On Rare Nonresonant Regions and Subdiffusive Transport in an Interacting Disordered Quantum Chain

summary

The gist

We study rare nonresonant regions in a canonical one-dimensional disordered quantum spin chain by directly implementing the iterated Schrieffer–Wolff construction underlying the recent work of De…

In short

This study investigates rare regions where a one-dimensional disordered quantum spin chain remains nonresonant during iterated Schrieffer–Wolff transformations. By numerically simulating this process, researchers found that survival probability decays exponentially, revealing scale-resolved failure rates. This suggests localized regions stop diffusion and implies a scale-free process at a critical time $t_c$.

Key concepts

Iterated Schrieffer–Wolff Construction
This is a mathematical method used to study quantum systems by iteratively applying small, sequential transformations. In this paper, it is used to model how disorder affects the system's evolution across different energy scales, helping to find regions where the system avoids resonance.
Survival Probability $P_{ ext{conv}}(L)$
This measures the likelihood that a specific region in the disordered chain remains nonresonant after applying successive transformation steps. The paper shows this probability decays exponentially with system size, indicating that nonresonant regions are rare and localized.
Scale-Resolved Rates $a_k(t)$
These rates quantify how quickly the probability of resonance changes at different stages ($k$) of the transformation process. Analyzing these rates reveals a hierarchy and suggests a finite radius of convergence, pointing towards a scale-free transport mechanism.
$t_c$ (Critical Time)
This is a specific time point where the physical interpretation of the resonance probability changes. At this time, the probability of having a resonance becomes independent of the scale $k$, suggesting that at $t_c$, diffusion is governed by a process smaller than any exponential decay.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

On Rare Nonresonant Regions and Subdiffusive Transport in an Interacting Disordered Quantum Chain · Read on arXiv

A. Scardicchio, S. L. Sondhi

Abdus Salam ICTP · INFN · Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics, University of Oxford

We study rare nonresonant regions in a canonical one-dimensional disordered quantum spin chain by directly implementing the iterated Schrieffer-Wolff construction underlying the recent work of De Roeck, Giacomin, Huveneers and Prosniak on subdiffusive transport. For finite systems, we compute the probability that a disorder realization remains nonresonant through successive scales of the flow, while separately monitoring operator proliferation and the spatial localization of dressed local observables. The survival probability decays at most exponentially with system size over the numerically accessible regime. Resolving this decay scale by scale yields failure rates associated with successive Schrieffer-Wolff steps. The first rate is obtained analytically in excellent agreement with numerics, while higher-scale rates decrease rapidly throughout the regime studied. These results support the summability mechanism required for exponentially rare but parametrically long nonresonant regions, which provide the insulating bottlenecks responsible for subdiffusive transport. At the smallest couplings studied, the survival probability under our conditions exceeds the rigorous lower bound by six to seven orders of magnitude, demonstrating how conservative the constants required by the proof are while confirming that its underlying physical mechanism is quantitatively visible at accessible scales. More broadly, our results show how direct numerical implementations can provide an independent and physically transparent test of technically demanding constructive proofs, a methodology that may become increasingly useful as machine-assisted proofs become more common.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "On Rare Nonresonant Regions and Subdiffusive Transport in an Interacting Disordered Quantum Chain".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We study rare nonresonant regions in a canonical one-dimensional disordered quantum spin chain by directly implementing the iterated Schrieffer–Wolff construction underlying the recent work of De Roeck, Giacomin, Huveneers and Pro´sniak on subdiffusive transport Core Methodology The study involves computing the probability that a disorder realization remains nonresonant through successive scales of the flow while separately monitoring operator proliferation and the spatial localization of dressed local observables The survival probability decays at most exponentially with system size over the numerically accessible regime, and resolving this decay scale by scale yields failure rates associated with successive Schrieffer–Wolff steps The first rate is obtained analytically in excellent agreement with numerics, while higher-scale rates decrease rapidly throughout the regime studied Analysis of Rare Regions The survival probability under the implemented conditions exceeds the rigorous lower bound by six to seven orders of magnitude at the smallest couplings and system sizes where a comparison can be made, demonstrating how conservative the constants required by the proof are while confirming that its underlying physical mechanism is quantitatively visible at accessible scales The total probability of remaining nonresonant is controlled by the product of the Sk’s, and hence by the sum a = X k≥1 ak If this series is convergent, the probability of a completely nonresonant interval remains exponentially small in its length; if it does not, that probability becomes smaller than exponential and the rare-region mechanism used in the transport argument fails Scale-Resolved Rates The measured rates decrease rapidly in the perturbative regime, and the data presently resolve several successive rates and show a clear hierarchy indicative of convergence over the range of couplings in which the calculation is well controlled At larger couplings, our data suggest that successive resonance rates approach one another, pointing in turn to a finite radius of convergence of the resonance-free Schrieffer–Wolff hierarchy The first result is that the decay of Pconv(L) is perfectly exponential, see Fig.1 Implications for Transport The exponential decay of P is the main result of DRGHP and what implies the existence of rare, localized regions which are sufficient to stop diffusion The second observation is that the physical interpretation of the statement ak+1(t)/ak(t) = 1 at t = tc is clear, suggesting a scale free process where the probability to have a resonance at scale k is independent of k This implies that at tc the probability is smaller than any exponential Pconv(t > tc, L) ∼ e−bL ln L Verification and Future Directions The numerical implementation provides an independent and physically transparent test of technically demanding constructive proofs, a methodology that may become increasingly useful as machine-assisted proofs become more common The work suggests that the DRGHP bound is loose by a factor of 10-15 on the per spin total rate a(t), which translates into many orders of magnitude on the probability itself A natural continuation of this work would consist of finding, accurately, ak(t) for k ≥ 4 (at least to k = 6) which is doable by running our code on a cluster The goal is to engage with the DRGHP proof by independently interrogating both the correspondence between the formal statement and the physical claim and a sufficient number of the key steps to develop a much better appreciation of what the proof is actually doing Acknowledgments We thank Wojciech De Roeck and Fran¸cois Huveneers for the considerable time and effort they devoted to explaining the ideas and technical structure of the DRGHP proof at the Oxford meeting in August 2024, and Vedika Khemani for helping to convene that meeting The work of AS has also been supported by the European Union–NextGenerationEU under the NRRP Project “National Quantum Science and Technology Institute” (NQSTI), Award Number PE00000023, Concession Decree No.

Kai: 1564 of 11.10.2022 adopted by the Italian Ministry of Research, CUP J97G22000390k Appendix Summary The analytic expression for a1(t) is exact and checkable in closed form for a given disorder realization – it is 4L inequalities, one per site per sign choice, requiring no Pauli string For higher steps failure rates ak≥2(t), the leading new off-diagonal terms come from

A(1), V (0): , and the final result in this approximation is a2(t) = 7/3 t squared ln(c2/t) The radius of convergence of the series a(t) = 3/2 t + X k≥2 Nkρk(0)t k ln(ck/t), is determined by the unknown pre-factors Nkρk: tc = 1/ρ lim k→∞ (Nkρk(0))1/k The correspondence between the objects of

27: and those measured here is not identical, as DRGHP eliminate at step k only the diagrams of order g < Lk+1, whereas the present flow eliminates the whole of V(k) at every step and has no analogue of the scale separation Lk = (1 + β)k The locality statement, which concerns the shape of Λk(m) rather than its normalization, is unaffected by it The exponential decay of the Λk(m) is evident in Figure 5, for all t, L, k checked, for both A and V The reason why the locality of Ak and Vk is numerically proved in our work is that it is guaranteed by their NRII condition The rate a2(t) ∼ t 1.

Title and authors: Kai: We've touched on the title and authors, and it really zeroes in on these rare nonresonant regions, which are the key bottlenecks for subdiffusive transport in an interacting disordered quantum chain. The authors are Scardicchio and Sondhi.

Mira: They aren't just looking at one specific type of disorder; they are exploring a generic setting where interactions matter, which is important because it moves beyond simpler models to something more realistic for condensed matter systems.

Lev: And the implication here for me, as someone who builds error correction codes, is that if we can find a way to characterize these rare regions mathematically through this flow, it gives us a concrete target for where we might look for localization effects in real systems.

Kai: Right. The paper sets up the framework by focusing on computing the probability that a disorder realization stays nonresonant through these successive scales of the flow while also watching how operators proliferate and how localized they get spatially.

Mira: That monitoring of operator proliferation and spatial localization is crucial because it tells us if we're just looking at a mathematical artifact or if there’s some actual physical mechanism causing the transport to slow down.

Lev: I wonder if the computational complexity of tracking those observables across scales makes this method very hard to apply outside of these controlled numerical regimes, especially since they are pushing up to system sizes like thirty-two.

Kai: They do push it, but they claim that for finite systems in the numerically accessible regime, that survival probability decays at most exponentially with the system size over time.

The paper's summary: Mira: To summarize what this paper is doing, they are using these successive scales of the Schrieffer–Wolff construction to calculate failure rates associated with each step of that flow. They find that the first rate they compute analytically matches their numerical results almost perfectly.

Kai: That analytic result for the first rate is actually quite clean—it's obtained in excellent agreement with numerics—which gives them a solid starting point, even though the higher-scale rates decrease very quickly as you go deeper into the flow.

Lev: I’m interested in those higher-scale rates because they represent more complex physics, and if they decrease rapidly, it means we can focus our computational effort on just these first few scales for a good approximation.

Mira: Exactly. The paper shows that the total probability of remaining nonresonant is controlled by a series called the sum over alpha, which depends on how many steps you take and the coupling strength of each step.

Kai: That series is what they call alpha equals X k greater than or equal to one alpha equals X k ak, and if this series converges, it means the probability of having a completely nonresonant interval that is also exponentially small in its length <ref:2609.13834#pg1>.

The paper's improvements: Lev: When we look at what they suggest as an improvement over previous work, it’s that their numerical implementation provides an independent and physically transparent test for these constructive proofs, which is pretty valuable when you're dealing with those technically demanding methods.

Kai: They are essentially checking the formal statements of the De Roeck, Giacomin, Huveneers and Pro´sniak work by directly running the construction and seeing if it matches what they predict physically.

Mira: And they point out that their numerical implementation shows that the rigorous lower bound from their proof is loose by a factor of six to seven orders of magnitude at the smallest couplings and system sizes where you can actually compare them.

Lev: That factor is huge, so it tells us that while the physical mechanism described in the proof is definitely there, it’s not as restrictive as the math initially suggested when you look at accessible scales.

Kai: And they also show that the decay of these survival probabilities is perfectly exponential for their first result, which is a very clean piece of information to have when you are trying to map out a transport regime.

Conclusion: Mira: So, wrapping up this paper on "On Rare Nonresonant Regions and Subdiffusive Transport in an Interacting Disordered Quantum Chain," the main result is that the exponential decay of the survival probability is what implies these rare, localized regions are sufficient to stop diffusion.

Kai: They also point out something interesting about a ratio, ak plus one over ak at time tc being equal to one, suggesting a scale free process where whether you have a resonance at scale k doesn't depend on k.

Lev: That scale-free idea implies that at that critical time tc, the probability of having any resonance in the long length L becomes smaller than any exponential decay with L.

Mira: So for anyone listening who only cares about the physics, it means there are these rare bottlenecks where transport gets stuck, and this paper gives us a way to calculate how likely those bottlenecks are to exist.

Kai: It’s a lot of machinery, but they managed to make the formal structure of the DRGHP proof physically visible through their simulation. The work on "On Rare Nonresonant Regions and Subdiffusive Transport in an Interacting Disordered Quantum Chain" gives us a better way to check these deep theoretical bounds.

Lev: For me, it’s about verifying that the mathematical correspondence holds up when you try to map it onto actual, physically realized systems with their known limitations.

Mira: Indeed. It shows that the mechanism for subdiffusion is rooted in these rare regions, and this paper provides a concrete way to probe those regions through iterated construction.

More episodes

← Home