local gravitational inhomogeneities on the large-scale spacetime can mimic cosmological phenomena like dark energy. It arises because the global time coordinate used for large-scale FLRW dynamics is not synchronized with the proper time of a single local observer.
Effective Equation of State Parameter
This parameter describes how the effective dark energy component evolves over cosmic time in the simplified large-scale FLRW model. The authors show that by appropriately setting the initial energy distribution, this parameter can reproduce any polynomial function for dark energy's behavior.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

A class of decelerating inhomogeneous cosmological models giving rise to accelerating FLRW universes at large scales · Read on arXiv

Leandro G. Gomes

Federal University of Itajubá (UNIFEI)

In this manuscript, we develop a class of inhomogeneous relativistic cosmological models with the following properties: (i) They contain cosmological observers to whom the spatial geometry and the expansion are homogeneous and isotropic; (ii) Matter behaves closely to dust, as it is formed by an ensemble of massive particles whose number density 4-vector is conserved and reacts viscously to the local tidal forces; (iii) They generalize the dust FLRW model; (iv) They give rise to effective models on large scales that reproduce the FLRW behaviour with dust and a running dark-energy term, which appears as a backreaction effect from the local gravitational potential; (v) By suitably setting the distribution of energy in the current universe, the effective large-scale equation-of-state parameter can reproduce, in principle, any polynomial on the scale factor whose term of order zero is negative; (vi) The luminous distance observations imply an apparent large-scale acceleration, as the deceleration parameter is negative, while in reality the universe is decelerating.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A class of decelerating inhomogeneous cosmological models giving rise to accelerating FLRW universes at large scales".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A class of decelerating inhomogeneous cosmological models giving rise to accelerating FLRW universes at large scales is developed by investigating how backreaction effects can reconcile a decelerating underlying spacetime with observed large-scale acceleration The luminosity distance derived from the large-scale FLRW model implies acceleration—i.e., a negative deceleration parameter—even though the underlying inhomogeneous spacetime itself is decelerating Model Characterization and Assumptions The class of models is characterized by several properties, including admitting cosmological observers for whom the spatial geometry and expansion are both homogeneous and isotropic The matter content is an ensemble of massive particles with number conservation and responding viscously to the local tidal forces On large scales, these models reduce to FLRW cosmologies with dust and a dark-energy term arising through backreaction By appropriately choosing the current energy distribution, the large-scale equation-of-state parameter reproduce any polinomial for an evolving dark-energy sector The global time coordinate employed in the large-scale FLRW description cannot be identified with the proper time of any local observer experiencing homogeneous and isotropic expansion Gravitational Interaction Analogy The authors establish a Newtonian-like gravitational analogy by choosing a unit and vorticity-free timelike vector field u, which brings the splitting of space from time closer to the notion of an inertial frame in Newtonian mechanics The choice of u as an "inertial frame" and treating φ as the gravitational potential is presented as a valuable and intuitive guide A particle released by the u-observer instantaneously feels the gravitational force Fi = −m0 ∇uui = −m0Diφ at (t0,x0) The geodesic deviation equation provides a relativistic version for tidal forces, where Mkl plays an analog role to its Newtonian version The Newtonian tidal tensor M is decomposed into bulk and anisotropic components, with M = 1/3a squared D 2φ +Dφ squared Matter Description and Phenomenological Approach The matter content is described phenomenologically as an ensemble of classical particles interacting viscously with the Newtonian-like tidal forces they generate Instead of a fluid picture, the model assumes a swarm of particles executes random motions around their local centre of mass, neglecting thermodynamic effects for simplicity The total energy-momentum tensor is given by Tµν = (m0 n+ε) uµuν +E uµnˆν +uν nˆ µ − ζB M gµν +uµuν − ζA Mcµν The local stress tensor of matter is related to the tidal acceleration by T(L)i j −T(LPF)i j ∝ −Mkl Large-Scale Dynamics and Effective Equation of State The large-scale dynamics are governed by an effective FLRW spacetime where the equation of state parameter has the form w(a) = w0 +w1 (a−1) + w2 2!(a−1) 2 +… The late-time acceleration is explained by the fact that the global time t cannot be realized as the proper time of homogeneous and isotropic observers The deceleration parameter is negative for w0 < −1/3, indicating a large-scale apparent acceleration The paper concludes that the rise of w0 < 0 and w1 to the mean value of the inhomogeneities of the local gravitational field is a significant result in the literature of backreaction in Cosmology This approach supports that backreaction can be big enough to account for the observed universe at least in principle The apparent contradiction between deceleration and acceleration is resolved by noting that the global time coordinate employed in the large-scale FLRW description cannot be identified with the proper time of any local observer experiencing homogeneous and isotropic expansion Table 1: FLRW analogues Epoch FLRW analogue with the leading term of w(a) Early times P = 0 with Λ = Ω(0)L ρc Late times P = w0 ρ with w0 ≤ 0 arbitrary References

1: Weinberg S 2008 Cosmology (Oxford University Press) ISBN 978-0-19-852682-7

2: Clarkson C, Ellis G, Larena J and Umeh O 2011 Reports on Progress in Physics 74 112901

3: Buchert T and Ehlers J 1996 Astronomy & Astrophysics 320 1–7 available at the SAO/NASA Astrophysics Data System

4: Buchert T 2000 General Relativity and Gravitation 32 105–125

5: Buchert T 2001 General Relativity and Gravitation 33 1381–1405

6: Buchert T, Mourier P and Roy X 2020 General Relativity and Gravitation 52 27

7: Wiltshire D L 2007 New Journal of Physics 9 377–377

8: Wiltshire D L 2007 Physical Review Letters 99 251101

9: Lindquist R and Wheeler J 1957 Reviews of Modern Physics 29 432–443

10: Clifton T, Ferreira P G and O’Donnell K 2012 Phys.

Kai: Rev.

Mira: D 85(2) 023502

11: Liu R 2015 Physical Review D 92 063529

12: Clifton T and Ferreira P G 2009 Phys.

Kai: Rev.

Paper summary: Kai: So what they’re claiming is this class of models has three key things. First, they include observers who experience a homogeneous and isotropic universe, which is important for us to even talk about cosmology. Second, the matter content is described as an ensemble of massive particles that obey number conservation and react viscously to the local tidal forces >

Lev: So what does that mean for us when we think about running this on hardware? It sounds like the particle description is complex because it involves these local tidal forces influencing how the matter behaves, which means you have a lot of terms to handle in simulations >

Mira: Exactly. And third, on large scales, these inhomogeneous models simplify down to an FLRW cosmology with dust and a dark energy term that comes from this backreaction effect from the local gravitational potential >

Kai: That backreaction is what really hooks us. They argue that by picking the right distribution of energy in our current universe, you can make the effective equation-of-state parameter reproduce any polynomial for an evolving dark energy sector >

Lev: That sounds like a lot of tuning. If we were trying to model this on real hardware, figuring out how that potential phi influences the scale factor a(t) would be tricky because it’s all coupled together >

Mira: And the big result they point to is this: even though the underlying spacetime itself is decelerating, the luminosity distance derived from that large-scale FLRW model implies acceleration, which means a negative deceleration parameter >

Conclusion: Kai: So looking at "A class of decelerating inhomogeneous cosmological models giving rise to accelerating FLRW universes at large scales," what we've seen is that the paper suggests this apparent contradiction between deceleration and acceleration isn't a real problem if you look at the right scale >

Mira: It really hinges on the idea that the global time coordinate they use for that large-scale FLRW description just cannot be identified with the proper time experienced by those local observers who are actually seeing something decelerating >

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this suggests that we might see acceleration when we average over things, but if you try to measure it locally using a clock that's tied to the actual gravitational potential, you’ll just see deceleration >

Kai: So the authors conclude that the rise of the dark energy term w zero and its dependence on inhomogeneities is a significant finding in backreaction research because it supports that backreaction can be large enough to account for what we observe at large scales > <ref:2603.11377#pg3>

More episodes

← Home