Towards post-growth policymaking: Barriers and enablers for wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics government initiatives
summary
The gist
Providing wellbeing for all while safeguarding planetary boundaries requires governments to pursue post-growth policies Overall…
In short
The study examined barriers and enablers for post-growth government initiatives like wellbeing economies and Doughnut economics across nine European countries, New Zealand, and Canada. It found that economic growth paradigms are a major barrier, while crises have enabled these initiatives. Structural changes and civil society engagement are needed to move beyond current growth-focused policies.
Key concepts
- Wellbeing Economy
- An economy designed to prioritize human wellbeing while strictly respecting ecological limits. It focuses on meeting human needs within the boundaries of the planet's capacity, moving away from endless material expansion.
- Doughnut Economics
- A framework that envisions an 'ecologically safe and socially just space for humanity.' This means ensuring basic human needs are met without exceeding planetary boundaries, creating a balanced space between social and ecological limits.
- 5Ps Framework
- A tool used to categorize factors influencing post-growth initiatives. It looks at five dimensions: Paradigms (dominant theories), Pressures (crises), Polity (structural institutions), Politics (negotiation processes), and Policy (decision-making instruments).
- Economic Growth Paradigm
- The dominant system built around continuous economic expansion. The research found this paradigm acts as a significant barrier to post-growth initiatives because it is deeply embedded in many aspects of society and governance.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Towards post-growth policymaking: Barriers and enablers for wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics government initiatives · Paper Radio
The paper
Towards post-growth policymaking: Barriers and enablers for wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics government initiatives · Read on arXiv
Laura Angresiusa, Milena B"uchsb, Alessia Greselinc, Daniel W. O’Neill
UB School of Economics, Universitat de Barcelona · Sustainability Research Institute, School of Earth, Environment and Sustainability, University of Leeds · Faculty of Social Sciences, Tampere University
Providing wellbeing for all while safeguarding planetary boundaries requires governments to pursue post-growth policies. An important question is how transformative government-led post-growth initiatives can be within the existing institutional context. While first empirical studies on this question demonstrate some of the current limitations of government-led post-growth initiatives, a broader empirical assessment of underlying barriers and enablers across institutional contexts is so far lacking. To address this gap, we examine wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics government initiatives across governance scales in Europe, New Zealand, and Canada. To identify barriers and enablers as well as priorities for future action, we apply a framework that captures systemic and political dimensions to analyze the data. Overall, our results suggest that the overarching economic growth paradigm severely limits the initiatives scope of action. Important enablers of existing initiatives are crises, the political agency of key individuals and high-level political support. Policymakers who promote growth-critical perspectives often face tensions: they need to appeal to broad stakeholder groups while avoiding cooptation. Structural changes and a closer engagement with, and pressure from, civil society are required to support post-growth government initiatives.
DOI: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2026.149790
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Economics. The day in economics: theory, mechanisms and the evidence beneath them.
Ruth: I'm Ruth.
Warren: And I'm Warren, here with Iris.
Ruth: We're looking at the paper: "Towards post-growth policymaking".
Warren: Here's the gist of the paper. Providing wellbeing for all while safeguarding planetary boundaries requires governments to pursue post-growth policies Overall, our results suggest that the overarching economic growth paradigm severely limits the initiatives’ scope of action Important enablers of existing initiatives are crises, the political agency of key individuals and high-level political support Policymakers who promote growth-critical perspectives often face tensions: they need to appeal to broad stakeholder groups while avoiding cooptation Structural changes and a closer engagement with, and pressure from, civil society are required to support post-growth government initiatives The core research question and methodology The study examines which barriers and enablers of post-growth government initiatives are common across wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics initiatives, country contexts, and governance levels To help answer this question and identify priorities for future actions, we collect primary data from 14 wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics initiatives across 9 European countries, New Zealand, and Canada We also employ an explicit analytical framework which allows us to classify different barriers and enablers The term “wellbeing economy” refers to an economy geared towards the provision of human wellbeing within ecological limits “Doughnut economics” outlines an “ecologically safe and socially just space for humanity” in which basic human needs are met without transgressing planetary boundaries To categorize barriers and enablers, we apply what we call a 5Ps framework, consisting of the systemic factors of paradigms (P1) and pressures (P2), and the political dimensions of polity (P3), politics (P4), and policy (P5) Analysis through the 5Ps framework The 5Ps framework is used to capture key factors that the literature has identified so far, including systemic and state-specific factors Paradigms refers to the dominant theories, models or discourses that current (economic, social, political, technological, etc.) systems are built around Pressures refers to crises that indicate problems within existing (economic, social, political, technological, etc.) systems that require transformative responses To capture and categorize barriers and enablers that relate to state institutions, we adopt the threefold distinction between polity, politics, and policy from political science (Pichler, 2023; Rohe, 1994) Polity refers to the structural features of political institutions, such as their organization and legislation Politics refers to the processes through which actors pursue competing interests and negotiate change Policy includes the instruments and outcomes of political decision-making Key findings on systemic barriers and enablers Overall, we find that the economic growth paradigm acted as a barrier whereas crises enabled the implementation of Doughnut economics and wellbeing economy initiatives The three political dimensions related to both barriers and enablers In the dimension of paradigms, we did not identify any enablers Several interviewees mentioned the embeddedness in a growth-dependent economic system as a barrier Interviewees at the regional and local scale underscored the limited ability of subnational scales to move beyond framework conditions set by the national level because “at the moment, the growth idea, economic growth, is so embedded in kind of everything” Interviewees described various expressions of hegemonic pro-growth discourses In the dimension of pressures, we did not identify any barriers Interviewees described the exposure to multiple crises, for instance the COVID-19 pandemic, as placing wellbeing higher on the public and government agenda and encouraging system rethinking On an international level, the 2007/2008 financial crises prompted the emergence of a discourse around alternative measures of welfare which multiple interviewees mentioned In the dimension of polity, we found that the siloed organization of governmental institutions was described as hampering integrative, post-growth-oriented policymaking Institutional disincentives to change translate into change-averse attitudes of individual policymakers which led one interviewee to remark that “a lot of people are just very resistant to change in general” Implications for future action Structural changes are required to address one of the key barriers to transformation: the economic growth paradigm Developing civil society initiatives that can directly deliberate and develop post-growth approaches with citizens as well as a greater presence of post-growth approaches in the media and economics education would be needed for post-growth discourses to become more accepted Wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics initiatives themselves could aim to openly criticize the continuous pursuit of economic growth and collaborate with civil society initiatives that support post-growth-aligned mindsets among citizens Initiatives could strive to enable deliberative forms of democratic participation, to open spaces to debate and challenge the hegemony of economic growth within institutions in order to allow for more ambitious postgrowth policies in the long term Contributions and limitations Our research empirically contributes to understanding the role of government-led postgrowth initiatives in post-growth transformations in two ways First, while previous research is based on a small number of empirical cases of either wellbeing economy or Doughnut economics initiatives, we collected primary data from wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics initiatives across governance levels in nine European countries, plus New Zealand and Canada Second, we adopt a 5Ps framework to categorize barriers and enablers across the systemic dimensions of paradigms and pressures, and the political dimensions of polity, politics and policy Our study faces several limitations As we draw on insights from a range of countries and governance scales, we cannot provide in-depth analysis of the institutional settings, actor constellations, or power dynamics in respective contexts and governance scales Moreover, this study does not provide an empirical analysis of the relative importance of different barriers and enablers Overall, we find that the hegemony of the economic growth paradigm limits the scope of action of wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics initiatives and shapes political dimensions as reflected in the dominance of growth-focused government departments, funding, policy priorities and political actors Highly motivated individuals and high-level support from within political institutions have facilitated several government-led postgrowth initiatives, supported by interactions with civil society Policymakers who aim to foster growth-critical perspectives face tensions between appealing to a broad stakeholder base and ensuring the longevity of the project, on the one hand, and aiming to advocate for bold changes and avoid cooptation on the other Moreover, despite the focus on policies within the post-growth literature, our results suggest that they have limited transformative potential in the current system Acknowledgments and funding We would like to thank all interviewees who gave their time generously to participate in this study Ethics approval was obtained from the University of Barcelona (Bioethics Commission), and from the University of Leeds (Faculties of Business, Environment, and Social Sciences Ethics Committee, reference 0937), covering full informed consent from interview participants and anonymization of interview data in research outputs This research received funding from the European Union’s Horizon Europe research and innovation programme under grant agreement number 101094211 (ToBe: “Towards a Sustainable Wellbeing Economy: Integrated Policies and Transformative Indicators”) and UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) under grant agreement number 10052343 References The references listed support the claims made throughout the paper Bärnthaler, R., Novy, A., Arzberger, L., Krisch, A., & Volmary, H.
Ruth: (2024).
Warren: The power to transform structures: Power complexes and the challenges for realising a wellbeing economy Cattaneo, C., Lemos, M.
Ruth: M.
Paper summary: Ruth: So this paper is looking at how governments can actually make these post-growth things happen, specifically focusing on wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics initiatives. The main thing they’re trying to figure out is what the actual barriers and enablers are when you try to implement them in an existing government setting.
Warren: Right, so the core idea here seems to be that just having good ideas for a wellbeing economy isn't enough; there are real structural things stopping those initiatives from taking off within our current systems. The authors are trying to map out what those roadblocks and accelerators actually look like across different countries and levels of government.
Iris: It sets up this specific framework they call the 5Ps, which breaks things down into systemic factors like paradigms and pressures, and then political dimensions like polity, politics, policy <ref:2501.17600#pg3>. That sounds pretty systematic for analyzing this kind of complex policy problem.
Ruth: Exactly. They use the 5Ps to organize their thinking about where these initiatives get stuck or where they can actually gain traction in practice <ref:2501.17600#pg3>. It helps them move beyond just talking about abstract theory and look at concrete institutional friction points.
Warren: I read the summary, and it’s pretty telling: the economic growth paradigm is seen as a major barrier, but crises seem to have been what enabled some of these wellbeing economy initiatives to even start gaining traction. It suggests a tension there between the dominant system and those alternative approaches.
Iris: And they find that while paradigms are roadblocks, they didn't actually identify any specific enablers within that dimension in their empirical check across the examples they looked at. That’s an interesting finding because it implies that just having the right theory isn't enough to overcome the entrenched system.
Ruth: It points toward a deeper issue—that even when people are talking about these alternative economic models, the growth-dependent structure of society is so deeply embedded in everything else that it acts like a wall. The interviewees highlighted how hard it is for local or regional scales to move away from what's happening at the national level because "the growth idea, economic growth, is so embedded in kind of everything."
Warren: That sounds like a classic institutional inertia problem. And when you look at the pressures dimension, they found nothing blocking things; instead, they saw that exposure to multiple crises, like the COVID-nineteen pandemic or those financial crises around two thousand seven or two thousand eight actually put wellbeing higher up on the public and government agenda.
Iris: So the crisis acts as a catalyst for rethinking things when there’s no inherent barrier there—that’s a key distinction they're making. But then they did find barriers in the political dimension, specifically around how government institutions are organized.
Ruth: Yeah, the siloed organization of governmental institutions was described as something that hampered integrative policymaking oriented toward post-growth goals. They also found institutional disincentives to change that lead to what one interviewee put as a quote: "a lot of people are just very resistant to change in general."
Warren: That resistance is something I deal with every day on the trading floor, where the strategy itself becomes hard to unwind when things get turbulent. It translates directly into these change-averse attitudes among policymakers, which is a big operational headache for any transition.
Iris: So, to summarize the main point from "Towards post-growth policymaking: Barriers and enablers for wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics government initiatives," the paper argues that moving towards these new economic ideas requires structural changes because they identify that the economic growth paradigm is a barrier, even though crises have sometimes enabled their adoption.
Ruth: And it stresses that to actually make this transformation work, we need structural changes—meaning we need things like developing civil society initiatives to deliberate with citizens directly and getting more post-growth approaches into media and education so these ideas become more accepted.
Warren: It sounds like the path forward isn't just about tweaking policy documents; it’s about changing the underlying political landscape and making sure there are enough motivated individuals at the top to push those bold changes through.
Iris: The paper makes a strong point about how policymakers who champion these growth-critical perspectives run into real tension, balancing the need to appeal to a wide stakeholder group against needing to avoid cooptation by the existing system. That political tightrope is pretty difficult.
Ruth: It really does highlight that even with focus on policy instruments in the literature, our results suggest those policies have limited transformative potential if they don't tackle that core issue of the economic growth paradigm itself.
Warren: So, to wrap up on this paper about "Towards post-growth policymaking: Barriers and enablers for wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics government initiatives," it’s essentially a diagnostic tool showing us that the current system is structurally resistant, but crises offer openings. It points toward the necessity of shifting focus from just economic policy tools to fundamental structural changes in how we organize government and how society thinks about progress.
Iris: And I think the authors' main contribution here is providing this systematic 5Ps framework, which helps us see these barriers and enablers across both systemic theory and political structure, giving a clearer roadmap for where to focus our future efforts <ref:2501.17600#pg3>.
Conclusion: Ruth: So we’ve seen how this study maps out the barriers and enablers for wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics initiatives, focusing on what actually gets implemented in government settings.
Warren: The title itself, "Towards post-growth policymaking: Barriers and enablers for wellbeing economy and Doughnut economics government initiatives," it sounds like a real roadmap trying to navigate that tension between the old system and these new ideas.
Iris: It’s an attempt to be systematic about it, looking at everything from the big economic theories down to how specific government departments actually organize themselves.
Ruth: Exactly. The paper boils down pretty simply that even with good intentions, you run into serious roadblocks because of how deeply embedded economic growth is in everything else we do.
Warren: It suggests that these post-growth ideas aren't just missing a few policy tweaks; they’re fighting a fundamental structure.
Iris: And the study points to structural changes being absolutely necessary—things like developing civil society groups to deliberately shape these approaches with citizens, and getting more of this thinking into the media and education system.
Ruth: It also highlights that policymakers trying to push for growth-critical views face a real political tightrope, having to talk to everyone without letting the existing growth departments just co-opt them.
Warren: So, even when you have high-level support, there’s this internal friction about who gets listened to and what the actual priorities are.
Iris: And the authors conclude that while these initiatives show promise in theory, their immediate transformative power is limited unless they tackle that core issue of the growth paradigm itself.
Ruth: It means we need to think beyond just writing better policies; we need a deeper rethink of how our economic systems are organized and funded.
Warren: That sets up a big question for us about what kind of structural changes are actually feasible in the next few years to make that happen.
More episodes
- Daily Summary for 2026-11-19
- 2608.21274-Recommendation Quality and the Concentration of Consumption: Experimental Evidence from Netflix
- 2408.02757-A nonparametric test for diurnal variation in spot correlation processes
- 2306.16393-High-Dimensional Canonical Correlation Analysis
- 2605.17299-Geometric Brownian motion with intermittent entries and exits
- 2607.04753-Fooling Yourself: how narratives shape beliefs
- 2408.14671-Inference on Treatment Effects with Repeatedly Mismeasured High-Dimensional Controls
- 2201.06898-Difference-in-Differences Estimators for Treatments Continuously Distributed at Every Period
- 2501.15307-Influence Functions: A Unified Differentiation-Based Framework
- The day in conversation for 2026-11-19