Introducing and Repealing an EV Subsidy: Evidence from New Zealand's Clean Car Discount

summary

The gist

The study evaluates the impact of financial incentives and penalties under New Zealand’s Clean Car Discount (CCD), accompanied later by the introduction of the Road User Charges (RUC)…

In short

The study examined how New Zealand's Clean Car Discount (rebates) and later Road User Charges affected electric vehicle (EV) adoption. Rebates initially boosted registrations, but their removal caused a significant 72% relative drop compared to Queensland. The policy changes also correlated with a sharp decrease in carbon emissions.

Key concepts

Clean Car Discount (CCD)
This was New Zealand's financial incentive scheme designed to encourage people to buy cleaner cars, specifically electric vehicles (BEVs) and plug-in hybrids. It involved giving buyers rebates, which the study found initially coincided with increased EV sales.
Difference-in-Differences (DiD)
This statistical method compares the change in EV registrations in New Zealand against those in Queensland, Australia, to isolate the specific effect of New Zealand's policy changes. It helps determine how much more or less EVs were sold due to the CCD.
Structural Break Analysis
This technique identifies specific points in time when the underlying pattern of EV registrations changed significantly. The study found major shifts corresponding exactly with when rebates started and ended, pinpointing the exact timing of policy impacts.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Introducing and Repealing an EV Subsidy: Evidence from New Zealand's Clean Car Discount · Read on arXiv

Fabian Dunker, Jyotsna Garg

University of Canterbury

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Economics. The day in economics: theory, mechanisms and the evidence beneath them.

Ruth: We're looking at the paper: "Introducing and Repealing an EV Subsidy".

Warren: Here's the gist of the paper. The study evaluates the impact of financial incentives and penalties under New Zealand’s Clean Car Discount (CCD), accompanied later by the introduction of the Road User Charges (RUC), on EV adoption patterns in the country The introduction of rebates coincided with a strong increase in EV registrations in New Zealand, but EV registrations grew by a similar proportion in Queensland, and the average effect relative to Queensland is not statistically significant There is suggestive evidence that the rebates gradually accelerated EV uptake in New Zealand relative to Queensland In contrast, the repeal of the rebates reduced EV registrations in New Zealand by about 72% relative to Queensland, although part of this decline reflects buyers bringing purchases forward before the rebates ended Additionally, a sharp drop in average carbon emissions coinciding with the policy changes is consistent with targeted policy interventions mitigating transport-related emissions Structural Shifts in Vehicle Registrations The structural break analysis identified breaks that align with the timing of the policy interventions, particularly around the introduction and end of rebates for BEVs and PHEVs, and around the start of fees for petrol and diesel vehicles The most prominent breaks in the original time series for vehicle registrations are identified between 2021 and 2023, with a sharp dip in the registrations of BEVs, PHEVs, and Hybrids in December 2023 emerging as the consistent breakpoint The largest positive level shifts occur at the 2021 and 2022 breakpoints, around the start of the CCD and its extension in April 2022<ref:2611.15947#pg19> Whereas the large negative level shift after the December 2023 breakpoint represents the combined effect of CCD withdrawal and RUC announcements<ref:2611.15947#pg19> Quantifying Causal Effects via Difference-in-Differences The study uses a 2x2 Difference-in-Differences (DiD) regression model on log-transformed registrations, using Queensland, Australia, as a reference group<ref:2611.15947#pg10> The DiD estimator is Y22 - Y21 – (Y12 - Y11), which measures how much more the average log registrations changed in New Zealand than in Queensland<ref:2611.15947#pg10> The repeal estimate indicates a decline of about 72% in New Zealand’s EV registrations relative to Queensland, part of which reflects buyers bringing purchases forward before the rebates ended<ref:2611.15947#pg22> The DiD estimate is −1.26 (SE = 0.28; 95% CI

−1.81, −0.72: ; p < 0.001), corresponding to a decline of about 72% in New Zealand’s EV registrations relative to Queensland<ref:2611.15947#pg22> Impact on Carbon Footprints The motivation for these policies was to reduce the transport-related emissions, and the drops in the carbon emissions coincide with the peaks in BEV and PHEV registrations, suggesting that the feebate scheme played a role in reducing carbon emissions<ref:2611.15947#pg24> The forecasted values for Segment 2 saw a rapid decline, with the lowest predicted annual carbon emissions in December 2027, underscoring how a surge in EV fleet penetration can potentially reduce emissions<ref:2611.15947#pg24> Limitations of the Analysis Several limitations should be noted, including that the difference-in-differences design rests on a single control region and obtaining monthly initial-registration data for jurisdictions with market conditions comparable to New Zealand proved challenging<ref:2611.15947#pg25> Furthermore, with only two units, inference relies on Newey-West HAC standard errors rather than cluster-robust methods, and formal period-by-period event-study inference is not feasible<ref:2611.15947#pg25> The parallel trends assumption is violated in untransformed registrations but plausible in log-transformed registrations<ref:2611.15947#pg25> The two regions received treatments that were not identical in timing, eligibility, or strength, and New Zealand’s contemporaneous penalties on high-emission vehicles may also have shaped the estimated effects<ref:2611.15947#pg25> The results suggest two lessons for policymakers: first, the introduction of purchase rebates coincided with a period of strong EV growth in both regions, so that the additional effect of the rebates in relative terms is difficult to detect<ref:2611.15947#pg25> Second, the abrupt end of the rebates caused a rush of purchases followed by a sharp and persistent drop; a gradual and pre-announced phase-out might reduce such disruptions<ref:2611.15947#pg25> Average CO2 emissions fell markedly during the CCD period and rebounded after its end, although part of the decline is likely also related to the global increase in EV supply<ref:2611.15947#pg25> The study examines how monetary benefits and financial penalties affected EV adoption in New Zealand between 2014 and 2024<ref:2611.15947#pg2> References Aasness, M.

Ruth: A., & Odeck, J.

Warren: (2015).

Ruth: The increase of electric vehicle usage in Norway — incentives and adverse effects.

Paper summary: Warren: So wrapping up this look at the paper "Introducing and Repealing an EV Subsidy: Evidence from New Zealand's Clean Car Discount," the main thing is that both introducing rebates and then repealing them created distinct structural shifts in vehicle registrations across different time periods.

Iris: They found that the introduction of the rebate coincided with a period of strong EV growth in both New Zealand and Queensland, but those relative effects weren't statistically significant on their own. However, they did see evidence that the rebates gradually accelerated EV uptake specifically within New Zealand compared to Queensland.

Ruth: And then when they look at the repeal, that’s where the big effect is: a decline of about seventy-two percent in New Zealand’s EV registrations relative to Queensland. The authors are careful to say part of that drop is due to buyers bringing purchases forward before the rebates ended, which is important context.

Warren: It means policy tools aren't just about giving a temporary nudge; they create momentum, but the way you stop giving that nudge dictates whether you see a sustained trend or a sharp correction. The paper highlights how timing in policy implementation can fundamentally alter adoption patterns on a regional level.

Iris: The study uses structural break analysis and difference-in-differences to isolate these effects, and while they have limitations regarding the control region choice, the findings suggest that financial incentives and penalties under schemes like the Clean Car Discount do have measurable impacts on EV penetration in a real market context.

Ruth: It’s important for policymakers to recognize that these policies create measurable shifts in vehicle fleets. The lesson from "Introducing and Repealing an EV Subsidy: Evidence from New Zealand's Clean Car Discount" is that abrupt policy changes, like ending a rebate suddenly, cause market reactions that buyers can anticipate and react to before the incentive disappears.

Warren: So for anyone listening, it’s a reminder that when you look at these kinds of subsidy policies, you need to consider the whole lifecycle—the introduction and the eventual removal—to understand where the real movement in adoption is happening.

Conclusion: Ruth: So, we're wrapping up our look at "Introducing and Repealing an EV Subsidy: Evidence from New Zealand's Clean Car Discount." Essentially, this paper is about what happens when you introduce financial help for electric cars and then take it away.

Warren: Yeah, they show how those policy swings cause real structural changes in how many EVs people actually buy in New Zealand compared to somewhere else like Queensland.

Iris: The authors use a difference-in-differences approach, comparing the effect of the rebate introduction against what would have happened otherwise in Queensland. That lets them isolate the policy's impact from other things happening at the same time.

Ruth: It’s interesting how they found that while starting that rebate helped EV uptake, it didn't make a huge difference when you compare New Zealand to Queensland on its own. They suggested it was suggestive evidence for a gradual boost in New Zealand compared to Queensland.

Warren: But then they show the repeal part, and that’s where things get pretty dramatic. There's about a seventy-two percent drop in New Zealand's EV registrations relative to Queensland when the rebate got removed.

Iris: That seventy-two percent is a big number, but they immediately add the caveat that some of that drop happens because buyers were just getting ahead of the game, bringing their purchases forward before the rebate ended.

Ruth: Exactly. It shows that policy doesn't always create a straight line effect; there's this rush when things change, followed by a sharp correction as people adjust to the new rules.

Warren: And it’s not just about sales volume either. They also looked at carbon emissions, and they found those drops in pollution line up right with the times when EV registrations were peaking during that discount period.

Iris: That suggests the whole point of these kinds of policies is working, at least in terms of cutting down transport-related emissions during that phase. But they do note limitations, like the comparison region not being perfectly comparable or the way they handled those initial registration data points.

Ruth: So, ultimately, what this means for us is that when you design a financial incentive for something like electric vehicles, you have to think about the whole timeline—the start of the offer and especially how you plan to end it.

Warren: It’s not just about getting the initial uptake; it’s about managing those transitions so you don't get those sudden dips we saw when they pulled back.

Iris: And this points toward needing a more gradual phase-out strategy instead of an abrupt cutoff to avoid that kind of market disruption.

Ruth: Exactly. So next up, we're going to look at how these kinds of policy timing issues play out in other contexts around the world.

More episodes

← Home