Priced In or Bet On? Cram-School Lessons, Jeonse Leases, and Expected Appreciation in Seoul

summary

The gist

South Korean families incur significant expenditures on hagwons, private cram schools preparing students for university entrance exams…

In short

The study examined whether access to private cram schools warrants a housing premium in Seoul. Using apartment sales and jeonse contracts, it found that proximity to high-school exam hagwons increases sale prices and jeonse deposits. This premium reflects the current utility of the amenity rather than expected future appreciation.

Key concepts

Hagwon Access Premium
This refers to the extra cost paid for housing near private cram schools that prepare students for university entrance exams. The study found this premium is capitalized proportionally into both sale prices and jeonse deposits, suggesting it's a current-use benefit rather than a future appreciation bonus.
Jeonse Lease
Jeonse is a lump-sum deposit lease common in South Korea where the tenant pays a large upfront deposit to rent an apartment. The analysis used this contract type to compare housing costs and see how amenities like hagwons affect these payments.
Current-Flow Amenity
This concept describes an amenity, like a cram school, whose value is captured in current rental or sale prices rather than being expected to increase significantly in the future. The findings suggest hagwon access is treated as a current-flow amenity, meaning its value is reflected immediately in housing costs.
Jeonse-to-Price Ratio
This ratio compares the cost of a jeonse lease to the actual sale price of an apartment. The research showed that while hagwon access didn't change this ratio for the same flat type, nearby shops did raise it, indicating that local commercial density is a more significant factor than hagwon proximity in this specific metric.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Priced In or Bet On? Cram-School Lessons, Jeonse Leases, and Expected Appreciation in Seoul · Read on arXiv

Samiha Tariq

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Economics. The day in economics: theory, mechanisms and the evidence beneath them.

Ruth: We're looking at the paper: "Priced In or Bet On? Cram-School Lessons, Jeonse Leases, and Expected Appreciation in Seoul".

Warren: Here's the gist of the paper. South Korean families incur significant expenditures on hagwons, private cram schools preparing students for university entrance exams, and this paper investigates whether access to these services warrants a premium in housing, specifically examining its relationship with housing costs and expected appreciation.

Ruth: Utilizing 2,197,510 Seoul apartment sales and *jeonse* contracts from 2015 to 2026—geocoded by new business addresses—the analysis compares flats within the same middle-school assignment zone and month.

Warren: The core finding is that proximity to high-school exam preparation hagwons increases both sale prices (by 11.8%) and *jeonse* deposits (by 7.3%) when moving from the median complex to the 97th percentile of such facilities within a 500-meter radius.

Ruth: Holding complex size fixed, this move is associated with sale price premiums of 5.6% and deposit premiums of 5.9%.

Paper summary: Ruth: To wrap up this paper, "Priced In or Bet On? Cram-School Lessons, Jeonse Leases, and Expected Appreciation in Seoul," the main idea is that housing access to exam prep hagwons isn't just a side effect; it's a measurable cost of competing for education.

Warren: They show that moving near those top-tier cram schools actually bumps up sale prices by eleven point eight percent and jeonse deposits by seven point three percent when you move into the very best clusters of those facilities, even when you control for complex size and hold the hagwons fixed <ref:2611.05767#pg1,11.8% and jeonse deposits>.

Iris: What this means is that if you're looking at housing in Seoul, especially in areas with intense academic competition, you can't just look at the school zone or subway proximity alone to predict how much your rent or purchase price will be.

Ruth: It challenges the idea that housing premiums are purely driven by expected future growth or location; instead, this paper suggests they are heavily influenced by immediate amenity access related to education.

Warren: The authors use this data to show that the housing premium is stable, even through major education policy announcements like the two thousand nineteen plan to abolish elite high schools or the two thousand twenty-three changes regarding exam questions; these events didn't cause a measurable jump in premiums <ref:2611.05767#pg1>.

Iris: They also pointed out a limitation—that while they look at high-school hagwons, the paper doesn't fully capture how this premium is distributed among different types of tutoring spending.

Ruth: Right. The paper contributes by showing that jeonse leases can serve as a second way to price an amenity within the same complex, and that lease reforms show temporary markups, not lasting entry fees for new tenants.

Warren: So ultimately, this work suggests that families are paying a housing cost associated with the competition for university places, which is often left out of how much money people spend on actual tutoring.

Conclusion: Ruth: So, to wrap up this paper, it's about figuring out if paying for those private cram schools actually makes you pay more in housing, specifically when you factor in expected price jumps.

Warren: Yeah, the title itself asks that question—"Priced In or Bet On?"—and the authors are looking at how access to tutoring services affects housing costs and appreciation.

Iris: They’re using a massive dataset from Seoul apartment sales and jeonse contracts spanning two thousand fifteen to two thousand twenty-six geocoded by new business addresses, comparing flats in the same middle school zone.

Ruth: The core finding there is that being near those high-school exam prep hagwons increases sale prices by about eleven point eight percent and jeonse deposits by about seven point three percent when you move into the top percentile of those locations within five hundred meters.

Warren: That’s a pretty big number, but they do it after controlling for the size of the apartment complex, so that part is interesting—they found that holding the complex size fixed gives you sale premiums of about five point six percent and deposit premiums of five point nine percent.

Iris: But they also looked at hagwons teaching younger kids, and those didn't add any sale premium when we held everything else constant. That suggests the premium is tied specifically to the high-school level competition.

Ruth: Exactly, it points toward this housing cost being a direct result of the education race itself rather than some abstract future growth prediction in real estate.

Warren: It seems like a measurable cost of competing for those university spots that people don't usually include when they calculate how much they spend on actual tutoring.

Iris: The paper does point out that while proximity to shops and subway stations raises the jeonse-to-price ratio, the hagwon access doesn't change that ratio as much within the same complex.

Ruth: That’s a key distinction—the premium is capitalized into both prices and deposits, acting like an immediate amenity rather than something you expect to grow in value later.

Warren: So what this means for someone listening right now is that if you’re buying or renting in a competitive education market, the location isn't just about convenience; it’s about paying a premium directly into your housing transaction.

More episodes

← Home