Second law of thermodynamics in closed quantum many-body systems

summary

The gist

The paper addresses how the second law of thermodynamics emerges in closed quantum many-body systems by introducing key quantum-mechanical concepts…

In short

The paper explores how thermodynamics arises in closed quantum systems by using macroscopically reasonable states (iMATE) and operations. It proves two quantum versions of the second law: macroscopic passivity and an entropy increase law. This shows that classical thermodynamics emerges from quantum mechanics under specific, physically relevant conditions.

Key concepts

iMATE
This is a class of quantum states where the average values (expectation values) of all additive properties match their expected equilibrium values. It is chosen because these properties correspond to the additive quantities found in classical thermodynamics, making it a suitable bridge to thermal physics.
Macroscopic Operations
These are defined as unitary evolutions caused by a time-dependent Hamiltonian, which represent adiabatic processes. They model how a system changes over time using external control, such as changing the Hamiltonian gradually.
Quantum Macroscopic Entropy Density
This is a newly introduced quantum measure of entropy that is shown to match the standard thermodynamic entropy density for iMATE states. It can be calculated by measuring additive observables on small parts of the system, offering a new way to quantify thermodynamic disorder.
Macroscopic Passivity
This result shows that no extensive work can be extracted from an iMATE state using macroscopic operations whose duration is independent of the system's size. This provides a quantum mechanical constraint analogous to the second law, preventing unbounded energy extraction.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Second law of thermodynamics in closed quantum many-body systems · Read on arXiv

Yuuya Chiba, *, Yasushi Yoneta, †Ryusuke Hamazaki, ↵Akira Shimizu

RIKEN Hakubi Research Team · Center for Quantum Computing RIKEN Center for Interdisciplinary Theoretical and Mathematical Sciences RIKEN Institute for Photon Science and Technology The University of Tokyo Center for Quantum Information and Quantum Biology The University of Osaka

DOI: 10.1103/3y8f-yrp8

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Second law of thermodynamics in closed quantum many-body systems".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper addresses how the second law of thermodynamics emerges in closed quantum many-body systems by introducing key quantum-mechanical concepts: infinite-observable macroscopic thermal equilibrium (iMATE) and macroscopic operations.

Kai: The authors define iMATE as a class of states where the expectation values of all additive observables agree with their equilibrium values.

Mira: Macroscopic operations are defined as unitary evolution generated by a time-dependent additive Hamiltonian, corresponding to adiabatic operations.

Kai: Key results established in the macroscopically uniform case include: 1.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper about the second law of thermodynamics in closed quantum many-body systems. The authors introduce this idea of infinite observable macroscopic thermal equilibrium or iMATE as a new way to handle these problems >

Mira: Right, so they're suggesting that iMATE is a class of states where the average values of all additive observables match what you expect for thermal equilibrium >

Lev: And they define macroscopic operations as unitary evolutions created by time-dependent Hamiltonians that only affect those additive observables, which they call macroscopic operations >

Kai: The main thrust seems to be showing how the second law actually emerges in these systems using these specific definitions, linking them to standard thermodynamic ideas >

Mira: They establish a few key things. First, they show macroscopic equivalence preservation under any macroscopic operation for a time independent of the system size, which they call t being proportional to L zero >

Lev: That's significant because it means we don't need the operation time to be astronomically long just to maintain state similarity, right? And then there’s this quantum Planck’s principle or macroscopic passivity result >

Kai: They prove that for any iMATE state, you can't extract extensive work using macroscopic operations if the time is independent of the system size >

Mira: That means the expectation value of the initial Hamiltonian doesn't decrease extensively after those operations, which seems like a direct statement about irreversibility >

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that passivity constraint on operation time being proportional to L zero is really tight; it sets the boundary for what’s physically achievable with current hardware setups >

Kai: They also introduce this quantum macroscopic entropy density, which they call s mac,, and they claim it matches the thermodynamic entropy density for any iMATE state >

Mira: That agreement is important because it connects a quantum concept directly to the classical thermodynamic quantity, and in the limit of very large systems, this quantum density converges to the standard one, s TD(betaH) >

Lev: So they're not just saying thermodynamics happens; they’re giving us a measurable quantity that scales correctly for large systems, which is what we need for anything practical >

Kai: They also prove the law of increasing entropy under two different conditions: first, assuming thermalization leads to an increase in standard entropy density, and second, under a weaker assumption involving a finite-time operation followed by infinite-time relaxation >

Mira: That second condition is interesting because it doesn't require the system to be fully thermalized initially, just that the final relaxation process respects the thermodynamic trend >

Lev: What this means for real hardware is that even if we don't reach perfect equilibrium in finite time, we can still track the entropy increase as long as the final state is governed by a standard Hamiltonian >

Kai: The paper argues that these results show how thermodynamics comes from quantum mechanics using iMATE states and macroscopic operations, and they show it’s consistent with the second law under thermalization assumptions for the final step >

Mira: They also contrast iMATE with microscopic thermal equilibrium, MITE, showing that iMATE is a broader class of states better suited for thermodynamics because it focuses on additive observables >

Lev: So they're arguing that MITE might be too restrictive, and we need this more general iMATE concept to bridge the gap between pure quantum mechanics and macroscopic thermal physics >

Kai: They also propose a novel way to measure thermodynamic entropy by measuring additive observables on small pieces of the system, which gives you the thermodynamic entropy density without needing many separate thermal equilibrium measurements >

Mira: That measurement method is quite elegant because it bypasses the need for multiple temperature steps that we usually see in conventional thermodynamics >

Lev: If this measurement works, it suggests a pathway to actually probe these quantum systems directly with less overhead than we might think >

Kai: Ultimately, the paper proposes two versions of the second law: macroscopic passivity and increasing entropy, and they show these two concepts are actually not equivalent in this context >

Mira: The conclusion is that thermodynamics emerges from quantum mechanics when you use these specific classes of states and operations, which seems to be a big step in connecting the two fields >

Lev: It gives us a concrete framework for thinking about how we can observe thermal behavior in systems that are fundamentally quantum and isolated >

Conclusion: Kai: So we've been looking at how these authors try to make sense of the second law of thermodynamics in systems that are actually governed by quantum rules, like those superconducting qubits we build on here >

Mira: Exactly. They introduce this idea called infinite observable macroscopic thermal equilibrium or iMATE as a way to define the kind of state we should look at when talking about heat and energy flow >

Lev: And they tie this to macroscopic operations, which are basically controlled unitary evolutions that only affect those specific additive quantities in the system >

Kai: The main point is showing how these definitions lead to things that resemble thermodynamics, like entropy density matching what we expect from classical physics in the right limits >

Mira: They prove a few things, starting with this macroscopic equivalence preservation under any operation for a time shorter than the system size scales, which is quite a specific constraint >

Lev: That constraint is important because it sets a limit on how long you can run those operations before the quantum state starts looking totally different from where it started >

Kai: Then they establish this quantum Planck’s principle, showing that extensive work extraction using these operations has to be limited by the system size scales >

Mira: And they link this to a quantum macroscopic entropy density that actually matches standard thermodynamic entropy density for states in iMATE >

Lev: That matching is key because it suggests there's a bridge between the microscopic quantum world and the macroscopic thermal world using these specific state definitions >

Kai: They also show that the law of increasing entropy holds under conditions where we assume some form of thermalization happens at the end of a process >

Mira: So they are proposing two versions of this second law, one based on passivity and another on entropy increase, and they show those two concepts aren't actually the same thing here >

Lev: It’s interesting that they call iMATE a broader class than microscopic thermal equilibrium because it works better for connecting to actual thermodynamics >

Kai: The authors are basically saying that by using these specific mathematical tools, we can see how the second law of thermodynamics emerges directly from quantum mechanics, provided we use the right definitions for states and operations >

Mira: It gives us a new framework to think about how thermal behavior appears in systems that are fundamentally quantum and isolated, which opens up some new ways to study things.

More episodes

← Home