Lithium redistribution and electrode degradation in commercial NMC/Graphite and LCO/Graphite cells under high-rate cycling conditions

summary

The gist

Fast charging accelerates degradation in lithium-ion batteries, but the effects of cathode chemistry and charging protocol remain difficult to separate The paper investigates how commercial…

In short

The study investigated how commercial NMC/Graphite and LCO/Graphite batteries degrade when subjected to fast charging rates (high-rate cycling). Results showed that both chemistries lose capacity significantly at higher rates, with LCO/Gr showing a much stronger degradation response. Significant lithium accumulation on the graphite anodes was observed at 2C, and structural changes in the NMC cells indicated layer expansion.

Key concepts

Capacity Retention Trends
This measures how much of the battery's original energy it can still deliver after being cycled at different charging speeds (C-rates). The study found that while NMC/Gr retained capacity better at lower rates, LCO/Gr suffered a much steeper drop in performance when cycled quickly.
Lithium Accumulation and Morphology
Researchers used techniques like NRA and SEM to see where lithium builds up on the graphite anode surface during fast charging. They found that at 2C, both cell types accumulated significantly more lithium deposits, suggesting this accumulation is a key factor in their degradation.
Structural Evolution Under Rate
X-ray diffraction (XRD) was used to track physical changes within the battery cells as the charging rate increased. For NMC cells, this showed the layered structure expanding along one axis when charged faster, while LCO showed a different, non-monotonic change in its crystal structure.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Lithium redistribution and electrode degradation in commercial NMC/Graphite and LCO/Graphite cells under high-rate cycling conditions · Read on arXiv

Naisargi Kanabar, Nicholas Fusco, Seiichiro Higashiya, Devendra Sadana, Stephen Bedell, Haralabos Efstathiadis

Department of Physics, University at Albany (SUNY) · Department of Nanoscale Science and Engineering, University at Albany (SUNY)

Fast charging accelerates degradation in lithium-ion batteries, but the effects of cathode chemistry and charging protocol remain difficult to separate. Here, commercial NMC811/graphite (200 mAh) and LCO/graphite (45 mAh) coin cells were cycled for 100 cycles at 0.3C, 1C, 2C, and 3C, followed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM), X-ray diffraction (XRD), and nuclear reaction analysis (NRA). Both cell types exhibited a transition in cycling stability between 1C and 2C. NMC811/graphite retained approximately 99.7% of its initial discharge capacity at 0.3C and 1C, decreasing to 72.3% at 2C and 63.5% at 3C, while LCO/graphite retained only 11.1% at 2C. NRA revealed maximum lithium accumulation in graphite anodes at 2C for both chemistries, supported by SEM observations of granular surface deposits. XRD showed rate-dependent shifts in cathode (003) and graphite (002) reflections, indicating structural changes during cycling. The lower lithium accumulation at 3C was associated with reduced charge throughput, while the LCO/graphite 3C condition was limited by its charging protocol. These findings highlight the importance of anode-side degradation and charging protocols in interpreting high-rate cycling performance of commercial lithium-ion batteries.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Lithium redistribution and electrode degradation in commercial NMC/Graphite and LCO/Graphite cells under high-rate cycling conditions".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Fast charging accelerates degradation in lithium-ion batteries, but the effects of cathode chemistry and charging protocol remain difficult to separate The paper investigates how commercial NMC/Graphite and LCO/Graphite cells degrade under high-rate cycling conditions, highlighting the importance of anode-side degradation and charging protocols in interpreting performance Capacity Retention Trends Both commercial NMC/Gr and LCO/Gr cells exhibited a transition in cycling stability between 1C and 2C For NMC/Gr, the cell retained approximately 99.7% of its initial discharge capacity at 0.3C and 1C, decreasing to 72.3% at 2C and 63.5% at 3C In contrast, LCO/Gr exhibited a stronger high-rate response, retaining only 11.1% after 100 cycles at the 2C condition The largest absolute capacity loss occurred for NMC/Gr at 2C (44.99 mAh) Lithium Accumulation and Morphology NRA and SEM revealed significant lithium accumulation and granular surface deposits on graphite anodes at 2C for both chemistries Lithium accumulation increased by approximately 8.16 and 20.27 times relative to C/3 for NMC/Gr and LCO/Gr, respectively These observations suggest accumulation of lithium-containing material at or near the graphite surface The SEM images showed that the most pronounced surface change occurred at 2C for LCO/Gr, where the graphite flakes were almost completely covered by a rough, granular layer with visible cracks Structural Evolution Under Rate XRD analysis revealed distinct C-rate-dependent structural evolution in the NMC/Gr and LCO/Gr cells For NMC, the (003) reflection progressively shifted toward lower 2θ from 18.66° at 0.3C to 18.59° at 3C, indicating progressive expansion of the layered NMC structure along the c-axis with increasing C-rate Conversely, LCO exhibited a non-monotonic response, with the (003) peak shifted from 18.84° at 0.3C to 18.92° at 2C and 18.

Paper summary: Kai: So, wrapping up this look at the paper "Lithium redistribution and electrode degradation in commercial NMC/Graphite and LCO/Graphite cells under high-rate cycling conditions," what's the big picture takeaway for anyone listening who isn't a battery expert?

Mira: Simply put, fast charging doesn't just cause capacity fade; it triggers physical changes inside the anode and cathode that are dependent on the specific chemical makeup of the battery.

Lev: The authors are showing that you need to look at both lithium moving into the graphite and how those materials physically expand during cycling when you push those high rates.

Kai: It means that choosing a cell chemistry, like NMC versus LCO, isn't just about energy density; it's about predicting how it will handle the charging speed you impose on it over its life.

Mira: The paper emphasizes that the way lithium moves and deposits on the anode surface is a key indicator of long-term degradation under aggressive cycling conditions.

Lev: For those of us building real hardware, this means we can't just focus on the cathode performance; we have to design protocols that respect how much physical stress those materials are under at high currents.

Kai: So when you hear about battery performance, remember that the degradation pathways are not universal; they are tied directly to the cell chemistry and the rate of charge.

Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at how lithium moves inside commercial cells when you push them really hard under fast charging, focusing on NMC and LCO chemistry.

Mira: The paper's title is pretty descriptive, it sets up that comparison between NMC and LCO cells specifically looking at how lithium redistributes and then what happens to the electrodes when they cycle fast.

Lev: It’s interesting because it doesn't just look at the overall capacity loss, it’s digging into where that lithium actually ends up on the graphite surface.

Kai: Right, so what they found was a difference in how stable those cells were between one times current and two times current cycling rates.

Mira: For NMC/Graphite, they saw a drop to seventy-two point three percent of its initial capacity when cycling at two times current compared to just one times current.

Lev: That’s a significant difference, especially since we're talking about real hardware running high rates; the degradation path is clearly different for that chemistry.

Kai: And LCO/Graphite showed a much steeper drop, retaining only eleven point one percent of its capacity after one hundred cycles at that two times current condition.

Mira: The researchers pointed out that the biggest absolute loss for NMC/Graphite happened specifically at the two times current rate, which is forty-four point nine nine milliampere hour.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, we need to know exactly how much structural change happens under those high currents before we can model it accurately.

Kai: And they used X ray diffraction to show that the NMC structure actually expands along the c-axis when you increase the current rate from zero point three times current up to three times current.

Mira: That means as you push harder, the layered structure of NMC is physically stretching out in a specific direction.

Lev: If that expansion happens, it puts physical stress on the interfaces, which is exactly what we need to worry about when building reliable energy storage systems.

Kai: It shows that you can't just treat these materials as static; they react physically to the charging protocol you impose on them.

Mira: The implication is that understanding the specific chemical makeup, whether it’s NMC or LCO, dictates how much structural strain those materials will take under rapid use.

Lev: So if we want to design better batteries for fast charging, we have to focus our modeling not just on chemistry but on that physical redistribution and structural evolution under high rate cycling.

Kai: Exactly. This paper gives us the specific data points on what’s happening physically at the anode surface when you push those limits.

Mira: It really highlights that separating cathode chemistry effects from charging protocol effects is tough because both are driving these physical changes simultaneously.

More episodes

← Home