Coexistence of Direct-to-Device (D2D) Satellite Systems with 5G/6G Terrestrial Networks: Cross-Border Aggregate Interference Analysis in Saudi Arabia

summary

The gist

Direct-to-device (D2D) satellite systems deliver connectivity to standard mobile phones and IoT devices using terrestrial International Mobile Telecommunications (IMT) spectrum…

In short

This study assessed potential harmful interference from two hypothetical Direct-to-Device (D2D) satellite systems operating in Jordan and Iraq into terrestrial 5G/6G networks in Saudi Arabia using the 698-960 MHz band. The analysis showed that protection criteria were exceeded up to 88% of the time, requiring significant additional isolation. Coexistence is infeasible without mitigation.

Key concepts

Direct-to-Device (D2D) Satellite Systems
These are satellite systems designed to connect standard mobile phones and IoT devices directly to a satellite, bypassing traditional terrestrial infrastructure. They use existing mobile spectrum but introduce the risk of interfering with ground-based networks.
Aggregate Downlink Interference
This refers to the total amount of unwanted radio signal energy received by a victim terrestrial network from multiple D2D satellite systems operating across different borders simultaneously. The study quantified this combined effect.
Protection Criterion
This is the established technical threshold that defines acceptable levels of interference for existing terrestrial mobile networks. Exceeding this criterion indicates that the D2D system's operation is causing unacceptable disruption to the incumbent network.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Coexistence of Direct-to-Device (D2D) Satellite Systems with 5G/6G Terrestrial Networks: Cross-Border Aggregate Interference Analysis in Saudi Arabia · Read on arXiv

Muneer M. AlZubi, MUHAMMAD ALRABEIAH, KHALID ALDUBAIKHY, ABDULLAH ALQASIR, MAJED ALSIFAEE, MOHAMED-SLIM ALOUINI

King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST) · Communications, Space & Technology Commission (CST) of Saudi Arabia · Department of Electrical Engineering, Qassim University

Direct-to-device (D2D) satellite systems, particularly those based on 3GPP-compliant non-terrestrial networks (NTN), deliver connectivity to standard mobile phones and IoT devices using terrestrial International Mobile Telecommunications (IMT) spectrum. This raises the risk of harmful cross-border interference into incumbent terrestrial IMT networks, an issue considered under Agenda Item 1.13 of the ITU World Radiocommunication Conference 2027 (WRC-27). This paper presents an ITU-R-compliant assessment of aggregate downlink interference from two hypothetical D2D systems operating in Jordan and Iraq into terrestrial IMT user equipment (UE) in Saudi Arabia, operating in the 698-960 MHz band. Unlike prior studies that evaluate a few test points near a simplified ideal tri-border intersection, we distribute multiple victim UEs along realistic national borders within various strips at a distance of 0-40 km from the borders. We compare two satellite selection strategies: highest-elevation and random strategies. The CDF of the interference-to-noise ratio (I/N) together with the intra-system and inter-system aggregation factors are analyzed. Results show that the protection criterion is exceeded up to 88% of the time, requiring up to 27 dB of additional isolation, so coexistence is infeasible without interference mitigation. In general, random selection produces higher interference because low-elevation beams place victims closer to boresight. Two mitigation techniques are then evaluated. A border isolation zone of one cell diameter yields only a moderate improvement under both strategies, whereas a narrow-beam, deep-null phased-array pattern lowers the exceedance to about 40% irrespective of strategy, providing an important input for spectrum regulatory considerations.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Electrical Engineering. The day in electrical engineering: signals, systems and the hardware that carries them.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Coexistence of Direct-to-Device (D2D) Satellite Systems with 5G/6G Terrestrial Networks".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. Direct-to-device (D2D) satellite systems deliver connectivity to standard mobile phones and IoT devices using terrestrial International Mobile Telecommunications (IMT) spectrum, raising the risk of harmful cross-border interference into incumbent terrestrial IMT networks <ref:2611.12644#pg2>.

Rosa: This paper presents an ITU-R-compliant assessment of aggregate downlink interference from two hypothetical D2D systems operating in Jordan and Iraq into terrestrial IMT user equipment in Saudi Arabia, operating in the 698-960 MHz band <ref:2611.12644#pg2>.

Dev: Results show that the protection criterion is exceeded up to 88% of the time, requiring up to 27 dB of additional isolation, so coexistence is infeasible without interference mitigation <ref:2611.12644#pg4>.

Rosa: Simulation Setup and Methodology The study employs a Monte Carlo simulation methodology developed based on frameworks established in ITU-R Working Party 4C contributions <ref:2611.12644#pg4>.

Title and authors: Rosa: So we're looking at this paper today, "Coexistence of Direct-to-Device (D2D) Satellite Systems with 5G/6G Terrestrial Networks: Cross-Border Aggregate Interference Analysis in Saudi Arabia" <ref:2611.12644#pg1,Coexistence of Direct-to-Device (D2D) Satellite Systems with 5G/6G Terrestrial>. It sounds super technical, but essentially it’s about how these satellite systems that connect phones and IoT devices are messing with the regular mobile networks.

Dev: Right. It’s a problem because these D2D systems use the same spectrum as our terrestrial cellular networks, and when they cross borders, that interference gets into someone else's network. This paper is trying to figure out exactly how bad that interference is when it happens across Jordan, Iraq, and Saudi Arabia.

Taro: I’m thinking about the physical setup here. It’s not just a theoretical problem; it's about beams spanning borders and hitting users in a third country without permission <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Rosa: Exactly, Taro. They are focusing on how these satellite beams, even if authorized for use in one country, can illuminate mobile phones right across the border into another network. It sets up this risk for those incumbent terrestrial networks in Saudi Arabia <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Dev: And the core thing they’re tackling is that aggregate interference, meaning not just one source, but all those D2D systems adding up at the same time, which makes it way harder to predict <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Taro: It makes sense. If you have multiple sources hitting a victim phone simultaneously, the noise floor gets much higher and the signal gets lost more easily <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Rosa: So they’re putting this all together into a study that follows ITU-R guidelines, which is important because it gives us a standard way to look at this kind of interference problem <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Dev: And the paper is trying to provide some concrete numbers on what happens in that six hundred ninety-eight to nine hundred sixty MHz band, which is where these systems are operating <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

The paper's summary: Rosa: So, when we look at the actual findings of this paper, they present a rigorous characterization of this cross-border aggregate downlink interference into terrestrial IMT users in Saudi Arabia <ref:2611.12644#pg3>. They look at the impact of isolation distance inside the D2D operating countries on things like the interference-to-noise ratio and how that distributes over time, called the cumulative distribution function or CDF <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Dev: What I find interesting is their main contribution, which they call their first rigorous ITU-R compliant characterization of this kind of cross-border aggregate D2D downlink interference in that specific frequency range <ref:2611.12644#pg3>. That’s a big step for the regulatory side.

Taro: They also analyze the aggregation factor, which is how much those multiple systems are adding up together, both within their own system and across different systems <ref:2611.12644#pg3>. I wonder if that aggregation factor is something we can really model accurately in real-world deployments <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Rosa: They also look at the intra-system and inter-system aggregation factor analysis specifically in that six hundred ninety-eight to nine hundred sixty MHz band <ref:2611.12644#pg3>. It’s trying to map out exactly how much interference is added when you have multiple D2D systems active simultaneously <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Dev: So, the paper is setting up this mathematical framework so that regulators can actually make decisions about coexistence, which is what the two thousand twenty-three World Radiocommunication Conference Resolution two hundred fifty-three was pushing for <ref:2611.12644#pg2>.

Taro: It helps us understand the spatial origin of this interference too. They show that how a satellite is selected critically affects where the harmful interference actually lands—like high elevation selection confines it to border-adjacent cells, while random selection spreads it out to cells further away <ref:2611.12644#pg5>.

The paper's improvements: Rosa: Now, the authors suggest some ways we can actually make this coexistence situation better by improving the systems themselves. They introduce an improvement for System three where they use a narrow-beam, deep-null phased-array pattern <ref:2611.12644#pg4>.

Dev: That change is significant because they state that this pattern "lowers the exceedance of the protection criterion to about forty percent and makes it largely independent of selection strategy" <ref:2611.12644#pg4>. That sounds like a big win for system design.

Taro: I’m curious how much that actually changes in practice. They suggest that antenna pattern requirements could be a more robust and strategy-independent basis for mitigating cross-border D2D interference than just using geographic isolation zones <ref:2611.12644#pg4>.

Rosa: So, they’re pushing the idea that regulating the antenna pattern itself is better than just drawing lines on a map to keep things separate <ref:2611.12644#pg4>.

Dev: That points towards a way for regulators to get better operational control over this interference, which is something we need when dealing with real-time loops and safety cases <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Taro: And they also offer a way for planning—they provide a technical basis for optimum mitigating techniques that could be really helpful to the people who actually make the regulations <ref:2611.12644#pg4>.

Conclusion: Rosa: So, wrapping this up, the main implication here is that coexistence isn't just something we hope for; it seems infeasible without some kind of active interference mitigation <ref:2611.12644#pg2>. They found that the protection criterion is exceeded up to eighty-eight percent of the time, meaning if you don't do something, things are going to get really bad quickly <ref:2611.12644#pg4>.

Dev: And they say it requires up to twenty-seven decibels of additional isolation just to make it work without interference mitigation <ref:2611.12644#pg4>. That’s a big number for the required separation <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Taro: From my side, what this means is that we can't just assume the system will work fine; we have to design it to be resilient when the world misbehaves and interference starts leaking in <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Rosa: Exactly. So, the paper "Coexistence of Direct-to-Device (D2D) Satellite Systems with 5G/6G Terrestrial Networks: Cross-Border Aggregate Interference Analysis in Saudi Arabia" shows us that careful engineering and regulatory guidance are absolutely necessary for this to work <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Dev: It’s a complex picture, but it gives engineers and regulators the technical basis they need to start designing solutions instead of just hoping for the best with deployment <ref:2611.12644#pg3>.

Taro: We need to keep looking at these spatial distribution effects because we learned that satellite selection strategy critically affects where the interference is actually coming from, not just how much there is <ref:2611.12644#pg5>.

More episodes

← Home